Main Page: Difference between revisions

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Content deleted Content added
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
Some people are itching to place essay-type material on Wikipedia.
Some people are itching to place essay-type material on Wikipedia, both about Wikipedia and about other subjects. We've found that this distracts our attention from actual encyclopedia article writing.

But please, follow '''the Wikipedia commentary area rule''': Name your essay either as a subpage of the commentary page, [[/Like this]], or as a subpage of your personal home page, [[Larry Sanger/Like this]]. Expect essays named according to any other convention to be renamed appropriately. We simply must not run the risk of people mistaking commentary for encyclopedia content.

'''The commentary'''

*Ethics, philosophy, objectivity, religion


Expect essays named according to any other convention to be renamed appropriately. We simply must not run the risk of people mistaking commentary for encyclopedia content.


Ethics, philosophy, objectivity, religion
:[[Simple View of Ethics and Morals]]
:[[Simple View of Ethics and Morals]]
:[[A definition of Philosophy]] and Fields of Knowledge (Ray Van De Walker)
:[[A definition of Philosophy]] and Fields of Knowledge (Ray Van De Walker)
Line 23: Line 19:
:[[Belief in God spectrum]]
:[[Belief in God spectrum]]


*The world and where it's going
The world and where it's going
:[[Middle East Reconciliation]] ([[Uriyan]])
:[[Middle East Reconciliation]] ([[Uriyan]])
:[[Stupid Republicans]] (author unknown)
:[[Stupid Republicans]] (author unknown)
Line 29: Line 25:
:[[Internet Authority Disease]] by [[Sammy snake]]
:[[Internet Authority Disease]] by [[Sammy snake]]


*Content of Wikipedia
Content of Wikipedia
:[[Proposal for an Encyclopedian Recycling Endeavor]] ([[BryceHarrington]])
:[[Proposal for an Encyclopedian Recycling Endeavor]] ([[BryceHarrington]])
:[[Please help build 911 Attack memorial]]
:[[Please help build 911 Attack memorial]]
:[[Project Sourceberg]] (what to do about primary sources)
:[[Project Sourceberg]] (what to do about primary sources)


*Form of Wikipedia
Form of Wikipedia
:[[The elements of an encyclopedia project]] (Larry Sanger and whoever else joins in)
:[[The elements of an encyclopedia project]] (Larry Sanger and whoever else joins in)
:[[Breadth and depth]] ([[Larry Sanger]] and others)
:[[Breadth and depth]] ([[Larry Sanger]] and others)
Line 43: Line 39:
:[[Kill the Stub Pages]] ([[BryceHarrington]])
:[[Kill the Stub Pages]] ([[BryceHarrington]])
:[[Improving Portal Pages]] ([[BryceHarrington]])
:[[Improving Portal Pages]] ([[BryceHarrington]])
:[[Get rid of subpages entirely]] ([[Larry Sanger]]) 
:[[Get rid of subpages entirely]] ([[Larry Sanger]])

:[[How to write non-american names]]
:[[How to write non-american names]]
:[[U.S. vs. US]]
:[[U.S. vs. US]]
:[[Use pinyin not Wade-Giles]]
:[[Use pinyin not Wade-Giles]]


*Wikipedia and where it's going
Wikipedia and where it's going
:[[Best debates]] about Wikipedia articles
:[[Best debates]] about Wikipedia articles
:[[Wikipedia Anti-Rules]] (Anonymous and others)
:[[Wikipedia Anti-Rules]] (Anonymous and others)

Revision as of 15:53, 9 November 2001

Some people are itching to place essay-type material on Wikipedia, both about Wikipedia and about other subjects. We've found that this distracts our attention from actual encyclopedia article writing.

Expect essays named according to any other convention to be renamed appropriately. We simply must not run the risk of people mistaking commentary for encyclopedia content.

Ethics, philosophy, objectivity, religion

Simple View of Ethics and Morals
A definition of Philosophy and Fields of Knowledge (Ray Van De Walker)
Drawbacks of Philosophical Understandings (Bryan Mayo)
The Problem of Defining Sanity (Bruce Hamilton)
Investigator as Philosopher (Bruce Hamilton)
Ethics or Morals (Bruce Hamilton)
Ethics vs. Morals -- some rather old discussion about the difference between ethics and morals
Media Bias (collectively written)
The Myth of the Lone Inventor (Lee laments the innacuracy of much reporting on inventions and discoveries)
A pome of sorts in narrative style... (Bruce Hamilton)
Folklore, myth and religion (various)
Faith vs science with regard to the Wikipedia
Disability Etiquette
Belief in God spectrum

The world and where it's going

Middle East Reconciliation (Uriyan)
Stupid Republicans (author unknown)
The best president to have a beer with (various Wikipedians)
Internet Authority Disease by Sammy snake

Content of Wikipedia

Proposal for an Encyclopedian Recycling Endeavor (BryceHarrington)
Please help build 911 Attack memorial
Project Sourceberg (what to do about primary sources)

Form of Wikipedia

The elements of an encyclopedia project (Larry Sanger and whoever else joins in)
Breadth and depth (Larry Sanger and others)
Modular content creation (TimShell and others)
Wiki is not paper (a discussion about ways to improve upon the traditional encyclopedia concept)
Should Wikipedia Use Profanity? (Stephen Gilbert and others)
When should I link externally? (GWO)
Kill the Stub Pages (BryceHarrington)
Improving Portal Pages (BryceHarrington)
Get rid of subpages entirely (Larry Sanger)
How to write non-american names
U.S. vs. US
Use pinyin not Wade-Giles

Wikipedia and where it's going

Best debates about Wikipedia articles
Wikipedia Anti-Rules (Anonymous and others)
Making Wikipedia profitable (Neeklamy and others)
The future of Wikipedia (Kpjas and others)
How to Destroy Wikipedia (The Cunctator) - an open challenge
How to Build Wikipedia (The Cunctator) - an open exhortation
Making fun of Britannica
A better Wikipedia
The Wikipedia Community
Search Engine
configuration management
Responding to the Critics (Stephen Gilbert)
Larrys Big Reply (originally on Creationism/Talk)
(AKA "The Ten Point Plan", or, "We should not impose our values on other thinking people.")
SJKs Wikipedia-Specific License proposal
Would Larry and Cunc just drop it please
Larry Sanger/Columns (Larry Sanger and people who respond to him)