Bureaucrat: Difference between revisions

From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Content deleted Content added
Transformation realme
Tags: Reverted Visual edit Mobile edit Mobile web edit
→‎== Removing access ==: br.wikimedia crats are also able to revoke themselves, per se
Tag: 2017 source edit
 
(44 intermediate revisions by 25 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
<languages/>
<languages/>
<translate><!--T:1--> Within Wikimedia projects, a '''bureaucrat''' is a user who has the technical ability to:</translate>
[[Transvert|Beareucrat]]<translate><!--T:1-->
Within Wikimedia projects, a '''bureaucrat''' is a user who has the technical ability to:</translate>
{{TOCright}}
{{TOCright}}
<translate>
<translate>
<!--T:2-->
<!--T:2-->
* Promote other users to [[<tvar|admins>Special:MyLanguage/Administrator</>|administrator]] or bureaucrat;
* Promote other users to [[<tvar name="admins">Special:MyLanguage/Administrator</tvar>|administrator]] or bureaucrat;
* Grant and revoke a user's [[<tvar|bots>Special:MyLanguage/Bot</>|bot]] flag;
* Grant and revoke a user's [[<tvar name="bots">Special:MyLanguage/Bot</tvar>|bot]] flag;
* Add and remove users from the [[<tvar|ias>Special:MyLanguage/Interface administrators</>|interface-admin]] group;
* Add and remove users from the [[<tvar name="ias">Special:MyLanguage/Interface administrators</tvar>|interface-admin]] group;
* Add and remove users from custom local groups created by local consensus like ''account creator'', ''deleter'', etc;
* Add and remove users from custom local groups created by local consensus like ''account creator'', ''deleter'', etc.;
* Remove a user's administrator and/or bureaucrat flags on some projects listed [[<tvar|ra>#Removing_access</>|below]].
* Remove a user's administrator and/or bureaucrat flags on some projects listed [[<tvar name="ra">#Removing access</tvar>|below]].


<!--T:3-->
<!--T:3-->
[[<tvar|stewards>Special:MyLanguage/Stewards</>|Stewards]] fulfill these roles on wikis without bureaucrats using the [[<tvar|srp>Steward requests/Permissions</>|requests for permissions]] page. A small community generally doesn't require a local bureaucrat, because stewards can easily handle the low traffic of requests from that wiki with little delay; generally a user with this access is not needed until several local administrators are present. Other positions may be subject to global policies like the [[<tvar|cu>Special:MyLanguage/CheckUser policy</>|Checkuser policy]] and the [[<tvar|ovs>Special:MyLanguage/Oversight policy</>|Oversight policy]], which define minimum community requirements.
[[<tvar name="stewards">Special:MyLanguage/Stewards</tvar>|Stewards]] fulfill these roles on wikis without bureaucrats using the [[<tvar name="srp">Steward requests/Permissions</tvar>|requests for permissions]] page. A small community generally doesn't require a local bureaucrat, because stewards can easily handle the low traffic of requests from that wiki with little delay; generally a user with this access is not needed until several local administrators are present. Other positions may be subject to global policies like the [[<tvar name="cu">Special:MyLanguage/CheckUser policy</tvar>|Checkuser policy]] and the [[<tvar name="ovs">Special:MyLanguage/Oversight policy</tvar>|Oversight policy]], which define minimum community requirements.</translate> <translate><!--T:4--> The default configuration of the <tvar name="mw">{{ll|MediaWiki}}</tvar> software permits bureaucrats with access to <tvar name="spec-userrights"><code>Special:UserRights</code></tvar> to add and remove users from all user groups. On [[<tvar name="wmp">Special:MyLanguage/Wikimedia projects</tvar>|Wikimedia projects]] only [[<tvar name="stewards">Special:MyLanguage/Stewards</tvar>|stewards]] have full access to <tvar name="spec-userrights2"><code>Special:UserRights</code></tvar>, while bureaucrats can add/remove only a subset of rights.</translate>

</translate><translate><!--T:4-->
The default configuration of the <tvar|mw>{{ll|MediaWiki}}</> software permits bureaucrats with access to <tvar|spec-userrights><code>Special:UserRights</code></> to add and remove users from all user groups. On [[<tvar|wmp>Special:MyLanguage/Wikimedia projects</>|Wikimedia projects]] only [[<tvar|stewards>Special:MyLanguage/Stewards</>|stewards]] have full access to <tvar|spec-userrights2><code>Special:UserRights</code></>, while bureaucrats can add/remove only a subset of rights.</translate>
<translate>
<translate>
== Promoting users and bots == <!--T:5-->
== Promoting users and bots == <!--T:5-->
</translate>
</translate>
:''<translate><!--T:6-->
See also: a [[<tvar|help>Special:MyLanguage/Help:Promoting users</>|tutorial]]</translate>''


<translate><!--T:7-->
<translate><!--T:7-->
If you are a bureaucrat, to give or remove another user administrator, bureaucrat or bot access (or any other access), go to <tvar|spec-userrights>[[Special:UserRights]]</> on the wiki where you are a bureaucrat. There is a link to this on the list of [[<tvar|spec-pages>Special:Specialpages</>|special pages]].
If you are a bureaucrat, to give or remove another user administrator, bureaucrat or bot access (or any other access), go to <tvar name="spec-userrights">[[Special:UserRights]]</tvar> on the wiki where you are a bureaucrat. There is a link to this on the list of [[<tvar name="spec-pages">Special:Specialpages</tvar>|special pages]].


<!--T:8-->
<!--T:8-->
Line 28: Line 24:
</translate>
</translate>


[[{{lm|Userrights local|png}}|800px|alt=<translate><!--T:9-->
[[{{lm|Userrights local|png}}|800px|alt=<translate><!--T:9--> Screenshot showing the interface of <tvar name="spec-userrights"><code>Special:UserRights</code></tvar> on a local wiki.</translate>]]
Screenshot showing the interface of <tvar|spec-userrights><code>Special:UserRights</code></> on a local wiki.</translate>]]


<translate><!--T:10-->
<translate><!--T:10-->
Type the user's name into the box, and enter a reason for the change. Choose the rights you wish to assign/remove to the user by ticking/unticking the relevant boxes. Note that if the user group has an asterisk (*) next to it, you will not be able to remove it yourself. When you are done, press the ''<tvar|btn-save-ug>{{int:Saveusergroups}}</>'' button.
Type the user's name into the box, and enter a reason for the change. Choose the rights you wish to assign/remove to the user by ticking/unticking the relevant boxes. Note that if the user group has an asterisk (*) next to it, you will not be able to remove it yourself. When you are done, press the ''<tvar name="btn-save-ug">{{int:Saveusergroups}}</tvar>'' button.


<!--T:11-->
<!--T:11-->
The user will gain their access immediately and the action will be recorded at the [[<tvar|spec-log>Special:Log/rights</>|User rights log]].
The user will gain their access immediately and the action will be recorded at the [[<tvar name="spec-log">Special:Log/rights</tvar>|User rights log]].


<!--T:12-->
<!--T:12-->
If you make a mistake and need to remove an access level which you cannot remove, contact a [[<tvar|stewards>Special:MyLanguage/Stewards</>|steward]].
If you make a mistake and need to remove an access level which you cannot remove, contact a [[<tvar name="stewards">Special:MyLanguage/Stewards</tvar>|steward]].

== Renaming users == <!--T:13-->
</translate>
:''<translate><!--T:14-->
See also: a [[<tvar|help>Special:MyLanguage/Help:Renaming users</>|tutorial]]</translate>''

<translate><!--T:16-->
Prior to 15 September 2014, bureaucrats were able to rename local accounts through <tvar|spec-renameuser><code>Special:RenameUser</code></>. The <tvar|right-ru><code>renameuser</code></> right was [[<tvar|gerrit>gerrit:160158</>|removed]] from bureaucrats' toolset as part of [[<tvar|h-sul>Special:MyLanguage/SUL finalization</>|SUL finalization]]. After this date, only [[<tvar|stewards>Special:MyLanguage/Stewards</>|stewards]] are able to rename local accounts. Renaming of [[<tvar|h-ul>Special:MyLanguage/Help:Unified login</>|global accounts]] are now done by [[<tvar|gr>Special:MyLanguage/Global renamers</>|global renamers]] and stewards. See [[<tvar|grp>Special:MyLanguage/Global rename policy</>|global rename]] for details.
</translate>

{{anchor|Removing access}}
<translate>


== Removing access == <!--T:17-->
== Removing access == <!--T:17-->


<!--T:18-->
<!--T:18-->
Below is a list of public wikis where bureaucrats can remove sysop and bureaucrat access. Normally these removals have to be done by the stewards. On all private or fishbowl wikis, bureaucrats are able to remove both administrator and bureaucrat flags.
Below is a list of public wikis where [[<tvar name="1">Special:MyLanguage/Limits to configuration changes#Changes that are likely to be declined</tvar>|bureaucrats can remove]] sysop and/or bureaucrat access. Normally these removals have to be done by the stewards. On all private or fishbowl wikis, bureaucrats are able to remove both administrator and bureaucrat flags.
</translate>
</translate>

<!-- README: Please use YYYY-MM-DD (ie. 2022-02-12 for Feb 12, 2022). C.f. https://xkcd.com/1179/ -->

{| class="wikitable" style="width:100%"
{| class="wikitable" style="width:100%"
!colspan="4"|<translate><!--T:19-->
!colspan="4"|<translate><!--T:19--> both administrator and bureaucrat flags</translate>
both administrator and bureaucrat flags</translate>
|-
|-
!<translate><!--T:21--> Wiki</translate>
!<translate><!--T:21--> Wiki</translate>
Line 67: Line 52:
|- valign="top"
|- valign="top"
|-
|-
| <s> Meta </s> || <s>[[bugzilla:13509|bug 13509]]</s> || <s>24.04.2008</s> || Removed per [[phab:T106291]].
| <s>Meta</s> || <s>[[phab:T15509|bug 13509]]</s> || <s>2008-04-24</s> || Removed per [[phab:T106291]].
|-
|-
| <s>[[s:ru:|ru.wikisource]]</s> || <s>[[bugzilla:14568|bug 14568]]</s> || <s>05.07.2008</s> || <s>It looks like this was set inadvertently. </s> Now removed [[phab:T44105]]
| <s>[[s:ru:|ru.wikisource]]</s> || <s>[[phab:T16568|bug 14568]]</s> || <s>2008-07-05</s> || <s>It looks like this was set inadvertently. </s> Now removed [[phab:T44105]]
|-
|-
| [[wmse:|se chapter wiki]] || [[bugzilla:14665|bug 14665]] || 05.07.2008 || It looks like this was set inadvertently, but the Swedish chapter board [[bugzilla:42105#c29|wishes to keep]] this configuration.
| [[wmse:|se chapter wiki]] || [[phab:T16665|bug 14665]] || 2008-07-05 || It looks like this was set inadvertently, but the Swedish chapter board [[phabricator:T44105#463773|wishes to keep]] this configuration.
|-
|-
| <s>[[b:no:|no.wikibooks]]</s> || <s>[[bugzilla:13853|bug 13853]]</s> || <s>03.06.2009</s> || <s>It looks like this was set inadvertently.</s>Now removed [[bugzilla:42105]]
| <s>[[b:no:|no.wikibooks]]</s> || <s>[[phab:T15853|bug 13853]]</s> || <s>2009-06-03</s> || <s>It looks like this was set inadvertently.</s>Now removed [[phab:T44105|bugzilla:42105]]
|-
|-
| rowspan="2" | [[w:fi:|fi.wikipedia]]
| rowspan="2" | [[w:fi:|fi.wikipedia]]
| No bug || 04.03.2009 || Originally very likely to have been set inadvertently in March 2009.
| No bug || 2009-03-04 || Originally very likely to have been set inadvertently in March 2009.
|-
|-
| [[bugzilla:42114|bug 42114]] || 04.01.2013 || Local consensus reached (see bugs [[bugzilla:42114|42114]] and [[bugzilla:42105|42105]], and [//fi.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Kahvihuone_%28k%C3%A4yt%C3%A4nn%C3%B6t%29&oldid=12379948#Summary this summary]).
| [[phab:T44114|bug 42114]] || 2013-01-04 || Local consensus reached (see bugs [[phab:T44114|42114]] and [[phab:T44105|42105]], and [[:fi:Special:PermanentLink/12379948#Summary|this summary]]).
|-
|-
| [[wmfi:|fi chapter wiki]] || [[bugzilla:25668|bug 25668]] || 27.10.2010 ||
| [[wmfi:|fi chapter wiki]] || [[phab:T27668|bug 25668]] || 2010-10-27 ||
|-
|-
| <s>[[wm2014:|wikimania2014 wiki]]</s>|| <s>[[bugzilla:55480|bug 55480]]</s> || <s>11.10.2013</s> || Wiki closed, reset to default.
| <s>[[wm2014:|wikimania2014 wiki]]</s>|| <s>[[phab:T57480|bug 55480]]</s> || <s>2013-10-11</s> || Wiki closed, reset to default.
|-
|-
| [[wmbr:|br.wikimedia]] || {{phab|T65345}} || 2014-04-17 || [https://br.wikimedia.org/wiki/?oldid=33792 consensus]
| [[w:hu:|hu.wikipedia]] || [[bugzilla:72055|bug 72055]] || 16.10.2014 ||
|-
|-
| [[w:hu:|hu.wikipedia]] || [[phab:T74055|bug 72055]] || 2014-10-16 ||
| [[w:pt:|pt.wikipedia]] || [[phabricator:T107661|bug T107661]] || 11.08.2015 || [[:w:pt:Wikipédia:Esplanada/propostas/Implementar a remoção local do estatuto de administrador (20jul2015)|Local consensus]]
|-
|-
| [[w:pt:|pt.wikipedia]] || [[phabricator:T107661|bug T107661]] || 2015-08-11 || [[:w:pt:Wikipédia:Esplanada/propostas/Implementar a remoção local do estatuto de administrador (20jul2015)|Local consensus]]
!colspan="4"|<translate><!--T:25-->
only administrator flag</translate>
|-
|-
| [[wmco:|co.wikimedia ]] || [[phab:T300779|task T300779]] || 2022-02-02 || Non-fishbowl chapter wiki.
| [[wikt:|en.wiktionary]] || No bug || || Per [http://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?oldid=19278091 a community vote] and [[bugzilla:42113|bug 42113]], enwiktionary bureaucrats lost the power to remove the bureaucrat right (which was apparently never asked for).
|-
|-
!colspan="4"|<translate><!--T:25--> only administrator flag</translate>
| <s>[[wmpa-us:|pa-us chapter wiki]]</s> || <s>[[bugzilla:10611|bug 10611]]</s> || <s>16.09.2008</s> || Wiki was closed.
|-
|-
| [[testwiki:|test.wiki]] || || ||
| <s>[[wmuk:|uk chapter wiki]]</s> || <s>[[bugzilla:17388|bug 17388]]</s> || <s>26.02.2009</s> || Wiki was redirected.
|-
|-
| [[w:simple:|simple.wikipedia]] || [[bugzilla:20271|bug 20271]] || 24.09.2009 ||
| [[test2wiki:|test2.wiki]] || || ||
|-
|-
| [[wikt:|en.wiktionary]] || No bug || || Per [http://en.wiktionary.org/w/index.php?oldid=19278091 a community vote] and [[phab:T44113|bug 42113]], enwiktionary bureaucrats lost the power to remove the bureaucrat right (which was apparently never asked for).
| [[wikt:simple:|simple.wiktionary]] || [[bugzilla:22522|bug 22522]] || 22.02.2010 ||
|-
|-
| [[n:|en.wikinews]] || [[bugzilla:23392|bug 23392]] || 08.05.2010 ||
| <s>[[wmpa-us:|pa-us chapter wiki]]</s> || <s>[[phab:T12611|bug 10611]]</s> || <s>2008-09-16</s> || Wiki was closed.
|-
|-
| <s>[[wikt:hi:|hi.wiktionary]]</s> || <s>[[bugzilla:29702|bug 29702]]</s> || <s>11.07.2011</s> || Removed per {{phab|T214765}}.
| <s>[[wmuk:|uk chapter wiki]]</s> || <s>[[phab:T19388|bug 17388]]</s> || <s>2009-02-26</s> || Wiki was redirected.
|-
|-
| [[w:|en.wikipedia]] || [[bugzilla:18390|bug 18390]] || 11.08.2011 ||
| [[w:simple:|simple.wikipedia]] || [[phab:T22271|bug 20271]] || 2009-09-24 ||
|-
|-
| [[w:ru:|ru.wikipedia]] || [[bugzilla:30307|bug 30307]] || 11.08.2011 ||
| [[wikt:simple:|simple.wiktionary]] || [[phab:T24522|bug 22522]] || 2010-02-22 ||
|-
|-
| [[outreachwiki:|outreach.wiki]] || [[phab:T25118|bug 23118]] || 2010-04-09 || Ability to remove bureaucrat flag was removed in [[phab:T214133]].
| [[w:ba:|ba.wikipedia]] || [[bugzilla:33769|bug 33769]] || 17.01.2012 ||
|-
|-
| [[n:|en.wikinews]] || [[phab:T25392|bug 23392]] || 2010-05-08 ||
| [[w:fr:|fr.wikipedia]] || [[bugzilla:35258|bug 35258]] || 12.04.2012 ||[https://fr.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipédia:Prise_de_décision/Droit_de_retrait_du_statut_d%27administrateur_par_les_bureaucrates&oldid=162051287 Community Consensus]
|-
|-
| [[voy:en:|en.wikivoyage]] || [[bugzilla:43851|bug 43851]] || 17.01.2013 ||
| <s>[[wikt:hi:|hi.wiktionary]]</s> || <s>[[phab:T31702|bug 29702]]</s> || <s>2011-07-11</s> || Removed per {{phab|T214765}}.
|-
|-
| [[testwiki:|test.wiki]] || || ||
| [[w:|en.wikipedia]] || [[phab:T20390|bug 18390]] || 2011-08-11 ||
|-
|-
| [[w:ru:|ru.wikipedia]] || [[phab:T32307|bug 30307]] || 2011-08-11 || [[w:ru:Википедия:Опросы/Предоставление бюрократам технической возможности для снятия флага с администраторов|Community consensus]]
| [[fa:|fa.wikipedia]] || [[phab:T140810|T140810]] || 20.07.2016 || [//fa.wikipedia.org?oldid=17637262#.D8.AF.D8.B3.D8.AA.D8.B1.D8.B3.DB.8C_.D8.AF.DB.8C.D9.88.D8.A7.D9.86.D8.B3.D8.A7.D9.84.D8.A7.D8.B1.D8.A7.D9.86 Community consensus]
|-
|-
| [[w:ba:|ba.wikipedia]] || [[phab:T35769|bug 33769]] || 2012-01-17 ||
| [[outreachwiki:|outreach.wiki]] || [[bugzilla:23118|bug 23118]] || 09.04.2010 || Ability to remove bureaucrat flag was removed in [[phab:T214133]].
|-
|-
| [[w:fr:|fr.wikipedia]] || [[phab:T37258|bug 35258]] || 2012-04-12 ||[[:fr:Special:PermanentLink/162051287|Community consensus]]
| [[wmnyc:|nyc.wikimedia]] || {{phab|T226591}} || 26.06.2019 || Wikimedia New York City Chapter wiki.
|-
|-
| [[c:|commons]] || {{Phab|T261481}} || 06.10.2020 || [[:c:Commons:Village pump/Proposals/Archive/2020/08#Proposal: Allow bureaucrats to remove administrator permission|Community consensus]]
| [[voy:en:|en.wikivoyage]] || [[phab:T45851|bug 43851]] || 2013-01-17 || [[:voy:en:Wikivoyage talk:Bureaucrats#Local removal of adminship|Community consensus]]
|-
|-
| [[fa:|fa.wikipedia]] || [[phab:T140810|T140810]] || 2016-07-20 || [//fa.wikipedia.org?oldid=17637262#.D8.AF.D8.B3.D8.AA.D8.B1.D8.B3.DB.8C_.D8.AF.DB.8C.D9.88.D8.A7.D9.86.D8.B3.D8.A7.D9.84.D8.A7.D8.B1.D8.A7.D9.86 Community consensus]
| [[test2wiki:|test2.wiki]] || || ||
|-
| [[wmnyc:|nyc.wikimedia]] || {{phab|T226591}} || 2019-06-26 || Wikimedia New York City Chapter wiki.
|-
| [[wmbd:|bd.wikimedia]] || {{Phab|T251078}} || 2020-04-28 ||
|-
| [[c:|commons]] || {{Phab|T261481}} || 2020-10-06 || [[:c:Commons:Village pump/Proposals/Archive/2020/08#Proposal: Allow bureaucrats to remove administrator permission|Community consensus]]
|-
| [[w:de:|de.wikipedia]] || {{Phab|T331921}} || 2023-04-20 || [[:de:Wikipedia:Meinungsbilder/Zusätzliche Rechte für Bürokraten|Community consensus]]
|}
|}
{{user groups}}
{{user groups}}

Latest revision as of 07:11, 28 May 2024

Within Wikimedia projects, a bureaucrat is a user who has the technical ability to:

  • Promote other users to administrator or bureaucrat;
  • Grant and revoke a user's bot flag;
  • Add and remove users from the interface-admin group;
  • Add and remove users from custom local groups created by local consensus like account creator, deleter, etc.;
  • Remove a user's administrator and/or bureaucrat flags on some projects listed below.

Stewards fulfill these roles on wikis without bureaucrats using the requests for permissions page. A small community generally doesn't require a local bureaucrat, because stewards can easily handle the low traffic of requests from that wiki with little delay; generally a user with this access is not needed until several local administrators are present. Other positions may be subject to global policies like the Checkuser policy and the Oversight policy, which define minimum community requirements. The default configuration of the MediaWiki software permits bureaucrats with access to Special:UserRights to add and remove users from all user groups. On Wikimedia projects only stewards have full access to Special:UserRights, while bureaucrats can add/remove only a subset of rights.

Promoting users and bots[edit]

If you are a bureaucrat, to give or remove another user administrator, bureaucrat or bot access (or any other access), go to Special:UserRights on the wiki where you are a bureaucrat. There is a link to this on the list of special pages.

You will see the following form:

Screenshot showing the interface of Special:UserRights on a local wiki.

Type the user's name into the box, and enter a reason for the change. Choose the rights you wish to assign/remove to the user by ticking/unticking the relevant boxes. Note that if the user group has an asterisk (*) next to it, you will not be able to remove it yourself. When you are done, press the Save user groups button.

The user will gain their access immediately and the action will be recorded at the User rights log.

If you make a mistake and need to remove an access level which you cannot remove, contact a steward.

Removing access[edit]

Below is a list of public wikis where bureaucrats can remove sysop and/or bureaucrat access. Normally these removals have to be done by the stewards. On all private or fishbowl wikis, bureaucrats are able to remove both administrator and bureaucrat flags.


both administrator and bureaucrat flags
Wiki Bug Fixed on Notes
Meta bug 13509 2008-04-24 Removed per phab:T106291.
ru.wikisource bug 14568 2008-07-05 It looks like this was set inadvertently. Now removed phab:T44105
se chapter wiki bug 14665 2008-07-05 It looks like this was set inadvertently, but the Swedish chapter board wishes to keep this configuration.
no.wikibooks bug 13853 2009-06-03 It looks like this was set inadvertently.Now removed bugzilla:42105
fi.wikipedia No bug 2009-03-04 Originally very likely to have been set inadvertently in March 2009.
bug 42114 2013-01-04 Local consensus reached (see bugs 42114 and 42105, and this summary).
fi chapter wiki bug 25668 2010-10-27
wikimania2014 wiki bug 55480 2013-10-11 Wiki closed, reset to default.
br.wikimedia task T65345 2014-04-17 consensus
hu.wikipedia bug 72055 2014-10-16
pt.wikipedia bug T107661 2015-08-11 Local consensus
co.wikimedia task T300779 2022-02-02 Non-fishbowl chapter wiki.
only administrator flag
test.wiki
test2.wiki
en.wiktionary No bug Per a community vote and bug 42113, enwiktionary bureaucrats lost the power to remove the bureaucrat right (which was apparently never asked for).
pa-us chapter wiki bug 10611 2008-09-16 Wiki was closed.
uk chapter wiki bug 17388 2009-02-26 Wiki was redirected.
simple.wikipedia bug 20271 2009-09-24
simple.wiktionary bug 22522 2010-02-22
outreach.wiki bug 23118 2010-04-09 Ability to remove bureaucrat flag was removed in phab:T214133.
en.wikinews bug 23392 2010-05-08
hi.wiktionary bug 29702 2011-07-11 Removed per task T214765.
en.wikipedia bug 18390 2011-08-11
ru.wikipedia bug 30307 2011-08-11 Community consensus
ba.wikipedia bug 33769 2012-01-17
fr.wikipedia bug 35258 2012-04-12 Community consensus
en.wikivoyage bug 43851 2013-01-17 Community consensus
fa.wikipedia T140810 2016-07-20 Community consensus
nyc.wikimedia task T226591 2019-06-26 Wikimedia New York City Chapter wiki.
bd.wikimedia task T251078 2020-04-28
commons task T261481 2020-10-06 Community consensus
de.wikipedia task T331921 2023-04-20 Community consensus