Requests for new languages: Difference between revisions

Add links
From Meta, a Wikimedia project coordination wiki
Browse history interactively
← Older edit
Content deleted Content added
VisualWikitext
Tag: 2017 source edit
 
Line 1: Line 1:
{{LangCom discussion}}
'''''Note:''' In the very near future this page, among others, will be integrated into the process at [[incubator:Incubator:New language Requests|Wikimedia Incubator]]. You may wish to withhold suggestions until the interchange is complete.''
{{process header

| title = [[Requests for new languages]]
{{Projects}}
| section =
''This page is intended for discussing the creation of new language editions of existing projects. This is not the page to [[Proposals for new projects|propose a new project]].''
| previous = ←[[Special:MyLanguage/Meta:Index/Requests and proposals|Requests and proposals]]

| next = [[:Category:Requests for new languages|Archives]]→
----
| shortcut = [[RFL]]
The [[Wikimedia Foundation]] aims to facilitate the dissemination of knowledge in many different languages. Currently, wikis have been created in over 200 languages. If you would like to work in a language that does not yet have a wiki, you may request it here.
| notes = This page lists requests for new language wikis of existing projects (to start an entirely new project, see [[Proposals for new projects|requests for new projects]]). '''All requests must conform to the [[Meta:Language proposal policy|Language proposal policy]]''' (see [[Language committee/Handbook (requesters)#Making a new request|instructions for adding a new request]]).

==Procedure==
There are several steps to follow if you would like to create a new language [[Wikipedia]], [[Wiktionary]], [[Wikibooks]], [[Wikisource]], or [[Wikiquote]]. The [[Wikimedia Commons]] and [[Wikispecies]] are multi-lingual projects, meaning that there are no separate editions for individual languages. The Wikisource project has [http://wikisource.org/wiki/Wikisource:Language_domain_requests its own page] to request a new language.

#Peruse the [[complete list of Wikimedia projects]]. If the language you are looking for is not listed, look for very similar languages. Your proposed language must be sufficiently different, in its written form, from any other already-created language.
#You '''must''' have an account here on the [[Meta]] wiki.
#Copy and paste the [[#Template|template]] to the '''end''' of the [[#Discussion ongoing|discussion ongoing]] section.
#Find the [http://www.loc.gov/standards/iso639-2/englangn.html ISO 639-2 code] or [[#What do I do if there is no ISO code for my language?|propose a code for your language]] (for future compatibility, be sure to consult the [http://www.sil.org/iso639-3/ ISO 639-'''3''' ''draft''], which covers most of the world's languages).
#Fill in '''all''' fields in the template.
#If many potential contributors to your language's wiki are likely to speak a different language that already has a wiki, try and drum up support at a community discussion area on that wiki. Encourage anyone who wants to contribute to your proposed language to come to this page and add their support for your proposal.
#If there is a consensus to create a wiki in your proposed language, send a message to the appropriate [[mailing list]] asking a developer to set up the wiki.
#Be patient, as our [[developer]]s are very busy volunteers. You may work on articles, interface files and help or instruction pages using an offline word processor so that you can quickly get your new wiki going. You may want to look at the [[List of articles all languages should have]].

==FAQ==

* 1. What do I do if there is no ISO code for my language?
** If there is no standard code (no [http://www.loc.gov/standards/iso639-2/langhome.html ISO code]) for your language, you will need to propose a code that is more than three letters long. The most standard way to create a code is to use a generic code for a language family (such as ''gem'' for Germanic languages) and a three letter code for the proposed language, resulting in codes like ''fiu-vro'' (from the code for ''other Finno-Ugric languages'' and the Voro language) and ''roa-rup'' (from the code for ''other Romance languages'' and the Aromanian language). This procedure may not be ideal for all circumstances, but should be followed if reasonable.
* 2. How do I know if my language is sufficiently different from a language that already has a wiki?
** This is an issue that is decided by consensus.
* 3. Can there be wikis in ancient languages?
** Yes. There are already wikis available in [[:en:Latin|Latin]], [[:en:Old English language|Old English]], [[:en:Gothic language|Gothic]] and [[:en:Pali|Pali]].
** Please add new requests for wikis in ancient languages to [[Requests for new languages/Ancient]].
* 4. Can there be wikis in artificial languages?
** Yes. There are already wikis available in [[:en:Esperanto|Esperanto]], [[:en:Ido|Ido]], [[:en:Interlingua|Interlingua]], [[:en:Occidental language|Interlingue]], [[:en:Lojban|Lojban]] , [[en:Volapük|Volapük]]. There used to be a [[:en:Toki Pona|Toki Pona]] wiki, but it was decided that the Toki Pona language was not used widely enough to support a wiki.
** '''However''', it is quite possible that a fictional language will get little favor. Many considered the existence of the [[:en:Klingon language|Klingon]] Wikipedia to be unacceptable, and a proposal to shut it down eventually succeeded (See also [[Talk:Requests for new languages/Archive#Klingon|Talk page]]).
** Please place all new requests for Wikipedias in artificial languages at [[Requests for new languages/Non-natural]].
* 5. How many speakers are necessary?
** No language has ever been refused ''solely'' because of an insufficient number of speakers. For natural languages, this will probably never be an issue; for artificial languages, however, a low number of speakers may be taken as evidence that the language is not widely spoken enough to deserve a wiki.
** The actual number of users who know the language and work on the wiki is an important issue, but it is not known how many are necessary for a wiki to gain momentum and solid growth. The dedication of the users may be more important than the number, since a few devoted users may write more, and higher quality, articles than a larger number of casual users.

==Template==
{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= Name of the proposer and Wiki accounts in Meta and in Wikipedia
|User accounts of others= User accounts of others
|Language code= Language code
|Proposed domain= Proposed domain
|Wikipedia article= Wikipedia article
|Native name= Native name
|English name= English name or description
|Number of speakers= Number of speakers
|Locations spoken= Locations spoken
|Related languages= Related languages
|Promoting organizations= Promoting organizations
|Request on mailing list= Request on mailing list
}}
}}
{{lc-navigation}}


__TOC__
==Moved requests ==
*All conlangs, play languages (such as Pig Latin or leet), and fictional languages: [[Requests for new languages/Non-natural]] and [[Requests for new languages/Tolkien languages]] (Quenya, Sindarin)
*All ancient languages: [[Requests for new languages/Ancient]]
*Sinitic languages / Chinese dialects: [[Requests for new languages/China]] and [[Proposal for Sinitic linguistic policy]]
*Luba-Katanga, South Ndebele, North Ndebele, Ojibwe, Tigre, Inari Sami, Skolt Sami, Indian English, Kokborok, Porjidlo: [[Requests for new languages/No supporters]]
*Hindustani, Unserdeutsch, Mayan, Mikasuki, Real Dutch, Palauan, Haida, Azeri with other alphabets, Silbo Gomero, Fala&Extremaduran, American English, Bahasa Riau, Filipino, Rotas: [[Requests for new languages/One supporter]]
*Simple German: [[Requests for new languages/Einfach]]
*Former USSR minority languages: Aleut, Crimean, Erzya, Ingush, Karachay-Balkar, Karakalpak, Mari, Moksha, Tuvinian, Yakut [[Requests for new languages/Former USSR]]
* [[Requests for new languages/Archive]]
* [[Requests for new languages/Denied]]
* [[Approved requests for new languages]]
* [[Requests for new languages/Native speaker support]]


{{anchor|Requests}}
==Discussion ongoing==
==Open requests==
''Please don't forget to log in (especially if you want to vote on a request). Thank you!''
See also the related edit logs: [[Special:Recentchangeslinked/Category:Open requests for new languages|open]], [[Special:Recentchangeslinked/Category:Waiting requests for new languages|on hold]], [[Special:Recentchangeslinked/Category:Requests for new languages verified as eligible|verified as eligible]].
<!-- PLEASE ALWAYS ***SORT ALPHABETICALLY***; the alphabet is this: ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ! If title is having diacritics, please also consider that letter as without diacritics, this is following the rules of machine-readable codes of passport -->


=== Wikibooks ===
{{requests for new languages/pl-sl}}
<!-- PLEASE SORT ALPHABETICALLY; the alphabet is this: ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ! -->
{| class="wikitable sortable"
|+Wikibooks requests
|-
!scope="col"| Project
!scope="col"| Official status
!scope="col"| Status since
!scope="col"| Notes
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Ancash Quechua | eligible | 2018-09-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Assamese | eligible | 2019-12-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Badaga | eligible | 2009-11-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Burmese | eligible | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Cantonese | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Cebuano 2 | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Central Bikol | eligible | 2022-10-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Dusun | eligible | 2018-02-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Gilaki | eligible | 2008-01-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Gujarati | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Hausa | discussion | 2023-07-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Interlingue | discussion | 2023-04-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Javanese 2 | eligible | 2007-05-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Ladino | eligible | 2014-01-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Latvian | eligible | 2010-09-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Min Dong Chinese | eligible | 2021-08-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Nias | eligible | 2021-06-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Pashto | eligible | 2017-12-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Saraiki | eligible | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Sindhi 2 | eligible | 2017-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Sylheti | discussion | 2022-11-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Talysh | eligible | 2022-10-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Zazaki | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
|}


=== Wikinews ===
===Pfälzisch (15 support, 6 oppose<!--that anonymous vote should not be taken seriously-->, 2 neutral)===
<!-- PLEASE SORT ALPHABETICALLY; the alphabet is this: ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ! -->
{{New-language-template
{| class="wikitable sortable"
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= [[de:Benutzer:SPS]], [[de:Benutzer:PälzerBu]], [[de:Benutzer:Mundartpoet]]
|+Wikinews requests
|User accounts of others=
|-
|Language code= pfl (ISO 639-3)
!scope="col"| Project
|Proposed domain= pfl.wikipedia.org
!scope="col"| Official status
|Wikipedia article= [[de:Pfälzische Dialekte]]
!scope="col"| Status since
|Native name= Pälzisch
!scope="col"| Notes
|English name= Palatinian Franconian (germanic)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Afrikaans | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
|Number of speakers=
{{lc-row| Wikinews Amharic | eligible | 2008-05-25 }}
|Locations spoken= much of Rhineland-Palatinate in Germany, some neighboring areas, several emigration communities (in the Americas + elsewhere)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Armenian | eligible | 2012-12-25 }}
|Related languages= the [[en:West Central German]] dialects, including [[en:Luxembourgish dialect]]
{{lc-row| Wikinews Assamese | eligible | 2022-10-04 }}
|Promoting organizations=
{{lc-row| Wikinews Azerbaijani | eligible | 2011-03-30 }}
|Request on mailing list=
{{lc-row| Wikinews Basic English | discussion | 2024-02-03 }}
}}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Basque | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
Words from person who made the request: Pfälzisch (in English perhaps Palatinian) is a German dialect, spoken in the South-West. Nearly everyone who lives there and whose ancestors come from there is able to speak the dialect. [[User:84.171.216.148|84.171.216.148]] January 6, 2005 14:53 (CET)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Belarusian | eligible | 2019-01-25 }}
*'''Support'''--[[User:Fratele lui Bonaparte, il cunosti?|Fratele lui Bonaparte, il cunosti?]] 17:01, 8 August 2006 (UTC)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Bengali | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
*'''Support''' - [[User:Belgian man|Belgian man]] <small>([[:nl:Gebruiker:Cars en travel|nl]] [[:na:User:Belgian man|na]] [[en:User:Belgian man|en]])</small> 13:15, 7 January 2006 (UTC)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Cantonese 2 | eligible | 2010-02-28 }}
*'''Support'''. [[User:Caesarion|Caesarion]] Dear anonymous user, did you post a message about this at [[de:Wikipedia:Fragen zur Wikipedia]]? 13:50, 7 January 2006 (UTC)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Croatian | eligible | 2011-03-30 }}
*'''Support''' Come on. There is a Ripuarian Wikipedia, so why not a Palation one??? --[[User:Abzt|Abzt]] 16:53, 23 May 2006 (UTC)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Danish | eligible | 2010-07-30 }}
*'''Neutral''', because I would like to get more information. But I've added the template above and the links to articles about the language, where there was only a ''poor'' paragraph to request. German users are the key for this request. I hope they will have some interest for it, and find enough native or advanced users to help it. :o) [[User:Hégésippe Cormier|Hégésippe]] | [[User talk:Hégésippe Cormier|±Θ±]] 05:22, 9 January 2006 (UTC)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Dusun | eligible | 2018-02-13 }}
*'''moderate Support'''. I love the language, several near to me use it every day. I cannot support it as an author because I'm not in sufficient command of the language. Hint: [[Approved_requests_for_new_languages#Pennsylvania German (17 support; 1 oppose)|Approved_requests_for_new_languages]] has a section titled ''Pennsylvania German'' which is a closely related yet distinct language. [[User:Purodha|Purodha Blissenbach]] 01:37, 10 January 2006 (UTC)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Galego | eligible | 2011-08-15 }}
* '''Oppose''' - Who on earth would benefit from a Wikipedia in this German dialect? Not a single person because _every_ single speaker knows High German just as well or better. I don't live there but I bet when they write something down they write it down not in dialect but in High German like just everybody else in Germany. High German has specialised terms for all fields of science, the dialects mostly don't. The High German wikipedia will always be a source of information many times bigger and better then the Pfälzisch one - so the Pfälzisch one will actually be useless. I could go on with a few more points but I think it's enough now. -- [[User:Raetius|Raetius]] 11:56, 10 January 2006 (UTC)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Georgian | eligible | 2008-11-05 }}
**We have had some very similar discussions before: Pfälzisch should be considered a seperate language - and would, if the concepts of Germany, Germans and "the" German language didn't exist. [[User:Caesarion|Caesarion]] 13:17, 10 January 2006 (UTC)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Gilaki | eligible | 2008-01-14 }}
** [[User:Raetius|Raetius]] is wrong. I personally know ''many'' people from Palatinate who do not speak the so called "High German" although they moderately understand it on TV etc. when they read (German) books or newspapers loudly, they do so in palatinian. Whenever wording or grammar do not match well enough, the outcome is funny for non-Palatinians. The majority of those people is from rural areas, elderly, hardly computer-literate, neither reading or writing English; so they're unlikely to show up here and vote. -- [[User:Purodha|Purodha Blissenbach]] 13:59, 25 April 2006 (UTC)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Hindi | eligible | 2008-04-22 }}
* '''Oppose''' - Pfälzisch is not a separate language, just a specific mispronouncing of a German province. Moreover, where should this trend to create new splitted WPs lead? [[User:84.163.38.161|84.163.38.161]] 21:29, 10 January 2006 (UTC)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Indonesian | eligible | 2010-03-27 }}
**Sorry, but if still have the dumb conviction that regioanl languages are "mispronunciations" of standard languages, you have '''absolutely NO business here!!!''' Dialects are older, much, much older than standard languages, start reading at least ''something'' about West Germanic dialects before you '''ever''' do one edit to this page again! [[User:Caesarion|Caesarion]] 23:16, 11 January 2006 (UTC)
{{lc-row| Wikinews Javanese | eligible | 2008-04-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Kazakh 2 | discussion | 2023-03-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Khowar | eligible | 2017-12-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Kurdish | eligible | 2010-03-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Kurdish (Sorani) | eligible | 2018-02-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Kupang Malay | discussion | 2020-08-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Ladino | eligible | 2022-10-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Lithuanian | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Low Saxon | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Macedonian | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Malagasy | eligible | 2009-02-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Malay | eligible | 2008-08-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Malayalam | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Marathi | eligible | 2017-02-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Min Dong Chinese | eligible | 2018-09-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Nepali | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Pashto | eligible | 2018-09-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Pipil | eligible | 2018-12-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Pu-Xian Min | eligible | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Saraiki | eligible | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Shan | eligible | 2022-10-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Sicilian | eligible | 2008-11-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Sinhala | eligible | 2010-12-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Slovak | discussion | 2023-06-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Slovene | eligible | 2008-05-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Sylheti | eligible | 2022-10-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Tagalog | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Tatar | eligible | 2022-10-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Thai | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Tswana | eligible | 2022-10-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Urdu | eligible | 2009-01-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Uyghur | eligible | 2010-02-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Vietnamese | eligible | 2011-04-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Western Panjabi | eligible | 2018-02-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Zazaki | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
|}


=== Wikipedia ===
*'''Neutral''' - by the way, I oppose a Portuguese wikipedia. Portuguese is not a separate language. It's just a mispronouncing of a Spanish province. [[User:Stettlerj|Stettlerj]] 22:21, 11 January 2006 (UTC)
<!-- PLEASE SORT ALPHABETICALLY; the alphabet is this: ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ! -->
{| class="wikitable sortable"
|+Wikipedia requests
|-
!scope="col"| Project
!scope="col"| Official status
!scope="col"| Status since
!scope="col"| Notes
{{lc-row| Wikipedia ǃXóõ | waiting | 2023-03-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Achomi | discussion | 2020-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Acoli | discussion | 2020-06-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Adilabad Gondi | discussion | 2023-04-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Aghem | eligible | 2017-01-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ahirani | eligible | 2011-12-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ainu 2 | eligible | 2018-07-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Akkadian | discussion | 2024-04-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Aklanon | eligible | 2017-01-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Akoose | eligible | 2012-05-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Akpa | discussion | 2021-03-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Alabama | eligible | 2008-09-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia American Sign Language 2| eligible | 2008-11-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ancash Quechua | eligible | 2018-02-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ancient Greek 4 | discussion | 2013-04-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Angolar Creole | discussion | 2024-03-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Angkola | discussion | 2021-03-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ao | eligible | 2007-04-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Arakan | eligible | 2022-10-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Arbëresh | discussion | 2022-03-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Asi | eligible | 2017-01-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Assyrian Neo Aramaic | eligible | 2017-02-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Badaga | eligible | 2009-11-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bafia | eligible | 2018-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bajjika | waiting | 2023-06-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bakhtiari | eligible | 2008-06-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Balantak | discussion | 2020-08-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Balkan Romani | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Balochi | discussion | 2010-06-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bangka | eligible | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Baniwa | eligible | 2011-06-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Baoulé | eligible | 2017-01-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bari | eligible | 2017-01-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Basaa | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Belgorod Dialect | discussion | 2023-01-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bodo | eligible | 2017-01-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bole | discussion | 2023-11-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bororo | discussion | 2022-12-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Brahui | eligible | 2010-04-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Brazilian Sign Language| eligible | 2018-10-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia British Sign Language | eligible | 2010-11-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Buhinon | discussion | 2023-08-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bunun | eligible | 2019-04-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Cajun French | eligible | 2007-07-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Caló | discussion | 2023-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Campidanese Sardinian | eligible | 2017-03-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Canadian French | discussion | 2020-02-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Cape Verdean Creole | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Capiznon | eligible | 2010-01-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Caribbean Hindustani | eligible | 2017-01-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Carpathian Romani | discussion | 2020-11-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Central Alaskan Yup'ik | eligible | 2010-08-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Central Dusun | eligible | 2011-07-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Central Kanuri | discussion | 2023-07-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Central Morocco Tamazight| eligible | 2009-07-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Central Tagbanwa | discussion | 2023-08-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Chakma | eligible | 2018-06-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Chesterian | discussion | 2021-04-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Chhattisgarhi | eligible | 2017-01-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Chinuk wawa | eligible | 2018-02-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Chitonga | discussion | 2023-06-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Chittagonian | eligible | 2022-12-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Choctaw | eligible | 2018-06-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Chuj | discussion | 2022-09-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Chukchi | eligible | 2017-01-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Classical Japanese 3 | discussion | 2022-04-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Coptic 3 | eligible | 2017-07-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Damascene | discussion | 2023-11-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dangme | discussion | 2023-08-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dargwa | eligible | 2017-01-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dendi | eligible | 2023-04-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dholuo | eligible | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dimasa | eligible | 2018-12-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dobrujan Tatar | discussion | 2023-10-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dogri | eligible | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Duala | eligible | 2017-01-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia East Franconian German | eligible | 2013-10-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia East Frisian 3 | discussion | 2020-02-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Eastern Arrernte | discussion | 2021-07-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Eastern Balochi | discussion | 2010-08-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Eastern Bolivian Guaraní| eligible | 2017-02-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Eastern Pwo | eligible | 2018-10-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Efik | eligible | 2023-01-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ekpeye | discussion | 2024-05-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Eldeine | discussion | 2021-04-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Elfdalian 2 | eligible | 2017-02-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Eton | eligible | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ewondo | eligible | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Fala | eligible | 2017-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Falam-Chin | eligible | 2017-01-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Fataluku | eligible | 2010-10-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Finnish Sign Language | eligible | 2008-11-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia French Simple 3 | eligible | 2018-09-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Galo | discussion | 2020-10-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Garhwali | eligible | 2017-01-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gayo 2 | discussion | 2020-06-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gęlþaska | discussion | 2023-12-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gheg | eligible | 2008-01-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ghomala | eligible | 2017-01-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ghomara | discussion | 2024-04-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Goalpariya | eligible | 2018-08-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Guadeloupe Creole | discussion | 2023-04-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gutnish | discussion | 2016-01-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hadauti | discussion | 2023-05-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hainanese 2 | waiting | 2019-11-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hakha-Chin | eligible | 2008-02-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hanja 3 | discussion | 2022-10-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Haryanvi | eligible | 2018-04-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hassaniya | discussion | 2023-01-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hawrami | eligible | 2010-11-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hijazi Arabic | discussion | 2016-02-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hiligaynon 2 | eligible | 2007-08-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hindko | discussion | 2022-02-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hindustani 3 | discussion | 2013-05-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hla’alua | eligible | 2018-10-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hmong Daw | eligible | 2010-10-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ho | discussion | 2016-10-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hsilgne | discussion | 2023-12-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hutsul | discussion | 2016-10-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Iban | eligible | 2010-02-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ingrian | eligible | 2018-04-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Innu-aimun | eligible | 2017-07-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Interglossa | discussion | 2023-08-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia International Sign | discussion | 2023-11-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Interslavic | discussion | 2024-05-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Jambi Malay | eligible | 2021-06-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Jazayri | eligible | 2009-07-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Jeju 2 | eligible | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Juǀ'hoan | waiting | 2019-01-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Jutish | discussion | 2016-05-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kaili | discussion | 2020-10-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kalanga | discussion | 2020-08-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kalasha | discussion | 2016-04-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kanakanavu | eligible | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kanikkaran | eligible | 2009-11-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kaqchikel | eligible | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Karai-Karai | discussion | 2023-08-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Karaim | discussion | 2021-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Karbi | discussion | 2016-08-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Karelian 2 | eligible | 2008-04-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Karuk | waiting | 2019-04-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kavalan | eligible | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Keliko | discussion | 2023-11-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Khakas | eligible | 2018-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Khasi | eligible | 2010-10-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Khinalug | eligible | 2018-07-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Khmu | discussion | 2021-07-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Khorasani Turkic | eligible | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Khowar | eligible | 2017-01-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kichwa | eligible | 2017-12-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kildin Sami | eligible | 2018-04-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kiluba | discussion | 2016-07-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kinaray-a 2 | eligible | 2007-04-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kirmanjki | eligible | 2008-09-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kohistani Shina | discussion | 2022-12-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Komering | eligible | 2024-02-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Koyraboro Senni Songhay| waiting | 2019-04-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Krio | eligible | 2008-01-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kriol | eligible | 2019-12-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Krymchak | discussion | 2023-01-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kumyk | eligible | 2017-10-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kupang Malay 2 | discussion | 2020-07-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kutchi | eligible | 2018-01-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kven 2 | eligible | 2019-06-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Láadan | discussion | 2022-02-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Laki | eligible | 2013-02-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Lakota | eligible | 2018-04-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Laz 2 | eligible | 2010-02-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Levantine Arabic | eligible | 2021-08-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Libon Bikol | discussion | 2023-08-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Limbu | eligible | 2019-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Livonian | eligible | 2011-07-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Logudorese Sardinian | discussion | 2022-03-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Louisiana Creole | discussion | 2016-09-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Lower Silesian | eligible | 2008-08-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Lushootseed | discussion | 2023-01-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Magahi | discussion | 2021-06-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Maghrebi Arabic | discussion | 2015-05-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Maguindanaon | discussion | 2023-11-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Makassar Malay | discussion | 2016-03-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Makassarese | eligible | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Makhuwa | discussion | 2023-10-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mam | eligible | 2018-03-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mampruli | discussion | 2023-03-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Manado Malay | discussion | 2020-06-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Manobo | discussion | 2020-09-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Manchu 2 | eligible | 2018-01-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mandailing | eligible | 2018-12-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mandar | waiting | 2019-11-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mapudungun 2 | eligible | 2009-07-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mara | discussion | 2020-07-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Marwari | eligible | 2018-04-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Marwari (Pakistan) | waiting | 2019-01-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Masbateño | discussion | 2023-08-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mauritian Creole | eligible | 2008-09-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Meänkieli 2 | eligible | 2010-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Medumba | waiting | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Megleno-Romanian | eligible | 2008-01-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mentawai | eligible | 2008-02-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mesopotamian Arabic 2 | eligible | 2024-03-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Michif | discussion | 2021-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Micmac | eligible | 2018-07-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Minbei | eligible | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Miraya Bikol | eligible | 2019-06-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mizo | eligible | 2009-10-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mohawk | eligible | 2017-12-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mongolian written in Mongolian script| eligible | 2017-12-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mongondow | discussion | 2020-10-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Montenegrin 5 | waiting | 2017-12-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mooré | eligible | 2022-09-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Muniche | discussion | 2024-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Naandi | discussion | 2016-10-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nenets | eligible | 2018-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nengone | discussion | 2016-11-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ngaju | discussion | 2023-03-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ngiemboon | discussion | 2016-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nheengatu | eligible | 2008-04-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Niuean | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nogai | eligible | 2018-02-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia North Ndebele | eligible | 2019-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Northeastern Thai | eligible | 2018-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Northern Altai | eligible | 2019-12-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Northern Thai | eligible | 2010-02-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Northern Tujia | eligible | 2013-11-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Northwestern Ojibwa | discussion | 2023-12-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nuer(Thok Nath) | discussion | 2023-05-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nuosu | eligible | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nupe | discussion | 2023-12-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nyungar | eligible | 2017-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Obolo | eligible | 2019-09-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Oi | discussion | 2016-06-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Oji-Cree | discussion | 2024-02-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Okanagan | discussion | 2023-05-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Okinawan | eligible | 2010-11-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Orang Seletar | eligible | 2008-01-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Osing | eligible | 2019-01-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ottoman Turkish 5 | discussion | 2023-02-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pacha Malayalam | discussion | 2023-12-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Palembang | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pamona | eligible | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pannonian Rusyn 2 | eligible | 2022-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pazeh | waiting | 2020-07-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pemon | eligible | 2010-02-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Petjo | discussion | 2024-01-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pipil | eligible | 2018-01-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pitjantjatjara | discussion | 2021-06-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Plautdietsch | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pökoot | eligible | 2007-08-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pothwari | discussion | 2022-02-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Prussian 2 | eligible | 2019-11-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pu-Xian Min | eligible | 2018-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Puyuma | eligible | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Qashqai | eligible | 2019-11-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Queretaro otomi | discussion | 2022-03-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Rajasthani | discussion | 2015-11-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Rajbanshi | eligible | 2019-06-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Rapa Nui | eligible | 2010-02-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Rejang | eligible | 2018-04-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Reunion Creole | eligible | 2013-02-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Rinconada | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Riograndenser Hunsrückisch| eligible | 2018-05-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Romanesco | discussion | 2016-02-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Romanized Kyrgyz | discussion | 2024-02-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Rotuman | eligible | 2007-05-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Rukai | eligible | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Saint Lucian Creole French| eligible | 2013-03-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia SaiSiyat | eligible | 2018-10-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Salar | eligible | 2008-08-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sanaani | eligible | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sasak | waiting | 2019-11-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sassarese | eligible | 2007-09-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Semai | eligible | 2022-08-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sencilla es | discussion | 2020-04-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Serer | eligible | 2018-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Seri | eligible | 2007-10-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sgaw Karen | eligible | 2018-11-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sheshi kham | eligible | 2017-05-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Shina | eligible | 2019-12-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Shughni | eligible | 2013-03-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Siberian Tatar | discussion | 2021-04-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Siberian Yupik | discussion | 2018-09-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Simple Esperanto | discussion | 2023-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Skolt Sami 2 | eligible | 2022-04-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Solomon Pijin | eligible | 2010-06-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia South African English | discussion | 2023-12-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia South African Sign Language| discussion | 2023-12-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia South Ndebele | eligible | 2018-07-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Southern Balochi | eligible | 2008-08-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Southern Kurdish | eligible | 2010-03-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Southern Luri | eligible | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Southern Sami | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Southeastern Kolami | discussion | 2023-04-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Spanish Visual Impairment| discussion | 2023-02-09}}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sumerian | discussion | 2024-01-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sylheti | eligible | 2019-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tai Nüa | eligible | 2022-09-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Taivoan | discussion | 2019-03-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Taiwan Sign | discussion | 2023-11-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tamang | eligible | 2019-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tangut | discussion | 2023-11-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tarifit | eligible | 2007-08-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tati | eligible | 2008-03-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tausug | eligible | 2013-03-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ter Sami | eligible | 2018-04-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Thao 2 | eligible | 2022-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tharu | eligible | 2018-04-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tigre | discussion | 2021-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tiv | waiting | 2022-09-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tokelauan 2 | eligible | 2010-02-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Toki Pona 2 | discussion | 2022-03-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Torres Strait Creole | eligible | 2010-03-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tourangeau | discussion | 2019-12-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Triqui | discussion | 2016-04-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tsakonian | waiting | 2022-09-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tsou | eligible | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tucano | eligible | 2011-06-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tunica | discussion | 2016-09-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tunisian | discussion | 2014-09-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Turoyo | eligible | 2013-03-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tver Karelian | discussion | 2020-09-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Upper Saxon German | discussion | 2020-07-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Urum | discussion | 2021-03-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ushojo | discussion | 2022-12-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Vai 2 | discussion | 2021-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Vilamovian | eligible | 2012-08-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Votic | eligible | 2013-03-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Wallisian | eligible | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Waorani | eligible | 2010-06-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia West Coast Bajau | discussion | 2020-12-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Western Apache | discussion | 2021-05-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Western Balochi | discussion | 2014-10-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Westphalian | eligible | 2008-05-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Wolaytta | eligible | 2017-02-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Xiang | eligible | 2008-10-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Xibe | discussion | 2021-01-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Yaeyama | discussion | 2021-06-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Yami | eligible | 2019-04-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Yangben | eligible | 2013-03-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Yawi | eligible | 2011-06-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Yidgha | eligible | 2013-03-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Yilan Creole | discussion | 2023-11-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Yoron | discussion | 2021-09-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Yucatec Maya | eligible | 2010-02-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Yonaguni | discussion | 2021-06-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Yurok | discussion | 2020-04-11 }}
|}


=== Wikiquote ===
*'''Oppose''' - as it was said, no one there would write down something in that dialect. The only German Dialects which are sometimes used as a written language are (AFAIK) Lower German and Swiss German, which both have already a Wikipedia. Everyone who speaks/understands Pfälzisch can also understand High German and get information at de:. That Pfälzisch Wikipedia would only be a copy of some easy "translated" de: articles to have many language links in the articles in High German. --[[User:Steffen Löwe Gera|Steffen Löwe Gera]] 09:00, 16 January 2006 (UTC)
<!-- PLEASE SORT ALPHABETICALLY; the alphabet is this: ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ! -->
**No it wouldn't. Any new Wikipedia is created of its own. The Limburgic Wikipedia is not just an easy translation of the Dutch Wikipedia, neither are the Platt and Alemannic Wikipedias, even though they all know German and write it with more ease than their own vernacular language. Any natural language (and Pfälzisch is a language of its own indeed!) deserves to be written down and cultivated, no matter whether it suffers low prestige or the presence of a standard language. The only thing we should be worried about is whether there are contributors for it, or perhaps if the proposed Wikipedia will not be redundant with an existing project. [[User:Caesarion|Caesarion]] 09:37, 16 January 2006 (UTC)
{| class="wikitable sortable"
*'''SUPPORT''' well, it's the same old story and dance... if we use such a deletionist criteria, then NO language is needed, apart from US English. Who on earth is going to use a computer without knowing at least basic English? So why on earth would you need a German wiki at all? Still you have it, and it made a wonderful edition, too. I think these guys have the right to speak and write as they wish (no matter whether you call this a language, a dialect, or just a mispronounciation). If they can make a good wiki, then why not? And since it's so easy for Germans to read and speak in Pfälzisch (it's just a different sound, isn't it? ;) then de.wiki will have no problems in importing any interesting content from it. That's if we have to be logical (which is the very least you'd expect from people writing an encyclopedia). --[[User:Bertodsera|Bertodsera]] 10:46, 18 May 2006 (UTC)
|+Wikiquote requests
|-
!scope="col"| Project
!scope="col"| Official status
!scope="col"| Status since
!scope="col"| Notes
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Ancient Greek | eligible | 2010-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Aragonese 2 | eligible | 2008-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Avar | discussion | 2022-03-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Bhojpuri | eligible | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Burmese | eligible | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Cantonese | eligible | 2017-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Gilaki | eligible | 2007-11-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Dzongkha | discussion | 2022-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Haitian Creole | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Hausa | eligible | 2022-07-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Ido 2 | eligible | 2018-12-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Javanese | discussion | 2021-09-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Khowar | waiting | 2019-09-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Komering | discussion | 2024-01-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Malay | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Minangkabau | waiting | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Nepali | eligible | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Occitan | eligible | 2008-02-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Oriya | eligible | 2011-09-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Oromoo | eligible | 2021-06-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Pashto | eligible | 2018-05-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Punjabi | eligible | 2011-04-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Quechua | eligible | 2010-06-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Saraiki | eligible | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Shona | discussion | 2023-07-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Sindhi | eligible | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Sinhala | eligible | 2018-12-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote South Azerbaijani | eligible | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Sylheti | discussion | 2022-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Tajik | eligible | 2018-09-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Tatar | eligible | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Twi | discussion | 2023-03-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Tyap | discussion | 2022-11-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Western Panjabi | eligible | 2008-12-01 }}
|}


=== Wikisource ===
* '''Oppose.''' No need for this. It's not Wikipedia's business to cultivate languages. All Pfälzisch speakers benefit from the German Wikipedia just as much as all the other German speakers do. That should suffice. – [[User:Jondor|Jondor]] 13:29, 17 January 2006 (UTC)
<!-- PLEASE SORT ALPHABETICALLY; the alphabet is this: ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ! -->
:It may not be WP's business to cultivate languages, but it certainly is Wikipedia's business to help out those who cultivate their languages and give them the opportunity to make their own Wikipedia. Mr. Jondor, all Catalan speakers can use the Spanish Wikipedia very well, but the Catalan Wikipedia was created on the '''very same''' day as the Spanish was. So not allowing certain languages their own Wikipedias goes counter to the policy Wikipedia has been leading for five years now. [[User:Caesarion|Caesarion]] 13:40, 17 January 2006 (UTC)
{| class="wikitable sortable"
|+Wikisource requests
|-
!scope="col"| Project
!scope="col"| Official status
!scope="col"| Status since
!scope="col"| Notes
{{lc-row| Wikisource Afrikaans | eligible | 2019-10-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Albanian | eligible | 2008-06-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Ancient Greek 2 | eligible | 2010-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Aragonese 2 | eligible | 2008-02-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Baluchi | eligible | 2008-06-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Bashkir | eligible | 2019-10-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Bhojpuri | discussion | 2021-01-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Bishnupriya Manipuri | eligible | 2020-12-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Cantonese | discussion | 2020-06-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Central Bikol | discussion | 2021-08-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Coptic | eligible | 2010-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Interlingue | eligible | 2018-11-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Kabardian-Circassian | eligible | 2011-03-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Kazakh | discussion | 2022-01-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Khmer | eligible | 2010-02-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Kurdish | eligible | 2017-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Literary Chinese | waiting | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Livvi-Karelian | eligible | 2017-04-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Lojban | eligible | 2017-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Low Saxon | eligible | 2007-12-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Lozi | eligible | 2007-12-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Maithili | waiting | 2019-10-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Manchu | eligible | 2017-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Mauritian Creole | eligible | 2018-09-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Meadow Mari | eligible | 2013-05-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Min Dong 2 | eligible | 2006-10-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Minangkabau | waiting | 2020-07-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Northern Sami | eligible | 2019-10-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Occitan | eligible | 2008-04-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Old Norse | eligible | 2008-08-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Old Tupi | discussion | 2022-10-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Oromo | waiting | 2019-12-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Pashto | eligible | 2017-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Sinhala | eligible | 2018-09-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Sorbian | eligible | 2010-03-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Saraiki | waiting | 2019-10-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Sylheti | discussion | 2023-06-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Tagalog | eligible | 2010-08-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Tajik | eligible | 2017-05-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Tatar | eligible | 2011-07-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Urdu | eligible | 2017-11-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Uzbek | eligible | 2017-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Volapük | eligible | 2007-10-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Western Punjabi | eligible | 2017-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Zazaki | eligible | 2017-04-22 }}
|}


=== Wikiversity ===
I would work with, if such a wikipedia existed (I'm the one who asked for). I'm also a native speaker. My username on the German wikipedia is SPS, btw. -- [[User:84.171.227.43|84.171.227.43]] 17:22, 23 January 2006 (UTC)
<!-- PLEASE SORT ALPHABETICALLY; the alphabet is this: ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ! -->
{| class="wikitable sortable"
|+Wikiversity requests
|-
!scope="col"| Project
!scope="col"| Official status
!scope="col"| Status since
!scope="col"| Notes
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Afrikaans | waiting | 2019-07-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Albanian | eligible | 2017-12-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Belarusian | waiting | 2019-10-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Bengali | waiting | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Bulgarian | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Cantonese | eligible | 2018-11-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Catalan | eligible | 2007-12-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Central Bikol | discussion | 2023-08-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Dagbani | discussion | 2021-06-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Dutch | eligible | 2008-04-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Estonian | eligible | 2009-11-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Galician | eligible | 2009-02-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Georgian | eligible | 2008-10-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Gilaki | eligible | 2008-01-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Hausa | discussion | 2021-12-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Haitian Creole | eligible | 2008-02-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Hebrew | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Hungarian | eligible | 2008-04-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Indonesian 2 | waiting | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Kurdish | eligible | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Limburgish | eligible | 2008-03-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Lithuanian | eligible | 2012-07-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Malayalam | discussion | 2022-07-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Marathi | discussion | 2020-07-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Mazandarani | eligible | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Nepali | waiting | 2018-12-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Pa'O | discussion | 2023-11-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Pashto | eligible | 2018-09-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Persian | eligible | 2008-05-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Polish 2 | eligible | 2008-04-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Punjabi | eligible | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Romanian 2 | eligible | 2017-12-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Saraiki | waiting | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Sinhala 2 | discussion | 2020-05-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Slovak | eligible | 2008-02-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Sylheti | discussion | 2023-06-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Tamil 2 | waiting | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Telugu | discussion | 2021-03-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Turkish 2 | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Ukrainian 2 | eligible | 2010-10-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Uzbek | discussion | 2023-10-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Vietnamese | eligible | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Zazaki | eligible | 2018-05-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Yoruba | discussion | 2020-07-21 }}
|}


* '''Support'''I am a native speaker of Palatian, and would help with a palatian Wiki, whether it exists. If the alemannic wikipedia has a "right to exist", I would say a Palatian would have it, too. I would also propose another language code. PAL would be more apposite than PFL. If you aquate the "ä" with the "a", PAL would be the first three letters of te language name in English (Palatinate), and in Palatian itself (Pälzisch). [[User:PaelzerBu|PaelzerBu]] 13:40, 17 January 2006 (UTC)


=== Wikivoyage ===
*'''Support'''.--[[User:Harvzsf|Harvzsf]] 05:44, 7 February 2006 (UTC)
<!-- PLEASE SORT ALPHABETICALLY; the alphabet is this: ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ! -->
{| class="wikitable sortable"
|+Wikivoyage requests
|-
!scope="col"| Project
!scope="col"| Official status
!scope="col"| Status since
!scope="col"| Notes
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Afrikaans | discussion | 2023-02-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Arabic | eligible | 2013-03-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Armenian | eligible | 2013-02-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Azerbaijani | eligible | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Belarusian | eligible | 2018-10-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Bulgarian | eligible | 2013-03-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Cantonese | eligible | 2018-12-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Catalan | eligible | 2018-12-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Czech | eligible | 2018-12-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Danish | eligible | 2013-01-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Georgian | eligible | 2013-03-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Hungarian | eligible | 2012-11-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Indonesian | eligible | 2013-01-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Korean | eligible | 2014-01-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Latin | waiting | 2020-12-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Latvian | eligible | 2018-12-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Malayalam | eligible | 2018-05-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Marathi | eligible | 2013-01-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Nepali | eligible | 2018-10-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Saraiki | eligible | 2019-09-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Serbian | eligible | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Serbo-Croatian | eligible | 2022-01-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Sindhi | eligible | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Slovak | eligible | 2014-02-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Slovenian | waiting | 2019-12-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage South Azerbaijani | eligible | 2019-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Southern Balochi | waiting | 2020-12-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Sylheti | discussion | 2022-10-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Tagalog | eligible | 2013-01-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Tajik | eligible | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Tamil | eligible | 2014-01-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Thai | eligible | 2013-03-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Urdu | eligible | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Veps | eligible | 2013-03-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Vilamovian | discussion | 2024-03-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Welsh | eligible | 2018-12-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Zazaki | eligible | 2013-03-08 }}
|}


=== Wiktionary ===
*'''Support''' --[[User:Melancholie|Melancholie]] 04:22, 11 February 2006 (UTC)
<!-- PLEASE SORT ALPHABETICALLY; the alphabet is this: ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ! -->
{| class="wikitable sortable"
|+Wiktionary requests
|-
!scope="col"| Project
!scope="col"| Official status
!scope="col"| Status since
!scope="col"| Notes
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Acehnese | eligible | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary American Sign Language| eligible | 2010-11-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Ancash Quechua | eligible | 2018-04-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Ancient Greek | discussion | 2020-01-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Assamese | eligible | 2018-02-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Bakhtiari | eligible | 2019-01-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Balinese | eligible | 2021-11-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Bashkir | eligible | 2012-03-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Betawi | discussion | 2023-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Bhojpuri | eligible | 2018-02-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Bodo | eligible | 2018-09-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Buginese | eligible | 2008-11-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Buhinon | discussion | 2023-08-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Caló | eligible | 2020-12-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Cebuano | eligible | 2018-07-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Central Sierra Miwok | eligible | 2018-11-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Chavacano | eligible | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Chuvash | eligible | 2011-08-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Crimean Tatar | discussion | 2023-04-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Doteli | eligible | 2017-02-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Dusun | eligible | 2018-02-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Eastern Pwo | eligible | 2018-11-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Emilian | eligible | 2018-02-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Erzya | eligible | 2010-04-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Friulian | eligible | 2011-07-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Gan | eligible | 2009-07-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Gilaki | eligible | 2008-01-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Guadeloupean Creole | discussion | 2023-12-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Hawaiian | eligible | 2018-02-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Haitian Creole | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Ishɛ | discussion | 2020-03-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Jamaican Creole English | eligible | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Jazayri | discussion | 2015-05-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Jeju | eligible | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Judaeo-Spanish | eligible | 2008-08-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Jutlandic | eligible | 2008-02-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Kabyle | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Kirmanjki (Northern Zazaki) | eligible | 2009-07-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Komering | discussion | 2023-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Krio | discussion | 2022-11-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Kupang Malay | discussion | 2020-08-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Laki | eligible | 2019-01-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Lavukaleve | discussion | 2022-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Ligure | eligible | 2008-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Lozi | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Lushai | eligible | 2018-05-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Madurese | discussion | 2023-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Magahi | discussion | 2024-02-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Maguindanaon | discussion | 2023-11-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Maithili | eligible | 2018-02-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Manchu | eligible | 2018-12-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Mara | discussion | 2023-07-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Masry | eligible | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Mazandarani | eligible | 2008-11-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Meänkieli | eligible | 2017-11-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Mingrelian | eligible | 2011-07-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Mirandese | eligible | 2009-03-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Moksha | eligible | 2012-10-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Moroccan Arabic | discussion | 2023-11-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Motu | eligible | 2019-01-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Musi | discussion | 2023-09-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Neapolitan | eligible | 2019-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Nepal Bhasa 2 | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Nheengatu | eligible | 2008-08-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Nigerian Pidgin | eligible | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Norman | eligible | 2018-07-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Northern Sami | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Northern Sotho | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Ossetic | eligible | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Paiwan | eligible | 2022-01-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Papiamento | eligible | 2010-06-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Pazeh | waiting | 2020-07-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Picard | eligible | 2014-01-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Piedmontese | eligible | 2012-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Pitjantjatjara | eligible | 2008-01-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Rinconada Bikol | discussion | 2021-10-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Romagnol | eligible | 2017-11-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Rusyn | eligible | 2018-02-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Sakha | eligible | 2020-12-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Sardinian | eligible | 2010-02-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Scots | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary S'gaw Karen | discussion | 2021-11-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Shona | discussion | 2022-06-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Silesian | eligible | 2008-11-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Slavey | eligible | 2018-10-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Southern Sami | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Sylheti | eligible | 2023-08-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Tachelhit | eligible | 2009-10-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Talysh | discussion | 2021-12-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Thao | eligible | 2022-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Tigre | discussion | 2023-12-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Tulu | eligible | 2018-11-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Tumbuka | discussion | 2023-01-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Tunisian | discussion | 2015-04-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Tyvan | eligible | 2019-01-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Veps | eligible | 2013-03-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Waray-Waray | eligible | 2009-11-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Wayuu | eligible | 2010-03-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Wu Chinese | eligible | 2018-07-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Wymysorys | eligible | 2017-11-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Zealandic | eligible | 2007-12-19 }}
|}


=== Wikidata ===
:I've just changed the title, cause I had counted six supports, and not just five ;-) --[[de:Benutzer:SPS]] 13.02.2006 12:46 (CET)
The current procedure for adding new languages to Wikidata can be found at [[:d:Help:Monolingual text languages]].


== Closed requests ==
*'''Oppose''' - Pfälzisch is German. There is <u>one</u> common standard for writing German that covers all regional spoken variants. <u>No</u> other standard than Hochdeutsch is ever used in non-fictional texts (for good reasons, I guess). Ignoring this fact and trying to create Wikipedias for all different spoken "Germans" will very probably lead to a plethora of incomplete, unreliable wikis of inferior quality forever redundant with the mutually intelligible, first-rate standard German WP. Nichts gegen Lokalpatriotismus - but I'd strongly disencourage such a development. [[User:Arbeo|Arbeo]] 17:23, 27 February 2006 (UTC)
** [[User:Arbeo|Arbeo]], you're appearing stupidly ignorant to me in you ongoing attempts to descredit the root languages from which current Standard German has been created. Read the [[:de:Deutsche Sprache|Article on the German language]], ''it is an artificial language and thus should not have a Wikipedia'' would be as much an exaggeraton as your statements - only bending reality to the other end. However good, or complete, any Wikipedia will be, should not be anyones but the contributors business in the first place, and before not a comparable amount of labor has been invested, a 'comparison' to the German WP is impossible and '''pure perjudice'''. Your (presumably intentionally) false claim about all non-fictional text were in Standard German is ignoring the tiny bit of more than 1000 years of history before something like Standard was begun to be constructed, driven by political interest, and even evidently false thereafter. The Hanse, a multinational organization comparable to EFTA, EWG, or the current European Union (at least) in its early years, always had Low German, (Plattdüütsch) as their official language. The EU only recently embraced the baltic states and is slowly catching up somewhat to the former Hanse. Read the "German Dialect" section in the [[:de:Falscher Freund|German Wikipedia Article]] on [[:w:false friend|false friend]]s - it lists a handful words that are different betwwen Standard German and some other German language, and at the same time prone to provoke misunderstandings since they're sounding similar to something else. These examples are not even the snowflake on the tip of the iceberg. For one German minority language alone, I could give you a list of several hundreds more 'false friend' words, leave alone the ones not bearing any similarities, leave alone the fact, that there are almost no identical words (sharing both meaning and pronounciation) leave alone quite remarkable differences of grammars. (Compare this to e.g. language pairs like Dutch/Afrikaans, Bokmâl/Nynorsk, Urdu/Hindi - all undoubtedly different languages recognized by international standards on the highest possible level of differentiation, ISO-369-1 - even though Hindi/Urdu are 100% mutually intellegible deviating in less than 2 dozen words) There is a motion of ultra right wing extremists that there should be ony one unified language with which all others must be brought in line (see also [[:de:Luxemburgische Sprache|German Wikipedia]] on [[:w:Luxembourgish language|Luxembourgish]], re ''dräimol Lëtzebuergesch'', under Hitlers reign). [[User:Arbeo|Arbeo]] I offer you an examination to publicly prove your claim, that there were only some slight spelling deviations between the various Languages of Germany. Knowing of the huge set of 'false friend's at disposition, I know that you're bound to fail a test, if you're really as ignorant as you appear to be presenting youself here. If you take the challenge and do not fail, however, that would then clearly document that (a) vast differences in additon to spelling exist, and (b) make evident that you are very knowleadgeable about them and purpously misinforming readers here, likely following some hidden personal or politcal agenda. Interested? -- [[User:Purodha|Purodha Blissenbach]] 16:46, 13 August 2006 (UTC)


<div style="border:1px solid #000; padding:0.5em;">Once a wiki has been approved, delays are beyond the control of the [[language committee]]. Please address any comments about such delays on the linked task page or in the IRC channel {{channel|wikimedia-tech}} (see [[IRC/Instructions]]).
*'''Oppose''' NO NO NO! See [[User:Arbeo|Arbeo]] - what next ''Berlinerisch''? Where is the end, if any minor dialect gets his won Wiki? [[User:Kenwilliams|Kenwilliams]] 20:04, 13 March 2006 (UTC)
**Ken, have you ever heard of the slippery slope logical fallacy? ''This is it!'' "We can't admit variant X, that'll lead us to accept even smaller scale variant Y in the future". I recommend that you stay away as long as you do not show any knowledge of the linguistical landscape in Germany. The term "German" is very, very unlucky, since the variants spoken by people identifying as German are, however related, definitely ''not'' the same language. Saying that a Low Saxon or a Bavarian does not speak "German" as such (that means, either Standard German or another High Franconian dialect) does not mean he isn't German. Palatian is Middle Franconian, it has a different history and a different present state. Its speakers are Germans, their language may be German but it is a different language from the language of the Bundestag and the theatre. [[User:Steinbach|Steinbach <small>(formerly Caesarion)</small>]] 13:19, 18 May 2006 (UTC)
**[[User:Kenwilliams|Kenwilliams]], ''if any minor dialect gets his won Wiki?'' (as you write), this would (a) only be for those language variants having enough supporters who also take on themselves to make an own Wikipedia and thus do not already feel at home in an existing one, i.e. if there is demand, and (b) it was exactly what Wikimedia Foundation set out to do in their mission statement. (c) Who does not like the language might safely ignore it's Wikipedia, and (d) it enriches the world. -- [[User:Purodha|Purodha Blissenbach]] 01:37, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' [[User:Ciosek|Ciosek]] 20:59, 17 March 2006 (UTC) I see more logical arguments for support than to negate. Arguments for opose are quite illogical and some discriminatory - show NPOV love to standardization. [[w:Germanic substrate hypothesis]]

*'''Support''' A language, not a dialect. [[nl:Boudewijn Idema]] , 13:52 , 19 March 2006 (UTC)

:Title actualized once again --[[de:Benutzer:SPS]] 22:20, 10 April 2006 (CEST)

*'''Oppose''' It's clearly a dialect, not a language. There's a definite dialect continuum and no "border" for Pfälzerisch. Plus, there's no standard orthography and not even a standardized "Hochpfälzerisch". Why didn't anyone suggest a Wikipedia in Sächsisch yet, or Erzgebirgisch? Or even better: Leipzigerisch (as the Sächsisch of Dresden and Leipzig is not the same). This request is quite silly in my opinion. If we had a Saxon Wikipedia, people from Dresden, Chemnitz and Leipzig would constantly edit between "ni", "net" and "nüsch". I imagine similar things for other dialects of German. —[[en:User:N-true]] 5:21, 15 April 2006

*'''Support''' Like someone said, Ripuarian is a dialect of German, and we have that. 22:53, 6 June 2006 (UTC)

*'''Support''' [[de:Benutzer:Elvis untot]] 14:45, 26 July 2006 (UTC)

*'''Support''' I would like to answer to some of the arguments used by the opponents of the proposal: Indeed, Pfälzisch is just a dialect but that is true for Alemannisch, Ripuarisch, Limburgisch and many other Wikipedias. If you read a text in Pfälzisch and know High German, you will surely be able to see a large difference, maybe more than between Czech and Slovakian, Croatian and Serbian, Danish and Norwegian, which are considered separate languages just for political reasons. Also, dialect does not simply mean a mispronunciation or a variation in pronunciation, for German linguists ''Dialekt'' means there is a different grammar and some different idioms (in Palatinian there are some taken from French and Yiddish), while a ''Mundart'' is more a regional pronunciation of the standard language. Examples for a Mundart are Sächsisch or Hessisch but I would not vote against a Wikipedia in Sächsisch, Hessisch, Fränkisch etc, as there are still enough people to work on the Standard German version, maybe even more because who can write good articles in a dialect will probably be able to do so in Standard German. There are theoretically be hundreds of thousands of people who speak Palatinian actively, are able to use a computer and to write articles, although the language is rarely to hear in towns like Heidelberg because it is considered as a sign for poor education and little knowledge by people who did not learn it in their youth. This process could be turned if a Wikipedia in Palatinian could motivate more people to write in what is actually their mother tongue. In rural areas in the west of the Palatine it is used in shops, offices, schools, restaurants and theatres and Standard German is somehow considered to be foreign and unusual, although all official documents are in Standard German because Palatinian is not considered a minority language like Plattdüütsch or Alsatian in France. If you ever heard German high-ranking politicians like Kurt Beck or Helmut Kohl speak on local event in the home area, you would quickly forget the idea that Pfälzisch is just a variation of High German. There should not be too many problems with orthography, as everybody could write in the dialect of his hometown, all of them are understandable (there is no need to have one Wikipedia in the dialect of Ludwigshafen and another one in that of Kaiserslautern, Mannheim, Heidelberg and so on - as little as there is a need to have several Wikipedias in the dialects of Leipzig, Dresden or Chemnitz;-)), as there is no standard orthography of written Palatinian no form can be considered wrong as long is someone speaks it and writes in it; the main thing is people write in the language they (or at least their parents and grand-parents) speak, which is classical and pure Palatinian. A Wikipedia in a dialect or a local language naturally never has a high scientific level, people write more about regional or every-day topics, articles on elaborate and more complicate topics are mostly direct translations but they never form the main part of the encyclopedia. By the way: There are versions in Manx and Cornish, which are actually extinct languages, Latin, which is not used by anybody as a mother tongue for centuries and even Gothic, in which just a few words are still known to us. As long as some people are interested in writing articles and know the dialect good enough to do so, there are no reasons against setting up a new Wikipedia. [[de:Benutzer:stefanbw]] 01:48, 30 July 2006 (UTC)
** Well said. From experience, I agree, discussing orthography/spelling is futile. This has implications:
**# You may need quite many redirects for spelling variants. There is a tool under development that can make bulk submissions easy.
**# You'll have to have a way to decide which spelling is going to be an article name. Pragmatic approach: keep the 1st writer's choice. Chances are, that creates an even distribution and no-one feels set back.
**# You may need to (or want to) keep text consistent, at least at times. That needs contributors with awareness and knowledge.
**# Category names are more problematic than article names, since their spelling has to be remembered by writers, who don't want to engage in time consuming look-ups all the time. There is a tool under development for navigating the category tree and select some for insertion.
**# If there is demand, and/or there are suficiently different orthograpies, you may want, or even need to have, variant spellings of the language user interface. If present, these can be selected in the user preferences. Serbian and Chinese have that already. The group of Ripuarian languages will, too.
**Good luck! --[[User:Purodha|Purodha Blissenbach]] 01:37, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
* {{support}} -- [[de:Benutzer:Mundartpoet]] 21:55, 6 Aug 2006 (CEST)

{{requests for new languages/azb-ir}}

{{requests for new languages/pa-pk}}

===Wikiquote in french===
[[Image:Bandeau wikiquote.jpg|right|350px|]]
<div class="toccolours" >
* Proposer: [[User:Greudin|Greudin]] (N)
* Language code: fr
* Proposed domain: fr.wikiquote.org
* Relevant links:
** [[Wikiquote FR]]
** [[w:fr:Wikiquote]]
* Link to request on a mailing list: http://mail.wikipedia.org/pipermail/wikifr-l/2006-April/004868.html
</div>
</div>
Some requests were closed because of a lack of activity; you may create a new request if you are interested in contributing a test project.


See also the related edit logs: [[Special:Recentchangeslinked/Category:Approved requests for new languages|approved]], [[Special:Recentchangeslinked/Category:Failed requests for new languages|rejected]].
====Comments====
*There is currently no community. I'll be glad to support such an attempt to rebuild the french wikiquote, but only if you can find at least ten reliable and '''established''' Wikimedians/Wikipedians ready to invest themselves to help you with the project. [[User:Solensean|Solensean]] ᛁ[[User_Talk:Solensean|<big><big><big>ᛉ</big></big></big>]]ᛁ 01:46, 13 April 2006 (UTC)
:Plus que 8 on est deux ;) [[User:Greudin|Greudin]]
::No :) You're alone..[[User:Solensean|Solensean]] ᛁ[[User_Talk:Solensean|<big><big><big>ᛉ</big></big></big>]]ᛁ 13:49, 13 April 2006 (UTC)
* Maybe you should have provided us with some info on why the old French Wikiquote was closed. Well, I've searched for myself and don't mind sharing what I've found ;-) [[Communications subcommittees/Press/2006/03/28 fr.Wikiquote brief|'''<info en>''']] [[Communications subcommittees/Press/2006/03/28 fr.Wikiquote brief/fr|'''<info fr>''']] -- [[User:Arbeo|Arbeo]] 14:57, 28 April 2006 (UTC)

* I've posted quotes in "Gascon", and I got their from my neighbors. Anyone are gotten from any book, and are quotes used in their family when they were young. How can I must write the source of these quotes?<small>J'avais écris toutes les citations de la page en "Gascon", que j'avais eu grace à mes voisins. AUCUNE n'étaient sortie d'un quelconque livre; elles étaient utilisée dans leur famille, quand ils étaient jeunes, et que cette langue se parlait encore courrement dans la campagne. Comment indiquer la source de ces citations ?</small> [[User:Lolo_32|Lolo 32]]ᛁ 17:07, 15 August 2006 (UTC)

====Support====
*I would like to contribute to this project. [[User:Poppypetty|Poppypetty]] 18:17, 13 April 2006 (UTC) ([[fr:User:Poppy]]).
*I can also help, particularly in the beginning. [[User:Seb35|Seb35]] 22:01, 13 April 2006 (UTC)
*Quand vous voulez, on peut s'y mettre --[[User:Jonathaneo|Jonathaneo]] 13:08, 14 April 2006 (UTC)
* Une 5e...--[[User:BeatrixBelibaste|BeatrixBelibaste]] 18:17, 14 April 2006 (UTC) ([[fr:User:BeatrixBelibaste]]).
*--[[User:Absar|Absar]] 11:23, 15 April 2006 (UTC)
* Moi aussi, mais tant qu'à faire je préférerais Wikicitations. [[User:86.217.125.20|86.217.125.20]] 12:18, 15 April 2006 (UTC)
:Enregistre toi, ça a bcp plus de poids ! [[User:Greudin|Greudin]]
: <small>« Wikicitations » est une bonne idée d'intitulé. L'emploi d'un nouveau titre permettrait de symboliser le changement par rapport à la précédente version. [[User:Teofilo|Teofilo]] 12:11, 18 April 2006 (UTC)</small>
* I can help you a bit. Je souhaiterais surtout faire le ménage/rengement comme je le fais déjà sur Wikipédia. Et puis commencer un nouveau projet c'est se conduire en batisseurs. --[[User:Pseudomoi|Pseudomoi]] 21:58, 20 April 2006 (UTC)
*I don't have any problems of this. Sounds like a good idea. [[User:Computerjoe|Computerjoe]] 11:23, 9 July 2006 (UTC)
*Of course. --[[User:OldakQuill|Oldak]] [[User_talk:OldakQuill|Quill]] 18:22, 23 July 2006 (UTC)
*Full support, but only for public domain texts. --[[User:Bsm15|Bsm15]] 17:36, 12 August 2006 (UTC)
* Je veux aussi contribuer sur ce projet. Il est nécessaire avec un encadre strict sur les droits d'auteur. --[[User:Grondin|Bertrand GRONDIN]] 17:43, 15 August 2006 (UTC)

====Oppose====
* I support a new fr.wikquote for old texts in the public domain only. I oppose the new rules that allow quotes from films and contemporary authors, because I believe this clashes the French copyright law. See [[Talk:Wikiquote FR]]. <small>Je suis pour la réouverture d'un Wikiquote francophone seulement pour les textes anciens tombés dans le domaine public. Je suis opposé aux nouvelles règles qui incitent à citer des films et des auteurs contemporains, parce que je pense que cela n'est pas compatible avec les lois françaises sur les droits d'auteurs. Voir [[Talk:Wikiquote FR]]</small> [[User:Teofilo|Teofilo]] 12:08, 18 April 2006 (UTC)
:A bit franco-centred, isn't it? [[User:Greudin|Greudin]]
::Though it is the same reason why the fr.wikiquote was closed in the first place, because of those French(France) copyright laws. [[User:132.204.207.108|132.204.207.108]] 12:59, 21 April 2006 (UTC)
:::As Greudin says, French is spoken internationally. Why not base the rules on Canadian, Belgian or Swiss law? All this is irrelevant as the servers are in the US so will be governed by US law. US law permits such quotation. --[[User:OldakQuill|Oldak]] [[User_talk:OldakQuill|Quill]] 18:19, 23 July 2006 (UTC)
J'ai perdu sans préavis mes deux pages utilisateurs qui fourmillaient de citations tout à fait légales. Je pense, avant de créer quoique ce soit, qu'il faudrait réactiver cette partie de l'ancienne version quelques semaines et nous laisser recouvrer notre travail initial. Signé QuoiNonne aka [[User:82.224.88.52|82.224.88.52]] 17:01, 21 April 2006 (UTC)
* {{oppose}} How to avoid the same problems happening again ? [[User:Traroth|Traroth]] 21:29, 15 August 2006 (UTC)

====List of people willing to involve themselves in the project====
I'd like to see a list of people willing to involve themselves in a new fr.wikiquote. Write your name below. [[User:Solensean|Solensean]] ᛁ[[User_Talk:Solensean|<big><big><big>ᛉ</big></big></big>]]ᛁ 21:42, 30 July 2006 (UTC)
*--[[User:Bsm15|Bsm15]] 10:45, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*--[[User:Lolo_32|Lolo_32]] 17:07, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*--[[User:Grondin|Bertrand GRONDIN]] 17:46, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
*--[[User:Maximini1010|Maximini1010]] 17:05, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
*--[[User:BeatrixBelibaste|BeatrixBelibaste]] 01:09, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
{{requests for new languages/cg}}

=== Hiligaynon Wikipedia (13 support, 1 oppose)===
{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer=[[en:User:Jose77|Jose77]]
|User accounts of others=
|Language code= hil (ISO 639-3)
|Proposed domain= hil.wikipedia.org
|Wikipedia article= [[en:Hiligaynon language]]
|Native name= Hiligaynon, Ilonggo
|English name= Hiligaynon
|Number of speakers= 7 million
|Locations spoken= [[en:Visayas|Visayas]] ([[en:Philippines|Philippines]])
|Related languages= [[en:Visayan languages|Visayan languages]]
|Promoting organizations= [http://www.copewithcytokines.de/NAGATUON/ Hiligaynon on the web], [http://www.bansa.org/?q=dictionaries/cmd&dict_lang=Hiligaynon Bansa.org Hiligaynon Dictionary], [http://www.dinagyang.com Ilonggo Community], [http://IlonggoNation.blogspot.com Ilonggo Nation Movement Blog], [http://hometown.aol.com/hiligaynon/hili.htm?f=fs Hiligaynon Nation]
|Request on mailing list=
}}

==== Support:====
*'''Strong Support'''-found some speakers in wiki, [[en:User:23prootie|23prootie]] 17 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Strong Support''' - Hiligaynon is one of the 12-13 major languages of the Philippines. It has more native speakers than [[:war:|Waray-Waray]] and [[:pam:|Kapampangan]] both of whom currently have functional, active Wikipedias --[[User:Harvzsf|Harvzsf]] 05:23, 17 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Strong Support''' - it's a major regional lingua franca in western Visayas, making it the 4th most-spoken Philippine language. --[[en:User:Christopher Sundita|Chris S.]] 05:54, 17 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' if supported by two or more native speakers ;-) --[[User:Arbeo|'''A'''<span style="font-variant:small-caps;text-transform:lowercase">RBE</span>'''0''']] 16:35, 17 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Strong Support'''. it's about time. this should have been requested long time ago after the [[:ceb:|cebuano wikipedia]]. but sure, more native speakers should help. -- [[User:Saluyot|Saluyot]] 03:06, 19 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Strong Support'''. As a native speaker of Illongo I highly support a Hiligaynon Wikipedia. It is quite a large language.
[[User:24.4.106.220|24.4.106.220]] '''(N)''', 01:23, 29 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Strong Support'''.- It's the fourth largest native language in the Philippines in terms of number of speakers, and is a lingua franca in the Western Visayas --[[User:Katimawan2005|Katimawan2005]] 07:16, 7 August 2006 (UTC)
:The '''Hiligaynon Test Wikipedia''' can now be found [http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Test-WP/hil Here] alongside the other [http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Template:N_en/test Incubation Wikipedias].
*{{Support}} --'''[[User:Taichi|Taichi]]''' - ([[User talk:Taichi|あ！]]) 09:48, 29 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' --[[User:Belgian man|Belgian man]] <small>([[:nl:Gebruiker:Cars en travel|nl]] [[:na:User:Belgian man|na]] [[en:User:Belgian man|en]])</small> 12:04, 3 July 2006 (UTC)
*{{Support}} Seven million native speakers should be enough! --[[User:84.150.255.207|84.150.255.207]] '''(N)''', 20:14, 19 July 2006 (UTC)
:The '''Hiligaynon Test Wikipedia''' can now be found [http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Test-WP/hil Here] alongside the other [http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Template:N_en/test Incubation Wikipedias].

*{{Support}} Good luck! --[[User:Weekeejames|Weekeejames]] 10:59, 22 July 2006 (UTC)
*{{Support}} per above. However, more '''registered''' native speakers would be nice (see below). --[[User:Sky Harbor|<font color="#0066ff" ><b>Sky Harbor</b></font>]] 16:43, 22 July 2006 (UTC)
*I agree with "Chris S.". I even know someone who speaks it, but I think not in the native level. So as a resident in the Philippines, I'll '''Support''' the wiki. [[User:A-yao|A-yao]] 15:01, 23 July 2006 (UTC)
*{{Support}} --[[User:OldakQuill|Oldak]] [[User_talk:OldakQuill|Quill]] 18:30, 23 July 2006 (UTC)
*{{Support}} I do not speak Hiligaynon or Ilonggo, but I know some native speakers and I know enough to make small contributions. I think this would be an important encyclopedia since there are otherwise very few works in Ilonggo outside of the Philippines (and there are many Filipinos outside of the Philippines). [[w:User:Gronky]] 14:06, 24 July 2006 (UTC)

==== Oppose:====

*'''Oppose with fire ''' no native speakers requested this. - [[User:FrancisTyers|FrancisTyers]] 10:18, 16 June 2006 (UTC)
:'''Question:''' If native speakers show up and prove willingness to take responsibility for the implementation of this project will you withdraw your current opposition?--[[User:Harvzsf|Harvzsf]] 05:23, 17 June 2006 (UTC)
::If more than five dedicated native speakers show up, and request this Wiki with the intention of building an encyclopaedia then sure I'd withdraw my opposition. We don't need another [[:tg:|Tajik Wikipedia]], with no good articles and no native speakers to improve it. - [[User:FrancisTyers|FrancisTyers]] 16:18, 17 June 2006 (UTC)
:::For what it's worth, the [[:nrm:|Norman Wikipedia]] has only 2 native speakers (one at start) and is now nearing 1,000 articles. A successful test wikipedia is a much better sign than counting the number of native speakers. That said, I'm '''Weak Oppose''' against anything that does not have a test Wikipedia with at LEAST 25 articles. [[User:Jade Knight|The Jade Knight]] 05:33, 14 July 2006 (UTC)
::::I would like to further add that Tajik Wikipedia does have a dedicated native speaker now; in fact, the number of articles over there has slowly grown from 31 to 81. --[[User:Jose77|Jose77]] 10:53, 15 July 2006 (UTC)

====Comments:====
Suggestion to help this proposal: since there are anonymous IPs who list themselves as native speakers who are willing to the growth of the Hiligaynon Wikipedia, it is highly recommended that these people register as to make their votes count. Or if they have an account on an existing Wikimedia project (i.e. Wikipedia), they can list that too! --[[User:Sky Harbor|<font color="#0066ff" ><b>Sky Harbor</b></font>]] 14:36, 20 July 2006 (UTC)

:Hi everyone, the '''Hiligaynon Test Wikipedia''' can now be found [http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Test-WP/hil Here] alongside the other [http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Template:N_en/test Incubation Wikipedias].
:--[[User:Jose77|Jose77]] 22:21, 27 July 2006 (UTC)

=== Chaldon-Siberian (48 support, 29 oppose)===
<div class=usermessage>ALL VOTES FROM NEW/ANONYMOUS USERS WILL BE DELETED. Could someone have a look over and delete the new user/anonym votes? Anyone tallying this up should ignore them. (see under the Chaldon section orange bar [[Requests for new languages/Non-natural|here]] for relevant discussion) 10:52, 5 June 2006 (UTC)</div>
{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= [[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] (N)
|User accounts of others=
*** [[User:Nickitos|Nickitos]] (N) 17:15, 30 May 2006 (UTC)
*** [[User:Kurukull|Kurukull]] 14:17, 30 May 2006 (UTC)
*** [[User:Baznica|Baznica]] (N) 15:55, 30 May 2006 (UTC)
*** [[User:Romych|romych]] (N) 16:24, 30 May 2006 (UTC)
*** [[User:ChaldonFighter|ChaldonFighter]] (N) 04:47, 31 May 2006 (UTC)
*** [[User:Ima|Ima]] 19:15, 5 June 2006 (UTC)
*** [[User:Steel archer|Steel archer]] 23:44, 7 June 2006 (UTC)
*** [[User:Ghzhnfh|Ghzhnfh]] 17:11, 6 July 2006 (UTC)
|Language code= none, <s>sib</s> <small>[http://www.ethnologue.com/show_language.asp?code=sib sib is the Sebob Kenyah code]. [[User:Belgian man|Belgian man]] <small>([[:nl:Gebruiker:Cars en travel|nl]] [[:na:User:Belgian man|na]] [[en:User:Belgian man|en]])</small> 15:43, 29 May 2006 (UTC)</small>
|Proposed domain= ru-sib.wikipedia.org <small>[http://www.ethnologue.com/show_language.asp?code=sib <tt>sib</tt> is the Sebob Kenyah code]. [[User:Belgian man|Belgian man]] <small>([[:nl:Gebruiker:Cars en travel|nl]] [[:na:User:Belgian man|na]] [[en:User:Belgian man|en]])</small> 15:43, 29 May 2006 (UTC)</small>
|Wikipedia article= [be:Сібірская мова]] [[ru:Сибирский язык]] [[uk:Сибірська мова]]
|Native name= Сибирской говор, чалдонской говор
|English name= Chaldon-Siberian dialect of Russian ??
|Number of speakers= 5 - 10 millions, about 20% of slavonic siberian population still remember the language (???)
|Locations spoken= [[en:Siberia]]
|Related languages= Russian, Ukrainian, Belarusian, Don Balachka (Surzhik) ([[en:East Slavic Languages]]
|Promoting organizations= http://volgota.com, http://www.sibiria.org, http://www.baznica.info, http://inache.net
|Request on mailing list=
}}
* Test wiki: [[incubator:Test-WP/chal]]

: Member of the Commonwealth of East-Slavonic Test wikipedias http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Template:Sodruzhestvo-sib



====Support====
*'''Support''' --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 09:30, 28 May 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' --[[User:Fratele lui Bonaparte, il cunosti?|Fratele lui Bonaparte, il cunosti?]] 13:57, 7 August 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' -- --[[User:ChaldonFighter|ChaldonFighter]] 04:47, 31 May 2006 (UTC)
*'''Weak Support'''. Just to see if something worthwhile comes out out of it. It seems that only a handful of ehthusiasts are interested in this project. But if it works out, why not? --[[User:Rydel|Rydel]] 14:45, 3 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' see [[:w:ru:Сибирский язык]] --[[User:Yakudza|Yakudza]] 15:42, 14 June 2006 (UTC)
::this even hardly could be called dialect. just unpopular slang of several people. [[User:Elk Salmon|Elk Salmon]] 17:02, 14 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Weak support''', I hope this project can develop later. But now it isn't so popular. --[[User:AndyVolykhov|AndyVolykhov]] 20:59, 14 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' -- [[User:Bluz|Volodymyr Forostyna]] 00:28, 08 June 2006 (UTC)
**I think difference between Siberian and Komi - Komi acknowledged by autorities of Russia. Than Siberian has same rights.
*'''Support''' - --[[User:Kivan|Kivan]] 17:36, 1 June 2006 (UTC) Siberian is language of my ancestors, i wish to restore it and i want that it had the free reference in territory of Siberia. Or we should drown moscovites in blood. Thanks
*'''Support''' --[[User:MountainBlueAllah|MountainBlueAllah]] 06:58, 17 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' -- [[User:Zlobny|Jan Marozau]], Miensk, janmarozau@gmail.com http://hondurazian.livejournal.com
*'''support'''. [[User:IJzeren Jan|IJzeren Jan]] 16:50, 16 June 2006 (UTC)
**<s> '''Support''' --[[User:Yakudza|Yakudza]] 15:28, 14 June 2006 (UTC)</s>
***: Already voted. [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 09:23, 26 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' [[User:Jcb|Jcb]] 22:25, 22 June 2006 (UTC) - The wiki would start with more than 200 articles, which is quite a lot for a starting wiki.
:Already 1200 --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 14:47, 7 August 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support'''. This language is an interesting thing to learn and to try speaking it is even more interesting.[[User:Ghzhnfh|Ghzhnfh]] 17:11, 6 July 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' - [[User:Asmen|Asmen]]
*'''Support''' - [[en:User:Anclation|Anclation]]
*'''Support''' - [[be:User:Mienski|Mienski]]
*'''Support''' - I do not pass judgement on the status of this language. Whether or not it is real doesn't concern me. What does, is that they have hundreds of articles already, and they are dedicated to building a Wikipedia. --[[User:Node ue|Node ue]] 20:19, 8 August 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' -- Steel archer@uk.wikipedia.org, steel_archer@livejournal.com
*'''Support''' -- Pavel Levushkan http://www.baznica.info
*'''Support''' -- Aleksej Tajlakov(N) addpri@mail.ru
*'''Support''' -- Roman Baiduk bydook@gmail.com
*'''Support''' -- rutopist editor@inache.net
*'''Support''' -- Nefis (N) manzara@mail.ru
*'''Support''' -- Oleg Dudnyk knyga@ukr.net
*'''Support''' -- Alexei aka Axios tarseo@mail.ru
*'''Support''' -- Helgi Litvin vujaka@yandex.ru
*'''Support''' -- Siarhiej Bałachonaŭ balachon@gmail.com http://balachonau.puls.by
*'''Support''' --vaenn; vaenn.livejournal.com 00:28, 08 June 2006 (UTC)
*Support --Alex_Yesod 18:17, 30 May 2006 (UTC)
*Support -- Dmitry Petuk 00:28, 08 June 2006 (UTC)
*Support -- totsamjy forumm@mail2000.ru
*Support -- Михаил kow@mail.ru
*Support -- Сергій Вдовиченко, Київ mlody.gniewny@gmail.com vates-faith.livejournal.com
*Support -- Ihar Trafimovicz http://unutranyholas.com/
*Support -- Sergey Sechiv sergeyv4 @ gmail.com
*Support -- Виктор Николаев, Санкт-Петербург v_shavy@yahoo.com
* Support -- Елена Львова, Санкт-Петербург, elenabenaryeh@msn.com
* Support -- Роман Еримеенко, Луганск, romychvk@gmail.com http://megalit.ru
*Support -- Maria Sadzhenytsya , Lviv, rikitiki@ukr.net
*Support -- Taras Manolov, Lund (taras.manolov@med.lu.se)
* Support -- Kojpiš Anton, Minsk kojpish@bk.ru http://incubator.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Coipition%27Tong
* Support - I'm ready to write and read. -- --Nickitos 18:07, 30 May 2006 (UTC)
* Support -- (Oleksiy, Odessa) (zvoopz@ua.fm)
* Support (Petro Batozhenko) (http://yanek.livejournal.com/).
* Support (Yan Roginevich)(http://kvasimodo.livejournal.com/).
*'''Support''' --[[User:A1|A1]] 09:28, 19 August 2006 (UTC) (Kiev)
--Kvasimodo 12:34, 2 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' -- Every language should have the ground to protect and develop itself whether it's documented or not. -- 03:28, 17 July 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support''' - [[be:User:Mienski|Mienski]]

====Oppose====
*'''Oppose''' - None references in Google nor Wikipedia, doubtful about the approximate number of speakerse because the absent of ISO 639 code.--'''[[User:Taichi|Taichi]]''' - ([[User talk:Taichi|あ！]]) 18:25, 28 May 2006 (UTC)
** It's not true - [http://www.google.com.ua/search?hs=p70&hl=uk&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla%3Aru-RU%3Aofficial&q=%D1%81%D0%B8%D0%B1%D0%B8%D1%80%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B8%D0%B9+%D1%8F%D0%B7%D1%8B%D0%BA&btnG=%D0%9F%D0%BE%D1%88%D1%83%D0%BA&meta= "сибирский язык"] gives about 767 000 links and [http://www.google.com.ua/search?hl=uk&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla%3Aru-RU%3Aofficial&q=siberian+language&btnG=%D0%9F%D0%BE%D1%88%D1%83%D0%BA&meta= siberian language] gives about 2 560 000 links. --[[User:A1|A1]] 09:34, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
:Ethnologue.com is the reference about if this language exists, is a lie about the 5-10 millions, exists languages with few speakers (hundreds or dozens) and has a ISO code. I suspect about the support of the IP annonymous, because only Yaroslav is the unique registered user. --'''[[User:Taichi|Taichi]]''' - ([[User talk:Taichi|あ！]]) 22:41, 28 May 2006 (UTC)
: Requests to ethnologue.com and ISO today were made by our group --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 13:41, 3 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''STRONG oppose - slb is the code for [http://www.ethnologue.com/show_language.asp?code=slb the Saluan language].

: '''sib''' but not '''slb''' --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 04:27, 29 May 2006 (UTC)

: Just please type "Chaldon Siberia" in Google, and we can show a lot of people how know the language, and promote it. All the three east-slavonic wikis (russian, ukrainian, belorussian) have articles about the language --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 18:36, 28 May 2006 (UTC)
*'''Strongly oppose''' -- '''sib''' is the ISO 639 code for the '''Sebob language spoken in Kenyah''', classified as a living language in Ethnologue and accepted in the ISO 639 standard. <span style="color:red">'''Please stop inventing codes'''</span> like this. '''First check ISO 639 resources'''. If there's no code in ISO 639, don't assign your own code (all 2or 3 letter codes are reserved for exclusive assignment in ISO 639). For now the only viable code will be based on the code for Russian, i.e. as a variant of Russian: ''ru-siberian'', or using the RFC 3066 recommadned notation for languages without codes: (e.g. ''x-siberian-chaldon''). I really urge you to contact the Russian standard organism to ask for assistance if you want a code in ISO 639. And also, try to find accurate (academic) references about this language, because there's for now no evidence that it is really different from Russian, and no evidence that it is even classified in the East Slavonic language family! And also there's no evidence from other native people in this area (other areas outside Russia do use recognized East Slavonic languages but there may be legends about the Siberian variant that they have never actually heard!).

: Academic refrences about differences between siberian dialects and official russian will be enough or not? And what is about other native people? 10 of them went here for vote. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 21:07, 15 June 2006 (UTC)

:: Note that if this is a reconstructed language, its base is still the modern Russian, and the variant is based on Old Slavonic, so the code to use should reflect this: the only viable code for now is '''ru-''' followed by the ISO 639 code '''chu''' assigned for Old Church Slavonic (don't use the two letter code there because it's reserved for ISO 3166 country codes). This would give the final code '''ru-chu'''.
:: The people in other countries that are supporting the project won't accept to use Russian as the base for this reconstruction, although they may support the idea of reintroducing features from the Old Slavonic language. They would then create a variant that would be different from the variant being built in the far Siberia, and so they would create things like '''uk-chu''' in Ukrainia or '''ge-chu''' in Georgia, which will remain unofficial dialects until they get a true population. For now, those theoric constructions are NOT living languages. [[User:Verdy p|Verdy P]] 16:59, 14 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Oppose'''. Language itself is [[:en:Wikipedia:No original research|original research]]. Does it exist somewhere beyond LJ? Does any scientific institution codify it? --[[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 20:51, 28 May 2006 (UTC)

:Yes, in real dialects of the Chaldons and in literary form in vlogota.com and other sites beyond LJ. Do you want to say that Chaldons do not exist or that volgota.com do not exist?--[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 21:06, 28 May 2006 (UTC)

:: I think that http://samir74.livejournal.com, http://volgota.com/ and [[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] are same person. Please avoid self-references. It's still original research.
:: According to [[:ru:Сибирский язык]] (still not NPOV): Chaldon-Siberian is project of constructed language ... Created in 2005. (''Сиби́рский язы́к — проект искусственного языка, создаваемого на базе восточнославянских диалектов Сибири, в основном старожильческих говоров XIX века, с участием тюркских, монгольских и арабских заимствований. Возник в 2005.''). I don't know how much common it has with language of Chaldons. Other linguists could answer this question. Please give any credible references.
:: [[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 03:13, 29 May 2006 (UTC)

::: 1. Chaldon dialect exists: http://www.yandex.ru/yandsearch?rpt=rad&text=%F1%E8%E1%E8%F0%F1%EA%E8%E9+%F1%F2%E0%F0%EE%E6%E8%EB%FC%F7%E5%F1%EA%E8%E9+%E3%EE%E2%EE%F0
::: 2. The literary form exists: http://www.yandex.ru/yandsearch?text=%F1%E8%E1%E8%F0%F1%EA%E8%E9+%FF%E7%FB%EA&stype=www
::: 3. Russian wiki lies for political reasons, hating any language except russian for siberian slavonians. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 04:27, 29 May 2006 (UTC)

:::: According to http://uk.wikipedia.org/: "Сибірська мова — літературна мова, створена у 2005 році на основі східнослов'янських діалектів Сибіру, здебільшого старожитецьких говірок XIX сторіччя" (Siberian language is literary language based on dialects of Siberia", but russians they themselves consider their article not NPOV. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 04:36, 29 May 2006 (UTC)

::::: Please don't lie for political reasons too. And please don't talk about politics here. According to [[:be:Сыбірская мова]] it's still ''праект штучнай мовы'' (project of constructed language). From uk: article (from beginning to 29 січня 2006 version, excluding last days editing) ''напівштучна мова'' (half-constructed, as far a I understand Ukrainian). Again, where are references to external sources? --[[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 13:44, 29 May 2006 (UTC)

:::::: What lie, when russian wiki tried to write there "this is a project which is against russian state", and only protests of siberian and belorussian democrats stopped to do this? The history is available, and anybody can see this. The belorussian version just translates russian one. http://volgota.com, http://inache.net and other sites that promote - is it enough for external sources? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 13:52, 29 May 2006 (UTC)

::::::: Anyway, moved to non-natural, though it is natural, and there is about 20 voices in support yet --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 13:55, 29 May 2006 (UTC)

::::::::Please move the request to [[Requests for new languages/Non-natural]], because this is an artificial language. --'''[[User:Taichi|Taichi]]''' - ([[User talk:Taichi|あ！]]) 05:03, 29 May 2006 (UTC)

::::::::: It is not, but it is possible to create the wiki if it will be considered artificial? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 06:14, 29 May 2006 (UTC)

*'''Oppose''' language does not seem to be natural; otherwise Slavonic variants spoken in Siberia are simply Russian dialects not really much different from Moscow or St.-Peterburg Russian. [[User:Steinbach|Steinbach <small>(formerly Caesarion)</small>]] 13:37, 29 May 2006 (UTC)

: Really, we want to restore the ancient dialect of 17-18 centuries, and to make it modern language. I do not know how it can be classified, as natural or non-natural, but there are many enthusiasts of this project. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 19:39, 5 June 2006 (UTC)

*'''Oppose''' for as long as Yaroslav doesn't provide information from <u>independent, neutral</u> sources that indicates that this is a distinct and existing language (I can't find any at present). [[User:Arbeo|'''A'''<span style="font-variant:small-caps;text-transform:lowercase">RBE</span>'''0''']] 12:26, 30 May 2006 (UTC)
: Ok, I know it is hard to find and <u>independent, neutral</u> source in such topic - all russian sources denies the language with great energy, and all tha siberian separatists and some kazakhstan and ukrainian sources support it with the same energy. Well, if I will work with the wiki as if it would be an artificial language (request is already made), and it will be five or more contributors from native siberians or not, who will write in such wiki, will you oppose then? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 12:54, 30 May 2006 (UTC)

: Ha, imagine, they write here "the whole language is invented by Yaroslav". What word, I wonder? "Odnako" or maybe "shanezhka" or maybe "basko"?))) And in their wiki they write "invented by Yaroslav to destroy Russia". Well, if they themselves want Russia to be destroyed, we shall destroy Russia. Long live Great Novgorod and free Siberia! --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 19:44, 1 June 2006 (UTC)

: I have some time now. Links about the siberian language NOT FROM LJ or Volgota.com:

: http://e-novosti.info/forumo/viewtopic.php?t=1819 (discussion about necessary of tukr words are they allowed or not)

: Kazakhstan article http://www.dialog.kz/site.php?lan=russian&id=76&pub=1032 (positive)

: Ukrainian article http://lab.org.ua/article/727/ (positive)

: Latvian forum http://www.evangelie.ru/forum/archive/t-14778-p-2.html (positive reaction)

: Ukrainian forums http://forum.sevastopol.info/viewtopic.php?p=134921&sid=e1bfb2dad69ccbe92f653f8e69a61352
: http://www.novy.tv/ru/forum/viewtopic.php?t=20068&sid=6dfe6e7e13df8be971f34aa81aa365c5
: (positive reaction, people reciting verses in siberian)

: Russian forum http://www.disenteria.ru/index.php?act=ST&f=1&t=7492&s= (some people from Siberia testify that they know this words and grammar)

: Moscow forum http://forum.msk.ru/wap/news.wml?id=2200 (negative reaction, but the language considered natural)

: All this sources do not belong to me, but all of them consider the language natural (the lie about it's non-naturality was completely made by russian nationalists), and all of them consider that the language is based on real dialects of old siberian people.

: There are some sources not from the Internet, but perhaps nobody here read russian magazines.
--[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 19:41, 2 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Oppose''', and bring here false users votes will not help this request. [[User:Hégésippe Cormier|Hégésippe]] | [[User talk:Hégésippe Cormier|±Θ±]] 12:28, 3 June 2006 (UTC)

: Why do you think they are false? IP are from all the world, and they provide their emails. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 13:26, 3 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Oppose''' - All of it is nothing but a Svidomy Ukrainian stunt [http://community.livejournal.com/ukr_nationalism/ see Monday, May 29th, 2006]. [[en:User:Kuban kazak|Kuban Cossack]].

:FYI 'svidomy' translates from Ukrainian as 'conscious'; 'conscientious', "сознательный" by Russian. Some bad people called 'ruspats' using it for offending Ukrainians. Амиго, приезжай в Украину, подарю тебе атлас мира, чтобы ты смог ощутить разницу между Украиной и Сибирью. Кстати, ты хоть там хоть там бывал? -- --[[User:Fanex|Dmitry Petuk]] 11:53, 8 June 2006 (UTC)[User:Fanex|Dmitry Petuk]

::Amigo my wife is from Rivne (where I lived for three years) and right now I am writing from Feodosiya. However the point is not between Ukraine and Siberia, the point is: '''ARE YOU GOING TO PARTICIPATE IN CHALDON-SIBERIAN WIKIPEDIA?''' and '''ARE YOU NATIVE OF SIBERIA?'''. Because so far I am '''yet to see a Siberian IP in the list'''. So are you trying to use your ''conscience'' to prove that you are capable of starting a pointless wiki, because in such a case it really is a waste of conscience. BTW, thanks for the world atlas, but I have one already, although I must say when one sees Siberia in full he really could not take not to notice how small '''and near''' does Ukraine appear to its western borders ;). [[en:User:Kuban kazak|Kuban Cossack]]

:::In fact [http://community.livejournal.com/ukraine_russia/201519.html]. Bottom phrase is ''Считаю, что пост имеет прямое отношение к теме сообщества, так как сибирский язык в настоящее время не признается официально в России, но официально признается на многих сайтах украинского Интернета.''

::: I feel that the post has direct relation to our community because the sibirian language is officialy unrecognised in Russia but is officialy recognised on many Ukrainian sites. That appears to be the only reason and it is fully anecdotical. [[en:User:Kuban kazak|Kuban Cossack]]

:::: So do you believe that ukrainians have no rights to vote in wikipedia? Are the votes false because part of them are ukrainians?:-) --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 16:17, 3 June 2006 (UTC)
:::::And how many articles are going to be written in that language? Will those Ukrainians write them? Or will it be an empty encyclopedia? Also it is true that Ukrainians, particulary the IP adresses of those that voted do not originate from Sibirea. So if the request was put up by '''native Siberian people''' then I would have understood the '''handful of ehthusiasts''' argument, and supported them, but this I am sorry is nothing but a political stunt and a sham, which IMO is deragotory in such a sense.
:::::Well perhaps if it does succeed, I wonder how long will it be before there would wikis in Surzhik, Trasyanka, our Kuban balachka or even UDAFF.net dialogue (because you can't really call that a language.)--[[en:User:Kuban kazak|Kuban Cossack]]

::::::: Really we need seven more:

1. Great Novgorod language wikipedia.

2. Pomor language wikipedia.

3. Don Balachka wikipedia

4. Tver language wikipedia

5. Pskov language wikipedia.

6. Great Vladimir language wikipedia.

7. Smolensk language wikipedia.

But siberian language is the most developed and have very large community (1200 articles made in 1,5 months)--[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 13:07, 15 July 2006 (UTC)

:: The wiki is tested now, and it is not empty. Why do you think it is relevant to the vote to be from Siberia or not? And to make Kuban balachka a full language and write wikipedia on it seems for me a good idea)) --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 15:57, 9 June 2006 (UTC)

:::That is the whole point, balachka is not a full language because its is a hybrid between Russian and 18th century Ukrainian. lso as it has no script or grammar and as it varies with locations (one stanitsa will pronounce the Гs as Hs, another as Gs or some will muffle them altogether) and generations (compare to how some old Cossacks speak and how some young children talk - BIG difference) so what is going to define it? Same with Surzhik and trasianka and even udaff... It would be nothing but a waste of time, as there is no printed literature in balachka let alone written sources. Moreover if official academies of Sciences from various states decree it as a dialect of Russian how are you going to make it a separate language? It is as rediculous as having different English wikis, and not American and British, but English and Scottish would be the comparison. Finally it is relevant that none of the votes originate from Siberia as it puts suspicion on just how widespread the project will become. Finally the fact that it has '''no international language code''' as opposed to tongues that are right now EXTINCT, I see very little prospect for it, and view this as nothing but a Livejournal.com April Fools joke. [[en:User:Kuban kazak|Kuban Cossack]]

:::: But if the balachka had its own tradition, it would be a language. And we are just trying to make this tradition for siberian language, which has many cossack words too, because old siberians was some kind of mixture from cossacks, pomors, and aborigens. International language code can be achieved, and we work at this. About 10 of the voters were from Siberia, so your argument is irrelevant. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 20:00, 9 June 2006 (UTC)

:::::This is not tradition, this is a language that is unrecognised and has no grammatical or linguistic structure. That is what is important. As for votes here we go:
:::::#[http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=368357&oldid=367967 fanex], IP - Cherkassy, Ukraine
:::::#[http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=367869&oldid=367865 vaenn], IP - Dnebrovsky, Dnepropetrovsk Oblast - Ukraine
:::::#[http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=prev&oldid=367865 Alexei], IP - Ukraine
:::::#[http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=362511&oldid=362501 Alex Yesod], IP - Moscow
:::::#[http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=360904&oldid=360903 Helgi Litvin], IP - Germany.
:::::#[http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=360901&oldid=360899 Siarhiej Bałachonaŭ] IP - Gomel
:::::#[http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=360896&oldid=360883 Oleg Dudnyk] IP - Kiev, Ukraine
:::::#[http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=360866&oldid=360864 rutopist] IP - St. Petersburg
:::::#[http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=360852&oldid=360840 Roman Baiduk] IP - Kiev (actually some of the IPs look so similar in numbers that it makes me want to really wonder how many real users there are...)
:::::#[http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=360839&oldid=360816 Aleksej Tajlakov] IP - Tomsk (1st Siberian author)
:::::#[http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=360816&oldid=360807 Pavel Levushkan] IP - Latvia
:::::#[http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=360727&oldid=360639 Steel Archer] IP - Ukraine
::::So '''ONE''' native Siberian editor. Rydel is Belarusian, Nefis whose user page is deleted [http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Nefis&action=edit]. Kivan, whose strong nationalistic russophobia is not a valid reason for a wikipedia as it will immediately question the future neutrality. So '''where are your Siberian voters'''? Finally why is it 33 when I count 16 supporters, of which only '''one''' is confirmed Siberian. [[en:User:Kuban kazak|Kuban Cossack]]

:::: Nickitos, Baznica, Kivan, I, Misha - all are from Siberia. Just see voting in non-natural section. I summarize votes in non-natural and natural sections, because it is all the same for us, if the lang will be considered natural or not, and I appealed to the ours vote in non-natural section because it is more likely to be successful. And there are about 10 siberians. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 08:51, 10 June 2006 (UTC)

*'''Oppose'''. So-called siberian "language" is not actually a language, but a dialect of Russian. --[[User:Jaroslavleff|Jaroslavleff]] 09:08, 4 June 2006 (UTC)
* '''Strong Oppose'''. This so-called "language" isn't natural. [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 15:17, 6 June 2006 (UTC)
** На основании чего ты делаешь столь брутальные выводы? [[User:Steel archer|Steel archer]] 23:41, 7 June 2006 (UTC)
*** Ёлки-палки, кого я вижу. Наши оранжевые друзья уже здесь. Вот откуда весь сыр-бор. Надо будет попробовать открыть Википедию на албанском :) [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 14:57, 9 June 2006 (UTC)


*<s>'''Strongly Oppose''' --[[User:64.229.157.212|64.229.157.212]] 00:45, 10 June 2006 (UTC)
This "proposal" should be classified as vandalism. This language is not real people! What next, should we legalize Marklar from [[South Park]] too?<s>
*'''Oppose.''' It is rather a practical joke similar to the currently discussed at [[w:Wikipedia:Deletion_review#Siberian_language]]. If chaldon enthusiasts have bandwidth to waste, by all means. But not within the common project. [[User:Mikkalai|Mikkalai]] 00:03, 12 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Strong Oppose'''. It's a joke... -- [[User:Grafikm fr|Grafikm fr]] 18:23, 12 June 2006 (UTC)
:P.S.: My meta account is new, but my [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Grafikm_fr en Wiki account] is my main one, don't forget this please :))
*'''oppose''', enthusiasm is no proof of language and no reason for wikipedia section. --[[User:Irpen|Irpen]] 07:45, 14 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Strongly Oppose''', there are no 5-10mln of speakers, where the hell did you digged them out? Siberia population is 20mln, where 80% are Russians and most of them came to Siberia durring Soviet urbanisation of Siberia. [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Elk_Salmon Elk Salmon] 08:17, 14 June 2006 (UTC)
: I consider every northern dialect speaker as speaker of siberian --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 18:43, 14 June 2006 (UTC)

:: You could consider as much as you want. But they should consider your language before opening Wikipedia on it. --[[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 14:09, 15 June 2006 (UTC)

: And Sberıa ıs not only SFO, but SFO + UFO + DFO, about 40 mln, 25% sons of the old siberians. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 19:52, 14 June 2006 (UTC)
:: Far East is not Siberia and as well as Ural. And where is figure 25% from? Just your fantasy? This is not language, not even dialect, but just slang of '''several''' people. [[User:Elk Salmon|Elk Salmon]] 23:59, 15 June 2006 (UTC)
::: About Ural for example read the article "Siberia" in english wiki. The map there covers Ural and northern areas of UFO. Siberian goverments of 1918 considered Far East as part of siberia. Putin's SFO is not Siberia, just modern demarkation. About the percentage read: "По подсчетам новосибирского ученого В.Н. Курилова, "удельный вес потомков русских старожилов в современном населении Западной Сибири может быть оценен в 15–20%". Этот вывод не кажется справедливым, так как русские старожилы не исчезли физически, более того, как показывает исследование современного этнического самосознания русских сибиряков, современные жители Сибири являются прямыми наследниками старожильческого населения, поскольку унаследовали от них этническую идентичность" http://ethnography.omskreg.ru/page.php?id=728

::: Yes, and comparing to this [[en:Category:Russian internet slang|Russian internet slang]] ([[ru:Жаргон падонков|Жаргон падонков]]) is very popular ;) [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 18:14, 14 June 2006 (UTC)

:::: But Russian internet slang contains about 100 words and no grammar, and Siberian language 15 000 words and specific grammar. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 14:08, 18 June 2006 (UTC)

*Oppose [[User:Ochkarik|Ochkarik]] 01:34, 15 June 2006 (UTC)

*'''Strong oppose''', this is ridiculous. [[User:MaxSem|Max<font size="+1">''S''</font>em]] 16:34, 14 June 2006 (UTC)

*'''Strong oppose'''. Small flash mob-like group of russian LJ users tries to promote their project in Wiki. --[[:ru:user:Boleslav1|Boleslav1]].
*'''Strong Oppose''' -- I live in Siberia but I have never heard about any "Siberian language". This is a recently constructed language which exists only in LJ. Only several people use it. [[:ru:user:DonaldDuck|DonaldDuck]]
:Еще услышишь. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 04:58, 1 July 2006 (UTC)

* '''Oppose'''. Strange, but my previous vote about it was removed by somebody. [[User:Maximaximax|MaxiMaxiMax]] 05:58, 15 June 2006 (UTC)
* '''Oppose'''. [[User:Amdf|Amdf]] 12:06, 15 June 2006 (UTC)
* '''Oppose'''. This 'language' really exists in LJ only. [[:ru:user:Dm]]
* '''Oppose'''. So called "Russian scam". [[:ru:user:Otf|OckhamTheFox]]

::Quite fine to hear this from Russian --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 16:40, 16 June 2006 (UTC)
::: Ничего удивительного. Возможно, вы путаете слова scum и scam. [[:ru:user:Otf|OckhamTheFox]]
::: Quite fine to see Russian (not Ukranian or American!) saying so about ru.wiki and it's users :) [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 18:36, 16 June 2006 (UTC)
:::: What have I say about ru.wiki? We like russian people dialects, but OckhamTheFox names this "Russian scam". But he himself is russian, maybe his vote is also "Russian scam"? It is fun)) And no word about ruwiki here))) --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 18:54, 16 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Oppose''' [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g]] [http://en.wikipedia.org/w/wiki.phtml?title=User_talk:Drbug&amp;action=edit&amp;section=new ] 07:01, 17 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Oppose'''. I was born in Siberia and spent more than 20 years there. [[:ru:user:Neko]]
: Why not 555 years, and what relation it has to the request? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 13:31, 5 July 2006 (UTC)

*'''Oppose'''. <s>фтопку</s>. I was born in Siberia and spent more than 17 years there. [[:ru:user:Lone Guardian]]
* '''Oppose''', фэйк [[:ru:user:Glaue2dk]]
* '''Oppose'''. Apparently an artificially constructed language with no native speakers, a mixture of archaic Russian dialects of Siberia (composed by a bunch of total dilettants in Russian dialectology) with a large infusion of words from Arabic and Persian (sic!). The latter could be changed for Chinese or Pali "loans", were Yaroslav a Buddhist and not a Muslim. As a constructed language, this one does not seem to be known and employed enough so that to qualify for a distinct Wikipedia. Please, note that the article about this ideom itself has been deleted in en:wiki and is currently voted for deletion in ru:wiki. Wouldn't it be stupid on the part of Wiki-Community to proclaim a language not significant enough to be mentioned in Wikipedia at all and at the same time significant enough to start a special Wikipedia in it? P.S. This is my first edit at meta actually, but with 2500+ edits in ru:wiki and a few hundred in en:wiki, I think, I am not a complete newbie. -- [[User:Dmitry Gerasimov|Dmitry Gerasimov]] 18:29, 19 June 2006 (UTC)

::: No arabic words in current version, some attempts to use them were a year ago, but failed. Still mentioned in 4 wikis --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 20:29, 19 June 2006 (UTC)
* '''Oppose'''. This 'language' is not exist. --[[User:Kaganer|Kaganer]] 18:22, 21 June 2006 (UTC)
: If the language do not exist, by what language are written the articles in incubator?--[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 12:42, 4 July 2006 (UTC)
* '''Oppose'''. There could be some dialect of Russian in XIX century, but not distinct enough, neither it exists now. The project is proposed by persons who make some seditious insets in texts in Russian wikipedia, exaggerating the Siberian regionalism. Also the author failed to provide a reference to any reliable book (ISBN), so the language movement exists only in the Internet => '''original research'''. [[User:Siberiano|Siberiano]] 08:38, 5 July 2006 (UTC)
: Another russian comes to lie for political reasons. Were the words taken from the Internet, or from the books with ISBN? Just see 10 books in non-natural section from which the words were taken. And why if movement exists in Internet, it is OR? Who established this equality Internet=OR? About 20 articles about the language were published in the Net or not in the Net, so it can not be OR by definition. And about the russian wikipedia I do not understand you))) why your relation to the Siberian regionalism is relevant on question of language? The truth is that you hate siberian regionalism, and this is why you declare the language OR here. But you can not stop us, sibwiki is about 600 articles already, soon will be 1000, 2000, 3000, 10000. Everybody from us know that the words are real and we heard them from our fathers, who lived in Siberia for centuries. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 09:08, 5 July 2006 (UTC)

:: I have about 500 reliable sources about the siberian dialect. Just read the first 10 -

1. Блинова О.И., Мартынова С.Э. словарь образных слов и выражений народного говора. – Томск: Изд-во научно-технической литературы, 1997 – 206с.

2.Богословская З.М. Словарь вариантной лексики сибирского говора. – Томск, 2000. – Т.1 – 303с.

3. Вершининский словарь/ Гл. ред. О.И. Блинова. – Томск: Изд-во Том. ун-та, 1998-2001. Т.1-5.

4. Полный словарь сибирского говора/ Гл. ред. О.И.Блинова. – Томск: Изд-во Том. ун-та, 1992-1995. – т. 1-4.

5. Иванцова Е.В. Феномен диалектной языковой личности. – Томск: Изд-во Том. ун-та,2002. – 312с.

6. Словарь просторечных русских говоров/ Гл. ред. О.И.Блинова 1998. – 320с.

7. Раков Г.А. Диалектный идеографический словарь. – Томск. – изд-во Том. ун-та, 1998. – 345с.

8 Словарь русских старожильческих говоров Среднего Прииртышья. В 3 т. Томск, 1992.

9 Садретдинова Г.А. История заселения русскими Западной Сибири в связи с изучением сибирских старожильческих говоров. //Диалектологические и историко-лингвистические проблемы. Омск, 1999.

10 Даль В.И. Толковый словарь живого великорусского языка: в 4 т., М., 1989.

If you shall not stop your lie about siberian language and movement, I shall copy all the 500 sources here in the voting. You can see that siberians now write 100 articles a day, so we are very steady, and sure we shall copy the 500 sources here if moscovites will not cease to lie. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 09:42, 5 July 2006 (UTC)
:: No, that's you who lies. Nowhere in any Siberian city anybody speaks this language. You try to present a set of vocabulary deviations, dialects, for a single language. You mix together here the vocabularies of Siberian rural dialects and dialects of old believers who lived isolately. So, there is just a set of different words and different meanings that need explanation for a non-familiar, but not more. The titles say for everything: говор (patois). Why do you list here Даль В.И. (Dal V.I.), Russian dictionary? [[User:Siberiano|Siberiano]] 13:12, 5 July 2006 (UTC)

::: So siberian words exist and combined together they form the language which was spoken in 19 century, and this language we want to restore. Some words are in Dal vocabulary. Dal considered ukrainian, belorussian and siberian as three "dialect" the most different from the official Russian. The sources testify, that the language of old Siberians was VERY different from the official Rissian. This is truth, but you say lie - "not distinct enough, neither it exists now". It exists in Siberian villages, and in hearts of Siberian intellegent people. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 13:29, 5 July 2006 (UTC)
:: And stop that bullshit about regionalism. I'm a Sibeian regionalist. But you try to promote a fake language project for an unknown purpose. [[User:Siberiano|Siberiano]] 13:21, 5 July 2006 (UTC)
::: LOL, every moscovite here will soon declare himself siberian regionalist and siberian, for stop the development of the language)))) just read volgota.com and other sites about our purposes, and cease lie here. We shall do 1000 articles until the Siberian Independence Day (17 july), and 10 000 until the day of White-Green Army (29 january), and your lie will be of no effect. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 13:29, 5 July 2006 (UTC)
:::: LOL at you, man and about those tales of language living in "hearts of intelligent people". I know the history well, but the language is your invention. And I'm not a moscovite, lier. You can't prove anything without trying to pesonally insult the opposed. '''Do not feed the troll'''. [[User:Siberiano|Siberiano]] 14:00, 5 July 2006 (UTC)

:::: It was your goal to begin personal insult here, because you came with a complete lie and can not proof it, and came with personal insults about exaggeration of siberian regionalism) Provide any reliable sources that you are not moscovite)) By your own logic, if you can not proof that you are siberian, but fight in the Moscow part, I think that you are moscovite)) and this is a complete LOL that you are siberian regionalist) to what group do you belong, who is the leader of your group, in what actions did you participate? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 03:25, 6 July 2006 (UTC)

* '''Oppose'''. --[[User:Paginazero|Paginazero]] 19:05, 6 July 2006 (UTC)

* '''Oppose''' [[ru:user:VanHelsing.16|VanHelsing.16]]

Perhaps every Russian voted "oppose", or there are some more Russians in the world? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 14:47, 4 August 2006 (UTC)

:And only Mr. Zolotaryov contributed to adding some arguments for the case. Or are there some more "Sibereano-Chaldoneans" in the world?--[[User:Shakura|Shakura]] 13:55, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

:: Why do you lie? See above, about 10 voters argumenting, 10 persons write in the wiki, but you continue to lie - this is the last russian weapon in this world))) --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 14:15, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

* '''Oppose'''. There is no such language. I don't know what's the sense of artificially creating it. Is it the will to create some kind of further splits of Russian society? [[User:Voevoda|Voevoda]] 23:44, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

:This is complete lie about invention. Do not delete votes of real people who provide emails, votes of SteelArcher, Maviulke12 and other well=known persons. Please stop vandalizing in Meta. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 07:09, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

*{{oppose}} --[[User:B1mbo|B1mbo]] 20:27, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

=== Central Atlas Tamazight ===
{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= [[User:Amazigh]] (N)
|User accounts of others= <br>[[User:Massinissa]] (N)
|Language code= [http://www.ethnologue.com/14/show_iso639.asp?code=ber ber].See also:
**[http://www.ethnologue.com/show_language.asp?code=tzm tzm]
**[http://www.ethnologue.com/show_language.asp?code=kab kab]
**[http://www.ethnologue.com/show_language.asp?code=tmh tmh]
**[http://www.ethnologue.com/show_language.asp?code=zen zen]
|And other her [http://www.ethnologue.com/show_family.asp?subid=90002 berber]
|Proposed domain= tmz.wikipedia.org
|Wikipedia article= [[en:Berber language]]
|Native name=
|English name=
|Number of speakers= 60 to 80 millions
|Locations spoken=
**Africa: Morocco, Algeria, Mauritus, Sahara, Tunisia, Lybia, Egypt, Sudan, Ethiopia, Mali, Niger...
**World: France, Spain, Germany, Belgium, Netherlands, Québec, USA
|Related languages=
|Promoting organizations=
** Site officiel du Congrès Mondial Amazigh (CMA) Défense des droits et des intérêts de la nation amazighe http://www.congres-mondial-amazigh.org World Congress Amazigh
** Baby Wiki [http://www.tamazirght.org Support Amazigh.org french association]
** Amazigh-Voice.com; Amazigh Tamazight... Amazigh Cultural Association in America [http://www.amazigh-voice.com Amazigh Voice]
** when North Africa speaks about itself (AmazighWorld) [http://www.amazighworld.org Amazigh World]
** Amazigh - windows on the Amazigh (berber) world: culture, music, human rights, amazigh studies, gallery, communication, all about imazighen (Berbers) in Quebec [http://www.amazigh-quebec.org Amazigh Quebec]
** Amazigh.nl. Les imazirghens en Hollande - Bewust van de waarde van cultuur en identiteit Nederlandstalige site over de Amazigh taal, geschiedenis, culturele kenmerken, literaire werken, muziek [http://www.amazigh.nl Amazigh Netherlands]
|Request on mailing list=
}}

* '''Oppose''' The proposal is very wide and confusing; the berberian languages are numerous, the '''tzm''' code is used only for the Central Atlas Tamazight language, spoken by 3.1 millons of people in Morocco and Algeria.--'''[[User:Taichi|Taichi]]''' - ([[User talk:Taichi|あ！]]) 06:28, 4 June 2006 (UTC)
** Why opose? There are multiple [http://www.ethnologue.com/show_family.asp?subid=90005 Tamazight] languages see the reference to Ethnologue. When they support a few million people, I think that is ample for a new project. [[User:GerardM|GerardM]] 20:03, 11 June 2006 (UTC)
*** Oppose because the proposal is confusing. It is for the whole berberian language or for one in particular ? (1 August 2006)
** I agree (25 July 2006)
*'''Support''' - [[User:Belgian man|Belgian man]] <small>([[:nl:Gebruiker:Cars en travel|nl]] [[:na:User:Belgian man|na]] [[en:User:Belgian man|en]])</small> 09:50, 13 June 2006 (UTC)
*<s>'''Oppose''' no native speakers requested this. </s>- [[User:FrancisTyers|FrancisTyers]] 20:12, 14 June 2006 (UTC)
**Yes, they did. --[[User:Node ue|Node ue]] 22:57, 8 August 2006 (UTC)
* How is it related to French English or Spanish?--[[User:69.174.252.80|69.174.252.80]] 02:49, 19 June 2006 (UTC)
** Nothing, it is a wrong assertion of the proposer (25 July 2006)
* See request for Kabyle in [[Requests for new languages/Native speaker support]] (25 July 2006)
*'''Support''' --[[User:Node ue|Node ue]] 22:57, 8 August 2006 (UTC)
*'''Support'''. --[[User:Arbeo|'''A'''<span style="font-variant:small-caps;text-transform:lowercase">RBE</span>'''0''']] 14:50, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

===Aramaic/Syriac Wiktionary===
{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= makkow
|User accounts of others=
|Language code= syr
|Proposed domain= syr.wiktionary.org
|Wikipedia article= [[en:Syriac language]]
|Native name=
|English name= Syriac language
|Number of speakers= 2.5 Million speak fluently but in different dialects
|Locations spoken= Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Iran, Iraq, Lebanon, Palestine, Israel, Syria, Turkey
|Related languages= Ancient Aramaic
|Promoting organizations=
|Request on mailing list=
}}
* I propose that the should be a new wiktionary intended for aramaic/syriac speakers. I propose that it be titled "syr.wiktionary.org". This would be a good resource for Chaldeans, Assyrians, Maronites, other Syriac speaking people. I do speak the language, know its spellings, and I wish to administate this webpage to prevent false definitions of words or mispelled words. I need to know how to establish this wiktionary and to change the fonts used within it. I am Makkow [[User:makkow|makkow]] and i would greatly appreciate the help. Thank you!
* There are many languages considered Aramic and Syriac is only one [http://www.ethnologue.com/show_family.asp?subid=90041 Ethnologue] gives you a nice overview about this. Wiktionary aims to have all words of all languages with a userinterface in one language. When you pick one, you face an uphill struggle. When you want to concentrate on adding words of one or more of these languages, you might include it in an existing Wiktionary project. [[User:GerardM|GerardM]] 13:56, 3 June 2006 (UTC)
* {{Support}} --'''[[User:Bentael|Bentael]]'''
* {{Support}} [[User:Dovi|Dovi]] 07:43, 15 August 2006 (UTC)

===Romanized Persian ===
{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= [[User:Sorriz|Sorriz]] dj_sorre@hotmail.com (N)
|User accounts of others=
|Language code= fa-latn
|Proposed domain= per.wikipedia.org or pes.wikipedia.org
|Wikipedia article= [[en:Persian language]] [[en:UniPers]]
|Native name= Fârsi
|English name= Persian in latin script
|Number of speakers= around 110 million
|Locations spoken= Iran, Tadjikistan, Afghanistan and big minorities in USA, Canada, Germany and Sweden
|Related languages= [[en:Persian language]] ([[:fa:|fa]])
|Promoting organizations= http://www.unipers.com
|Request on mailing list=
}}

* '''Relevant infos:''' The language is Romanized Persian. This would be a great idea because there are millions of iranians outside of Iran who grew up in a foregin country with no possibilities of learning how to read Persian with Perso-Arabic letters. Romanized persian is great, because then all the iranians from all over the world could read and understand the persian language, not only the migrated Iranians, but also the Tajiks in Tajikistan who only know the Cyrllic and Latin alphabet (not the Perso-Arabic one). This is a huge issue among us Persian-speakers, not only locally, but globally aswell. This is a way of reuniting these countries and the versions of languages to one whole. This is a way for the people who use the latin alphabet to learn Persian easier.
In this stage, the Latinized Persian alphabet is introduced in schools as a phonemic standard alphabet for Persian transcription, as part of the regular curriculum. Such a simple and easy to use alphabet should be effortless and expeditious to learn for Persian speaking students. It will help them in learning the correct pronunciation of words they might have difficulty reading in the current alphabet. For non-Persian speaking students of the Persian language, it would lift the colossal barrier of having to learn the cumbersome Perso-Arabic script before starting to actually learn the language itself. The only books that would need to be transcribed in this phase are mainly language textbooks, and some of the major Persian literary works like the Shahnameh, Hafez's poetry, Balkhi's Masnavi, etc.
A scientific, phonemically structured new script based on the Alphabetic Principle. Mastering reading and writing would become straightforward and simplified. Children and beginners would be able to read any Persian book after only a few months of practice. Educated people would be able to master reading and writing in a very short time. Therefore, a phonemic script like UniPers would help boost interest among Persian speakers in their own literature, culture, and history. On the other hand, the old Perso-Arabic writing system is an obsolete script that completely violates the Alphabetic Principle.
Being based on the Latin alphabet would take advantage of its universality. It would make the Persian language much more accessible not only to our children and those who have obtained their secondary and higher education outside the Persian-speaking countries, but also to the non-Persian speaking people who have an interest in studying the Persian culture and history. Thus, Persian culture and language would become readily available to all without the hindrance of a complex, unfamiliar, and cumbersome writing system like Perso-Arabic.
A new Latin-based alphabet for Persian can help the language and enrich it. The weak argument that the Persian literary heritage would be lost is completely false. One can print and read the great literary works of Hafez, Sa'di and Ferdowsi even more easily in a phonemic Latin-based alphabet than in the Perso-Arabic. The Perso-Arabic alphabet has turned many Iranians off from reading literary and historical books. This means that unlike what the proponents of the old alphabet say about UniPers severing our contacts with our culture, Perso-Arabic has done more to achieve this break.


====Support====
#'''Comment''' - If there is a 1:1 correspondence between romanised Farsi and normal Farsi, wouldn't it be a much better idea to implement some sort of transliteration program? See the [[:sr:|Serbian wikipedia]] for an example. --[[User:IJzeren Jan|IJzeren Jan]] 10:33, 25 June 2006 (UTC)
#:*''see also arabian script Azerbaidjani, above, and'' [http://wiktionaryz.org WiktionaryZ] -- [[User:Purodha|Purodha Blissenbach]] 11:52, 4 August 2006 (UTC)

#{{Support}}--[[User:Fratele lui Bonaparte, il cunosti?|Fratele lui Bonaparte, il cunosti?]] 05:44, 10 August 2006 (UTC)
#'''Support''' It was always a great problem for me to learn persian because I can not fluently read arabic script, and need sufficient amount of time to begin read it fluently. Read text in new language with slow speed is a bad way to learn it. Even arabic has now latin script and there is Quran and Haddith in the Internet in arabic language and latin alfabet. But I know, many Muslims want to learn not only Arabic, but also Persian and Turk languages, because there are so many classic texts of our culture written in Persian and Turk. So I support this proposal and shall help to develop the wiki, if my basic Persian would be useful there:-) --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 22:03, 25 June 2006 (UTC)

'''Support''' --[[User:Maviulke12|Maviulke12]] 00:20, 1 July 2006 (UTC)

====Oppose====

* '''Oppose.''' Persian is doing well with the Perso-Arabic script. A spelling reform would be useful to remove some anomalies, but that's another issue. --[[User:Rasulo|Rasulo]]
** ''Comment.'' How do you know if Persian is doing well with the Perso-Arabic script? We see no motivation in your oppose. How could you possibly know anything about Persian when you are Finnish? That's the worst oppose I've ever heard. --[[User:Sorriz|Sorriz]]

===Children's English Wikipedia (9 support, 17 oppose, 1 neutral)===
{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= [[User:Jrothwell|Jrothwell]] 15:50, 13 June 2006 (UTC) (Metawiki, Wikipedia), [[User:Leon2323|Leon2323]] 15:20, 25 June 2006 (UTC) (ALL)
|User accounts of others=
|Language code=
|Proposed domain=
|Wikipedia article=
|Native name=
|English name=
|Number of speakers=
|Locations spoken=
|Related languages= Simple English
|Promoting organizations= [http://www.computerprojects.biz ComputerProjectsDotBiz]
|Request on mailing list=
}}
* This will be a Wikipedia aimed at children, with a less text-heavy interface, more friendly language, explicit content censored and special reference desks for homework help.

'''Support'''

* {{Support}} [[en:User:CrnaGora|CrnaGora]] 16:33, 17 June 2006 (UTC)
* {{Support}} [[en:User:Milan B.|Milo]] 16:50, 17 June 2006 (UTC)
* {{Support}} -- [[en:User:God of Chaos|God of Chaos]] 02:03, 21 June 2006 (UTC)
* {{support}} I beg to differ with the comment made by 89.176.54.194. Wikijunior is a series of books. '''Not''' a free-use site. I think that Simple English Wikipedia is made more for people who are '''''learning''''' English. A Childrens' Wikipedia would be more for teenagers, as many mainstream Wikipedia articles contain too many details, and details that they aren't meant too learn and thus many students will add information to an article (of which they have no idea what it means) may be asked to explain what this means. They will (generally) be incapable of doing so. On the other hand Simple English Wikipedia is way too simple to be accepted as a Upper Primary School/High School assignment. So this wiki should be somewhere in between if it is to work. However it should be re-named to ''Children's Wikipedia'' instead of ''Children's '''English''' Wikipedia''
[[w:en:User:Booksworm|Booksworm]] 13:56, 25 June 2006 (UTC) '''Och mein gott, was sind sie blötig schei...''' you lot are so bloody annoying it's amazing. Wikijunior is still in raw phase. It does not alreadyx exist I mean come on! [[User:Booksworm|Booksworm]] 14:52, 10 July 2006 (UTC)
* {{Support}} '''Strong support''' I actually came to this page to request for a childrens' Wikipedia after a request at Wikia failed, but hey, there's already a request. I am currently at secondary school but I find that EnWp is sometimes a bit too complex. It can use all these scientific names (blah, blah, blah). As for Simple English, that's for people ''learning'' English. On this wiki, we can play around with css and javascript to provide a ''friendly'' interface. I think that there are too few Wikipedians who are in the age group mentioned above (see [[en:Category:Wikipedians by generation]]). When I get back to school on Monday, I'll set up a petition. I'll send in the link to the 'petition website'. --[[User:Leon2323|Leon2323]] 15:20, 25 June 2006 (UTC) ([[en:User:Leon2323|EnWp]])
: Ok, I've asked the survey. I asked 22 people questions about wikis. You can find the results in a Microsoft Access database at [http://computerprojects.biz/Children.mdb http://computerprojects.biz/Children.mdb].
::* ''This is a proprietary format. Would it be possible to make it available in more usable format?''
:::* ''[[User:Leon2323/children|Here it is]]''
* {{Support}}. Adult language, the desire of LGBT people to insert gays/lesbians into every historical topic and the proliferation of artricles about pornstars and sexual positions often linked from most unexpected places (such as an article about "spoon") is the main argument in many schools against wikipedia. [[User:Mikkalai|Mikkalai]] 17:30, 9 July 2006 (UTC)
** Americans should give up their bigotry, censorship and sexual deprivation attempts against their growing-ups and young adults. We are talking about teens, i.e. men who have ''at most'' 2½ years left before they're able to become parents themselves. They usually need more time to develop their sexuality healthy, not less, and certainly not another set-back of ten more years! You're attmenpt is futile anyways in a society that allows their teens and pre-teens hours of commercial tv consumption each day where 1 out 12 advertisemnts and 8 of 10 music videos is (soft) porn. Come on! If it was only about this kinda stupidity, I'd '''strongly oppose''' this motion. -- [[User:Purodha|Purodha Blissenbach]] 12:49, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
* {{Support}} --[[User:Gray Porpoise|Gray Porpoise]] 18:40, 14 August 2006 (UTC)

'''Oppose'''

* {{Oppose}} There is already Simple English Wikipedia, and as for homework help, this should be in other sites. – [[User:Rotemliss|rotemliss]] – [[User Talk:Rotemliss|Talk]] 14:37, 14 June 2006 (UTC)
**The main idea is not the same as in simple english. [[User:71.146.70.205|71.146.70.205]] 17:03, 9 July 2006 (UTC)
* {{Oppose}} per Rotemliss. [[User:IJzeren Jan|IJzeren Jan]] 19:12, 14 June 2006 (UTC)
* '''Strong oppose''' [[User:Steinbach|Steinbach <small>(formerly Caesarion)</small>]] 17:33, 21 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Strong oppose'''. Simple English is bad enough, we don't need another one. &mdash;[[User:Nightstallion|<span style="font-variant:small-caps">Nightstallion</span>]] [[User talk:Nightstallion|''(?)'']] 05:57, 22 June 2006 (UTC)
**If it is bad, it is useless, but something age-oriented is necessary. We do have books specifically written to acomodate stages of human development. [[User:71.146.70.205|71.146.70.205]] 17:03, 9 July 2006 (UTC)
*'''Oppose''' unnecessary. - [[User:FrancisTyers|FrancisTyers]] 19:17, 22 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''En contra / Oppose'''. [[User:Taragui|Taragui]] 12:53, 23 June 2006 (UTC)
* '''[comment]''' This seed has already been sowed. Please help it grow instead of starting it all over again. Go here → [[b:Wikijunior]].
--[[User:89.176.54.194|89.176.54.194]] 16:24, 23 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Oppose'''. There are other ways for junior readers. [[User:Hégésippe Cormier|Hégésippe]] | [[User talk:Hégésippe Cormier|±Θ±]] 04:34, 24 June 2006 (UTC)
*{{Oppose}}: Please go to [[Wikijunior]]. --'''[[User:Taichi|Taichi]]''' - ([[User talk:Taichi|あ！]]) 09:41, 29 June 2006 (UTC)
*'''Oppose'''. Children learn best when they're not being talked down to. Beatrix Potter famously used the word "soporific" in a children's book; there's no reason children can't learn from the full-fledged English Wikipedia. [[User:Angr|Angr]] 16:54, 1 July 2006 (UTC)
**The main point here is elimination of sexually explicit content. "Simplified language" does not mean writing everything in 2-syllable words. It is wiki after all: any 20-dollar word may be wikilinked. [[User:71.146.70.205|71.146.70.205]] 16:56, 9 July 2006 (UTC)
*{{oppose}} [[User:Ek7|Ek7]] 13:57, 8 July 2006 (UTC)
*'''Oppose'''. What's wrong with Wikijunior? This concept here looks a bit half-baked to me. IMHO, the successful concept of a collaborative, self-organizing online encyclopedia editable by its readers will not work with children. Besides, children can only be prevented from seeing adult content by responsible parents not letting them go on the internet on their own, not by writing a new Wikipedia. --[[User:Arbeo|'''A'''<span style="font-variant:small-caps;text-transform:lowercase">RBE</span>'''0''']] 14:26, 22 July 2006 (UTC)
*{{Oppose}} Already simple and WikiJunior. Children are too wide ranging to have a single project. --[[User:OldakQuill|Oldak]] [[User_talk:OldakQuill|Quill]] 18:33, 23 July 2006 (UTC)
'''Oppose'''. There is a Simple English and a proposed Wikichildren. I think that's enough. [[User:Blue caterpillar|Blue caterpillar]] 20:48, 26 July 2006 (UTC)
* {{oppose}} [[User:200.217.166.126|200.217.166.126]] 13:20, 27 July 2006 (UTC) There's no point in creating one more Wikipedia in English.
* '''Oppose''' 100% unneccessary. Open a kids homework questions answered support page in Wikipedia. --[[User:84.60.245.132|84.60.245.132]]
* {{Oppose}} I didn't know children speak a different language than adults in english speaking countries... [[User:Traroth|Traroth]] 21:35, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
* {{Oppose}} - Reason: We may use Simple english Wikipedia for simple words. Even childrens don't know some English words like "nigard". [[User:A-yao|A-yao]] 14:51, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
* {{Oppose}} - There is already Simple english Wikipedia exists --[[User:A1|A1]] 09:21, 19 August 2006 (UTC)


'''Neutral'''

'''Un-Clear'''
*--[[en:User:Gaius Julius Caesar|Dicatator and General Gaius Julius Caesar IV a/k/a Julius Caesar]] 02:07, 21 June 2006 (UTC)

===Vai Wikipedia===
{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= [[User:Aeetlrsk|Aeetlrsk]] 22:24, 20 June 2006 (UTC) (Metawiki), [[en:User:Sahmeditor]] (English Wikipedia), [[wiktionary:User:Ko e aeetlrsk]] (English Wiktionary)
|User accounts of others=
|Language code= vai
|Proposed domain= vai.wikipedia.org
|Wikipedia article= [[en:Vai language]]
|Native name= Vai
|English name= Vai language
|Number of speakers= 105,000
|Locations spoken= Western Liberia, Sierra Leone
|Related languages=
|Promoting organizations=
|Request on mailing list=
}}
* Vai is spoken by 105,000 speakers in the Middle East. I think we should have a Vai Wikipedia.
* '''Support''' - [[User:Belgian man|Belgian man]] <small>([[:nl:Gebruiker:Cars en travel|nl]] [[:na:User:Belgian man|na]] [[en:User:Belgian man|en]])</small> 13:58, 27 June 2006 (UTC)

*Hello! I`ve got one request for you. I collect words in various languages. Now I`m looking for word "sugar" in other languages, but I can`t find a Vai dictionary. I`ve got counterparts of word "sugar" in Japanese, Ahmaric, Thai, Georgian and Chinese, so can you write me what is '''"sugar" in Vai language?''' I`ve got this word in 317 languages and dialects of many regions and countries in the world so it is very important for me! Thank you very much! '''[[:pl:Wikipedysta:Szoltys|Szoltys]]''' ''[[:pl:Dyskusja Wikipedysty:Szoltys|<talk>]]''

===Simple Spanish Wikipedia===
* Spanish is worldwide a big language. Would it be an idea to start a "simple
Spanish" wiki: sencillo.wikipedia.org? I would be prepared to contribute to
it. Greetings, [[User:Jcb|Jcb]] 21:18, 21 June 2006 (UTC)
** See also the [[incubator:Category:Sencillo test]] at incubator. [[User:Jcb|Jcb]] 22:23, 21 June 2006 (UTC)

====Support====
#Support. Fine articles, it can be used for learning Spanish for people who do not know it well. Even I with very basic level of Spanish was able to understand them. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 23:53, 21 June 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}} I'm learning Spanish, I don't see why not. --[[User:Jrothwell|Jrothwell]] 15:57, 22 June 2006 (UTC)
#Thats exactly what I would say! [[User:Dutchy-Dick|Dutchy-Dick]] 19:53, 22 June 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}} I'm learning Spanish too, yeah why not! --[[User:Flying DutchJan|Flying DutchJan]] 21:53, 22 June 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}} [[User:Jcb|Jcb]] 20:04, 22 June 2006 (UTC) - I don't know if I'm supposed to vote for my own proposal?
#{{Support}} A great idea! As interest to Spanish is growing worldwide, this wiki will be very popular. [[User:Slavik IVANOV|Slavik IVANOV]] 23:29, 29 June 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}} [[user:GangstaEB|<font color="black">Gang</font>]][[user talk:GangstaEB|<font color="red">staE</font>]][[Special:Contributions/GangstaEB|<font color=green>B</font>]] [[w:user:GangstaEB|<font color="blue">(W)</font>]] 18:19, 4 July 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}} Goddammit all those who wrote ''simple spanish'' isn't a language. Well, is Simple English? Bloody hell; If we can have a simple English, then why can't we have a simple for each Wiki with + 100'000 articles? I have never seen thicker people in my entire life (George Bush is less thick) [[User:Booksworm|Booksworm]] 14:43, 10 July 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}} --[[User:85.141.204.10|85.141.204.10]] 20:49, 3 August 2006 (UTC)
*{{Support}} - Purpose: for many people to learn the Spanish language. Suggestion: should the domnain be '''simspan.xxx.org'''? [[User:A-yao|A-yao]] 14:54, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

====Oppose====
#'''Oppose'''. I'm against Simple English, so it shouldn't come as a surprise that I'm also against a dumbed-down ''español sencillo''. &mdash;[[User:Nightstallion|<span style="font-variant:small-caps">Nightstallion</span>]] [[User talk:Nightstallion|''(?)'']] 05:58, 22 June 2006 (UTC)
# '''N En contra / Oppose'''--[[User:Lin linao|Lin linao]] 22:13, 22 June 2006 (UTC) : Ver comentarios / See comments.
#'''Strong oppose'''. There's not any standard ''simple Spanish''. Wikipedia in Spanish desperatedly needs more contributors rather than split into another version for newcomers. --[[User:JRGL|JRGL]] 22:31, 22 June 2006 (UTC)
# {{Oppose}} --[[User:Ecemaml|Ecemaml]] 08:42, 23 June 2006 (UTC)
# '''En contra'''. This has come up before, and, as before, I think that not only Simple English didn't fare too well, but also better choices exist for simplified content for junior readers. [[User:Taragui|Taragui]] 12:49, 23 June 2006 (UTC)
# '''EN CONTRA''' '''OPPOSE''' - ''Not an lamguaje'' ''Ja-ja''. [[User:Felipealvarez|Felipealvarez]] 14:37, 23 June 2006 (UTC)
# {{Oppose}} [[User:Gothmog|Gothmog]] 18:40, 23 June 2006 (UTC)
# '''Oppose'''. ''Simple English'' has already shown that the idea of ''Simple XXX Wikipedias'' is not a good idea. There are other ways for junior readers. [[User:Hégésippe Cormier|Hégésippe]] | [[User talk:Hégésippe Cormier|±Θ±]] 04:32, 24 June 2006 (UTC)
# {{Oppose}} Define ''simple spanish'' before, please. [[User:Platonides|Platonides]] (native) 10:23, 24 June 2006 (UTC)
# {{Oppose}} we had already voted this... --[[User:Equi|Equi]] 14:06, 24 June 2006 (UTC)
# {{oppose}} [[User:Airunp|Airunp]] 12:16, 25 June 2006 (UTC)
# {{Oppose}} – [[User:Rotemliss|rotemliss]] – [[User Talk:Rotemliss|Talk]] 12:33, 25 June 2006 (UTC)
# {{Oppose}} [[User:Oscar .|Oscar .]] 17:43, 25 June 2006 (UTC)
# {{Oppose}} -[[User:B1mbo|B1mbo]] 22:02, 25 June 2006 (UTC)
# '''Strong oppose'''. The samples are so full of grammar mistakes that should be taken as a joke. [[User:Cinabrium|Cinabrium]] 04:58, 27 June 2006 (UTC)
# {{Oppose}} [[User:Lasneyx|Lasneyx]] 11:39, 28 June 2006 (UTC)
# [[Image:Symbol oppose vote.svg|15px]] '''Oppose''' [[User:Comae|Comae]] 21:32, 28 June 2006 (UTC) "Simple Spanish" doesn't exist. And if the test pages are a good example of the kind of "Spanish" will be used, Spanish learners are bound to forget (or worse) whatever they already know. If you want to learn Spanish, use Wikipedia en español --tons of things to do for learners, and 95% of articles there have better Spanish than those test pages. Or use the translation project at Wikiversity, which was thought for language learners.
# {{Oppose}} --'''[[User:Taichi|Taichi]]''' - ([[User talk:Taichi|あ！]]) 09:30, 29 June 2006 (UTC): ¿Again? This proposal was rejected few months ago. Please, don't persist with this bad joke.
# {{Oppose}} [[User:Gizmo II|Gizmo II]] 02:04, 30 June 2006 (UTC)
# [[User:FML|FML]] 14:15, 4 July 2006 (UTC)
# {{oppose}} [[User:Orgullomoore|Orgullomoore]] 06:04, 10 July 2006 (UTC) Comae is right, it doesn't do a learner any good to read bad examples, but that's not our problem. It ''should'' be our problem, however, that Simple Spanish does not exist. The examples provided are examples of incorrect Spanish. Wikipedia as a whole, and especially the Spanish Wikipedia, doesn't have the extra resources available to waste on inventing new languages--let's stick with what we've got.
# {{oppose}} --[[User:Jpcristian|Jpcristian]] ([[es:Usuario:Jpcristian]]) 06:03, 10 July 2006 (UTC) It's a made-up language, it shouldn't be included.
# {{oppose}} [[User:Tomatejc|Tomatejc]] ([[es:Usuario:Tomatejc]]) 06:26, 10 July 2006 (UTC)
# {{oppose}} [[User:Aliman5040|Aliman5040]] 18:11, 11 July 2006 (UTC) ([[:es:Usuario:Aliman5040]])
# {{oppose}} [[User:Kordas|Kordas]] 09:47, 22 July 2006 (UTC)
# {{oppose}} --[[User:Mauricio Maluff|Mauricio Maluff]] 16:49, 23 July 2006 (UTC)
# {{oppose}} As much as I want to support, there is no "Simple Spanish" language. --[[User:Gray Porpoise|Gray Porpoise]] 15:55, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{oppose}} --[[User:Kokoo|Kokoo]] 17:17, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

====Other====
#'''[comment]''' I would oppose if I were logged in. By the looks of the two sample articles (full of grammatical errors), it's nothing more than an astute attempt by Spanish learners to get some free coaching. <code>;-)</code> --[[User:89.176.54.194|89.176.54.194]] 17:27, 22 June 2006 (UTC)
#'''[comment]''' Like the opinion before, if I were logged in I would vote against the idea of having a Simple Spanish Wikipedia. I have read the two test articles and as a native Spanish-speaker I must tell you they both are not well written. No sentence there is correct. And the faults are enormous. From my point of view, having a Wikipedia full of articles like these ones wouldn't help people to learn Spanish. [[ca:Usuari:Manu bcn]]
##My Spanish is good enough to '''know''' that this is not true. There is for certain not that amount of errors in the articles. [[User:Jcb|Jcb]] 18:51, 22 June 2006 (UTC)
*You think your Spanish is good enough. That's your oppinion and indeed untrue. --[[User:Ecemaml|Ecemaml]] 08:44, 23 June 2006 (UTC)
###As a spanish native speaker (my english sucks, sorry), I'm with Manu bcn. The sample articles are incorrect. Gender errors and the like. [[User:Tostadora|Tostadora]] 22:21, 22 June 2006 (UTC)
###Another Spanish native speaker here. Your Madrid article, for instance, has sentences like: ''En inviernos a veces es debajo 8º''. Any elementary Spanish learner should know how to build it correctly: ''En invierno a veces está por debajo de 8º''. Instead, it only misleads. --[[User:JRGL|JRGL]] 22:43, 22 June 2006 (UTC)
:::::Pero es que el articulo es un joke-fake, ¿en invierno a veces menos de 8º? ¿y en verano la media es 24º?, improbable cuando en invierno hay heladas todos los días (<0º) y en verano rara vez baja de 35º, siendo normal que esté sobre 40º, ¿seguro que se refiere a Madrid? [[User:Felipealvarez|Felipealvarez]] 14:41, 23 June 2006 (UTC)
# El Español Simple o Sencillo no es un lenguaje desarrollado con reglas específicas como el Inglés Simple, sino la forma en que el usuario Jcb piensa que resulta más sencillo. Ver [[:es:Wikipedia:Wikipedia no es una fuente primaria|Wikipedia:Wikipedia no es una fuente primaria]]. Lo siento, los ejemplos están llenos de errores y un hablante nativo podría tener problemas para entenderlos. (Simple Spanish or ''Sencillo'' is not a developed system as Simple English. Today is only the vision of User Jcb about how to make a simplified Spanish. See [[:en:Wikipedia:No original research]]. I'm sorry, samples contain a lot of errors. A native speaker could have problems reading them.)

#You know spanish enoguh to be able to understand it. Other english-learning people can understand it. But they're not in good spanish. This may be a case of newbies understandig themselves with invalid grammar. Please define ''simple spanish'' before. The 3 articles have different errors and nonsense-phrases (we can imagine what is intended to say, but the phrase is absurd). [[User:Platonides|Platonides]] 10:23, 24 June 2006 (UTC)
* Los artículos creador en el Incubator son una blasfemia al español, la redacción que se utilizó es pésima, ni siquiera un español hablaría así, se tienen rasgos muy tomados de la gramática del inglés u otro idioma germánico (¿influencias del idioma nativo de Jcb?). Propongo que esos tres artículos sean borrados porque así uno no habla en español, complejo, sencillo, para niños o ancianos. Así no es el español. --'''[[User:Taichi|Taichi]]''' - ([[User talk:Taichi|あ！]]) 09:36, 29 June 2006 (UTC)

===Belarusian (Orthography Revision of 1959) (16 support / 9 oppose) ===
{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= [[User:Pravapis1959]] ('''N''')
|User accounts of others=
*
*

**[[User:Bunker]] ('''N''')
**[[User:A. Yurkevich]] ('''N''')
**[[User:Mienski]] ('''N''')
**[[User:Boox]] ('''N''')
**[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]]
**[[User:Аlexander Gouk]] ('''N''')
**[[User:MaximLitvin]] ('''N''')

|Language code= bel
|Proposed domain= bel.wikipedia.org
|Wikipedia article= [[en:Belarusian language|Belarusian language]]
|Native name= Беларуская мова
|English name= Academic Belarusian language
|Number of speakers= 8 mln. (according to the latest cencus)
|Locations spoken= Republic of Belarus
|Related languages= [[:en:Russian language|Russian]], [[:en:Ukrainian language|Ukrainian]], [[:en:Polish language|Polish]], [[:en:Siberian language|Siberian]]
|Promoting organizations= [http://www.tbm.org.by/] (Tavarystva byelaruskay movy)
|Request on mailing list=
}}

Test wiki http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Test-wp/be/

: Member of the Commonwealth of East-Slavonic Test wikipedias http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Template:Sodruzhestvo-be

There has already been simmilar request in here. I put it here now again, because the the situation in Belarusian Wikipedia seems abnormal to me.

1.Every single page in 1959rev.pravapis is in category written in 2005rev.pravapis

2.More than the first, some pages have mixed orthographies ex. Бразілія, Балівія, Чылі, 1580 (there are some more of them actually) that is absolutely inadmisible.

3.1959rev. and 2005rev. do differ much more that just of "soft signs", "soft letters" (hard l - soft l). 2005rev. which pretends to be called "classical Belarusian" has different from 1959rev. phrase building (synthax) - while 1959rev. synthax has very few differents from Russian (when I was writing it I remembered only transition of the preposition "к" (in Russian) to preposition "да" (in Belarusian), 2005rev. has (or must have (there are still many syntax mistakes in 2005rev.orthography - contributors just put 1959rev.text with soft signs - this belarusan language phenomenon is called "tarakamauka" ("tarashkevitsa" (unofficial name of 2005rev.) + "narkamauka" (unofficial name of 1959rev.) which is not codified and saying honestly is ungrammar)) so, 2005rev. has much more differents from Russian (see. [http://txt.knihi.com/mova/losik.html Некаторыя ўвагі да беларускае літаратурнае мовы]), some examples of them are (
*1.use of verb infinitive - "вада піць" vs. "вада для піцця" in 1959rev.;
*2.use of expression of belonging - "пункт у гледжаньні" in 2005rev. vs. "пункт гледжання" in 1959rev.;
*3. use of expression of purpose of thing - "хустачка да носу" vs. "хустачка для носу" in 1959rev. and some more rules signed in the work on knihi.com)

4. For me, as for abiturient (i gonna enter unversity next year), and for all the abiturients who will have Belarusian exam it is terrible to read such a mixture of orthographies in an encyclopedia. After reading words "Галандыя" (1959rev.) and "сьмерці" (2005rev) in one article and then in other articles I have more possibilities to make mistake in school work and, what is horrible, in exam! And I can tell you I've made some already when I instictively wrote "зьмяшчае" (instead of right variant "змяшчае" - w/o soft sign) in school dictation. As a man who contributes to wikipedia and wants belarusian language to become the leading slavic language I can't stop contributing but, as I said, after contributing to such a be.wiki I get mess in my head! Surelly, split will help with Belarussian knowledge systematization.

(I'm a contributor in 2005rev., but i will surelly help new wikipedia in 1959rev. for some time for it to develop)

Thanks for attention ppl! - Анто́сь Казьмярчу́к

PS. I haven't voted for previous propose (Present Belarusian) because facts in there were not true. I would like 2 BELARUSIAN WIKIS TO HAVE EQUAL RIGHTS. Surely if one of WIKIS will be filial to another no one will contribute.

PPS Few words about the size, yes be.wiki is small to split, but we in be.wiki prefer quality over quantity (look, there are no empty articles about a year - all of them have some information)

'''Important''': There is already '''failed request''' for the SAME language revision here: [[Requests for new languages/Denied#Present Belarusian (7 support, 14 oppose)|Requests for new languages/Denied]]. So this poll should be cancelled, or at least votes from the previous poll should be transferred here. --[[User:Monk|Monk]].

====Support====
#{{support}} -- [[User:Mihas Skrypka|Mihas Skrypka]] 09:33, 9 July 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}} -- Agree with Cazimearciuc. --[[User:Node ue|Node ue]] 18:54, 19 July 2006 (UTC)
#{{support}} -- [[User:Bunker|Bunker]] 07:47, 2 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}} -- [[User:A. Yurkevich|A. Yurkevich]] 10:04, 3 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}} -- --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 14:57, 3 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}} -- --[[User:Mienski|Mienski]] 10:38, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}} --[[en:User:218|218]] 12:43, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}} -- --[[User:Dmitry Nikitin|Dmitry Nikitin]] 08:18, 5 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{support}} ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 12:28, 8 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{support}} --[[User:Fratele lui Bonaparte, il cunosti?|Fratele lui Bonaparte, il cunosti?]] 17:02, 8 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{support}} -- [[User:boox]] 02:13, 14 Aug 2006 (UTC)
#{{support}} -- [[User:Steel archer|Steel archer]] 19:17, 16 Aug 2006 (UTC)
#{{support}} --[[User:Alexander Gouk|Alexander Gouk]] 22:42, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{support}} --[[User:Red Winged Duck|Red Winged Duck]] 08:20, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{support}} --[[User:MaximLitvin|MaximLitvin]] 13:07, 18 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{support}} --[[User:Kojpiš Anton|Kojpiš Anton]] 22:52, 18 August 2006 (UTC)

====Oppose====
=====Summary=====
#{{oppose}} --[[User:Mikkalai|Mikkalai]]
#{{oppose}} --'''[[User:Taichi|Taichi]]'''
#{{oppose}} --[[User:FrancisTyers|FrancisTyers]]
#{{oppose}} --[[User:81.25.45.199|81.25.45.199]]
#{{oppose}} --[[User:Voevoda|Voevoda]]
#{{oppose}} --[[User:Yakudza|Yakudza]]
#{{oppose}} --[[User:Monk|Monk]]
#{{супраць}} --[[User:Belamp|Bełamp]]
#{{oppose}} --[[User:Improv|Improv]]
#{{oppose}} --[[User:W.V.-S.|W.V.-S.]]

=====Comments=====
#This vote recalled by voter ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 12:27, 8 August 2006 (UTC)
#:: ...(and see comments, too) ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 13:13, 9 July 2006 (UTC)
#:: So what's the matter about not opening new Academic-language Belarusian Wikipedia? [[User:Mienski]] 14:08, 5 August 2006 (UTC)
#::: Well, after the experiences of last 2 months, I feel I ''could'', possibly, re-consider changing my vote to support. I'd like to see the intentions of the proposers stated more clearly, however.
#::: - I understand the supposed name would be ISO639, bel.wikipedia.org -- and that's the only acceptable name in the situation.
#::: - What about that "100% normative orthography, syntax and everything"? While I consider the alternative orthography quite a un-needed and even harmful exercise, and while the wantonly introduction of the Polish words (like "выспа" for geogr. "island") is simply an abomination, I'd like to see some leeway on the syntax and morphology here, as some of the 1933-1959 changes in those ''had'' been objectively, un-Belarusian.
#::: So, what do you think? ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 22:10, 6 August 2006 (UTC)
#::: Іншымі словамі, калі кіраўніцтва новай ВП абяцае даваць ''пэўную'' ступень свабоды на сінтаксіс-марфалогію (невялікія вольнасці ў кіраваннях, у канчатках склонаў) і лексіку (сістэмна беларускія дадаткі да існуючай), то можна за яе стварэнне галасаваць. Таму што ўжо відаць, што з ВП пад назвай be.wikipedia.org толку не будзе, бо створана, каб рухаць "справу клясычнага правапісу". ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 19:51, 7 August 2006 (UTC)
#:: Well, I'm transferring my vote to support (although somewhat against my best judgement...) ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 12:27, 8 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{oppose}} I disagree that this suffering Belarusian language must be split in two. I see no problems in co-existing synonyms from two sources. English has both "trunk" and "proboscis" and other 5-cent and 20-dollar synonyms coming from German and Romance origins respectively. The only requirement would be consistency of ''orthography'' (and optionally vocabulary) in a single article, something like British/American English in en:wikipedia. Otherwise it is pointless dispersion of efforts of so scarse Belarusophone contributors. [[User:Mikkalai|Mikkalai]] 17:29, 9 July 2006 (UTC)
#: It's terrible, but this condition (about consistence of orthography) isn't met in Be-Wikipedia. [[User:Mienski]] 14:08, 5 August 2006 (UTC)
#: So, do you think that the differences of official Belarusian language and "neoclassical" are just a few words? No, it's a spelling of lots of words (about 30-40% of lexics), it's also differences in syntax, morphology, normalization of foreign words and so on, a lot more and more. The problem is not about few words, it's about inconsistency of Be-Wiki as an ENCYCLOPEDIA.
# {{oppose}} No different ortographical Wikipedias please. --'''[[User:Taichi|Taichi]]''' - ([[User talk:Taichi|あ！]]) 05:48, 10 July 2006 (UTC)
#: It's not just orthography, but also morphology, lexics and a lot more differences. [[User:Mienski]] 14:08, 5 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{oppose}} The difference between orthographies can probably be handled by computer, e.g. extend the software to allow display (first) then contributions (second) in both orthographies. - [[User:FrancisTyers|FrancisTyers]] 11:37, 12 July 2006 (UTC)
#:Err, this is one of be.wiki admin EugeneZelenko "arguments". So far, no such a script has been created (for about a year already). And, saying fairly, it cannot be done because of different transliteration of foreign words. No program imo can convert "філязофія" to "філасофія" using NO databases of words. But this example is not the only one, examples include practicaly any adoptedd words. Surely, no one can create such a database. And more than that, the database that keeps 2 variants of ANY SINGLE NAME of well-known people from EU, US, Africa etc. cannot be ever made.
#:* ''Good news:'' Such a database is being made. Of course, it needs contributors of scripts for those cases that can be handled along some general rules, and educated typists entering the rest. For the time being, if you have not more than a few thousand articles/names in the Беларуси Wikipedia, typing their Lemmata twice manually would not be too hard or time consuming a job. Refer to [[:Category:Ultimate Wiktionary]] for history, and [http://Wiktionaryz.org WiktionaryZ] for current reality, @ pre alpha state. If you have data bases of words of both orthograpies available, imho importing them would be a not too complicated task. If you have not, you might ask for a script that can convert semi-automatically, suggesting spellings, and a human says yes/no/which one, respectively, with a mouse click, allowing speedy conversions. -- [[User:Purodha|Purodha Blissenbach]] 13:23, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
#:: It's impossible to write software to translate neoclassic Belarusian variant into official: they are too different.
#Голос снят проголосовавшим --[[User:Dmitry Nikitin|Dmitry Nikitin]] 08:17, 5 August 2006 (UTC)
#:Дело в том, что именно тот вариант орфографии беларусского языка, который на данный момент используется в be.wikipedia.org, и является таким вот "дореволюционным" вариантом. Эта орфография поддердживалась в основном только эмигрантскими кругами, которые оказались за пределами Беларуси в связи с гонениями советской власти. Представьте себе ситуацию, когда бы русские эмигранты не приняли реформу русского языка начала 20го века ("т.к. она была проведена после революции при большевиках") и затем, после развала СССР, начали бы активно продвигать написание "ятей" и других архаичных значков. К сожалению, так и произошло у нас, в Беларуси. Вы спросите, почему тут написано 1957rev и 2005rev? Т.к. основы первого, официального, современного написания были приняты и внедрялись ещё с 1957 г., т.о. имея богатый культурный языковой материал. Та же орфография, которую некоторые пробуют представить как "класическую", была кодифицирована (причём ужасным образом - много ляпов, недоработок, отдалённость от живой беларуской традиции перенимания иностранных слов, употребление диалектизмов, полонизмов и т.д.; без широкого общественного обсуждения, опираясь на речь людей, которые даже не живут в Беларуси (старые эмиграционные издания, радио "Свабода" (которое вещает с территории Чехии и сотрудниками которого являются те же эмигрантские круги) только в 2005г.
#:: Вы меня убедили. Отзываю свой голос и иду ставить его выше - ЗА. Кстати, простите, что не подписался. И ещё, я сейчас сотру свой голос, но мне ведь могут сказать, что я вандалил, стирая чужие голоса так что поправьте там как нужно, если что --[[User:Dmitry Nikitin|Dmitry Nikitin]] 08:17, 5 August 2006 (UTC)
#::: Снова страшилки рассказывают... В be.wikipedia.org используются и нормативный и классический вариант. Единственная пока не разрешимая техническая проблема - категории. --[[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 14:43, 7 August 2006 (UTC)
#:::: Вторая единственная неразрешимая проблема - оболочка на старом варианте (главная страница и т.д.). Третья единственная неразрешимая проблема - совершенная неразбериха с орфографией. Четвёртая единственная неразрешимая проблема - излишняя прямая и косвенная (дом. страницы участников, статьи, дискуссии) политизированность нынешней версии, что для многих потенциально новых участников является достаточной преградой для регистрации и редактирования статей, равно как и существующая оболочка в ее ненормативном варианте. Пятая единственная неразрешимая проблема - просто отсутствие желания перепрыгивать с одной орфографии на другую, спотыкаться о слова и буквы, написанные в ином варианте, считаться с нововведениями: написал в два раза больше, взвесил, измерил и только тогда осмелился изменить правописание. Сторонники одного из вариантов написания практически '''никогда''' не вносят каких-либо значительных изменений в статьи, написанные в ином правописании. Наличие чёткого единого стандарта - неотъемлемая часть любой энциклопедии. Нынешний "однобокий плюрализм" уже не раз приводил к спорам и перепалкам и, как мне кажется, вряд ли они когда-нибудь прекратятся. Так что пора посадить ещё одно "деревце" и вселить жизнь в новый проект... И при всём при этом добавлю, что многие из небольшой горсточки нынешних участников нынешней версии пишут замечательные статьи, а некоторые :) очень добросовестно выполняют свои административные обязательства... --[[User:Alexander Gouk|Alexander Gouk]] 23:59, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
#:Что за дореволюционная '''грамматика'''? Товарищ сам понимает, что он написал? Суржик и трасянку поддерживаю, и донскую балачку, если только она не совпадает с суржиком. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 02:37, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
#:Имеется ввиду русская орфография до 1918 года. Согласен, лучше было бы написать "до реформы русской орфографии". Правда там были некоторые грамматические изменения. Но не суть. Мы сейчас про белорусский.--[[User:83.237.20.182|83.237.20.182]] 06:39, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{oppose}} --[[User:81.25.45.199|81.25.45.199]] 15:17, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
#: Can you explain or, maybe, authorize? [[User:Boox|Boox]] 23:37, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Oppose}} -- [[User:Voevoda|Voevoda]] 14:20, 9 August 2006 (UTC)
#: Can you explain your position of denying the Wikipedia for the state language of Belarus, country with 10 mln people?
# {{Oppose}}. Per Mikkalai. --[[User:Yakudza|Yakudza]] 11:26, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
#: Please, understand: problem could be handled ONLY by separation. This simple operation will do no harm for Belarusian Wikis: both would be written with its codified grammar, lexics, syntax and so on! [[User:Boox|Boox]] 23:37, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
#::I could be handled '''not only''' by separation, but by developing special software. Yes, it will be difficult, but it '''will not''' split Be.Wikipedia. -- [[User:Belamp|Bełamp]] 14:36, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#:: Проблему, как мне кажется, надо решать выработкой единого стандарта для языка, а не разделением на несколько. --[[User:Yakudza|Yakudza]] 07:44, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#:::: По сути вы правы, но ребята не могут выработать его в википедии, поскольку у каждой группы за плечами свой стандарт, выработанный не здесь, в этом-то все и дело, по-моему --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 07:52, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#:::::: В том и проблема, что 1. варианты сильно отличаются; 2. а) "тарашкевичи" (неоклассический вариант) никогда не сделают шаг в сторону официального варианта (в основном, по идеологическим причинам); б) официальный вариант беларусского языка имеет право на создание пространства для свободной работы над статьями. Более подробно на этот счёт посмотрите выше, в ответе Alexandra Gouka. Там определено множество неразрешимых противоречий, которые делают невозможным работу как на "неоклассической" норме, так и на официальной и нормативной.
# {{Oppose}}. I don't see any point in making two wikipedias for the same language - these two will be definitely worse than one common. Why not contributing to existing one? --[[User:Monk|Monk]] 12:02, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#:: Possibly, because people want '''just to write in Belarusian''' without additional ideology attached, as is the case with the 2005rev. People don't like to be hated on basis of their choice, too. ---~
#::: There is '''no''' any ideology with 2005rev. More, no one prevents you to use 1957rev, just don't begin ''"holy wars"''. -- [[User:Belamp|Bełamp]] 14:36, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#:::: Pah. The 2005rev is '''all about ideology''', from head to toes. If group of people discards normative rules of writing in favour of some garage-invented set and forces other people to regard this on equal footing with normative -- what it's about if not about ideology?
#:::: "No one prevents", my foot. There are screwy rules in belwiki forcing me to count chars before each commit -- I perceive this to be an obstruction. You want to play that particular ball -- suit yourself, just don't overstretch yourself. ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 20:44, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Супраць}} Чым займацца пустымі спрэчкамі й расколваць Вікіпэдыю, лепш бы прыхільнікі афіцыйнага правапісу (дарэчы, а чаму гэта ''толькі яны'' патрабуюць стварэньня асобнае Вікіпэдыі?) заняліся напісаньнем падтрымкі ўжытку абодвух правапісаў у межах адное Вікіпэдыі. Лічыце, гэта немагчыма? Паглядзіце на [http://pravapis.tut.by pravapis.tut.by]. Элемэнтарную падтрымку канвертаваньня клясычнага правапісу ў афіцыйны зрабіць можна (я маю на ўвазе мяккія знакі), правапіс асобных словаў можна захоўваць у спэцыяльнай вікі-базе дадзеных, каб кожны вікіпэдыст мог дадаваць у яе словы. Нават на найпрасцейшым узроўні гэта можна зрабіць зараз - выкарыстоўваючы шаблёны (пры ўмове аўтаматычнага даданьня мяккіх знакаў і іншых адрозьненьняў такога пляну. -- [[User:Belamp|Bełamp]] 14:36, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#: Нельга не пагадзіцца. Літаральна мае думкі. --[[User:MaximLitvin|MaximLitvin]] 15:48, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#:: Схамяніцеся. І падумайце, хто захоча супрацоўнічаць з людзьмі у якіх такія думкі.
#::: Па-першае, не "прыхільнікі", а проста вучылі мову ў школе. Дадатковы фактар падзелу і выніковы раскол зрабілі не "нарматыўнікі".
#::: Што гэта за роздум: "...чаму гэта ''толькі яны'' патрабуюць стварэньня асобнае Вікіпэдыі"? А што, "яны" не людзі? Ці вінаваты перад вамі самім фактам існавання? Сваю вікіпедыю маюць і жук і жаба, дык чаму не быць такой відавочнай?
#::: Што гэта за жлобства: "лепш бы прыхільнікі афіцыйнага правапісу... заняліся напісаньнем падтрымкі..." Ну-ну. Мо і вам падкінуць параду, чым вам бы лепш заняцца? Скажам, пачытаць даклад камісіі Некрашэвіча? І наогул -- хто прыдумаў дадатковыя праблемы -- той і піша модулі.
#::: Ну і той допіс, што ніжэй, таксама дарэчны, з п. гл. чалавечых адносінаў.
#::: Урэшце рэшт, што за бяда -- ну, будуць дзве. Ну, будуць перакладаць адна з адной -- каму горш? А працаваць прасцей абодвум бакам. Бо зараз мне прасцей плюнуць на пісанне беларускіх артыкулаў, чым увесь час спрачацца з кожнай пустой нагоды (вось як днямі пра "дайджэст" нн) з заідэалагізаванымі людзьмі. ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 21:08, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#:::: Полностью согласен, я с самого начала так в ЖЖ и говорил - ничего плохого для беларуской культуры не будет. Конечно, обе вики будут обмениваться материалами и людьми, а раз свободы будет больше, то и людей, и статей будет больше. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 21:18, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#::::: Ужо схамянуўся. Мае думкі датычацца толькі таго... а-а-а, што аб гэтым пісаць - марная справа, бо ўсё адно зразумееце адпаведна сваім уяўленням... Увогуле сам прыхільнік выкарыстання афіцыйнага

#:::::: Дык як вас наогул зразумець, калі па закранутай тэме не кажаце, а нешта зусім у іншы бок? І нашто за мяне дадумваць? --Ю.Т.

#::::: правапісу, але я супраць сепаратызму, бо гэта блага скончыцца. Па-першая, як толькі з'явіцца асобная Вікі

#:::::: Сепаратызму? Каго ад каго? Хто пачаў? --Ю.Т.

#:::::на афіцыйным правапісе адразу ўздымецца хваля па зачыненні Вікі на "неправільным" правапісе - у выніку не будзе ні воднай беларускай Вікі, а будзе адзін "афіцыйны" недагрызак. Па-другое, зноў уздымецца

#:::::: ''Глабальныя'' высновы, але сцверджанне не роўнае даказу. А мне дык думаецца, што цікавасць да "альтэрнатыўнай" мовы значна меншая, чым вам здаецца. --Ю.Т.

#::::: хваля стварэння розных Вікі-трасянак/суржыкаў, бо дзе две беларускіх Вікі, то там і тры, чатыры, пяць

#:::::: Тры, чатыры і пяць? Ну, дапусцім на хвілінку, што яны будуць. А хто тут палітычны камісар, казаць ім не быць? Ну, будуць -- хлеб адыймуць ці што? Мне дык няма ніякай цікавасці (і часу) ані да трасянкаў, ані да альтэрнатыўных правапісаў, ані ў тым, каб іх знішчаць (і рабіць з іх ахвяраў). А вось пісаць па-беларуску без лішніх абструкцый -- хочацца, але існуючы парадак гэтага не дазваляе. Думаю, і ў бальшыні ахвотных такая самая пазіцыя. --Ю.Т.

#::::: "беларускіх" Вікі, ці не так кажу. Да і дзе ж былі мы - "нарматыўнікі", калі гэтыя "нацыяналісты" стваралі "сабе" "сваю" Вікі на "сваім" правапісе? Га? Была б смешна, калі б не была так сумна бачыць гэтыя свары і

#:::::: Якая розніца, хто дзе быў? Я да ~чвэрці 2005 дык і не звяртаў дужа ўвагі на ВП --па маёй спецыяльнасці там слабыя матэрыялы. Большая актыўнасць, галасістасць, нават агрэсіўнасць меншасцяў, якія б ні былі -- наогул звычайная рэч. А вось ''што'' важней было тым альтэрнатыўнікам -- дабро ''агульнай'' справы ці ''уласная'' ідэалогія? Цяжка было зрабіць, каб усім беларусамоўным даць магчымасць?
#:::::: Урэшце, пытанні пра палітыку белвікі пачаліся праз пару тыдняў пасля адкрыця. Калі "тройка" не сцерла, то хто мае вочы, той пабачыць. --Ю.Т.

#::::: хворыя "прынцыпы"... --[[User:MaximLitvin|MaximLitvin]] 07:55, 18 August 2006 (UTC)

#:::::: Пра хворыя прынцыпы не зразумеў. А свары -- узгадайма, ці былі яны ''да'' ~1989-1990, калі і пачалася гэта кампанія? --Ю.Т.

#::::::: А і не трэба, разбірацца і разумець - хто пачаў, ад каго і як, бо дзіцячы сад нейкі. Увогуле, як Вы бачыце магчымыя будучыя стасункі паміж двумя беларускімі Вікіпедыямі (ці магчыма на Ваш погляд зрабіць сувязь паміж імі)? Гледзячы па Вашых настроях, баюся яны будуць варожымі. --[[User:MaximLitvin|MaximLitvin]] 09:20, 18 August 2006 (UTC)

#:::::::: Мае настроі тут ''абсалютна'' ні да чаго, бо я ''не'' цікаўлюся пытаннем гэтых стасункаў. Прапанаваны варыянт, па-першае, дае мне магчымасць без лішніх канфліктаў працаваць у ВП па-беларуску, ''без'' ідэалагічнай ношы, па-другое, не пагражае агульнай справе, наколькі я яе разумею. Захачу -- вазьму тэкст з якой захачу ВП, абы я ведаў мову. І ўсе стасункі, вельмі проста. :) --Ю.Т.


#::Я НЕ БАЧУ сэнсу ў стварэнні нейкага інтэрфэйсу ў афіцыйным правапісе ў вікіпедыі дзе большасць артыкулаў зроблена ў альтэрнатыўным правапісе, усе адміністратары - прыхільнікі альтэрнатыўнага правапіса, большасць удзельнікаў - людзі, што пішуць у альтэрнатыўным правапісе. Атрымаецца, што я буду падтрымліваць ці выцягваць з гаўна вікіпедыю, дзе большасць усіх не падзяляе адную з маіх найбольш фундаментальных пазіцый, дзе большасць удзельнікаў - упартыя як аслы, калі справа тычыцца правапіса, дзе за кожны накід павінна весціся барацьба за правапіс. Нашто? Хто вы такія? Я ведаю, што карыстаюся мовай, што ёсць афіцыйнай у дзяржаве, дзе ваша мова ёсць прызнанай ды афіцыйнай, га? Чаму я, прыхільнік стандарту, павінны ў вікіпедыі, зарэгістраванай на маю ж мову, цярпець прысутнасць нейкіх барацьбітаў, што чорт ведае за што змагаюцца. Каб ты, ды і іншыя адмоўнікі ведалі, пачаў я менавіта як ужывач "неа"-рэвізіі, аднак усё болей паглыбляючыся у рэсурсы у гэтым правпісе, я пабачыў, што ўяўляюць іншыя неа-ужыўцы. Вы ўсе ходзіце з сваім правпісам як з сцягам, ганарыцеся менавіта сваёй занятай пазіцыяй. Мне ж проста патрэбны правапіс, у якім я буду пісаць, які б не паказваў знарок маю пазіцыю, пісаць на роднай мове. Разам з тым я не магу памірыцца з пашырэннем гэтага правапіса, бо ён шкодзіць і маёй мове, адкідвае здабыткі ейныя на паўст. таму. І хопіць бараніцца ідэяй стварэння праграмаў канвертацыі - пакуль мне нехта не пакажа праграму якая паканвертуе мне любое існае прозвішча з аднаго правапіса ў іншы, гэты аргумент я не залічу. Гэта калі б пісалі таракамаўкай, была б такая магчымасць. І прытым надзвычай доўга васпаны "распрацоўваюць" гэты софт, звычайна марудзячы і нічога не робячы - ведама мне вашая пазіцыя "калі вам гэта патрэбна, дык рабіце". I wanna tell everybody this one is the most radical in wikipedia. His the only one to me in my mind from time to time starting orthography-wars in wikipedia and agitatin for 2005rev. to users, that use official standart. Sucha people are one of the reasons why i personally don't want to write to current be.wiki. This reason is not based on personal view to people like him (though it exists ofc), but they opress users that use 1959rev.. Once this man started a propaganda of 2005rev. to 1959rev.. Then i remember episod, when ADMINISTRATOR WAS TRYIN TO CANTRACT WITH 1959-USER FOR THIS USER TO CREATE templates ONLY IN 2005-REV. This user was blocked then for the reason that he creates MANY STUBS. Then, once when according to the rules of be-wiki this 1959-user added much context to 2 or 3 articles and got the right to change the orthography (what he ofc did) the administrator said THAT HE SHOULD HAVE CREATED A DISCUSSION WHERE OTHER USERS WILL ALLOW HIM TO CHANGE ORTH.-REVISION. From what time sucha situation is called ''equality in rights''?? -- [[User:82.209.208.161|82.209.208.161]] 16:44, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{Oppose}} - This can do nothing but harm the efforts to produce an encyclopedia for people who speak the language. It would be better to come up with traditions/style guides in the language to address this situation rather than split the language. If Traditional and Reformed Chinese can exist in the same wikipedia, which I believe is likely much more difficult than what is being attempted here, then I'm sure something can be worked out to prevent this division of community. If this is accepted, at best one of the wikis will become largely abandoned and the situation will be much as it is now. At worst, you'll end up with two separate communities, each with smaller, less impressive encyclopedias. Please don't go down that route. --[[User:Improv|Improv]] 16:42, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
:: You make a lots of assumptions, eh? "This can do nothing but...", ""-- lots of ppl beg to differ, in fact they expect quite opposite things to come. And who made the comparative analysis of this here situation and the Chinese deal? Finally, you ask for "please don't go" but wham it with a opposing vote. Oh joy. ---[[User:80.94.165.5|80.94.165.5]]

====Neutral====

# Если будете делать тестовую в инкубаторе, буду пытаться участвовать, кроме того из нашей тусовки четверо знают язык. Нам там все равно скучно среди курдов:-) По сути же дела я разрываюсь между двумя мотивами 1) я вообще за увеличение лингвистического разнообразия восточнославянских вик, так что не только за наркомовку и полесский, но и за поморский и казацкий; 2) с другой стороны, употребление наркомовки политически окрашено, и я в это ввязываться не хочу, не гражданин Беларуси. Поэтому пока не определился, зато точно буду это читать и пытаться контрибутить. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 05:59, 10 July 2006 (UTC)

: Я меняю свою позицию, наблюдая то, что творят представители авторитарного мышления на сибирском голосовании. Почему у французов, итальянцев, немцев есть вики на тех языках, которые не укладываются в национальный стандарт, а у восточных славян нет? На самом деле славяне сейчас в худшем положении, чем французы, у которых норманскую википедию открыли буквально два норманна. Единственный путь разрушать авторитарное сталинистское представление о том, что восточнославянских языков якобы только три, это открывать все новые и новые вики, на всех разновидностях, пока восточнославянских вик не будет как итальянских. Поэтому я поддерживаю любую новую восточнославянскую википедию. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 15:01, 3 August 2006 (UTC)

:: Зачем такие сложности? Писать официальным правописанием (наркамаўкай) можно и в белорусской Википедии. --[[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 13:36, 10 July 2006 (UTC)

::: Исхожу из того, что демократия - это многообразие. Но вы правы, если суппортер только один, значит это просто никому не нужно. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 15:35, 10 July 2006 (UTC)

::: "Наркомовка / наркамаўка" -- умышленно оскорбительный термин ("Narkamauka" is a deliberately derisive term). Thank you. ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 15:02, 10 July 2006 (UTC)
#My opinion on the matter is that belwiki should take drastic steps to upgrade its archaic version to the contemprory official standard. Менск and Ворша have to go '''permanentely'''. I mean if someone started writing in ru-wiki with yats and hard signs everywhere, I doubt it will be accepted warmly. --[[:en:User:Kuban kazak|Kuban Cossack]]. 12:33, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

====Comments====

* This proposal isn't well prepared, technically:
# You can't go around inventing the language codes (and Byel... was far more fair in rendering of the Belarusian diphtong, anyway :)).
# You can't push to the alternative namespace the literary and normative branch of the language (the only one taught in schools for 70+ years).
# References to unverifiables pushed forward ("...spoken in real life..."), references to verifiables dismissed (data of the polls of 1959, 1979, 1989, 1999, data on schooling etc.).
# There are much worse misuses of the Belarusian language now in (alternative-pushers-ridden) BE:WP, like using the Polish-influenced barbarisms instead of either the normative word or even the "pre-armageddon" (1933) word. The immediately known example is use of "выспа"/"паўвыспа" for "island"/"peninsula" instead of normative "востраў"/"паўвостраў" or "атока,абток"/"паўатока,паўабток" (as used by Lastowski, Akula).
# The "negative influence" of the "mix" is completely to blaim of the promoters of the alternative version of the orthography, insisting on everything in Belarusian to be done alternatively, not in the normative --- '''and''' on their terms, too.
# References to the dubious sources (knihi.com is a politically dedicated site) are used, with tells immediately:
## For "drinking water" there exists an expression "пітная вада" in Belarusian, not bizarre "вада піць" or secondary "вада для піцця"
## For "handkerchief" there exists an expression "насоўка" in Belarusian, not the Polish-influenced barbarisms "хустачка да носу" and "хустачка для носу"
## For "point of view" there exists an equivalent "пункт гледжання" or somewhat not-mainstream "гледзішча". The conflict of "пункт у гледжаньні" vs. "пункт гледжання" is either invented or something else is mistakenly perceived as such.
* If ''anything'' '''must''' be separated into its own namespace here, it would be the whole framework done in '''alternative''' orthography and wording. Something like be-alter, possibly. ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 13:13, 9 July 2006 (UTC)
: I think bel.wikipedia.org is a fine domain for Belarusian language.

: Though my examples appeared bad enough, this tutorial by Losik exists and it's not "politicaly dedicated document) and it seems like it's to be used for writing in 2005rev.
:*''# You can't go around inventing the language codes (and Byel... was far more fair in rendering of the Belarusian diphtong, anyway :)).
# You can't push to the alternative namespace the literary and normative branch of the language (the only one taught in schools for 70+ years).''
:Let it be bel.wiki, there mustn't be much of discussion.

:''# There are much worse misuses of the Belarusian language now in (alternative-pushers-ridden) BE:WP, like using the Polish-influenced barbarisms instead of either the normative word or even the "pre-armageddon" (1933) word. The immediately known example is use of "выспа"/"паўвыспа" for "island"/"peninsula" instead of normative "востраў"/"паўвостраў" or "атока,абток"/"паўатока,паўабток" (as used by Lastowski, Akula).''
:2. Show me where i have said 2005rev. contributors are exellently literate? Same things happen to 1959rev. users when they push russian words into articles. Personally i dislike this layer of polonismes, which appeared in the times of reincarnating of the classic spelling.

:''# The "negative influence" of the "mix" is completely to blaim of the promoters of the alternative version of the orthography, insisting on everything in Belarusian to be done alternatively, not in the normative --- '''and''' on their terms, too.''

:Yes, til all of admins use it. But, as it has been already discussed naming categories in 1959rev. style will cause bigger mess. And naming all the cathegories in 1959rev. is POV, as it's POV to name all the cathegories in 2005rev. The only right decision is to split as it seems to me.

:So I personally miss your point, you dislike 2005rev, but you denie new wiki too. What's the matter then? [[User:82.209.208.199|82.209.208.199]] 14:35, 9 July 2006 (UTC)



Why did you open new request instead of reopen [[Requests for new languages/Denied#Present Belarusian (7 support, 14 oppose)|old one]]? --[[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 13:54, 9 July 2006 (UTC)

:I didn't know it may be reopened/Facts were totally untrue in there.[[User:82.209.208.199|82.209.208.199]] 14:35, 9 July 2006 (UTC)

:: Which facts exactly? At least list of opposers/supporters and their arguments could be definitely shared.
:: Please register on meta.
:: [[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 14:55, 9 July 2006 (UTC)
::: Statements that 2005rev. is a couple of archaic dialects and 1959rev. is "a present-day belarusian". And i thought there was a proposal to keep 2005rev. as a filial of 1959rev, but not as separate project. It's a bit confusing for me, I'vent found that in the previous request, maybe i've read of it somewhere else. [[User:82.209.208.199|82.209.208.199]] 15:56, 9 July 2006 (UTC)

:::: ''And i thought there was a proposal to keep 2005rev. as a filial of 1959rev, but not as separate project.'' - it was condition for support from [[User:MaximLitvin|MaximLitvin]]. These words was not in request itself. --[[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 16:15, 9 July 2006 (UTC)


*I've read a terrible article about Homel recently. This is what i've noticed:
# Introduction is written in 2005rev.
# Part about name of the city is written in 1959rev.
# Part about history is written in 2005rev.
# Part about population is written in 1959rev. (тысяч instead of тысячаў)
# Part about education in Homel is mixed: subsection about univercities is written in 1959rev., subsection about institutes is written 2005rev. (word Мінистэрства uses both belarusian і and russian и for some reason)
# Parts about industry, sport and comments to external links are written in 2005rev.
And this is only 1 example of what this "encyclopaedia" contains. What do you think, is such a situation normal for Wikipedia?

: Could you please take a look into [[:be:Вікіпэдыя:Правапіс]] and [[:be:Абмеркаваньне Вікіпэдыя:Правапіс#Галасаваньне па новай рэдакцыі правіл]]? Rules are exists, but does anybody following them? If you have time, please fix article. --[[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 14:01, 10 July 2006 (UTC)

* The use of the ISO 639 codes for Belarusian language belongs to the normative, literary, academic branch of the Belarusian language, which millions of people are at least familiar with (1999 poll), which is taught in shool on mandatory basis, etc. etc. ad nauseaum.
* Consequently, the normative branch of language in Wikipedia declaring it's in "Belarusian language", '''must''' primarily provide the possibility for the use of the normative variant. Everything else, be it a dialect, an alternative orthography or anything, either co-exists non-disruptingly, or goes '''out''' into separate sub-spaces. It's not the business of the normal Belarusian language speaker that somebody wants everybody to use the brilliant new invented orthography and it can't be considered a POV that the un-curtailed use of the normative version of language is primarily expected in the wikipedia decalring itself Belarusian.
* However, what we have now in BE:WP is:
# The (3) admins and their pals pushing the use of the alternative orthography and inventing the "righteous" lexicon.
# The admins are backed by the rules which weren't voted on when introduced, and those rules are curtailing the use of the normative branch of the language.
# The currently on-going vote on so called "co-existence of orthographies" is conducted with all imaginable violations of procedure -- e.g., admin [[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] who opened the voting didn't put '''all''' of the proposals on vote, and refused to do so, when reminded, retorting that the proposals not put on vote were "not quite good". AFAIU, the right to vote is determined by the previous participation in BE:WP (subjected to the mentioned rules).

:: Only anonimous user are not allowed in [[:be:Абмеркаваньне Вікіпэдыя:Правапіс#Галасаваньне па новай рэдакцыі правіл|this voting]]. I think this is common practice in WP. --[[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 14:08, 11 July 2006 (UTC)

* Oh well, somebody (was it you, admin [[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]]?) had "cleverly" '''removed''' all the discussion on the proposals on the rules prior to June 25, 2006, complete with '''my proposal''' (which is '''not''' on voting) which '''initiated the discussion''' , on the prior to 25.06.2006, so now [[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] feels free to claim that "all is well" with the BE:WP procedure. What a '''"fearless fighters with regime"''' those persons are. What a '''petty falsificators'''. Have '''decency''' to stand by to your '''own''' actions, "admin" [[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]]! ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 06:26, 12 July 2006 (UTC)

* ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 15:25, 10 July 2006 (UTC)


:: So, you would agree if the current be.wiki stays for 1959rev. and 2005rev. articles are moved to, for ex., be-alt.wiki? Btw, i've now read one more article in even more odd orthography - about Joseph Yuho (Язэп Юхо), it's written in 1959rev. with the use of "soft signs" and 2005rev. Менск and Полацак words, i will try to correct that one but i doubt i'll have success; and while two orthographies so-exist, i think such "hybrid" articles will stay and the number of them will grow. [[User:82.209.209.240|82.209.209.240]] 16:23, 10 July 2006 (UTC)

::: Frankly, I would much rather if the admins and their pals quit their agit-propping and just do their service to the Belarusian people meaning serving technical side of the BE:WP and not dabbing in the politics, which they handle shoddily, anyway. :)
::: Just think -- two WPs means doubled effort on maintenance, two versions of everything... To what purpose? As if we have all of our problems solved... Personally, I'm not at all interested in technicalities, only in writing on certain tematics... However, the un-avoidable necessity for some kind of separation -- which you describe -- may yet arise, as the current crew still understand their mission here as some kind of &quot;struggle with regime". ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 22:54, 10 July 2006 (UTC)

::: I don't think that separation will solve such problems. In real life correctors work during book preparation. I don't think that people exist who never made spelling mistakes or used incorrect words :-) Think about corrector job as part of maintenance such as interwikis, categorization, formatting and so on. It's mainly technical, but necessary for improving quality of articles. Volunteer's positions are always opened :-) --[[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 14:08, 11 July 2006 (UTC)

::: Separation would hopefully solve the issue of petty falsificators and crooked "admins", though. Then all of your bunch will happily sit in your ivory tower, feeling smug and superiour to the other Belarusian folks. ---[[User:Yury Tarasievich|Yury Tarasievich]] 06:26, 12 July 2006 (UTC)
** be-1959.wikipedia.org ?
: I think bel.wikipedia.org would be great. [[User:Mienski]] 12:41, 5 August 2006 (UTC)

Official State language, not the archaic form, should have Wiki! [[User:boox]]
:Yes, you are definitely right, it ''has''! [[:be:|be.wikipedia.org]]! Official? '''Yes'''. Non-archaic? '''Yes'''. ''What else?'' ;) -- [[User:Belamp|Bełamp]] 21:42, 18 August 2006 (UTC)

=== '''Sheng''' ===
{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= [[User:Kenyan|Kenyan]]
|User accounts of others=
|Language code=
|Proposed domain= sheng.wikipedia.org
|Wikipedia article= [[en:Sheng language]]
|Native name= Sheng
|English name=
|Number of speakers= 2,000,000
|Locations spoken= Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania
|Related languages= [[en:Swahili language]]
|Promoting organizations=
*** http://africanlanguages.com/kdp/sheng/
*** http://www.g21.net/africa31.html
*** http://research.yale.edu/swahili/learn/?q=en/node/8543
*** http://www.blinkbits.com/en_wikifeeds/Sheng_language
*** http://www.reference.com/browse/wiki/Sheng_(language)
|Request on mailing list=
}}
* we are still trying to get Kenyans to understand the wiki.
* Sheng is a slang trnslation of Kiswahili (Swahili)
It is mainly spoken by Kenyan youth. For those who have issues with Sheng,
accept the fact that even the Kenyan president, Mwai Kibaki[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mwai_Kibaki]]) speaks sheng... Mjienjoy!!!
60% of Kenyans are between the ages 18-30. Thats about '''15,000,000''' 'youth'.
'''2,000,000''' Sheng speakers is conservative.

==== Support ====
* '''Support''' although Sheng is a slang, slang is language. [[User:Oscarcwk|Oscarcwk]] 11:46, 25 July 2006 (UTC)

==== Oppose ====

* '''Oppose''' because it is a street slang with many variants. I have the impression that Sheng is broken Swahili mixed with any other language that the speakers know. It's not an established language, it's more like a pidgin in creation. -- [[User:Rasulo|Rasulo]]
* On top of that, it is hardly ever written and the Swahili Wikipedia is far from flourishing at the moment. Imo we should focus on getting the regular Swahili Wikipedia up and running before even thinking of opening one in Sheng. [[User:Steinbach|Steinbach <small>(formerly Caesarion)</small>]] 10:01, 31 July 2006 (UTC)
* '''Oppose'''. There's nothing wrong about colloquial language (->"youth culture"), of course. But encyclopedias generally use more formal language, for good reasons. Plus we don't do Wikipedias for specific age groups. --[[User:Arbeo|'''A'''<span style="font-variant:small-caps;text-transform:lowercase">RBE</span>'''0''']] 15:10, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

===Wikinews in Cantonese===
* Cantonese Wikipedia is created to a formal wikipedia since 25 March 2006, but there has many news of cantonese districts. [[User:Oscarcwk|Oscarcwk]] 11:46, 25 July 2006 (UTC)

=== Simple French Wikipedia ===

:::== Language ==

::::this language is not used anywhere but I think that it would be useful for those who are being educated in the language, similar to "Simple English". Simple English has its own Wikipedia [http://simple.wikipedia.org here], so I think that it would be appropriate to have one for French, another common language.

* People interested (if native speaker, please mark (N)):
[[User:0L1|Myself (proposer)]]
* Language code (ISO 639): simplefr
* Proposed domain: simplefr.wikipedia.org (not taken)
* Relevant infos:
o Native name(s): Francais simple
o English name or description: Simple French Wikipedia
o Approximate number of speakers: A very large number know basic French
o Location(s) spoken: Worldwide
o Closely related languages, if any: [http://simple.wikipedia.org Simple English (link to Simple English Wikipedia)]
* Link to request on a mailing list: NONE

====Oppose====
* Oppose. Simple French is useless for people which speak French (including those who are at school). simplefr is not an ISO 639 code. French is not closely related to English. (1 August 2006)
*'''Oppose''' : non-sense. [[User:Hégésippe Cormier|Hégésippe]] | [[User talk:Hégésippe Cormier|±Θ±]] 00:42, 2 August 2006 (UTC)
*As a matter of fact, the government of Québec does employ simplified "handicap-accessible" French at times. But I'm not really interested in this project (count me as "weak neutral"). [[User:Jade Knight|The Jade Knight]] 06:43, 11 August 2006 (UTC)
*'''Oppose'''. There's no actual "Simple French" language. --[[User:Gray Porpoise|Gray Porpoise]] 15:57, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

=== Berber ===
{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer=
|User accounts of others=
|Language code= ber
|Proposed domain= ber.wikipedia
|Wikipedia article= [[en:Berber languages]]
|Native name= Tamazight
|English name= Berber languages
|Number of speakers= some millions
|Locations spoken= North Africa and emigration
|Related languages=
|Promoting organizations=
|Request on mailing list=
}}
* See the proposal for Kabyle in [[Requests for new languages/Native speaker support]] (1 August 2006)

===Surzhyk===


{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 14:39, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
|User accounts of others= --[[User:Dmitry Nikitin|Dmitry Nikitin]] 15:24, 4 August 2006 (UTC)

|Language code= none, proposed: ukr-sur
|Proposed domain= surzhyk.wikipedia.org
|Wikipedia article= [[:en:Surzhyk]], [[de:Surschyk]], [[eo:Surĵik]], [[fr:Surzhyk]], [[ko:수르지크어]], [[hr:Suržik]], [[nl:Soerzjyk]], [[pl:Surżyk]], [[ru:Суржик]], [[sr:Суржик]], [[fi:Suržyk]], [[uk:Суржик]]
|Native name= Суржик (or Балачка)
|English name= Surzhyk
|Number of speakers= apr 10-15 mln (?)
|Locations spoken= Eastern Ukraine, Southern Russia
|Related languages= Ukrainian, Russian, Siberian
|Promoting organizations=
|Request on mailing list=
}}

Test wiki: http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Test-WP/surzh

: Member of the Commonwealth of East-Slavonic Test wikipedias http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Template:Sodruzhestvo-sur

====Support====
# --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 14:39, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Support}} --[[User:Dmitry Nikitin|Dmitry Nikitin]] 15:01, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''(N)''' {{Support}} --Mikolasz, Mikolasz@mail.ru, Mikolasz.livejournal.com, 21:02, 4 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Support}} -- Ivan Kalatukhin, ivan.kalatukhin@gmail.com, 01:10, 6 August 2006 (UTC)
# --[[User:Node ue|Node ue]] 00:04, 8 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''(N)''' {{Support}} --[[en:User:218|218]] 19:44, 8 August 2006 (UTC)
#{{Support}}--[[User:Fratele lui Bonaparte, il cunosti?|Fratele lui Bonaparte, il cunosti?]] 05:42, 10 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Support}} -- [[User:A. Yurkevich|A. Yurkevich]] 15:24, 10 August 2006 (UTC)
#--[[User:Ђорђе Д. Божовић|George D. Bozovic]] 16:56, 11 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Support}} --[[User:Pauk|Pauk]] 07:41, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Support}} Yes, we must have this [[ru:user:VanHelsing.16|VanHelsing.16]]
# {{Support}} Yes! [[be:User:Mienski|Mienski]]
# {{Support}} --[[User:Kojpiš Anton|Kojpiš Anton]] 22:52, 18 August 2006 (UTC)

====Oppose====
* {{Oppose}}. Surzhik is mechanical mixture two languages (Ukrainian and Russian). The vocabulary usage of either of the languages varies greatly (see [[:w:Surzhyk]]). The percentage of Ukrainian or Russian words can be from 10% before 90%. On Surzhik no written sources. Wikipedia on Surzhik - simply unchancy fun. --[[User:Yakudza|Yakudza]] 10:28, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

: Я просто надеюсь, что раз группа поддержки есть, из этого мог бы вырасти литературный язык для Дона-Курска, там южнорусские диалекты, близкие к украинскому, а литературного языка до сих пор нет. Северорусское языковое движение очень большое, и поддерживает два стандарта - поморский и сибирский, а на Юге России мы ничего такого не видим. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 10:07, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
:: На юге тоже есть, связанное с казачеством. На http://fstanitsa.ru/ этот вопрос время от времени поднимается, словарь "казачьего языка" составяют. Но к суржику, все это имеет очень слабое отношение, т.к. эти попытки делаются на основе во многом сложившегося донского говора русского языка, а не на такой зыбкой "креольской" основе. У суржика, как мне кажется, просто никаких норм быть не может, это переходное явление. И очень сильно варьируется. Иногда можно услышать предложение на чистом украинском, и тут же рядом на чистом русском. Иногда это вкрапелиния отдельных русских слов, иногда вкрапления отдельных украинских слов. --[[User:Yakudza|Yakudza]] 18:03, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
::: На самом деле я не возражаю против того что вы говорите. Просто инициатива Никитина мне показалась удобным случаем хоть в чем-то поддержать казачество в этих попытках, может быть на основе креольского языка там что-то получится. Я же не могу реально к ним включиться, я не носитель донского диалекта. Поэтому к этому реквесту я и сам отношусь не так ревностно, как к сибирскому, понимая его дискуссионность. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 18:12, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

* {{Oppose}} per [[User:Yakudza|Yakudza]]. [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 10:46, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

* {{Oppose}} per [[User:Rostyk|Rostyk]] Людина, яка намагається проштовхнути цю ідею, сама не володіє суржиком, якщо взагалі суржиком можна володіти. Адже це не мова, тут немає правил!

: Ну это уже к Никитину, я и не пишу, что нейтив спикер. Около пятидесяти статей они там все же написали. Мы на наших ресурсах делали голосование, около 20 человек высказались, что будут писать на суржике. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 10:50, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

* {{Oppose}} Agree with [[User:Yakudza|Yakudza]]. --[[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 13:26, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
* {{Oppose}} Agree with [[User:Yakudza|Yakudza]]. [[User:Ilya K|Ilya K]] 12:22, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
* {{Oppose}}, it is Mystification. --[[User:Nikolay Kolpakov|Nikolay Kolpakov]] 12:55, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

=== Padonki (35 support, 8 oppose)===
See also [[Requests_for_new_languages/Non-natural]]
{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= [[User:Jaroslavleff]]/[[:ru:User:Jaroslavleff]] (N)
|User accounts of others= [[User:Edward Chernenko]]/[[:ru:User:Edward Chernenko]] (N), [[User:AndyVolykhov]]/[[:ru:User:Andyvolykhov]] (N), [[ru:User:VanHelsing.16]] (N), [[ru:User:pauk]]/[[en:User:paukrus]], [[ru:User:Lone Guardian]]/[[User:Lone Guardian]] (N), [[User:Zach0t]]/[[ru:User:Lengra]] (N), [[User:eugrus]]/[[:ru:User:eugrus]] (N) [[User:MountainBlueAllah]][[:ru:user:ГорныйСинийАллах]] (N)
|Language code= none, proposed: ru-pad, pad
|Proposed domain= padonki.wikipedia.org pad.wikipedia.org
|Wikipedia article= [[:ru:Падонки]], [[:ru:Жаргон падонков]]
|Native name= Падонкаффский йезыг
|English name= Padonkian language, Padonki language
|Number of speakers= almost all Russians, more than half other Slav language
|Locations spoken= Russian and ex-USSR Internet segment, also more and more people use it outside Internet
|Related languages= Russian
|Promoting organizations= [http://padonki.org/ Padonki.org], [http://udaff.com/ Udaff.com], [http://voffka.com Voffka.com], {{lj_comm|ru_preved}}
|Request on mailing list=
}}
Work in progress on the test padonki wiki: http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Test-wp/pad

==== <!-- Padonki --> Support ====
# '''(N)''' '''Support'''. --[[User:Jaroslavleff|Jaroslavleff]] 06:49, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''Strong Support'''. --[[User:Hojja_Nusreddin|Hojja_Nusreddin]] 06:51, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''Support'''. --[[User:193.19.83.9|193.19.83.9]] 06:53, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''Support'''. --[[User:85.141.213.14|85.141.213.14]] 06:57, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''Support'''. --[[User:Fallingfree|Fallingfree]] 07:01, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''(N)''' {{Support}} for sure. This is a large culture and a WP in this language will be very successful. [[User:Csman|Csman]] 07:03, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Support}} --[[User:Swix|Swix]] 07:11, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''Support''', much more popular than so-called "siberian". [[User:MaxSem|Max<font size="+1">''S''</font>em]] 07:16, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''(N)''' '''Support''', very popular language in Internet --[[User:Pauk|Pauk]] 07:22, 16 August 2006 (UTC) / [[ru:user:Pauk]]
# '''Support''', much more peoples speak in "padonkian" then "siberian" (Ф дисятке и ниипёт :)--[[User:Morpheios Melas|Morpheios Melas]] 07:26, 16 August 2006 (UTC) / ([[ru:user:Morpheios Melas]] +Sysop)
# '''Support''', the language is wide spread all over the world&nbsp;—[[User:lstar|lstar]] 07:29, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''(N)''' '''Strong support''', this language is really very popular in Russia. труъ! [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 07:36, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Support}}. Wikipedia in this language will be very popular. --[[User:Zserghei|Zserghei]] 07:41, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''Support'''. --[[User:195.131.209.98|195.131.209.98]] 08:03, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Support}}. --[[User:Kolen|kolen]] 08:29, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''(N)''' {{Support}}. --[[User:AndyVolykhov|AndyVolykhov]] 08:37, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''(N) Strong support'''. It is ''really'' popular and spoken. In contrast to Siberian [[:ru:user:VanHelsing.16|VanHelsing.16]]
# '''(N)''' {{Support}} --[[User:89.175.28.76|89.175.28.76]] 09:05, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''Support'''. ф дватцадке. [[:ru:User:OckhamTheFox|OckhamTheFox]]
# {{Support}} - unlike the infamous "Siberian language", it at least DOES really exist, and IS really popular among some groups. If there's a space for "Siberian language" in the wiki, there should be a space for the "Padonkian language", too. Despite none of them should be treated seriously, in my opinion. [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g ''(Vladimir V. Medeyko)'']] 11:01, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
#: There is no comparison between semi-criminal net slang and old dialect. And such comaprison is anti-siberian provocation. What harm did siberian language to the russians that you hate it so much? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 21:51, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
#:: Just because "Siberian language" initiative is strictly anti-Russian one (or, as your companions say, anti-"Muscovite" one), that's why. I was initially neutral about "Siberian dialect", and supposed to support it. But after I checked the backgound and examined who does promote this "language" (West-Ukrainian nationalists, so on), I clearly understood that this "Siberian language" initiative is not anyhow related to increase of human knowledge at all, and serves political goals only. Don't suppose that other wikipedians are less clever than you. [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g ''(Vladimir V. Medeyko)'']] 11:05, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#::: How can language be "anti-" in political meaning? It only exists, it is not weapon or political book. So you yourself recognize, that you oppose siberian only for political goals, just because west-ukrainians support it? But this is false reasoning, and saving the old dialect of all the Russian North will certainly increase human knowledge. The personal insult in the last sentence indicates that you are simply angry and agressive, and this agression also makes your reasoning false. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 11:15, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#:::: Dear Yaroslav, you of course DO '''KNOW''' that I'm right and correct. I'm quite interesting in recovering any ancient Russian dialects and other historical facts about my precursors (I possess both Russian and West-Belorussian ancestry), and I'm particularly interested in Ladoga and Novgorod archeological excavations. It's why I see clearly that your "Siberian language" initiative has nothing common with history and science. The "Siberian language" initiative (not ''language'', which is not existing, but ''initiative'') is clearly anti-Russian. Period. [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g ''(Vladimir V. Medeyko)'']] 11:26, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#::::: Of course I know that you are not right, and both pomor and siberian language have the same northern russian lexical and grammatical base. The enemies of siberian did not say even ONE word in siberian that is not natural, they only cry - it is not natural - without any proofs of it. And how can not exist language with 15000 words and 1200 texts? You lie for political goals and this is clear. Especially this padonki request shows this. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 11:36, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#:: None of scientifically reliable texts of those that you refer above are about "Siberian language". They discuss local dialects only, while there's no scientifically known single common language (at the level you pretend). Your "Siberian language" project is a mixture of different dialects and fantazies. It doesn't anyhow help in recovering the real historic facts. And it the final period. Thank you for conversation. [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g ''(Vladimir V. Medeyko)'']] 11:52, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#::: The language was combined from dialects, just like any language do. The words in the language are real historic words, and this can be prooved. So this is lie about it's non-naturality, lie, made only for political goals which you yourself recognize. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 11:58, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#:::: Ok, I agree to assume that you personally are just bona fide mistaken. Then, may I recommend you to take a course in the linguistic science first? A language is a complex system, not just a random collection of words! The "Siberian language" initiative approaches are definitely unscientific. Sorry. [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g ''(Vladimir V. Medeyko)'']] 13:42, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#::::: Combined together they forms system, as it is shown in texts written in siberian language. Your system argument plays only against padonkian, because random misspelling russian words do not form language system, as in Padonkian case. But using old north words and old north grammar in complex texts - this is just language system of Northern Russian language. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 13:50, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#::Dear Yaroslav, if you promoted Siberian language as a conlang, I would agree. Yes, I suppose, that Siberian is a conlang, created in some political agenda. And this language potentially may exist in a status of the '''constructed''' language (artificial language), there are many different conlangs in the world, created for different goals, including political. But you pretend it to be a historic language that was a spoken language in the past - and this is an evidently wrong allegation. I'd even dare to name it "lie". One of these lies is that there are "native speakers of Siberian", in my opinion. That is clear for any person who studied linguistics even at basic level. Sorry, maybe I'm a bit insulting. Sorry! [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g ''(Vladimir V. Medeyko)'']] 05:40, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
#::: No, I did '''never''' promote Siberian like "a historic language that was a spoken language in the past", but language is based on old dialects of Northern Russian. Theese dialects may have differences, and now we construct common '''standard''' for the Northern Russian. And this thing is clear and evident, also it is evident that the words were not invented. And native speakers of Siberian - they are speakers of dialects, which Siberian language codifies. And the situation is really ''clear for any person who studied linguistics even at basic level'', but your political prejudices make you blind and abusive. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 06:45, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
#:: It's a '''DIRECT AND BLATANT LIE'''!!! Here's [http://incubator.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Test-WP/chal/C%D0%B8%D0%B1%D0%B8%D1%80%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B9_%D0%B3%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%BE%D1%80&oldid=2917 a reference] to an article, created by '''you'''. The linked text is quite comprehensible to me, and it states clearly enough that it is a historic language that was a spoken language in the past. Just say frankly that it is a conlang, state clearly that "Siberian language" is a conlang based on remnants of different dialects of old Ilmen Slovene language and other slavic and non-slavic languages, non-scientifically mixing them - and '''nobody''' (or at least, very few) would oppose it, I think. The opposition to your initiative is caused by this your attempt to conceal your political agenda. Your initiative has nothing common with recontruction of PIE, and even with infamous attempt of reconstruction of the world proto-language. Your initiative is unscientific. Sorry again, but I have to call things in their natural names. [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g ''(Vladimir V. Medeyko)'']] 08:14, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
#::: '''STOP LIE YOURSELF'''. What is wrong with the article? Old siberians spoke by dialects of the language, which is codified now. Because words of the language were taken from their somewhat different dialects, this is their language. What is wrong and where is lie? If ANYBODY will propose OTHER STANDARD of North Slavonic, we shall not discuss with them. For example, pomors has somewhat other standrad, and there is no discussion between the siberian group and pomors. But you not only lie about Padonki slang - and this lie is evident and funny - you even lie about my position about the language. NOWHERE did I say that '''only this standard was spoken''', but this is '''standard proposed by Siberian Volgota group''', and there are nothing about this in the article about siberian language prohibited by ruwiki, there are nothing about this in Volgota site, in samir74 LJ, in 40 publications in media about the siberian project. You only lie for political causes. If any particular expression in the article "Siberian govor" in sibwiki disturbes you, you can change the expression by common way of Wikipedia, simply delete them. Maybe we simply do not understand the article or just my expression was not clear, it may be changed --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 08:29, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''Support'''. --[[User:217.70.122.58|217.70.122.58]] 11:19, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''(N)''' {{Support}} ф тридцатке--[[User:Lone Guardian|Lone Guardian]] 11:29, 16 August 2006 (UTC) / [[ru:user:Lone Guardian]]
# {{Support}} --[[User:Tassadar|Tassadar]] 11:53, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Support}}. But in such case, also a Wikipedia for Kashenite Language should be created. It is also fairly widespead and can be understood by Russian speakers. See also: [[ru:Кащенизм]], [[ru:Кащениты]]. --[[User:Oal|Oal]] 12:06, 16 August 2006 (UTC) / [[ru:user:Oal]]
# {{Support}} --[[User:Kink|Kink]] 12:57, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''(N)''' {{support}} Finally, after falling of USSR we found a way to speak at out real language! [[User:Medvedov-Prevedkovich|Medvedov-Prevedkovich]] 13:29, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''(N)''' {{Support}} Padonki language is quite wide spread. It shall never be forgotten! --[[User:Zach0t|Zach0t]] 15:11, 16 August 2006 (UTC) [[ru:user:Lengra]]
# {{Support}} -- [[User:Serebr|Serebr]] 17:08, 16 August 2006 (UTC) ([[ru:user:Serebr]])
# {{Support}} Really language, it is very popular in Russian regions.--[[User:Nikolay Kolpakov|Nikolay Kolpakov]] 18:41, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Support}} This language is really very popular in Russia and other post-USSR countries. I know many people whose native language is padonki language. This language is mush easier than Russian and Siberian! '''Падонки труЪ!''' - [[User:Oyster|Oyster]] 04:28, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
# '''(N)''' {{Support}} Is a formed and widely spread language in Russia. [[User:Eugrus|Eugrus]] 12:04, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Support}} дайте две! - [[User:Vald|Vald]] 21:45, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
# (N) {{Support}}, yes! --[[User:Larap|Larap]] 05:34, 18 August 2006 (UTC)
# (N) '''Strong support''', there is really great number of people speaking it. [[User:MountainBlueAllah|MountainBlueAllah]] 09:17, 18 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{Support}}, '''Strong support''' This must be very interesting projekt! Voting for both nearest to russian projects - '''padonki''' and '''siberian''', both of them wiil be '''''extremely cognitive'''''!--[[User:A1|A1]] 09:46, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

==== <!-- Padonki --> Oppose ====
{{oppose}} ''' Strong oppose'''
"Padonki" is in fact an artificial language developed by the internet community around www.udaff.com, and is nothing just banter and mocking on current Russian spelling system. The "padonki" language is just the mix of misspelled russian words (like "preved" instead of correct "privet"), obscene words (mostly genitals and the fucking, which -- compared to English or German -- is considered to be very offensive), and some words invented by the community. The language itself has no scientific value, since it is nothing but intentionally crippled Russian.
I would like to warn the Wikipedia-community, that it is quite common among "padonki" to arrange flash-mobs aiming at vandalizing certain pages or cheating the polls. The link to current discussion has been posted on some "padonki"-pages, so, we should expect many anonym votes or those from just registrated wikipedians.. [[User:Alaudo|Alaudo]] 18:23, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
:Same as Siberian :) --[[User:Morpheios Melas|Morpheios Melas]] 06:34, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

:: We have Bible in Siberian language. We have Quran in siberian language. You have in that slang only stories about fucking and violence. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 11:04, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
::: There's something like Bible (Genesis) in Padonkian, too. I don't remember exact link, but I have met this. [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g ''(Vladimir V. Medeyko)'']] 11:10, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
:::: Just atheistic parody of course, because the most popular words in padonkian are "fuck" and "cock". --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 11:17, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
:: I do not care that Siberian language is, but the latter doesn't use offensive and sacred words as Padonki language, which is basically nothing but that. And the language itself is not vivid at all, if you compare it to let's say Barkov's Luka, it is just repeated using of same offensive constructions written in mangled Russian.
::And, please, do not lie saying there are "native speakers". '''There are none'''. Native means you speak it basically at home, with you children and in family, and I do doubt it. So, there is nobody who speaks it and the whole mess-up here is just to entertain a couple of those "padonki", that's agaist the principle of Wikipedia! [[User:Alaudo|Alaudo]] 08:35, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
I think this is vandal proposing and should be deleted. Padonki slang is criminal in it's essence, so many criminals and people of similiar psychology will be interested, so wikipedia will have a large amount of vandals. Comparing to this, Siberian os only dialect of farmers, developed by some scholar enthusiasts, so they will play in siberian wiki, inventing names of the stars in Novgorod language, and nothing more)))--[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 18:41, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

It's just a primitive slang which appeared few years ago and will die in 3-4 years. {{unsigned|83.220.35.194}}
:Same as Siberian :) --[[User:Morpheios Melas|Morpheios Melas]] 12:15, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

Siberian appeared in 7 century AC --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 14:11, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

:O RLY? Please quote ANY reliable source proving that Slavic people lived there at that time (e.g. any archeological excavation data).--[[User:Shakura|Shakura]] 14:26, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

: Siberian is codification of Novgorod Slavonic language (so called 'north russian dialect'). But the north russian has very few similiar to the "russian" language, invented by Lomonosov in 18 century and used by Russian state and ruwiki.--[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 14:30, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
:: So, it's a dead language [[ru:User:VanHelsing.16|VanHelsing.16]]

::: Yes, dead language with sufficient remains in modern farmer's dialects, we want to revive it, the same was in Europe with occitan, aragon, etc, etc, so why russian nationalists so hate such a natural process of reviving old dialects, very common in Europe? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 15:24, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

Last article about the siberian language, just read it and cease lie:

""Где можно купить книги на диалектах русского языка?" Вопрос моей финской знакомой застает врасплох. А нигде... Приобрести книги на диалектах русского в России невозможно. Приходится объяснять, что в СССР с диалектами боролись, а в современной РФ освоение медиа-пространства на поморском или сибирском диалекте великого и могучего находится в зачаточном состоянии. И занимаются этим исключительно энтузиасты, которых подчас записывают чуть ли не в сепаратисты."
http://www.kasparov.ru/material.php?id=44E2DAC8CA37F

Every serious internet newspaper in Russia writes about tragedy of siberian people and siberian language, only 20 russian nationalists try to lie in international wikipedia about us. Stupid provocations combined with lie and personal insults - you are real descendants of your fathers, stalinist and czarists, who killed people speaking in novgorod-siberian and prohibited to write in it. You destroyed the Great Novgorod many times and your imperial civilization is founded on lie and violence. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 15:57, 16 August 2006 (UTC)


:: If so, padonki's language is codification of ancient australian natives language. [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 15:39, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
::: Such a stupid lie only shows that you are vandal. The salng was invented by udaffcom and has almost no differences from the russian--[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 15:43, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

'''Oppose''' - only 50 words are different from the russian, grammar and pronunciation are the same. The voting itself is only russian nationalist flash-mob for stop the development of Siberian wiki. Siberian wiki does no harm to the russians, but they hate every old slavonic dialects in their territory, trying to stop their revival by any ways, even vandalizing in Meta. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 14:19, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
: Russian nationalism? OMG! I thought you were wiser... [[ru:User:VanHelsing.16|VanHelsing.16]]
:: And personal insults combined with lie - this is all what you can do against me --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 15:24, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
::: Why should we do anything against you? All we want is a Wiki in our language! --[[User:Zach0t|Zach0t]] 15:35, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
:::: Меня просто дергает что склоняют сибирский. А вообще добро пожаловать в инкубатор)) Я даже не против вас принять в восточнославянское сообщество инкубатора) Когда начнется тестовая вика? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 15:43, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

: And how can we stop the development of Siberian wiki? It's founded. OK, we just want to have Padonkian as well! [[ru:User:VanHelsing.16|VanHelsing.16]]
:: +1 --[[User:Zach0t|Zach0t]] 15:35, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

:: just constant metioning of siberian in your mouths testifies about this. Having no proofs to you lie, having no support, hating real language of the russian people, you again and again come to fight with siberian, again and again want to dictate your imperial language to the slavonians of Russia and Siberia--[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 15:24, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

::: oh that's a kind of paranoia! I don't speak Siberian and I don't hate it (that's strange to hate a language). I don't dictate anything! I don't fight with it! If you want to speak it - speak. how can I deny using a language?!!
::: You use Sibearian, I use Padonkian. That's all. [[ru:User:VanHelsing.16|VanHelsing.16]]

:::: So why did you vote against Siberian?)) --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 16:08, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

::::: I don't like the idea of Siberian wikipedia. OK, the language exists, but very few people use it and very few are interested in learning and using it. Wikiproject must be large and useful. I don't believe it'll be large and useful (the amount of speakers is not enough) [[ru:User:VanHelsing.16|VanHelsing.16]]

:::::: But practice disproves this. After 2 months, in very bad condition in incubator, persecuted by the official ru-wiki, constantly attacked by russian vandals, we have more than 1200 articles, written by 10 persons, this is 99 level from 228 wikipedias --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 16:38, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

:: ''The voting itself is only russian nationalist flash-mob for stop the development of Siberian wiki.''
:: Oh. So, <s>I can also play this game.</s> I insist on creating a [[ru:кащенизм|kashenite]] Wikipedia, because non-creating it is a harrassing ignorance due to silencing the importance of jewisch internet dialects by russian nationalists. Huh? --[[User:Oal|Oal]] 17:08, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
:::: So you prove my own words, the majority of voters are just russian nationalists, crazy seeing prosperity of the siberian wiki. We are only 5 persons, and you fear us)))--[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 17:13, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
::::: Where did I say it? I'm not ''just russian nationalist'', I am rather a victim of them, being crushed by not-even-metioning the [[ru:кащениты| kashenite]] wiki. =] --[[User:Oal|Oal]] 17:38, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
:::::: Если вы думаете, что умно смотритесь, превращая это место в форум, вы ошибаетесь)) Наоборот этот реквест - ваше полное поражение. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 18:10, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

You came just to prove this part of the article from Kasparov about the siberian language: Возьмусь утверждать, что языковые права всех россиян бессовестным образом попираются. С обычным русским тоже далеко не все в порядке. Достаточно включить телевизор. На контролируемых государством каналах находит свое место блатная и тюремная лексика, чего ни одно уважающее себя государство себе не позволяет. ("violating human rights and destroing real dialects, russian goverment supports criminal slang, widely used in TV and other media") The padonki slang is only subset of this criminal slang, who is based on non-slavic words of western origin. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 17:20, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
: Товарищ, если можете, возьмите себя в руки, пожалуйста -- вы уже своей сибирякией всех заебали. Здесь обсуждают совсем другое. [[User:Csman|Csman]] 18:40, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

:: Прекратите материться в культурном месте. Please stop the offencive speaking and violating the rules of wikipedia. Отчего же якобы обсуждают совсем другое, а склоняют сибирский? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 18:43, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
::: Да никто ничего не склоняет! '''Кстати: прошу всех русских здесь воздержаться от выпадов в адрес сибирской вики.''' Мы вам не мешаем. Ну открыли вы свою вики, что теперь? Работайте, желаю вам удачи. Только уж другим не мешайте, ибо язык падонков действительно распространённее (это факт). Пожалуйста, Ярослав, не надо сейчас сыпать доказательствами. '''Всё, нам ваша сибвики до лампочки.''' А вот Ваш голос против с размусоливанием старой темы выглядит не то попыткой мелкой мести, не то вторым пиаром. Пожалуйста, давайте не будем больше обсуждать сибирский. По данному предложению Вы сказали: "этот язык ненастоящий, в нём нет грамматики, он придуман на удаффкоме, там только 30 слов". Это Ваш аргумент, и я его уважаю. Не мешайте и другим приводить свои аргументы. [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 18:52, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

:::: Кто начал склонять сибирский я или вы??? На самом деле я даже поддержал бы, если бы было хоть что-то позитивное. А так полукриминальный жаргон, практически идентичный с русским. Если вам лично сибвика до лампочки, какого хрена лично вы против нее голосуете? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 18:56, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
::::: Какая разница, если её уже открыли? Я голосовал против открытия, потому что полагал, что такого языка не существует (и в противном меня никто не убедит, мнения известных мне коренных сибиряков в любом случае звучат гораздо весомее). [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 19:20, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
:::::: вы хоть понимаете смысл самой фразы "языка не существует"? как он может не существовать, когда есть кодифицированный словарь, грамматика и тексты? Язык определенно существует, если отличается от других языков и употребляется. В данном случае падонковский не язык, поскольку коммуникативно недостаточен - применяется только в одной сфере, материться в интернете. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 19:29, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
::::::: Ну йа матеръюсь и нитолько ф интырнете, и чта? -[[User:Lone Guardian|Lone Guardian]] 03:30, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

* {{Oppose}} [[User:Ochkarik|Ochkarik]] 02:47, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
*: Why? [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 09:11, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
*:: Я считаю, что данный язык должен сначала появиться в викисловаре (как и сибирский, я голосовал против сибирского языка в википедии), а уже затем , и в википедии, очень малый словарный запас слов в языке. Я считаю, что написать о новом викисловаре на Request for new languages/Non natural . C уважением, [[User:Ochkarik|Ochkarik]] 09:34, 18 August 2006 (UTC)
*:: Translation of [[User:Ochkarik|Ochkarik]]'s comment: ''"I think this language should first appear in Wiktionary (just as siberian, I voted against siberian in Wikipedia) and only after that in Wikipedia. There is poor number of words in this language. I think you should first ask for new Wiktionary at Request for new languages/Non natural. Regards, [[User:Ochkarik|Ochkarik]]"'' - translated by [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 12:09, 18 August 2006 (UTC)

*{{Oppose}} -- [[User:A. Yurkevich|A. Yurkevich]] 10:50, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
*Lemme elucidate the situation abit. Padonki is not a language, it's more like a culture of appraisable commenting, commenting in the style much of Ella Shchukina from "12 Chairs". I'll remind, she used about 30 words to value any single event or object. Padonki are the same, they use some catchy phrases to value everything. So they act pseudo-dumb people. The important notice: all the phrases of padonki '''CAN BE TYPED WITH NO MISTAKES TO OFFICIAL RUSSIAN ORTHOGRAPHY''', their culture allows it (u can type ''в десятке'' (transl.: i've got into the number of first 10 commenters) with no mistakes, or ''фдисятке'', with mistakes).

Using the commenting padonki culture no one can create an article about, forex, Newton. The best one could be created imho sounds that way:

''Ньютон исаак (пендосы: Newton Isaak) - первонах, фдисятке, фтопку, ниибёт.''

The very simmilar culture (or subculture) of commenting in Russian is Troo-goth. It uses even fewer words to value things. THey are:

**'''Гламурна''' - ''excellent''
**'''Гламурненька''' - ''not bad''
**'''Гатич(ь)на''' - ''kewl''
**'''Аццкий сотона''' - ''the man that does thing in the coollest way''
**'''Труъ''' - ''true''

As the persons understaning Russian can see, Troo-goth culture uses settled ungrammar forms of Russian words, and 1 (''Труъ'') word that is transliterated from English.

Article about Newton could be done only in sucha way in Troo-goth:

''Ньютон исаак (труъ: Newton Isaak) - гламурна, гатичьна, аццкий сотона, труъ.''

Go then, there is even third culture in commenting (it's also a culture of funny pics) in Russian - ''Preved''. It has born in 2005, and is a more radical form of orthographical art. It ridicules the Russian language as a language that doesn't follow a phonetic principe and has alot of rules of "how to write it right". To make fun of Russian it goes even further from phonetic principe, replacing ''-ник-'' suffixes with ''-нег-'', replacing ''-чик-'' suffixes with ''-чег-'', ''-ик-'' suffixes with ''-ег-'' and replacing SOME ''-а-'' 's in the roots with non-phonetical ''-o-'' 's, -ий ends are replaced SOMETIMES with ''-ей'', phonetical ''-е-'' 's in roots are also SOMETIMES replaced with non-phonetical ''-и-'' 's. The basic words of Preved are:

**'''Превед''' - hello, or i'm here, or whata shit you wrote
**'''Кросавчег''' - nice one, cool
**'''Медвед''' - the bear in translation, the main hero and the 'God' of Preved culture. Often used with ''Превед'' word and then has the meaning of Превед word
**'''Соучаснег''' - the object in 'Preved' pictures that ''Медвед'' always makes fun of (or with).
**'''Кагдила?''' - How are you, how d'u feel
**'''Паканирадила''' - the answer to ''Кагдила'' (''haven't brought forth yet'')
**'''Пака''' - the answer to Превед (''bb'')

The article about Newton in Preved could'be done but it'll has minimal difference from russian.

And now there is an answer why i typed all this stuff. The language these people want to create wikipedia is called '''Olbanian''' (non-grammar version of 'Albanian' word) '''language'''. It consists of:
*''Padonki commenting''
*''Troo-goth commenting''
*''Preved commenting''
*''+ungrammar text, like it often watched on russian forums, where non-educated or badly-educated young people (or the persons imitating them) make alot of mistakes in words, phrases, sentences.''

Olbanian is not codified and cannot be, because it's the 'cool' unique featue of it. The next year, forex, some words of Olbanian, will become ''unfashionable'' (Preved practically has already become it) and young people will create new forms.

Also, this proposition can mean the proposition of '''Kashchenitski language''', which imitates how jews pronunciate russian words. This language is '''ANTI-SEMITIC''' from the time of birth, and infact has very little things to do with Olbanian language that's why i oppose it too.

Also, this proposition can mean the proposition of '''Ruzgey yezyg language''' (totally ungrammar variant of the name of ruslang in russian - ''Russkiy yazyk''). It's extreme form of ortho-art and is too chaotic (where the russian word of 3 letters can contain 7 or more mistakes: ''ещё'' - ''йишсчио'') I have nothing against sucha a creation, but as it's still not codified and is not going to be codified in near future i oppose it as TOO chaotic.


Такшта темаибли нираскрыто, фсем супортирам быстра фыпить йад. Мудоги. -- [[User:A. Yurkevich|A. Yurkevich]] 10:50, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

: Too many letters. Apparently, you have no clue what padonki language is about. Although a few of your points are true, the rest are either irrelevant or plain false.
:# It has way more rules than you think (according to your entry)
:# If preved gets outdated, who cares? Every language in the world is evolving and expressions are falling out of use all the time.
:# "Pseudo-dumb", "misspelled Russian" arguments are completely irrelevant. Belorussian, for instance, may seem to some like a misspelled version of Russian, but so what? I don't doubt for a second it's a valid language.
:# No one in their right mind would confuse Kashchenitski and padonki, and mentioning anti-semitism in padonki context is just plain wrong: with this comment you seem to be trying to create a pointless hysteria about this request instead of a reasonable argument. [[User:Csman|Csman]] 18:26, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
::: What comparison can be between Belarusian language and this criminal slang? Do you understand what are you speaking about??? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 18:37, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
:::: Товарищ, ну я же уже один раз попросил вас успокоиться. Какой ещё в задницу "криминал"? Вы вообще про Удава или превед хоть что-нибудь знаете? И кстати, про вежливость лучше скажите вашему [[User:Kivan|ебанутому дружку]] (или сокпаппету?), который наверху собирается [http://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&diff=prev&oldid=363920 "всех москвичей утопить в крови"]. Вы просто больные люди. Пожалуйста, оставьте нас и нашу заявку в покое. [[User:Csman|Csman]] 18:58, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
:::::: Пожалуйста, сами оставьте нас в покое, склоняя тут сибирский и теперь уже беларуский направо и налево. Киван собирается утопить в крови, если вы не дадите возродить сибирский насильственными средствами. Я не только знаю про Удава, я участвовал в К-К с 1999 года, и создал целую сеть КК-сайтов тогда у себя в регионе, когда была еще одна факра. Суть не в этом, а в том, что матерный сленг девиантного происхождения не может быть сравнен с полноценным языком и таким сравнением вы оскорбляете носителей других славянских языков, возможно сами не замечая этого. Хамство, с которым себя тут ведут товарищи с рувики, возможно, им самим незаметно, но на фоне общей вежливости должно бы резать глаз внешнему наблюдателю. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 19:04, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
::::::: Падонки вас фсех отправят фтопку, если будете камментить, постя фсякий низачот. Серьёзно: сибвики приводится исключительно в качестве прецедента. Сам сибирский язык мы не о(б)суждаем. [[User:Edward Chernenko|Edward Chernenko]] 12:09, 18 August 2006 (UTC)

:::::::::: Да где не обсуждаете-то??? Когда вы научитесь говорить правду и перестанете говорить за "всех"?? Поднимите глаза выше, вы только и обсуждаете сибирский, в пять-шесть глоток. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 14:07, 18 August 2006 (UTC)


: You are complete right, and Siberian with it's strongly codified grammar, based on old Novgorod standards, 15 000 codified words, collected from 30 dictionaries, 1200 entries in living wiki, has no similiarity to that slangs that you have described. This is simply anti-siberian provocation in context of general ruwiki politics on persecution of the Siberian language. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 10:59, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

Perhaps article about Newton in Olbanian language should be something like this:

Ньютон, нах. (Пендос. Newton). Превед, кросавчеги! Ньютон, нах, пендосский физег, нах! ТруЪ! Я кончел, нах! <nowiki> [[Category: Физеги]]</nowiki> --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 16:48, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

{{Oppose}} No slang Wikipedias please. What will be next? Wikipedia "в натуре"? Or "по фене"? --[[User:EugeneZelenko|EugeneZelenko]] 13:23, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

{{Oppose}} И вообще, мне интересно, почему это те, кто сравнивают падонкаффский с сибирским, мол, если есть один, должно быть место и другому, теме не менее, голосуют за падонкаффский, но против сибирского. Где логика? --Kojpiš Anton, Miensk (kojpish@bk.ru) --[[User:194.158.213.175|194.158.213.175]] 13:25, 18 August 2006 (UTC)
: Ну так за сибирский уже очень давно проголосовали, тогда и идеи созадния падонкаффской википедии не было. А теперь было принято решение о создании сибирской. Ну раз сибирский решили создавать, то пускай и падокаффский будет.[[ru:user:VanHelsing.16|VanHelsing.16]]
::Голосование за сибирский продолжается. Оно может закончится только с открытием полноценной вики (не в инкубаторе). Я был бы всё же не против существования обоих вик вместе. Но вот например, вы проголосовали против сибирской и здесь голосуете за. (и не только вы, таких много). Именно поэтому я и проголосовал против падонкоффской. Если бы голосующие за падонкаффскую и оргоментирующие это "Ну раз сибирский решили создавать, то пускай и падокаффский будет" не голосовали бы против сибирской, я бы не голосовал против падонкаффской.--[[User:Kojpiš Anton|Kojpiš Anton]] 22:52, 18 August 2006 (UTC)

::: Да это и так очевидно, что все шоу только для того и предназначено, чтобы не дать севернорусской вике открыться. То, что падонкоффский жаргон, на котором ни одной статьи написать невозможно, знают все участники дискуссии --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 06:48, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

'''Question''' By the way, when padonki test wiki will begin? If this is language, where are the articles? --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 16:31, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

Opened, but where is the encyclopedic content? Humorous articles, taken from '''russian''' Absurdopedia, and discussing of padonki slang. This is still russian language, untill specific grammar and wide dictionary will be developed. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 20:52, 18 August 2006 (UTC)
I have translated one of the "articles" to the siberian language.

Padonki "article":

Падонкаффский йезыг, йезыг падонкаф, олбанский йезыг — распрастранифшейеся ф Рунети в начали XXI века аццкое наречие c фонетически адекватным, но нарачита ниправельным нопейсанием слофф (т. н. ыративом), частым упатриблением сцуко мата и штампоф, хороктерных длйа сленгоф. Такжы известин как «сленк дибилоф».

Исторея йезыга

Первонахом в дикабре 1998 года пайявился йезыг кощенитов. Учаснеги конфы SU.KASCHENKO.LOCAL начели хуярить на беспесды гламурном новом диалекти. Фскори, в 2000 году падонок Дмитрий Соколовский аткрыл кошерный и ниибаццо известный рисурс Удафком, на катором мнагачислинныйе хуяторы и фтыкатели марозили фсякуй хуйню, заложиф тем самым зачотную аснову йезыга. Затем в Рунети стала ниибаццо папулярна лытбырня "Жывой Журнал", ф которой ригулярна праводяцца флешмопы, отжыги и прочий ужоснах, беспесды обогатифшый йезыг падонкаф новыми жосскими олбанскими баянами вроди преведа.

Siberian article:

Падонковской говор ("язык падонкаф") — наречче Рунета, спето в зачале XXI столеття. Порушат веры россейсково правописа, корыстоват матерны и дружны сленговски словы, головны сторонки Udaff.com и Fuckru.net.

По сути являтса сленгом россейского говора, пото чо не имат особой говорогородки, число онцовых словов коло 30.

Деянни гимговых сленгов россейсково говора

Первой ведомой гимговой сленг притянулса в 1998 годе. Дольники сборишша SU.KASCHENKO.LOCAL зачали мышлеть новы сленговы словы рожаючейся россейской гимги. В 2000 году было открыто Удафком, головна сторонка гимговово сленга ажно досель. Падонковско наречче корыстуетса ешшо в "Живучем Бытейнике", де доселе рожаютса новы сленговы словечки.


Everybody can see, thet "padonki" article is not encyclopedic - it uses many words with indefinite meaning, expressing only feelings of slang users (like "отжыг", "сцуко"). The part which has some meaning is written in russian language, without any constant orthography. So there is no any attributes of language in this slang - no constant orthography, no specific grammar but russian grammar, no specific words but 30-50 slang words, using for everything because there are no other padonki words. This is good content for russian Absurdopedia, not for different wikipedia. No slang wikipedias were opened in english slangs or german slangs, etc. Meanwhile, Siberian is just language based on dialects, and it is fit for Wikipedia, but Padonki unfit.
*{{Oppose}}. Padonki slang is more suitable for Uncyclopedia: this language section cannot be serious a priori. Just imagine language section with mangled english and abusive words. It is just unavailing: it can become really popular between udaff.com fans, but it will never become encyclopedic. The large support has been provoked because of misunderstanding about "siberian language" and should be annuled by [[:en:WP:POINT]]. --[[:ru:User:Boleslav1]] 11:37, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

:: Первый случай, когда я полностью согласен с Болеславом)) Agreed. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 11:55, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

* {{oppose}} ''' Strong oppose''' Vocabulary near 30 words...This idea is stupid. [[User:Steel archer|Steel archer]] 13:06, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

==== <!-- Padonki --> Comments ====
The work is starting on padonki test wikipedia here: http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Test-wp/pad [[User:Csman|Csman]] 20:08, 18 August 2006 (UTC)

===== Translation of some http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Test-wp/pad articles =====

To show you the level of padonkis' language independence we present some translations of it's articles.

*Translation of Test-wp/pad/Россея article
In origin:
Россея - страна с беспесды пицот от Европы и Азеи.
Исчо Россея ф дисятке по ВВП, количеству учаснегов и ф сотне по зачотной жизни. Шышечка Россеи - президент, креатифным органом являиццо федеральное собранее.
Многие учаснеги Россеи считают, что живут не песдато и защитывают слив правительству, высок уровнь фубля жизни. Распространено мнение, что правительство мешает раскрывать тему сисек, в особенности после обоссаки с законом об экстримизме.

Russian translation:
Россия - страна, занимающая значительную часть Европы и Азии.
Также Россия - одна из десяти стран с наиболее высоким уровнем ВВП, но уровень жизни достаточно низок. Главой россии является президент, законодательным органом Федеральное собрание.
У граждан России распространены мнение о неудолетворительности условий их жизни и критика в адрес правительства, многие живут за чертой бедности. Часто считается, что в России правительством ущемляется свобода слова, в особенности после ситуации с Российским "Законом об экстремизме".

English translation:
Russia is the country that occupies a considerable part of both Europe and Asia.
Russia is one of ten counties with the highest GDP rating, but the life rate is rather low and the level of out of cost living is high. Russia is headed by the president and Federal meeting is the legislative body.
Russians often find their life poor and are not satisfacted by the work of the goverment. It is a diffused opinion that Russian goverment tries to infringe upon the freedom of speech, especially in the present state of Russian "Extremism law".
[[User:Eugrus|Eugrus]] 23:27, 18 August 2006 (UTC)

: And all the translations are incorrect. Because word "с беспесды" means only "cool", and not "occupy considerable part". "количеству учаснегов" is not equal to "population", because padonki slang has no specific word for "population". "Участнег" can mean "any person", but not "citizen", there is no word for "citizen" in the slang. Etc., etc. Padonki slang has NO WORDS for writing science articles in it, but it has many political incorrect words like "хохлы", "чурки", "пендосы" (the later is abusive russian word for "American"). Kashenite subset is antisemitic. And this is Original Research that Padonlki is a language, there is NO ARTICLE in the world, where this is called "language", all media articles discussing that names it "slang", and this IS abusive russian slang, nothing more. And you still not have constant orthography, just your example shows this. Please cease discriminate and persecute real ancient language of working people of northern Russia, Siberian Language, and promote your criminal nationalistic slang here. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 01:39, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
:: It's just because you don't speak in Padonkian. For native Padonkis, the text above is clear. Neither Russian, nor English translations are word-to-word translations. Despite "учаснег" is not a direct synonym to "гражданин" or "citizen", "учаснег Россеи" is synonymic to "гражданин Российской Федерации" and "Russian citizen". You may trace etymology easily: "гражданин" and "cizen" are derived from middle-age quasi-states ("города" and "cities"), while "учаснег" is created in context of the modern quasi-states (web-projects). [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g ''(Vladimir V. Medeyko)'']] 06:02, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
::: And this is lie. Word "учаснег" means "participant", but not "citizen". So they speak "participant of Russia" instead of "citizen" only because they have not particular word "citizen". Your own dictionary in ruwiki says: Учаснег, Соучаснег (превед-эрратив участник) — участник. (участник= participant) http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%96%D0%B0%D1%80%D0%B3%D0%BE%D0%BD_%D0%BF%D0%B0%D0%B4%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2
And you lie here even when my arguments are evident, even when EVERY "official" padonki dictionary has not more than 50 words, and it is evident, that nobody can write wikipedia using only 50 words. You lie, because your political motivation forces you to lie even in very clear topics, like slang nature of the Padonki slang. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 06:54, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
::::Dear Yaroslav, you just didn't catch the idea behind my words: Russian "гражданин" (citizen) derived from "город" (city); compare Russian "'''гр'''а'''ж'''д'''анин'''" (citizen) and "'''г'''о'''р'''о'''жанин'''" (townsman). Consider French word "citoyen" (citizen), derived from "cite" (city, town), and ititially it meant just "townsman". If citizenship is derived from "participation in city's life" in old languages, what's wrong in derivation of modern word for citizenship from "participation in project's life"? It seems nothing. Is it clear? [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g ''(Vladimir V. Medeyko)'']] 07:33, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
::::: It is clear, that you '''have not''' specific word for "citizen", and use "participant" instead of citizen. The same is with many other words. Slang words are expressive, but they have indefinite meanings, and this is common thing in slangs. So Padonki slang is unfit for writing articles in it, because such articles will not have definite meanings. This is just like toki pona - you have only 50 words, and you '''invent''' their meanings depending on context. If you will continue this, I shall copy here large tables of meanings, in which you use such words like "отжыг" or "участнег". And you still have problems with orthography. You will be forced: or invent language in Wikipedia - this is original research - or write articles in russian language, simply damaging their orthography. And this is very easy to reveal, so I shall have fun during the nearest days, exposing your lie)))) --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 08:14, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
:::::: The thing that language's lexicon is relatively poor doesn't make it useless and doesn't disallow us to use wider concepts instead [[User:Eugrus|Eugrus]] 08:34, 19 August 2006 (UTC).
:::::::: Yes, Eugrus, and this is the thing which I want to reveal! '''Language's lexicon is relatively poor''', and unfit for wikipedia. Just read my position in current dicussion in LJ - "Это статьи на русском языке с использованием 10 жаргонных слов. Именно что это не годится для википедии, правила которой отрицают эмоциональную оценочность. Если бы там были словарь, грамматика, и это годилось бы для выражения хоть чего-то кроме эмоциональной оценки, то да, я считал бы языком"

There is no meaning 'гражданин' in current dictionaries of Padonki slang. So inventing the meaning '''in Wikipedia''' is definitely Original Research.--[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 08:42, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

::::I see, you still didn't catch the idea. It's quite easy: in middle age, people had no specific word for "citizen", and used "townsman" instead; (add German "Buerger" from "Burg" here - I forgot to mention it above). The same with "учаснег Россеи". And the second: I have no any problems. I don't have any plans to participate in creation of Padonkian texts, maybe minor corrections only; in this area, I'm just a researcher. [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g ''(Vladimir V. Medeyko)'']] 08:23, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
:::::: I catched the idea. but the idea is OR, because the idea is absent in non-wikipedia dictionaries of Padonki slang. It is good to research slangs, but slangs are '''definitely''' unfit for wikipedia articles. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 08:42, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
::::::::I don't bother about that. I have just proved a fact that '''your assertion''': '"Участнег" can mean "any person", but not "citizen"' is '''wrong'''. "Участнег" CAN mean "citizen". That's all, and all other your points do not matter in this context. [[User:Drbug|D'''r''' B'''u'''g ''(Vladimir V. Medeyko)'']] 12:38, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
:::::::::: "Участнег" CAN mean "citizen", because "ciizen" is person. And "Участнег" means "any person". There are no other neutral words in the slang for the persons, others are abusive. So you can not write wikipedia by such a language where meaning of the words are indefinite, you can only joke by it, so the slang can be used in Absurdopedia only --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 12:51, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

::::::: Dude, once again, can you leave us alone, please? We let you have your own personal wikipedia in whatever slang you have, why don't you apply all that immense energy of yours to it! Go on and create new things, don't just keep shitting on others, that's what I would suggest. [[User:Csman|Csman]] 10:02, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
::::::::: And this is the last argument that you have:-) No shit on you, just speaking truth. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 10:17, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

====One more "translation"====


Padonki:
Жывой Журнал (пендосский LiveJournal) -- пендосская лытбырня, ставшайя беспесды папулярной в Рунети посли 2002 года. Сриди учаснегов лытбырни -- гламурные деффачки, олкоголеки, многие падонки и флешмопперы, а такжы многийе знаминитые пейсатели и прочие афтары.

English:

LiveJornal (abusive word for Americans, LiveJournal) - blog of cursed Americans, cool and popular in Russia after 2002 year (the rest of the sentence is written in Russian - Y.Z.). It's participants are - prostitutes, alcoholics, criminals and flashmobers, and many well-known writers (the last word is changed antisemitically - Y.Z.) and other authors.

Where is science? Where is objectivity? It is impossible to write articles in criminal slang, and Wikipedia will loss it's reputation publishing politically incorrect and abusive articles. But there is no possibility to write normal articles in abusive language. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 02:01, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

Even russian wikipedia article is named "Жаргон падонков" (Padonki SLANG)(http://ru.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%96%D0%B0%D1%80%D0%B3%D0%BE%D0%BD_%D0%BF%D0%B0%D0%B4%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2). This is definitely slang, even CLASSICAL example of slang, and to name it language is definitely OR. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 02:28, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

: This translation is fully falsification. "Гламурные деффачки, олкоголеки, многие падонки и флешмопперы" are all names for communities, but not the things are written behind.

:"Падонки" is the name for the language speakers. "Гламурные деффачки" is the name for stylish girls, it is formed from Russian "glamourous girls", but has a separate meaning, and of couse it has nothing in common with prostitutes, the only reason for such translation was to discredit us.

:Somewhy [[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] also calls us nationalists when we hate and have nothing in common with nationalizm, and again, the only reason is to to discredit us

:[[User:Eugrus|Eugrus]] 08:22, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

::: Just show me padonki dictionary to prove that my translation is wrong. Slang words have indefinite meanings, so деффачки can be translated like "girls" or like "prostitutes", and by very-very other ways. Also with the word падонки and others. And what means the word алкоголики if not alcoholics? And nationalism is just using words хохлы and пендосы, and пейсатели --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 08:33, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

:::: English for "пейсатели" is just "writes" and has no link for any nations. [[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] is trying to hype. [[User:Eugrus|Eugrus]] 08:41, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
::::: Every Russian understands the etimology of the word пейсатели - russian писатели (writers) was mispronounced so it is no similiar to the word пейсы, and пейсы is attribute of jewish culture. The whole kashenite slang is antisemitic, as my belorussian friend have already said, and you know this, but lie. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 08:52, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
:::::: I'am a Jew and I do not find anything abusive for me in padonkis' language. I also sure you that пейсатели has no ethimological connection to пейсы [[User:Eugrus|Eugrus]] 09:24, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
:::::::: And this is your subjective position, but other persons find it. This is common thing with slangs, where words have no definite meanings. Meanwhile, authors of the Padonkian wiki write now definite lie in the articles - for example, article http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Test-wp/pad/%D0%9F%D0%B0%D0%B4%D0%BE%D0%BD%D0%BA%D0%B0%D1%84%D1%84%D1%81%D0%BA%D0%B8%D0%B9_%D0%B9%D0%B5%D0%B7%D1%8B%D0%B3 now contains information "Padonki language has 300000 words" which is not proved by external sources and this is definitely lie. So your Padonki wikipedia is version of Russian Absurdopedia, but you already has Absurdopedia, written in russian language using Padonki words. --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 09:33, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
::::::::: You are not right at all. There are 300.000 words used in language's own spelling and neary 100 having their own principially new meanings. [[User:Eugrus|Eugrus]] 10:17, 19 August 2006 (UTC)
::::::::::: And where is the dictionary where the 300 000 words are codified? Padonki slang have no codified spelling, and this is written in every article about it. And please provide any link about the 100 words with new meanings too. Even 30 words mentioned in the dictionary in ruwiki are mostly uncorrectly spelling russian words or common russian words using in expressive meanings --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 10:35, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

== Min Dong ==

{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer=[[en:User:Jose77|Jose77]]
|User accounts of others= [[en:User:GnuDoyng|GnuDoyng]] '''(N)'''
|Language code= cdo (ISO 639-3)
|Proposed domain= cdo.wikipedia.org
|Wikipedia article= [[en:Min Dong language]]
|Native name= Mìng-dĕ̤ng-ngṳ̄
|English name= Min Dong
|Number of speakers= 250,000
|Locations spoken= Mainly apoken in the area from Fu'an in northeastern Fujian to Fuzhou in east central Fujian. Also spoken in parts of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand. [http://www.nvtc.gov/lotw/months/may/SinoTibetanLanguageFamily.htm]
|Related languages= [[en:Min (linguistics)|Min family]]
|Promoting organizations= [http://blog.yam.com/gnudoyng Mindong on the web], [http://seng-ging.spaces.msn.com/ Foochowese Bible]
|Request on mailing list=
}}
* [[incubator:Test-wp/zh-min-dong/]]
==== Support:====
# {{support}} --'''[[User:Taichi|Taichi]]''' - ([[User talk:Taichi|あ！]]) 21:22, 5 August 2006 (UTC)
# [[User:Node ue|Node ue]] 00:25, 8 August 2006 (UTC)
==== Oppose:====
--[[User:Fratele lui Bonaparte, il cunosti?|Fratele lui Bonaparte, il cunosti?]] 11:01, 19 August 2006 (UTC)

====Comments:====
* The Mìng-dĕ̤ng-ngṳ̄ Test Wikipedia has been created [http://incubator.wikimedia.org/wiki/Test-wp/zh-min-dong/ Here].
--[[User:Jose77|Jose77]] 00:38, 1 August 2006 (UTC)
* The current article about Min Dong is merely a stub. For outsiders to understand the debate, people familiar with this language ought to provide some context. For example, they could provide some comparisons of Min Dong with Min Nan, and even Mandarin. I am not a Min Dong speaker, but in my opinion, Min Dong ("Eastern Min") is merely a dialect of the Min language whose pronunciations, slang, and minor grammatical points make it moderately unintelligible with other Min dialects, similar to ''Schwyzerdütsch'' ([http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alemannic_German Alemannic] or "[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_German Swiss German]")'s relationship with [http://wikipedia.org/wiki/German_language German]. So unlike Min itself, which is a distinct language (not a dialect) within the Chinese language family which includes Mandarin, Cantonese, and Wu (all virtually completely unintelligible languages as different as Spanish and French); Min Dong and Min Nan are dialects of the same language. And dialects of languages don't have their own wikipedias. Or do they: [http://als.wikipedia.org/wiki/ Wikipedia in Alemannic/Swiss German] [http://nds.wikipedia.org/wiki/ Low Saxon/German Wikipedia] --[[User:72.140.132.53|72.140.132.53]] 06:28, 9 August 2006 (UTC)
** No, you're wrong. Very, very, very, very wrong. "Bân-lâm" is Min Nan (Southern Min) equivalent of Min Dong (Eastern Min) word "Mìng-nàng". If you think "ban lam" and "ming nang" are phrases in the same language, you are insane. --[[User:Node ue|Node ue]] 08:52, 9 August 2006 (UTC)




== Laz language (Lazuri Nena) ==

{{New-language-template
|Wiki accounts of the proposer= =[[en:User:Macukali|Macukali]]
|User accounts of others= User accounts of others
|Language code= cdo (ISO 639-3)
|Proposed domain= lzz.wikipedia.org and lzz.wikionary.org
|Wikipedia article= [[en:Laz_language]] and [[en:Laz_people]]
|Native name= Lazuri
|English name= Laz
|Number of speakers= 500.000
|Locations spoken= North East [[en:Anatolia]], [[en:Turkey]] and [[en:Georgia_%28country%29]]
|Related languages= [[en:Megrelian_language]] [[en:Languages_of_the_Caucasus]]
|Promoting organizations= [http://www.karalahana.com], [http://www.lazuri.com], [http://lazebura.net]
|Request on mailing list= Request on mailing list
}}
==== Support:====
# {{support}} --
#<s> {{support}} [[User:64.56.235.16|64.56.235.16]] 15:00, 9 August 2006 (UTC)<s>
# {{support}} [[en:User:Kober|Kober]]
# {{support}} [[en:User:Khoikhoi|Khoikhoi]] 17:03, 9 August 2006 (UTC)
# {{support}} [[User:Belgian man|Belgian man]] <small>([[:nl:Gebruiker:Cars en travel|nl]] [[:na:User:Belgian man|na]] [[en:User:Belgian man|en]])</small> 11:12, 15 August 2006 (UTC)

==== Oppose:====
# --[[User:Node ue|Node ue]] 22:56, 9 August 2006 (UTC) until you find some native speakers.

====Comments:====
* If <code>cdo</code> is the ISO code, you will have to go with it for the subdomain, too. This appears a bit unfortunate, since ''laz'' would certainly be nice. If possible, try to have the ISO code changed, which I doubt would be easy or quickly accomplished. Good luck! -- [[User:Purodha|Purodha Blissenbach]] 00:16, 14 August 2006 (UTC)

== Request for Aramaic/Syriac Wiktionary==
I request that a wiktionary for the Aramaic/Syriac language be created for the many ethnicities that use this language. I also would like to be the Administrator of this wiktionary. [[Makkow]]

== Requests for Wikiversity Languages ==

Requests for creating a new language version of Wikiversity are a bit different from requesting a new language version of Wikipedia. In addition to making a formal request below, there must be a demonstration of support from at least 10 different users before the Wikiversity edition may be created. Request for trial version of Wikiversity can also be made on the incubator Wiki.

See http://mail.wikimedia.org/pipermail/foundation-l/2006-August/009046.html
for some additional details.

'''*Note*''' - this is not support of opposition to the concept of Wikiversity, just if you think the language itself should be supported for creation as a new language edition for Wikiversity.

=== English Wikiversity ===

English Wikiversity already exists : See [[v:]]. [[User:Guillom|Guillom]] 15:43, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
:It didn't at the time I made the request, but I'm glad to see that the developers (mainly Brion) were able to move so quickly. It certainly has been a busy couple of days now that it has come up. --[[User:Roberth|Roberth]] 13:19, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
::It has indeed :) [[User:Guillom|Guillom]] 16:05, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

==== Support ====
#[[User:Roberth|Roberth]] 13:39, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
* '''Support'''. Just to see how the project could evolve. But I am afraid that, initially, its viability is limited to the three languages (English, German and French) which have largest Wikipedias. [[User:Hégésippe Cormier|Hégésippe]] | [[User talk:Hégésippe Cormier|±Θ±]] 08:55, 16 August 2006 (UTC)

==== Oppose ====

=== German Wikiversity ===
'''Comment''' - in the case of German Wikiversity, the domain has been established for some time and the project does exist after a fashion. Indeed it was one of the reasons that started the whole proposal for Wikiversity through the new project process. This request is mainly a formality to document that de.wikiversity could have been set up had a formal vote for activation actually occured when the rest of the various language versions of Wikiversity were also set up, or what the fate of http://de.wikiversity.org/ should be.

==== Support ====
* '''Support'''. Just to see how the project could evolve. But I am afraid that, initially, its viability is limited to the three languages (English, German and French) which have largest Wikipedias. [[User:Hégésippe Cormier|Hégésippe]] | [[User talk:Hégésippe Cormier|±Θ±]] 08:56, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
* '''Support'''. --[[User:Frank Schulenburg|Frank Schulenburg]] 22:47, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
* '''Strong support'''. We shouldn't have Wikiversity in English alone, now, should we? :) --[[User:Gray Porpoise|Gray Porpoise]] 15:59, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

==== Oppose ====

=== Spanish Wikiversity ===

==== Support ====

==== Oppose ====

=== French Wikiversity ===

==== Support ====

* {{Support}} Great project ! I will help. [[User:Traroth|Traroth]] 21:37, 15 August 2006 (UTC)
* {{support}} Me too. Strong support. [[User:Guillom|Guillom]] 08:40, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
*{{support}} So do I / Moi aussi --[[User:Grimlock|Grimlock]] 08:51, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
* '''Support'''. Just to see how the project could evolve. But I am afraid that, initially, its viability is limited to the three languages (English, German and French) which have largest Wikipedias. [[User:Hégésippe Cormier|Hégésippe]] | [[User talk:Hégésippe Cormier|±Θ±]] 08:54, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
* {{Support}} This project looks like exciting and ''crazy''. Très intéressé par l'aventure. [[User:Jpm2112|Jpm2112]] 06:36, 18 August 2006 (UTC)
==== Oppose ====

=== Portuguese Wikiversity ===

==== Support ====
#[[User:Slade|Slade]] <sup>[[pt:Usuário:Slade|pt.wp]]</sup> 18:02, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
#[[User:Lightningspirit|Lightningspirit]] <sup>[[pt:Usuário:Lightningspirit|pt.wp]]</sup> 21:02, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
# [[User:FML|FML]] 01:12, 17 August 2006 (UTC)
#[[User:Roberth|Roberth]] 13:24, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

==== Oppose ====
#[[User:555|555]] 21:14, 16 August 2006 (UTC) Please, wait to beta.wikiversity.org is turned online.
#:I am personnally against the beta wikiversity, as Wikibooks seems to be doing almost everything that the "beta" wikiversity claims to be set up for, and what Wikibooks can't do, the Incubator Wiki supposedly can do the same as well. The Portuguese Wikiversity is currently hosted on pt.wikibooks at the moment, as there is some content development there. I don't know if I would encourage other language Wikibooks projects to start a new Wikiversity today given the semi-official (in beta) sister project status of Wikiversity, but I would like to see the beta proposal explained a bit more before it is turned on. --[[User:Roberth|Roberth]] 13:24, 17 August 2006 (UTC) (P.S. Don't turn my comment into a vote against. I'm actually in support of a pt.wikiversity! --[[User:Roberth|Roberth]] 21:51, 18 August 2006 (UTC))

=== Italian Wikiversity ===

==== Support ====

==== Oppose ====

=== Serbian Wikiversity ===

==== Support ====

==== Oppose ====
* '''Oppose''', for now. Let's get Wikiversities for more commonly spoken languages firmly established first. --[[User:Gray Porpoise|Gray Porpoise]] 16:00, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

=== Japanese Wikiversity ===

==== Support ====

==== Oppose ====

=== Polish Wikiversity ===

==== Support ====
* --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 02:03, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
* --[[User:Steel archer|Steel archer]] 16:22, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
==== Oppose ====

=== Finnish Wikiversity ===

==== Support ====


==== Oppose ====
=== Approved ===
{| class="wikitable sortable collapsible expanded"
|+Closed requests
|-
!scope="col"| Project
!scope="col"| Official status
!scope="col"| Status since
!scope="col"| Official request
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Bashkir | reopened | 2017-08-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Limburgish | created | 2010-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Shan | created | 2023-01-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Albanian | created | 2011-03-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Czech | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Dutch | reopened | 2017-07-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Esperanto | created | 2010-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Finnish | created | 2007-11-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Greek | created | 2011-03-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Gungbe | created | 2023-04-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Hungarian | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Korean | created | 2010-07-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Limburgish | created | 2018-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Persian | created | 2010-10-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Turkish | created | 2009-08-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Acehnese | created | 2009-08-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Adyghe | created | 2016-02-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Amis | created | 2021-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Angika | created | 2023-03-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Atayal | created | 2021-03-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Atikamekw | created | 2017-06-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Awadhi | created | 2020-04-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Balinese 3 | created | 2019-10-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Banjar | created | 2010-10-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Banyumasan | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bavarian | created | 2007-01-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Belarusian normative | created | 2007-03-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Betawi | approved | 2024-02-18 | T357866}}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bikol | created | 2007-11-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bishnupriya Manipuri | created | 2007-01-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Buginese | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Buryat | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Cantonese 2 | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Cebuano | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Chavacano | created | 2007-01-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Crimean Tatar 2 | created | 2008-01-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dagaare | created | 2023-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dagbani | created | 2021-06-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dinka | created | 2017-07-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Doteli | created | 2017-04-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Egyptian Arabic | created | 2008-11-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Emiliano-Romagnolo | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Erzya 3 | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Extremaduran | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Fante | created | 2023-04-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Fiji Hindi | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Fon | created | 2023-10-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Franco-Provençal | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Friulian | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gagauz 2 | created | 2010-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gan | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ghanaian Pidgin | created | 2023-07-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Goan Konkani | created | 2015-06-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gorontalo | created | 2018-04-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gothic | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Guianan Creole | created | 2019-11-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gungbe | created | 2022-03-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gurenɛ | created | 2023-02-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hakka 2 | created | 2007-05-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hill Mari | created | 2010-10-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Igala | approved | 2024-04-02 | T361644 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ilokano | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Inari Sami 2 | created | 2020-10-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ingush | created | 2018-04-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Jamaican | created | 2016-05-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kabardian | created | 2011-03-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kabiye | created | 2017-06-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kabyle | created | 2007-05-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kalmyk | created | 2006-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kapampangan | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Karachay-Balkar | created | 2010-03-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Karakalpak 3 | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kari Seediq | created | 2021-03-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Komi-Permyak 2 | created | 2010-10-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kotava | created | 2020-07-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kurdish (Sorani) | created | 2009-08-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kusaal | approved | 2024-03-10 | T359757 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ladin | created | 2020-08-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ladino | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Lak | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Latgalian 3 | created | 2011-02-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Lezgi | created | 2012-03-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ligurian | created | 2006-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Lingua Franca Nova 2 | created | 2018-04-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Livvi-Karelian | created | 2016-09-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Lombard | created | 2006-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Lower Sorbian 2 | created | 2008-01-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Madurese 2 | created | 2020-12-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Maithili | created | 2014-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mazandarani | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Meadow Mari | created | 2009-07-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Meitei | created | 2021-02-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Minangkabau | created | 2013-02-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mingrelian | created | 2011-07-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mirandese | created | 2009-08-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Moksha | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mon | created | 2019-11-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Moroccan | created | 2020-07-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Moroccan Amazigh | created | 2023-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Neapolitan | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nepal Bhasa | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nias | created | 2021-01-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nigerian Pidgin | created | 2022-08-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia N'Ko | created | 2019-09-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Norfuk | created | 2006-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Norman | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Northern Luri | created | 2015-06-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia North Frisian 3 | created | 2010-08-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Novial | created | 2006-12-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Old Church Slavonic | created | 2007-01-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Old English | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ossetian | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pa'O | created | 2022-07-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Paiwan | created | 2021-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Palatinate German 2 | created | 2010-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pangasinan | created | 2007-01-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Papiamentu | created | 2007-01-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pennsylvania German | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Picard | created | 2009-12-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Piedmontese | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pontic | created | 2009-03-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ripuarian | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Rusyn | created | 2011-01-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sakha | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Samogitian | created | 2006-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Santali | created | 2018-08-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Saraiki | created | 2020-12-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Saterland Frisian | created | 2008-01-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sakizaya | created | 2019-11-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Scots | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sepedi | created | 2011-10-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Serbo-Croatian | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Shan | created | 2018-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Silesian | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia South Azerbaijani | created | 2015-07-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Southern Altai | created | 2021-02-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sranan Tongo 2 | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tachelhit | created | 2021-06-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Talysh | created | 2023-08-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tarantino | created | 2007-01-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tatar | created | 2011-01-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tetum | created | 2006-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Toba Batak | created | 2023-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tulu | created | 2016-08-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tuvan | created | 2013-08-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tyap | created | 2022-05-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Udmurt | created | 2006-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Upper Sorbian | created | 2006-12-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Venetian | created | 2006-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Veps 2 | created | 2012-02-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Vlax Romany | created | 2006-12-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Võro | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Waray-Waray | created | 2006-12-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Wayuu | created | 2023-02-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia West Flemish | created | 2006-12-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Western Armenian | created | 2019-04-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Western Panjabi | created | 2009-08-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Wu | created | 2006-12-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Zazaki | created | 2007-01-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Zeelandic | created | 2007-01-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Assamese | created | 2023-01-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Banjar | created | 2023-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Bengali | created | 2022-10-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Breton | created | 2007-11-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Central Bikol | created | 2022-10-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Gungbe | created | 2023-01-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Limburgish | created | 2007-11-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Sanskrit | created | 2013-02-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Sakha | created | 2018-06-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Tagalog | created | 2022-10-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Igbo | created | 2022-10-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Armenian | created | 2007-11-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Assamese | created | 2013-01-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Balinese | created | 2021-06-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Basque | created | 2018-04-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Belarusian 2 | created | 2012-03-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Bengali 2 | created | 2007-09-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Breton | created | 2010-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Burmese | approved | 2024-03-27 | T361085 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Eastern Punjabi | created | 2017-04-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Esperanto | created | 2010-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Georgian | approved | 2024-04-22 | T363085 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Gujarati | created | 2012-03-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Hindi | created | 2019-10-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Javanese | created | 2021-08-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Ligurian | created | 2020-07-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Limburgish | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Malay | approved | 2024-04-20 | T363039 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Marathi | created | 2012-02-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Neapolitan | created | 2019-08-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Oriya | created | 2014-10-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Piedmontese | created | 2018-06-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Sakha | created | 2011-02-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Sanskrit | created | 2011-02-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Sundanese | created | 2023-08-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Tamil | created | 2007-05-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Venetian | created | 2010-11-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Walloon | created | 2020-12-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Arabic | created | 2011-07-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Chinese | created | 2018-08-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Czech | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Finnish 2 | created | 2009-04-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Greek | created | 2008-01-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Hindi | created | 2017-08-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Italian 2 | created | 2007-05-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Japanese 2 | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Korean | created | 2013-02-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Portuguese | created | 2008-05-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Russian 2 | created | 2009-11-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Slovene | created | 2012-03-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Swedish 2 | created | 2010-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Bengali | created | 2018-06-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Chinese | created | 2014-01-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Esperanto | created | 2020-12-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Finnish | created | 2016-12-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Greek | created | 2013-05-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Hebrew | created | 2013-03-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Hindi | created | 2017-09-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Japanese | created | 2020-08-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Spanish | created | 2013-01-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Pashto | created | 2018-06-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Persian | created | 2014-10-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Portuguese | created | 2013-01-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Polish | created | 2013-02-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Romanian | created | 2013-02-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Shan | created | 2022-03-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Turkish | created | 2021-01-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Ukrainian | created | 2013-03-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Vietnamese | created | 2013-08-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Bikol | created | 2021-01-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Cantonese | created | 2018-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Central Kurdish | created | 2023-03-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Fiji Hindi | created | 2017-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Gorontalo | created | 2023-01-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Gungbe | created | 2022-08-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Kabardian | created | 2023-04-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Karakalpak | approved | 2024-04-09 | T362135 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Konkani | created | 2020-04-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Lombard | created | 2021-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Mandailing | created | 2023-07-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Meitei | created | 2021-02-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Mon | created | 2021-03-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Minangkabau | created | 2019-11-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Nias | created | 2021-01-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Oriya | reopened | 2011-09-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Pa'O | created | 2023-08-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Saraiki | created | 2020-12-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Shan | created | 2020-06-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Tacawit | created | 2019-11-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Tyap | created | 2023-04-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Upper Sorbian | created | 2007-09-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Venetian | created | 2013-05-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Western Panjabi | created | 2012-02-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Zazaki 2 | created | 2021-01-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Banjar | created | 2022-08-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Igbo | created | 2022-10-10 }}
|}


=== Ukrainian Wikiversity ===
=== Rejected ===
{| class="wikitable sortable collapsible expanded"
|+Closed requests
|-
!scope="col"| Project
!scope="col"| Official status
!scope="col"| Status since
!scope="col"| Official request
{{lc-row| Old Wikipedia | rejected | 2012-03-03 }}
{{lc-row| MediaWiki Russian | rejected | 2009-01-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Classical Chinese | rejected | 2010-02-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Greenlandic | rejected | 2007-07-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Laki | rejected | 2019-12-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Lojban | rejected | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Meitei | rejected | 2019-11-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Multilingual | rejected | 2010-03-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Multilingual 2 | rejected | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Rajasthani | rejected | 2017-12-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Riograndenser Hunsrückisch | rejected | 2018-05-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Simple English | rejected | 2018-09-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikibooks Sindhi | rejected | 2007-04-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikijunior Hungarian | rejected | 2011-02-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikijunior Sindhi | rejected | 2006-11-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Hausa | rejected | 2019-11-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Irish | rejected | 2018-12-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Kazakh | rejected | 2018-12-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Latina | rejected | 2008-11-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Literary Chinese | rejected | 2019-10-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Meitei | rejected | 2019-11-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews multilingual | rejected | 2010-03-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Old English | rejected | 2019-10-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Riograndenser Hunsrückisch | rejected | 2018-05-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Simple English | rejected | 2008-02-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Simple English 2 | rejected | 2009-02-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikinews Sindhi | rejected | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Aeres | rejected | 2007-08-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ahe | rejected | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Albanskiy | rejected | 2017-01-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Aldorian | rejected | 2022-12-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Algero-Moroccan Arabic | rejected | 2007-04-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Alkaxus | rejected | 2012-08-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia American Norwegian | rejected | 2019-11-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ancient Greek 2 | rejected | 2008-02-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ancient Greek 3 | rejected | 2008-09-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ancient Hebrew | rejected | 2010-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Anglish | rejected | 2014-02-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Anglo-Norman | rejected | 2014-01-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Antwerpish | rejected | 2010-03-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Appalachian English | rejected | 2014-02-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Aramaic of Jesus | rejected | 2010-03-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Arwi | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Australian English | rejected | 2012-12-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Avestan 2 | rejected | 2017-02-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Badini Kurdish | rejected | 2021-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bahrani Arabic | rejected | 2018-07-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Base Ganu | rejected | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Baybayin Tagalog 2 | rejected | 2011-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Berber | rejected | 2009-09-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bhili | rejected | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Blacksea Turkısh | rejected | 2009-10-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bofonisk | rejected | 2017-01-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bosanski Simple | rejected | 2019-11-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Boso Kalongan | rejected | 2018-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Braille | rejected | 2017-01-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Brazilian Portuguese 2 | rejected | 2010-01-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Brazilian Portuguese 3 | rejected | 2010-03-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Brazilian Portuguese 4 | rejected | 2017-01-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia British English | rejected | 2008-09-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Buhid | rejected | 2018-07-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bulu | rejected | 2007-07-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Bungo | rejected | 2008-02-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Chianino | rejected | 2021-06-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Chamyuet | rejected | 2017-02-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Chinese (Pinyin) 2 | rejected | 2018-09-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Church Slavonic | rejected | 2008-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Classical Japanese 2 | rejected | 2008-02-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Classical Mongolian | rejected | 2022-07-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Classical Tagalog | rejected | 2009-09-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Cocopa | rejected | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Colloquial Cantonese | rejected | 2018-04-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Common Czech | rejected | 2008-09-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Cora | rejected | 2018-07-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Coptic 2 | rejected | 2008-01-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Creole Spanish | rejected | 2017-01-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Cypriot Greek | rejected | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Cyrillic Azerbaijani | rejected | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Cyrillic English | rejected | 2013-08-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Cyrillic Polish | rejected | 2008-06-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dalmatian | rejected | 2009-01-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dalmatian 2 | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Dari | rejected | 2012-11-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Daylami | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Drents | rejected | 2008-05-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Early Middle English (EMe) | rejected | 2013-11-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia East Frisian Low Saxon | rejected | 2018-06-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Egyptian | rejected | 2018-01-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Elfdalian | rejected | 2007-10-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Elven | rejected | 2007-10-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Emoji | rejected | 2021-05-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Empherian | rejected | 2017-12-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Enets | rejected | 2018-07-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia English Braille | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia English-Nepali | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Etruscan | rejected | 2018-10-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Eurofarsi | rejected | 2007-05-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia European Portuguese | rejected | 2007-04-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia European Portuguese 2 | rejected | 2010-02-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia European Portuguese 3 | rejected | 2017-01-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Evenki | rejected | 2008-12-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Frainc-comtou | rejected | 2017-03-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia French Simple | rejected | 2008-02-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ga | rejected | 2019-11-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Galego-AGAL | rejected | 2008-04-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Galician-Portuguese | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gondi | rejected | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gorkha | rejected | 2012-07-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Gronings | rejected | 2018-06-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hainanese | rejected | 2009-10-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hanja | rejected | 2008-04-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hanja 2 | rejected | 2021-03-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hantec | rejected | 2007-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hawaiian Pidgin | rejected | 2018-08-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hazaragi | rejected | 2017-12-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia High Norwegian | rejected | 2008-01-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hinglish | rejected | 2022-12-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Homshetsma | rejected | 2018-01-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Huichol | rejected | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Hunnic | rejected | 2016-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Illyrian | rejected | 2016-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Indonesian-Arabic Script | rejected | 2018-04-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Insubric | rejected | 2007-06-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Iranian Persian | rejected | 2010-10-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Irish | rejected | 2012-11-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Istriot | rejected | 2018-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Itawis | rejected | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Jamese | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Jassic | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Jawi | rejected | 2018-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Jeju | rejected | 2008-02-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Jewish Babylonian Aramaic | rejected | 2018-08-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kaikavian | rejected | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kamassian | rejected | 2020-12-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Karakalpak 2 | rejected | 2007-04-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Khandeshi | rejected | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kumaoni | rejected | 2018-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kunwinjku | rejected | 2019-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kupang Malay | rejected | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kurmanji | rejected | 2010-03-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kurukh | rejected | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Kwasio | rejected | 2018-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Latgalian 2 | rejected | 2007-10-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Latin (non-Vatican) | rejected | 2018-03-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia latinized Belorussian | rejected | 2021-07-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Latinized Kyrgyz | rejected | 2022-09-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Latinized Russian | rejected | 2007-08-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Leet(1337) | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Leonese | rejected | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Libyan Arabic | rejected | 2018-03-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Lingua Franca Nova | rejected | 2008-11-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Lisarbin | rejected | 2008-04-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Lishan Didan | rejected | 2019-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Llanito | rejected | 2009-07-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Lohorung | rejected | 2019-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Luba-Lulua | rejected | 2019-07-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Maasai | rejected | 2019-04-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Magar | rejected | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mandarin | rejected | 2009-01-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mandarin Chinese | rejected | 2010-02-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mandika | rejected | 2007-07-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Maranao | rejected | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Masovian | rejected | 2018-04-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mesopotamian Arabic | rejected | 2019-09-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Middle Dutch | rejected | 2008-09-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Middle English 2 | rejected | 2010-07-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Middle English 3 | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Middle English 4 | rejected | 2021-05-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Middle English 5 | rejected | 2022-06-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Middle Irish | rejected | 2018-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Modern English | rejected | 2010-07-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Modern Etruscan | rejected | 2009-09-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Moldavian-Romanian | rejected | 2008-05-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Moldovan Cyrillic | rejected | 2009-10-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Montenegrin | rejected | 2006-11-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Montenegrin 2 | rejected | 2007-04-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Montenegrin 3 | rejected | 2010-12-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Montenegrin 4 | rejected | 2011-05-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Morlakian | rejected | 2010-03-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Morse Code | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Muisca | rejected | 2010-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Multilingual | rejected | 2012-09-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mundang | rejected | 2018-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mundari | rejected | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Mycenaen Greek | rejected | 2011-04-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Namtrik | rejected | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Narom | rejected | 2019-01-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ngomba | rejected | 2018-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nones | rejected | 2019-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Norsk (bokmål) | rejected | 2011-08-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nord | rejected | 2007-12-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Norn | rejected | 2008-02-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Northern Bohemian | rejected | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Northern Wuu | rejected | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Northumbrian | rejected | 2019-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Northwest African Arabic | rejected | 2018-03-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Nûlaeg | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Old Devonian | rejected | 2009-09-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Old Georgian | rejected | 2009-01-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Old High German | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Old Norse 2 | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Old Persian | rejected | 2009-09-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Old Prussian | rejected | 2016-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Old Romanian | rejected | 2016-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Old Russian | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Old Saxon | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Old Tupi | rejected | 2022-12-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ottoman Turkish 2 | rejected | 2008-01-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ottoman Turkish 3 | rejected | 2010-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ottoman Turkish 4 | rejected | 2018-10-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pa-prostu | rejected | 2008-04-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pahlavi | rejected | 2018-10-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pali Character Thai | rejected | 2010-03-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pandan Bikol | rejected | 2018-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pannonian Rusyn | rejected | 2008-11-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Papuan Malay | rejected | 2019-05-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pax̌to | rejected | 2018-04-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Persian (in Latinized alphabet) | rejected | 2020-07-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Phoenician 2 | rejected | 2007-04-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pizzonese | rejected | 2008-10-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Polesian | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Prekmurian | rejected | 2017-07-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Pre-reform Russian | rejected | 2007-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Proto-Germanic | rejected | 2016-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Proto-Indo-European 3 | rejected | 2016-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Prussian | rejected | 2008-01-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Punjabi | rejected | 2019-12-18 | title = Wikipedia Punjabi (Romanized) }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Quenya | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Quiché | rejected | 2007-04-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Radical Croatian | rejected | 2009-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Resian | rejected | 2019-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Romanized Khowar | rejected | 2018-07-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Romanized Pashto | rejected | 2018-04-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Romanized Persian | rejected | 2018-06-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia ROT13 | rejected | 2007-03-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ruhrdeutsch | rejected | 2008-03-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Samoic Tongan | rejected | 2008-10-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Savoyâ | rejected | 2020-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Scanian | rejected | 2010-03-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Serbian-Macedonian | rejected | 2012-09-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Set English | rejected | 2007-03-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Shakhordoy | rejected | 2008-01-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Shanghainese | rejected | 2023-03-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Shawiya | rejected | 2019-11-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sherpa | rejected | 2018-08-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Shumerian | rejected | 2021-07-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sichuanese Mandarin | rejected | 2017-03-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Simple Chinese | rejected | 2018-08-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Simple Chinese 2 | rejected | 2018-10-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Simple German 2 | rejected | 2008-08-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Simple German 3 | rejected | 2010-06-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Simple German 4 | rejected | 2018-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Simple Hebrew | rejected | 2018-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Simple Latin | rejected | 2019-11-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Simple Spanish 3 | rejected | 2008-10-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Simple Spanish 4 | rejected | 2022-12-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sindarin | rejected | 2008-11-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sindarin 2 | rejected | 2022-09-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sindhi | rejected | 2018-12-04 | title = Wikipedia Sindhi (in Devanagari) }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sonsorol | rejected | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia South Korean | rejected | 2007-06-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia South Levantine Arabic | rejected | 2008-11-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Southern Min written with Hanji | rejected | 2018-01-30 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Southern Uzbek | rejected | 2019-11-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Standard Zazaki | rejected | 2008-10-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Standard Zazaki 2 | rejected | 2013-03-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sudanese Arabic | rejected | 2009-10-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Sunuwari | rejected | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Suomen puhekieli | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Basa Surabayaan | rejected | 2021-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Surzhyk 2 | rejected | 2007-04-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Swabian | rejected | 2018-01-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Swiss German | rejected | 2011-02-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Swiss Italian | rejected | 2019-09-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tabasaran | rejected | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Taiwanese Hokkien | rejected | 2013-07-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tamazight | rejected | 2009-09-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia TanaChugah | rejected | 2016-11-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tày-Nùng | rejected | 2019-06-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tegal | rejected | 2019-06-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Test3 | rejected | 2012-09-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Teochew | rejected | 2018-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Thao | rejected | 2018-10-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Toki Pona | rejected | 2017-03-18 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Traditional Chinese | rejected | 2010-06-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Traditional Greek | rejected | 2007-04-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Traditional Russian | rejected | 2020-12-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Triestino | rejected | 2019-06-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tsukurian | rejected | 2013-02-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tundra Yukaghir | rejected | 2021-07-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Turkmen yomut | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Tuscan | rejected | 2008-02-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ukrainian-old | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Ukrainian Latin | rejected | 2008-03-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Unserdeutsch 2 | rejected | 2018-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Usprenta | rejected | 2008-02-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Valencià | rejected | 2011-04-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Valenciano | rejected | 2018-07-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Varello | rejected | 2013-02-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Vegliot Dalmatian | rejected | 2009-07-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Veps | rejected | 2008-12-20 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Vestgjøtska | rejected | 2008-01-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Viejšnoryjan | rejected | 2018-06-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Vorarlbergerisch | rejected | 2018-06-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Vulgar Latin | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Värmlandic | rejected | 2007-06-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Värmlandic 2 | rejected | 2008-01-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Värmlandic 3 | rejected | 2008-03-05 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Warmian | rejected | 2011-06-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia West Frisian | rejected | 2007-10-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia West Frisian (creole) | rejected | 2007-08-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Zaparoan | rejected | 2009-10-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wikipedia Zygiligleth | rejected | 2017-01-29 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Baybayin Tagalog | rejected | 2011-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Kashubian | rejected | 2018-02-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Latvian | rejected | 2018-12-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Lingála | rejected | 2019-06-13 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Multilingual | rejected | 2018-04-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Riograndenser Hunsrückisch | rejected | 2018-05-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Simple English | rejected | 2018-04-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiquote Syriac | rejected | 2018-05-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Baybayin Tagalog 2 | rejected | 2011-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Belorussian | rejected | 2007-06-15 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Bengali | rejected | 2007-04-09 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Classical Chinese | rejected | 2010-03-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Classical Tagalog | rejected | 2009-09-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Middle Dutch | rejected | 2008-05-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource No linguistic content | rejected | 2011-04-01 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Old Norwegian | rejected | 2017-04-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Old Saxon | rejected | 2018-12-04 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Ottoman Turkish | rejected | 2011-06-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wikisource Wawa | rejected | 2018-02-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikispecies Greek | rejected | 2016-09-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikispecies Macedonian | rejected | 2008-05-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wikispecies Simple English | rejected | 2007-11-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Burmese | rejected | 2018-11-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Indonesian | rejected | 2018-11-21 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Simple English | rejected | 2018-09-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Sinhala | rejected | 2018-05-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Swedish | rejected | 2010-11-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Tajik | rejected | 2018-09-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Tamil | rejected | 2018-05-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikiversity Ukrainian-old | rejected | 2013-03-31 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Egyptian Arabic | rejected | 2019-06-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Gilaki | rejected | 2019-10-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Kazakh | rejected | 2018-12-24 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Kurdish | rejected | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Norwegian | rejected | 2019-11-12 }}<!--see request page. Rejected because content was not in Norwegian-->
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Simple English | rejected | 2018-09-26 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Tarifit | rejected | 2018-12-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wikivoyage Zeelandic | rejected | 2019-12-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Andalusian | rejected | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Aramaic | rejected | 2010-12-07 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Aranadan | rejected | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Baybayin Tagalog | rejected | 2011-03-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Buryat | rejected | 2018-05-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Chakma | rejected | 2019-07-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Chinese Hong Kong | rejected | 2019-01-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Classical Chinese | rejected | 2010-03-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Etruscan | rejected | 2019-09-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Flemish | rejected | 2018-07-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Hindustani | rejected | 2018-05-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Hong Kong Sign Language | rejected | 2019-07-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Jassic | rejected | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Khasi | rejected | 2018-09-28 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Klingon | rejected | 2013-11-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Lingwa de Planeta | rejected | 2017-03-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Lohorung | rejected | 2019-07-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Lugbara | rejected | 2018-05-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Malvi | rejected | 2018-05-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Mbya Guarani | rejected | 2019-01-08 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Melanau | rejected | 2018-02-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Muisca | rejected | 2008-11-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary multilingual | rejected | 2010-03-03 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Multimedia | rejected | 2021-05-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Newspeak | rejected | 2007-05-11 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Nogai | rejected | 2018-02-23 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary North Levantine Arabic | rejected | 2019-01-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Northern Luri | rejected | 2019-01-25 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Pali | rejected | 2018-11-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Pitcairnese | rejected | 2018-02-06 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Polabian | rejected | 2018-07-10 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Riffian | rejected | 2019-09-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Riograndenser Hunsrückisch | rejected | 2018-05-02 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Seychellois Creole | rejected | 2019-06-14 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Slovincian | rejected | 2017-11-17 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Sri Lanka Malay | rejected | 2018-03-19 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Syriac | rejected | 2018-05-22 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Värmlandic | rejected | 2008-02-16 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Wixarika | rejected | 2019-12-12 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Yerkish | rejected | 2009-09-27 }}
{{lc-row| Wiktionary Zazaki | rejected | 2007-07-14 }}
|}


==== Support ====
== See also ==
* [[:Category:Old requests for new languages]]
* --[[User:Yaroslav Zolotaryov|Yaroslav Zolotaryov]] 02:03, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
* --[[User:Steel archer|Steel archer]] 16:22, 16 August 2006 (UTC)
:: А чи буде в ній хтось працювати. В нас вже є напівживий Вікіпідручник і напівмертві Вікіновини. Боюсь, що цей проект може бути мертвонародженим. --[[User:Yakudza|Yakudza]] 08:05, 18 August 2006 (UTC)


{{RF}}
==== Oppose ====

Latest revision as of 11:40, 13 May 2024

Shortcut:
RFL
This page lists requests for new language wikis of existing projects (to start an entirely new project, see requests for new projects). All requests must conform to the Language proposal policy (see instructions for adding a new request).
Language committee
Language committee
Language committee
For requesting users
For members
Information
Closing projects (voluntarily)
This box: view · talk · edit

Open requests

See also the related edit logs: open, on hold, verified as eligible.

Wikibooks

Wikibooks requests
Project Official status Status since Notes
Wikibooks Ancash Quechua   Verified as eligible 14-Sep-2018
Wikibooks Assamese   Verified as eligible 18-Dec-2019
Wikibooks Badaga   Verified as eligible 19-Nov-2009
Wikibooks Burmese   Verified as eligible 06-Jun-2019
Wikibooks Cantonese   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017
Wikibooks Cebuano 2   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017
Wikibooks Central Bikol   Verified as eligible 04-Oct-2022
Wikibooks Dusun   Verified as eligible 13-Feb-2018
Wikibooks Gilaki   Verified as eligible 14-Jan-2008
Wikibooks Gujarati   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017
Wikibooks Hausa   Discussion 20-Jul-2023
Wikibooks Interlingue   Discussion 14-Apr-2023
Wikibooks Javanese 2   Verified as eligible 17-May-2007
Wikibooks Ladino   Verified as eligible 07-Jan-2014
Wikibooks Latvian   Verified as eligible 25-Sep-2010
Wikibooks Min Dong Chinese   Verified as eligible 03-Aug-2021
Wikibooks Nias   Verified as eligible 08-Jun-2021
Wikibooks Pashto   Verified as eligible 24-Dec-2017
Wikibooks Saraiki   Verified as eligible 06-Jun-2019
Wikibooks Sindhi 2   Verified as eligible 14-Nov-2017
Wikibooks Sylheti   Discussion 15-Nov-2022
Wikibooks Talysh   Verified as eligible 04-Oct-2022
Wikibooks Zazaki   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017

Wikinews

Wikinews requests
Project Official status Status since Notes
Wikinews Afrikaans   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017
Wikinews Amharic   Verified as eligible 25-May-2008
Wikinews Armenian   Verified as eligible 25-Dec-2012
Wikinews Assamese   Verified as eligible 04-Oct-2022
Wikinews Azerbaijani   Verified as eligible 30-Mar-2011
Wikinews Basic English   Discussion 03-Feb-2024
Wikinews Basque   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikinews Belarusian   Verified as eligible 25-Jan-2019
Wikinews Bengali   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017
Wikinews Cantonese 2   Verified as eligible 28-Feb-2010
Wikinews Croatian   Verified as eligible 30-Mar-2011
Wikinews Danish   Verified as eligible 30-Jul-2010
Wikinews Dusun   Verified as eligible 13-Feb-2018
Wikinews Galego   Verified as eligible 15-Aug-2011
Wikinews Georgian   Verified as eligible 05-Nov-2008
Wikinews Gilaki   Verified as eligible 14-Jan-2008
Wikinews Hindi   Verified as eligible 22-Apr-2008
Wikinews Indonesian   Verified as eligible 27-Mar-2010
Wikinews Javanese   Verified as eligible 24-Apr-2008
Wikinews Kazakh 2   Discussion 11-Mar-2023
Wikinews Khowar   Verified as eligible 06-Dec-2017
Wikinews Kurdish   Verified as eligible 05-Mar-2010
Wikinews Kurdish (Sorani)   Verified as eligible 13-Feb-2018
Wikinews Kupang Malay   Discussion 22-Aug-2020
Wikinews Ladino   Verified as eligible 04-Oct-2022
Wikinews Lithuanian   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikinews Low Saxon   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikinews Macedonian   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017
Wikinews Malagasy   Verified as eligible 17-Feb-2009
Wikinews Malay   Verified as eligible 25-Aug-2008
Wikinews Malayalam   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017
Wikinews Marathi   Verified as eligible 21-Feb-2017
Wikinews Min Dong Chinese   Verified as eligible 16-Sep-2018
Wikinews Nepali   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017
Wikinews Pashto   Verified as eligible 14-Sep-2018
Wikinews Pipil   Verified as eligible 04-Dec-2018
Wikinews Pu-Xian Min   Verified as eligible 06-Jun-2019
Wikinews Saraiki   Verified as eligible 06-Jun-2019
Wikinews Shan   Verified as eligible 04-Oct-2022
Wikinews Sicilian   Verified as eligible 12-Nov-2008
Wikinews Sinhala   Verified as eligible 14-Dec-2010
Wikinews Slovak   Discussion 22-Jun-2023
Wikinews Slovene   Verified as eligible 10-May-2008
Wikinews Sylheti   Verified as eligible 04-Oct-2022
Wikinews Tagalog   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikinews Tatar   Verified as eligible 04-Oct-2022
Wikinews Thai   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017
Wikinews Tswana   Verified as eligible 04-Oct-2022
Wikinews Urdu   Verified as eligible 27-Jan-2009
Wikinews Uyghur   Verified as eligible 19-Feb-2010
Wikinews Vietnamese   Verified as eligible 08-Apr-2011
Wikinews Western Panjabi   Verified as eligible 13-Feb-2018
Wikinews Zazaki   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017

Wikipedia

Wikipedia requests
Project Official status Status since Notes
Wikipedia ǃXóõ   On hold 06-Mar-2023
Wikipedia Achomi   Discussion 13-Jun-2020
Wikipedia Acoli   Discussion 23-Jun-2020
Wikipedia Adilabad Gondi   Discussion 20-Apr-2023
Wikipedia Aghem   Verified as eligible 21-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Ahirani   Verified as eligible 20-Dec-2011
Wikipedia Ainu 2   Verified as eligible 27-Jul-2018
Wikipedia Akkadian   Discussion 07-Apr-2024
Wikipedia Aklanon   Verified as eligible 21-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Akoose   Verified as eligible 16-May-2012
Wikipedia Akpa   Discussion 15-Mar-2021
Wikipedia Alabama   Verified as eligible 28-Sep-2008
Wikipedia American Sign Language 2   Verified as eligible 29-Nov-2008
Wikipedia Ancash Quechua   Verified as eligible 26-Feb-2018
Wikipedia Ancient Greek 4   Discussion 13-Apr-2013
Wikipedia Angolar Creole   Discussion 20-Mar-2024
Wikipedia Angkola   Discussion 26-Mar-2021
Wikipedia Ao   Verified as eligible 21-Apr-2007
Wikipedia Arakan   Verified as eligible 15-Oct-2022
Wikipedia Arbëresh   Discussion 25-Mar-2022
Wikipedia Asi   Verified as eligible 25-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Assyrian Neo Aramaic   Verified as eligible 06-Feb-2017
Wikipedia Badaga   Verified as eligible 19-Nov-2009
Wikipedia Bafia   Verified as eligible 07-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Bajjika   On hold 19-Jun-2023
Wikipedia Bakhtiari   Verified as eligible 08-Jun-2008
Wikipedia Balantak   Discussion 09-Aug-2020
Wikipedia Balkan Romani   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikipedia Balochi   Discussion 28-Jun-2010
Wikipedia Bangka   Verified as eligible 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Baniwa   Verified as eligible 25-Jun-2011
Wikipedia Baoulé   Verified as eligible 26-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Bari   Verified as eligible 26-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Basaa   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Belgorod Dialect   Discussion 15-Jan-2023
Wikipedia Bodo   Verified as eligible 26-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Bole   Discussion 04-Nov-2023
Wikipedia Bororo   Discussion 03-Dec-2022
Wikipedia Brahui   Verified as eligible 17-Apr-2010
Wikipedia Brazilian Sign Language   Verified as eligible 24-Oct-2018
Wikipedia British Sign Language   Verified as eligible 04-Nov-2010
Wikipedia Buhinon   Discussion 14-Aug-2023
Wikipedia Bunun   Verified as eligible 23-Apr-2019
Wikipedia Cajun French   Verified as eligible 21-Jul-2007
Wikipedia Caló   Discussion 14-Jun-2023
Wikipedia Campidanese Sardinian   Verified as eligible 19-Mar-2017
Wikipedia Canadian French   Discussion 02-Feb-2020
Wikipedia Cape Verdean Creole   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Capiznon   Verified as eligible 24-Jan-2010
Wikipedia Caribbean Hindustani   Verified as eligible 26-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Carpathian Romani   Discussion 27-Nov-2020
Wikipedia Central Alaskan Yup'ik   Verified as eligible 31-Aug-2010
Wikipedia Central Dusun   Verified as eligible 17-Jul-2011
Wikipedia Central Kanuri   Discussion 15-Jul-2023
Wikipedia Central Morocco Tamazight   Verified as eligible 21-Jul-2009
Wikipedia Central Tagbanwa   Discussion 16-Aug-2023
Wikipedia Chakma   Verified as eligible 21-Jun-2018
Wikipedia Chesterian   Discussion 02-Apr-2021
Wikipedia Chhattisgarhi   Verified as eligible 21-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Chinuk wawa   Verified as eligible 03-Feb-2018
Wikipedia Chitonga   Discussion 22-Jun-2023
Wikipedia Chittagonian   Verified as eligible 26-Dec-2022
Wikipedia Choctaw   Verified as eligible 21-Jun-2018
Wikipedia Chuj   Discussion 30-Sep-2022
Wikipedia Chukchi   Verified as eligible 23-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Classical Japanese 3   Discussion 10-Apr-2022
Wikipedia Coptic 3   Verified as eligible 29-Jul-2017
Wikipedia Damascene   Discussion 09-Nov-2023
Wikipedia Dangme   Discussion 18-Aug-2023
Wikipedia Dargwa   Verified as eligible 23-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Dendi   Verified as eligible 03-Apr-2023
Wikipedia Dholuo   Verified as eligible 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Dimasa   Verified as eligible 17-Dec-2018
Wikipedia Dobrujan Tatar   Discussion 18-Oct-2023
Wikipedia Dogri   Verified as eligible 12-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Duala   Verified as eligible 23-Jan-2017
Wikipedia East Franconian German   Verified as eligible 30-Oct-2013
Wikipedia East Frisian 3   Discussion 09-Feb-2020
Wikipedia Eastern Arrernte   Discussion 10-Jul-2021
Wikipedia Eastern Balochi   Discussion 10-Aug-2010
Wikipedia Eastern Bolivian Guaraní   Verified as eligible 20-Feb-2017
Wikipedia Eastern Pwo   Verified as eligible 30-Oct-2018
Wikipedia Efik   Verified as eligible 13-Jan-2023
Wikipedia Ekpeye   Discussion 13-May-2024
Wikipedia Eldeine   Discussion 25-Apr-2021
Wikipedia Elfdalian 2   Verified as eligible 20-Feb-2017
Wikipedia Eton   Verified as eligible 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Ewondo   Verified as eligible 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Fala   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2017
Wikipedia Falam-Chin   Verified as eligible 31-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Fataluku   Verified as eligible 25-Oct-2010
Wikipedia Finnish Sign Language   Verified as eligible 29-Nov-2008
Wikipedia French Simple 3   Verified as eligible 26-Sep-2018
Wikipedia Galo   Discussion 13-Oct-2020
Wikipedia Garhwali   Verified as eligible 23-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Gayo 2   Discussion 05-Jun-2020
Wikipedia Gęlþaska   Discussion 04-Dec-2023
Wikipedia Gheg   Verified as eligible 04-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Ghomala   Verified as eligible 23-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Ghomara   Discussion 12-Apr-2024
Wikipedia Goalpariya   Verified as eligible 07-Aug-2018
Wikipedia Guadeloupe Creole   Discussion 28-Apr-2023
Wikipedia Gutnish   Discussion 17-Jan-2016
Wikipedia Hadauti   Discussion 12-May-2023
Wikipedia Hainanese 2   On hold 11-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Hakha-Chin   Verified as eligible 29-Feb-2008
Wikipedia Hanja 3   Discussion 30-Oct-2022
Wikipedia Haryanvi   Verified as eligible 23-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Hassaniya   Discussion 26-Jan-2023
Wikipedia Hawrami   Verified as eligible 04-Nov-2010
Wikipedia Hijazi Arabic   Discussion 24-Feb-2016
Wikipedia Hiligaynon 2   Verified as eligible 12-Aug-2007
Wikipedia Hindko   Discussion 25-Feb-2022
Wikipedia Hindustani 3   Discussion 17-May-2013
Wikipedia Hla’alua   Verified as eligible 24-Oct-2018
Wikipedia Hmong Daw   Verified as eligible 22-Oct-2010
Wikipedia Ho   Discussion 02-Oct-2016
Wikipedia Hsilgne   Discussion 07-Dec-2023
Wikipedia Hutsul   Discussion 01-Oct-2016
Wikipedia Iban   Verified as eligible 19-Feb-2010
Wikipedia Ingrian   Verified as eligible 10-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Innu-aimun   Verified as eligible 18-Jul-2017
Wikipedia Interglossa   Discussion 12-Aug-2023
Wikipedia International Sign   Discussion 18-Nov-2023
Wikipedia Interslavic   Discussion 08-May-2024
Wikipedia Jambi Malay   Verified as eligible 27-Jun-2021
Wikipedia Jazayri   Verified as eligible 04-Jul-2009
Wikipedia Jeju 2   Verified as eligible 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Juǀ'hoan   On hold 25-Jan-2019
Wikipedia Jutish   Discussion 20-May-2016
Wikipedia Kaili   Discussion 15-Oct-2020
Wikipedia Kalanga   Discussion 15-Aug-2020
Wikipedia Kalasha   Discussion 30-Apr-2016
Wikipedia Kanakanavu   Verified as eligible 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Kanikkaran   Verified as eligible 25-Nov-2009
Wikipedia Kaqchikel   Verified as eligible 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Karai-Karai   Discussion 15-Aug-2023
Wikipedia Karaim   Discussion 22-Apr-2021
Wikipedia Karbi   Discussion 30-Aug-2016
Wikipedia Karelian 2   Verified as eligible 03-Apr-2008
Wikipedia Karuk   On hold 23-Apr-2019
Wikipedia Kavalan   Verified as eligible 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Keliko   Discussion 01-Nov-2023
Wikipedia Khakas   Verified as eligible 14-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Khasi   Verified as eligible 22-Oct-2010
Wikipedia Khinalug   Verified as eligible 16-Jul-2018
Wikipedia Khmu   Discussion 14-Jul-2021
Wikipedia Khorasani Turkic   Verified as eligible 11-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Khowar   Verified as eligible 20-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Kichwa   Verified as eligible 14-Dec-2017
Wikipedia Kildin Sami   Verified as eligible 02-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Kiluba   Discussion 30-Jul-2016
Wikipedia Kinaray-a 2   Verified as eligible 21-Apr-2007
Wikipedia Kirmanjki   Verified as eligible 30-Sep-2008
Wikipedia Kohistani Shina   Discussion 07-Dec-2022
Wikipedia Komering   Verified as eligible 21-Feb-2024
Wikipedia Koyraboro Senni Songhay   On hold 23-Apr-2019
Wikipedia Krio   Verified as eligible 05-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Kriol   Verified as eligible 18-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Krymchak   Discussion 03-Jan-2023
Wikipedia Kumyk   Verified as eligible 28-Oct-2017
Wikipedia Kupang Malay 2   Discussion 19-Jul-2020
Wikipedia Kutchi   Verified as eligible 02-Jan-2018
Wikipedia Kven 2   Verified as eligible 11-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Láadan   Discussion 28-Feb-2022
Wikipedia Laki   Verified as eligible 15-Feb-2013
Wikipedia Lakota   Verified as eligible 02-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Laz 2   Verified as eligible 27-Feb-2010
Wikipedia Levantine Arabic   Verified as eligible 03-Aug-2021
Wikipedia Libon Bikol   Discussion 14-Aug-2023
Wikipedia Limbu   Verified as eligible 14-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Livonian   Verified as eligible 17-Jul-2011
Wikipedia Logudorese Sardinian   Discussion 21-Mar-2022
Wikipedia Louisiana Creole   Discussion 12-Sep-2016
Wikipedia Lower Silesian   Verified as eligible 12-Aug-2008
Wikipedia Lushootseed   Discussion 22-Jan-2023
Wikipedia Magahi   Discussion 20-Jun-2021
Wikipedia Maghrebi Arabic   Discussion 30-May-2015
Wikipedia Maguindanaon   Discussion 12-Nov-2023
Wikipedia Makassar Malay   Discussion 06-Mar-2016
Wikipedia Makassarese   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Makhuwa   Discussion 04-Oct-2023
Wikipedia Mam   Verified as eligible 22-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Mampruli   Discussion 05-Mar-2023
Wikipedia Manado Malay   Discussion 15-Jun-2020
Wikipedia Manobo   Discussion 15-Sep-2020
Wikipedia Manchu 2   Verified as eligible 02-Jan-2018
Wikipedia Mandailing   Verified as eligible 10-Dec-2018
Wikipedia Mandar   On hold 11-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Mapudungun 2   Verified as eligible 04-Jul-2009
Wikipedia Mara   Discussion 08-Jul-2020
Wikipedia Marwari   Verified as eligible 09-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Marwari (Pakistan)   On hold 25-Jan-2019
Wikipedia Masbateño   Discussion 16-Aug-2023
Wikipedia Mauritian Creole   Verified as eligible 08-Sep-2008
Wikipedia Meänkieli 2   Verified as eligible 14-Jun-2010
Wikipedia Medumba   On hold 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Megleno-Romanian   Verified as eligible 27-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Mentawai   Verified as eligible 22-Feb-2008
Wikipedia Mesopotamian Arabic 2   Verified as eligible 16-Mar-2024
Wikipedia Michif   Discussion 14-Nov-2021
Wikipedia Micmac   Verified as eligible 16-Jul-2018
Wikipedia Minbei   Verified as eligible 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Miraya Bikol   Verified as eligible 11-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Mizo   Verified as eligible 02-Oct-2009
Wikipedia Mohawk   Verified as eligible 08-Dec-2017
Wikipedia Mongolian written in Mongolian script   Verified as eligible 01-Dec-2017
Wikipedia Mongondow   Discussion 07-Oct-2020
Wikipedia Montenegrin 5   On hold 18-Dec-2017
Wikipedia Mooré   Verified as eligible 11-Sep-2022
Wikipedia Muniche   Discussion 07-Mar-2024
Wikipedia Naandi   Discussion 27-Oct-2016
Wikipedia Nenets   Verified as eligible 14-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Nengone   Discussion 26-Nov-2016
Wikipedia Ngaju   Discussion 12-Mar-2023
Wikipedia Ngiemboon   Discussion 26-May-2016
Wikipedia Nheengatu   Verified as eligible 12-Apr-2008
Wikipedia Niuean   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikipedia Nogai   Verified as eligible 23-Feb-2018
Wikipedia North Ndebele   Verified as eligible 14-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Northeastern Thai   Verified as eligible 14-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Northern Altai   Verified as eligible 18-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Northern Thai   Verified as eligible 27-Feb-2010
Wikipedia Northern Tujia   Verified as eligible 19-Nov-2013
Wikipedia Northwestern Ojibwa   Discussion 27-Dec-2023
Wikipedia Nuer(Thok Nath)   Discussion 20-May-2023
Wikipedia Nuosu   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Nupe   Discussion 18-Dec-2023
Wikipedia Nyungar   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2017
Wikipedia Obolo   Verified as eligible 11-Sep-2019
Wikipedia Oi   Discussion 12-Jun-2016
Wikipedia Oji-Cree   Discussion 18-Feb-2024
Wikipedia Okanagan   Discussion 09-May-2023
Wikipedia Okinawan   Verified as eligible 27-Nov-2010
Wikipedia Orang Seletar   Verified as eligible 27-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Osing   Verified as eligible 25-Jan-2019
Wikipedia Ottoman Turkish 5   Discussion 13-Feb-2023
Wikipedia Pacha Malayalam   Discussion 10-Dec-2023
Wikipedia Palembang   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikipedia Pamona   Verified as eligible 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Pannonian Rusyn 2   Verified as eligible 07-Mar-2022
Wikipedia Pazeh   On hold 14-Jul-2020
Wikipedia Pemon   Verified as eligible 27-Feb-2010
Wikipedia Petjo   Discussion 30-Jan-2024
Wikipedia Pipil   Verified as eligible 16-Jan-2018
Wikipedia Pitjantjatjara   Discussion 19-Jun-2021
Wikipedia Plautdietsch   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikipedia Pökoot   Verified as eligible 28-Aug-2007
Wikipedia Pothwari   Discussion 27-Feb-2022
Wikipedia Prussian 2   Verified as eligible 20-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Pu-Xian Min   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2018
Wikipedia Puyuma   Verified as eligible 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Qashqai   Verified as eligible 12-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Queretaro otomi   Discussion 15-Mar-2022
Wikipedia Rajasthani   Discussion 13-Nov-2015
Wikipedia Rajbanshi   Verified as eligible 11-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Rapa Nui   Verified as eligible 27-Feb-2010
Wikipedia Rejang   Verified as eligible 23-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Reunion Creole   Verified as eligible 12-Feb-2013
Wikipedia Rinconada   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikipedia Riograndenser Hunsrückisch   Verified as eligible 02-May-2018
Wikipedia Romanesco   Discussion 07-Feb-2016
Wikipedia Romanized Kyrgyz   Discussion 07-Feb-2024
Wikipedia Rotuman   Verified as eligible 21-May-2007
Wikipedia Rukai   Verified as eligible 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Saint Lucian Creole French   Verified as eligible 31-Mar-2013
Wikipedia SaiSiyat   Verified as eligible 24-Oct-2018
Wikipedia Salar   Verified as eligible 12-Aug-2008
Wikipedia Sanaani   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Sasak   On hold 11-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Sassarese   Verified as eligible 10-Sep-2007
Wikipedia Semai   Verified as eligible 30-Aug-2022
Wikipedia Sencilla es   Discussion 06-Apr-2020
Wikipedia Serer   Verified as eligible 14-Nov-2018
Wikipedia Seri   Verified as eligible 07-Oct-2007
Wikipedia Sgaw Karen   Verified as eligible 21-Nov-2018
Wikipedia Sheshi kham   Verified as eligible 27-May-2017
Wikipedia Shina   Verified as eligible 18-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Shughni   Verified as eligible 31-Mar-2013
Wikipedia Siberian Tatar   Discussion 25-Apr-2021
Wikipedia Siberian Yupik   Discussion 09-Sep-2018
Wikipedia Simple Esperanto   Discussion 26-May-2023
Wikipedia Skolt Sami 2   Verified as eligible 24-Apr-2022
Wikipedia Solomon Pijin   Verified as eligible 23-Jun-2010
Wikipedia South African English   Discussion 06-Dec-2023
Wikipedia South African Sign Language   Discussion 14-Dec-2023
Wikipedia South Ndebele   Verified as eligible 30-Jul-2018
Wikipedia Southern Balochi   Verified as eligible 12-Aug-2008
Wikipedia Southern Kurdish   Verified as eligible 05-Mar-2010
Wikipedia Southern Luri   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Southern Sami   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikipedia Southeastern Kolami   Discussion 20-Apr-2023
Wikipedia Spanish Visual Impairment   Discussion 09-Feb-2023
Wikipedia Sumerian   Discussion 03-Jan-2024
Wikipedia Sylheti   Verified as eligible 14-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Tai Nüa   Verified as eligible 11-Sep-2022
Wikipedia Taivoan   Discussion 21-Mar-2019
Wikipedia Taiwan Sign   Discussion 08-Nov-2023
Wikipedia Tamang   Verified as eligible 14-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Tangut   Discussion 09-Nov-2023
Wikipedia Tarifit   Verified as eligible 12-Aug-2007
Wikipedia Tati   Verified as eligible 28-Mar-2008
Wikipedia Tausug   Verified as eligible 31-Mar-2013
Wikipedia Ter Sami   Verified as eligible 10-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Thao 2   Verified as eligible 07-Mar-2022
Wikipedia Tharu   Verified as eligible 02-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Tigre   Discussion 22-Dec-2021
Wikipedia Tiv   On hold 11-Sep-2022
Wikipedia Tokelauan 2   Verified as eligible 27-Feb-2010
Wikipedia Toki Pona 2   Discussion 03-Mar-2022
Wikipedia Torres Strait Creole   Verified as eligible 10-Mar-2010
Wikipedia Tourangeau   Discussion 15-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Triqui   Discussion 28-Apr-2016
Wikipedia Tsakonian   On hold 11-Sep-2022
Wikipedia Tsou   Verified as eligible 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Tucano   Verified as eligible 25-Jun-2011
Wikipedia Tunica   Discussion 16-Sep-2016
Wikipedia Tunisian   Discussion 27-Sep-2014
Wikipedia Turoyo   Verified as eligible 31-Mar-2013
Wikipedia Tver Karelian   Discussion 11-Sep-2020
Wikipedia Upper Saxon German   Discussion 06-Jul-2020
Wikipedia Urum   Discussion 02-Mar-2021
Wikipedia Ushojo   Discussion 07-Dec-2022
Wikipedia Vai 2   Discussion 06-Jun-2021
Wikipedia Vilamovian   Verified as eligible 22-Aug-2012
Wikipedia Votic   Verified as eligible 31-Mar-2013
Wikipedia Wallisian   Verified as eligible 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Waorani   Verified as eligible 20-Jun-2010
Wikipedia West Coast Bajau   Discussion 20-Dec-2020
Wikipedia Western Apache   Discussion 23-May-2021
Wikipedia Western Balochi   Discussion 09-Oct-2014
Wikipedia Westphalian   Verified as eligible 24-May-2008
Wikipedia Wolaytta   Verified as eligible 17-Feb-2017
Wikipedia Xiang   Verified as eligible 14-Oct-2008
Wikipedia Xibe   Discussion 03-Jan-2021
Wikipedia Yaeyama   Discussion 01-Jun-2021
Wikipedia Yami   Verified as eligible 23-Apr-2019
Wikipedia Yangben   Verified as eligible 31-Mar-2013
Wikipedia Yawi   Verified as eligible 28-Jun-2011
Wikipedia Yidgha   Verified as eligible 31-Mar-2013
Wikipedia Yilan Creole   Discussion 08-Nov-2023
Wikipedia Yoron   Discussion 02-Sep-2021
Wikipedia Yucatec Maya   Verified as eligible 19-Feb-2010
Wikipedia Yonaguni   Discussion 11-Jun-2021
Wikipedia Yurok   Discussion 11-Apr-2020

Wikiquote

Wikiquote requests
Project Official status Status since Notes
Wikiquote Ancient Greek   Verified as eligible 07-Mar-2010
Wikiquote Aragonese 2   Verified as eligible 14-Jun-2008
Wikiquote Avar   Discussion 29-Mar-2022
Wikiquote Bhojpuri   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2019
Wikiquote Burmese   Verified as eligible 11-Dec-2019
Wikiquote Cantonese   Verified as eligible 14-Nov-2017
Wikiquote Gilaki   Verified as eligible 04-Nov-2007
Wikiquote Dzongkha   Discussion 14-Nov-2022
Wikiquote Haitian Creole   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikiquote Hausa   Verified as eligible 21-Jul-2022
Wikiquote Ido 2   Verified as eligible 10-Dec-2018
Wikiquote Javanese   Discussion 08-Sep-2021
Wikiquote Khowar   On hold 11-Sep-2019
Wikiquote Komering   Discussion 31-Jan-2024
Wikiquote Malay   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikiquote Minangkabau   On hold 12-Dec-2019
Wikiquote Nepali   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2019
Wikiquote Occitan   Verified as eligible 09-Feb-2008
Wikiquote Oriya   Verified as eligible 22-Sep-2011
Wikiquote Oromoo   Verified as eligible 08-Jun-2021
Wikiquote Pashto   Verified as eligible 08-May-2018
Wikiquote Punjabi   Verified as eligible 14-Apr-2011
Wikiquote Quechua   Verified as eligible 01-Jun-2010
Wikiquote Saraiki   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2019
Wikiquote Shona   Discussion 09-Jul-2023
Wikiquote Sindhi   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2019
Wikiquote Sinhala   Verified as eligible 10-Dec-2018
Wikiquote South Azerbaijani   Verified as eligible 11-Dec-2019
Wikiquote Sylheti   Discussion 22-Dec-2022
Wikiquote Tajik   Verified as eligible 14-Sep-2018
Wikiquote Tatar   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2019
Wikiquote Twi   Discussion 11-Mar-2023
Wikiquote Tyap   Discussion 07-Nov-2022
Wikiquote Western Panjabi   Verified as eligible 01-Dec-2008

Wikisource

Wikisource requests
Project Official status Status since Notes
Wikisource Afrikaans   Verified as eligible 11-Oct-2019
Wikisource Albanian   Verified as eligible 19-Jun-2008
Wikisource Ancient Greek 2   Verified as eligible 07-Mar-2010
Wikisource Aragonese 2   Verified as eligible 16-Feb-2008
Wikisource Baluchi   Verified as eligible 10-Jun-2008
Wikisource Bashkir   Verified as eligible 11-Oct-2019
Wikisource Bhojpuri   Discussion 30-Jan-2021
Wikisource Bishnupriya Manipuri   Verified as eligible 17-Dec-2020
Wikisource Cantonese   Discussion 02-Jun-2020
Wikisource Central Bikol   Discussion 30-Aug-2021
Wikisource Coptic   Verified as eligible 07-Mar-2010
Wikisource Interlingue   Verified as eligible 28-Nov-2018
Wikisource Kabardian-Circassian   Verified as eligible 30-Mar-2011
Wikisource Kazakh   Discussion 20-Jan-2022
Wikisource Khmer   Verified as eligible 19-Feb-2010
Wikisource Kurdish   Verified as eligible 22-Apr-2017
Wikisource Literary Chinese   On hold 13-Jun-2019
Wikisource Livvi-Karelian   Verified as eligible 20-Apr-2017
Wikisource Lojban   Verified as eligible 22-Apr-2017
Wikisource Low Saxon   Verified as eligible 13-Dec-2007
Wikisource Lozi   Verified as eligible 08-Dec-2007
Wikisource Maithili   On hold 11-Oct-2019
Wikisource Manchu   Verified as eligible 22-Apr-2017
Wikisource Mauritian Creole   Verified as eligible 17-Sep-2018
Wikisource Meadow Mari   Verified as eligible 09-May-2013
Wikisource Min Dong 2   Verified as eligible 27-Oct-2006
Wikisource Minangkabau   On hold 14-Jul-2020
Wikisource Northern Sami   Verified as eligible 11-Oct-2019
Wikisource Occitan   Verified as eligible 23-Apr-2008
Wikisource Old Norse   Verified as eligible 26-Aug-2008
Wikisource Old Tupi   Discussion 17-Oct-2022
Wikisource Oromo   On hold 18-Dec-2019
Wikisource Pashto   Verified as eligible 22-Apr-2017
Wikisource Sinhala   Verified as eligible 14-Sep-2018
Wikisource Sorbian   Verified as eligible 13-Mar-2010
Wikisource Saraiki   On hold 11-Oct-2019
Wikisource Sylheti   Discussion 28-Jun-2023
Wikisource Tagalog   Verified as eligible 31-Aug-2010
Wikisource Tajik   Verified as eligible 27-May-2017
Wikisource Tatar   Verified as eligible 18-Jul-2011
Wikisource Urdu   Verified as eligible 16-Nov-2017
Wikisource Uzbek   Verified as eligible 22-Apr-2017
Wikisource Volapük   Verified as eligible 07-Oct-2007
Wikisource Western Punjabi   Verified as eligible 22-Apr-2017
Wikisource Zazaki   Verified as eligible 22-Apr-2017

Wikiversity

Wikiversity requests
Project Official status Status since Notes
Wikiversity Afrikaans   On hold 08-Jul-2019
Wikiversity Albanian   Verified as eligible 05-Dec-2017
Wikiversity Belarusian   On hold 11-Oct-2019
Wikiversity Bengali   On hold 06-Jun-2019
Wikiversity Bulgarian   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikiversity Cantonese   Verified as eligible 21-Nov-2018
Wikiversity Catalan   Verified as eligible 28-Dec-2007
Wikiversity Central Bikol   Discussion 17-Aug-2023
Wikiversity Dagbani   Discussion 10-Jun-2021
Wikiversity Dutch   Verified as eligible 21-Apr-2008
Wikiversity Estonian   Verified as eligible 02-Nov-2009
Wikiversity Galician   Verified as eligible 24-Feb-2009
Wikiversity Georgian   Verified as eligible 04-Oct-2008
Wikiversity Gilaki   Verified as eligible 14-Jan-2008
Wikiversity Hausa   Discussion 01-Dec-2021
Wikiversity Haitian Creole   Verified as eligible 06-Feb-2008
Wikiversity Hebrew   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikiversity Hungarian   Verified as eligible 03-Apr-2008
Wikiversity Indonesian 2   On hold 11-Dec-2019
Wikiversity Kurdish   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2019
Wikiversity Limburgish   Verified as eligible 01-Mar-2008
Wikiversity Lithuanian   Verified as eligible 27-Jul-2012
Wikiversity Malayalam   Discussion 06-Jul-2022
Wikiversity Marathi   Discussion 09-Jul-2020
Wikiversity Mazandarani   Verified as eligible 13-Jun-2019
Wikiversity Nepali   On hold 14-Dec-2018
Wikiversity Pa'O   Discussion 01-Nov-2023
Wikiversity Pashto   Verified as eligible 14-Sep-2018
Wikiversity Persian   Verified as eligible 03-May-2008
Wikiversity Polish 2   Verified as eligible 04-Apr-2008
Wikiversity Punjabi   Verified as eligible 11-Dec-2019
Wikiversity Romanian 2   Verified as eligible 05-Dec-2017
Wikiversity Saraiki   On hold 06-Jun-2019
Wikiversity Sinhala 2   Discussion 29-May-2020
Wikiversity Slovak   Verified as eligible 06-Feb-2008
Wikiversity Sylheti   Discussion 08-Jun-2023
Wikiversity Tamil 2   On hold 06-Jun-2019
Wikiversity Telugu   Discussion 11-Mar-2021
Wikiversity Turkish 2   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wikiversity Ukrainian 2   Verified as eligible 22-Oct-2010
Wikiversity Uzbek   Discussion 29-Oct-2023
Wikiversity Vietnamese   Verified as eligible 06-Jun-2019
Wikiversity Zazaki   Verified as eligible 14-May-2018
Wikiversity Yoruba   Discussion 21-Jul-2020


Wikivoyage

Wikivoyage requests
Project Official status Status since Notes
Wikivoyage Afrikaans   Discussion 02-Feb-2023
Wikivoyage Arabic   Verified as eligible 08-Mar-2013
Wikivoyage Armenian   Verified as eligible 01-Mar-2013
Wikivoyage Azerbaijani   Verified as eligible 11-Dec-2019
Wikivoyage Belarusian   Verified as eligible 08-Oct-2018
Wikivoyage Bulgarian   Verified as eligible 08-Mar-2013
Wikivoyage Cantonese   Verified as eligible 14-Dec-2018
Wikivoyage Catalan   Verified as eligible 14-Dec-2018
Wikivoyage Czech   Verified as eligible 10-Dec-2018
Wikivoyage Danish   Verified as eligible 28-Jan-2013
Wikivoyage Georgian   Verified as eligible 27-Mar-2013
Wikivoyage Hungarian   Verified as eligible 24-Nov-2012
Wikivoyage Indonesian   Verified as eligible 28-Jan-2013
Wikivoyage Korean   Verified as eligible 23-Jan-2014
Wikivoyage Latin   On hold 17-Dec-2020
Wikivoyage Latvian   Verified as eligible 14-Dec-2018
Wikivoyage Malayalam   Verified as eligible 08-May-2018
Wikivoyage Marathi   Verified as eligible 13-Jan-2013
Wikivoyage Nepali   Verified as eligible 08-Oct-2018
Wikivoyage Saraiki   Verified as eligible 11-Sep-2019
Wikivoyage Serbian   Verified as eligible 11-Dec-2019
Wikivoyage Serbo-Croatian   Verified as eligible 24-Jan-2022
Wikivoyage Sindhi   Verified as eligible 11-Dec-2019
Wikivoyage Slovak   Verified as eligible 23-Feb-2014
Wikivoyage Slovenian   On hold 18-Dec-2019
Wikivoyage South Azerbaijani   Verified as eligible 14-Jun-2019
Wikivoyage Southern Balochi   On hold 17-Dec-2020
Wikivoyage Sylheti   Discussion 24-Oct-2022
Wikivoyage Tagalog   Verified as eligible 22-Jan-2013
Wikivoyage Tajik   Verified as eligible 11-Dec-2019
Wikivoyage Tamil   Verified as eligible 14-Jan-2014
Wikivoyage Thai   Verified as eligible 27-Mar-2013
Wikivoyage Urdu   Verified as eligible 11-Dec-2019
Wikivoyage Veps   Verified as eligible 08-Mar-2013
Wikivoyage Vilamovian   Discussion 20-Mar-2024
Wikivoyage Welsh   Verified as eligible 24-Dec-2018
Wikivoyage Zazaki   Verified as eligible 08-Mar-2013

Wiktionary

Wiktionary requests
Project Official status Status since Notes
Wiktionary Acehnese   Verified as eligible 12-Dec-2019
Wiktionary American Sign Language   Verified as eligible 04-Nov-2010
Wiktionary Ancash Quechua   Verified as eligible 27-Apr-2018
Wiktionary Ancient Greek   Discussion 16-Jan-2020
Wiktionary Assamese   Verified as eligible 28-Feb-2018
Wiktionary Bakhtiari   Verified as eligible 08-Jan-2019
Wiktionary Balinese   Verified as eligible 28-Nov-2021
Wiktionary Bashkir   Verified as eligible 08-Mar-2012
Wiktionary Betawi   Discussion 22-Dec-2023
Wiktionary Bhojpuri   Verified as eligible 23-Feb-2018
Wiktionary Bodo   Verified as eligible 28-Sep-2018
Wiktionary Buginese   Verified as eligible 30-Nov-2008
Wiktionary Buhinon   Discussion 17-Aug-2023
Wiktionary Caló   Verified as eligible 20-Dec-2020
Wiktionary Cebuano   Verified as eligible 05-Jul-2018
Wiktionary Central Sierra Miwok   Verified as eligible 07-Nov-2018
Wiktionary Chavacano   Verified as eligible 07-Jun-2019
Wiktionary Chuvash   Verified as eligible 29-Aug-2011
Wiktionary Crimean Tatar   Discussion 14-Apr-2023
Wiktionary Doteli   Verified as eligible 21-Feb-2017
Wiktionary Dusun   Verified as eligible 13-Feb-2018
Wiktionary Eastern Pwo   Verified as eligible 07-Nov-2018
Wiktionary Emilian   Verified as eligible 28-Feb-2018
Wiktionary Erzya   Verified as eligible 29-Apr-2010
Wiktionary Friulian   Verified as eligible 20-Jul-2011
Wiktionary Gan   Verified as eligible 04-Jul-2009
Wiktionary Gilaki   Verified as eligible 14-Jan-2008
Wiktionary Guadeloupean Creole   Discussion 06-Dec-2023
Wiktionary Hawaiian   Verified as eligible 23-Feb-2018
Wiktionary Haitian Creole   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wiktionary Ishɛ   Discussion 13-Mar-2020
Wiktionary Jamaican Creole English   Verified as eligible 12-Dec-2019
Wiktionary Jazayri   Discussion 21-May-2015
Wiktionary Jeju   Verified as eligible 12-Dec-2019
Wiktionary Judaeo-Spanish   Verified as eligible 19-Aug-2008
Wiktionary Jutlandic   Verified as eligible 07-Feb-2008
Wiktionary Kabyle   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wiktionary Kirmanjki (Northern Zazaki)   Verified as eligible 04-Jul-2009
Wiktionary Komering   Discussion 14-Nov-2023
Wiktionary Krio   Discussion 10-Nov-2022
Wiktionary Kupang Malay   Discussion 24-Aug-2020
Wiktionary Laki   Verified as eligible 08-Jan-2019
Wiktionary Lavukaleve   Discussion 07-Mar-2022
Wiktionary Ligure   Verified as eligible 06-Nov-2008
Wiktionary Lozi   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wiktionary Lushai   Verified as eligible 22-May-2018
Wiktionary Madurese   Discussion 22-Dec-2023
Wiktionary Magahi   Discussion 05-Feb-2024
Wiktionary Maguindanaon   Discussion 12-Nov-2023
Wiktionary Maithili   Verified as eligible 21-Feb-2018
Wiktionary Manchu   Verified as eligible 10-Dec-2018
Wiktionary Mara   Discussion 07-Jul-2023
Wiktionary Masry   Verified as eligible 26-May-2008
Wiktionary Mazandarani   Verified as eligible 30-Nov-2008
Wiktionary Meänkieli   Verified as eligible 17-Nov-2017
Wiktionary Mingrelian   Verified as eligible 17-Jul-2011
Wiktionary Mirandese   Verified as eligible 02-Mar-2009
Wiktionary Moksha   Verified as eligible 10-Oct-2012
Wiktionary Moroccan Arabic   Discussion 21-Nov-2023
Wiktionary Motu   Verified as eligible 08-Jan-2019
Wiktionary Musi   Discussion 22-Sep-2023
Wiktionary Neapolitan   Verified as eligible 14-Jun-2019
Wiktionary Nepal Bhasa 2   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wiktionary Nheengatu   Verified as eligible 12-Aug-2008
Wiktionary Nigerian Pidgin   Verified as eligible 12-Dec-2019
Wiktionary Norman   Verified as eligible 03-Jul-2018
Wiktionary Northern Sami   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wiktionary Northern Sotho   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wiktionary Ossetic   Verified as eligible 12-Dec-2019
Wiktionary Paiwan   Verified as eligible 21-Jan-2022
Wiktionary Papiamento   Verified as eligible 01-Jun-2010
Wiktionary Pazeh   On hold 14-Jul-2020
Wiktionary Picard   Verified as eligible 23-Jan-2014
Wiktionary Piedmontese   Verified as eligible 06-Nov-2012
Wiktionary Pitjantjatjara   Verified as eligible 12-Jan-2008
Wiktionary Rinconada Bikol   Discussion 03-Oct-2021
Wiktionary Romagnol   Verified as eligible 17-Nov-2017
Wiktionary Rusyn   Verified as eligible 28-Feb-2018
Wiktionary Sakha   Verified as eligible 17-Dec-2020
Wiktionary Sardinian   Verified as eligible 27-Feb-2010
Wiktionary Scots   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wiktionary S'gaw Karen   Discussion 12-Nov-2021
Wiktionary Shona   Discussion 15-Jun-2022
Wiktionary Silesian   Verified as eligible 15-Nov-2008
Wiktionary Slavey   Verified as eligible 04-Oct-2018
Wiktionary Southern Sami   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007
Wiktionary Sylheti   Verified as eligible 21-Aug-2023
Wiktionary Tachelhit   Verified as eligible 16-Oct-2009
Wiktionary Talysh   Discussion 25-Dec-2021
Wiktionary Thao   Verified as eligible 07-Mar-2022
Wiktionary Tigre   Discussion 16-Dec-2023
Wiktionary Tulu   Verified as eligible 07-Nov-2018
Wiktionary Tumbuka   Discussion 16-Jan-2023
Wiktionary Tunisian   Discussion 12-Apr-2015
Wiktionary Tyvan   Verified as eligible 25-Jan-2019
Wiktionary Veps   Verified as eligible 31-Mar-2013
Wiktionary Waray-Waray   Verified as eligible 02-Nov-2009
Wiktionary Wayuu   Verified as eligible 01-Mar-2010
Wiktionary Wu Chinese   Verified as eligible 02-Jul-2018
Wiktionary Wymysorys   Verified as eligible 17-Nov-2017
Wiktionary Zealandic   Verified as eligible 19-Dec-2007

Wikidata

The current procedure for adding new languages to Wikidata can be found at d:Help:Monolingual text languages.

Closed requests

Once a wiki has been approved, delays are beyond the control of the language committee. Please address any comments about such delays on the linked task page or in the IRC channel #wikimedia-techconnect (see IRC/Instructions).

Some requests were closed because of a lack of activity; you may create a new request if you are interested in contributing a test project.

See also the related edit logs: approved, rejected.

Approved

Closed requests
Project Official status Status since Official request
Wikibooks Bashkir   Reopened 23-Aug-2017
Wikibooks Limburgish   Created 14-Nov-2010
Wikibooks Shan   Created 04-Jan-2023
Wikinews Albanian   Created 11-Mar-2011
Wikinews Czech   Created 26-May-2008
Wikinews Dutch   Reopened 05-Jul-2017
Wikinews Esperanto   Created 14-Nov-2010
Wikinews Finnish   Created 24-Nov-2007
Wikinews Greek   Created 20-Mar-2011
Wikinews Gungbe   Created 20-Apr-2023
Wikinews Hungarian   Created 26-May-2008
Wikinews Korean   Created 29-Jul-2010
Wikinews Limburgish   Created 14-Nov-2018
Wikinews Persian   Created 17-Oct-2010
Wikinews Turkish   Created 13-Aug-2009
Wikipedia Acehnese   Created 13-Aug-2009
Wikipedia Adyghe   Created 11-Feb-2016
Wikipedia Amis   Created 06-Nov-2021
Wikipedia Angika   Created 22-Mar-2023
Wikipedia Atayal   Created 22-Mar-2021
Wikipedia Atikamekw   Created 15-Jun-2017
Wikipedia Awadhi   Created 28-Apr-2020
Wikipedia Balinese 3   Created 14-Oct-2019
Wikipedia Banjar   Created 17-Oct-2010
Wikipedia Banyumasan   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Bavarian   Created 05-Jan-2007
Wikipedia Belarusian normative   Created 28-Mar-2007
Wikipedia Betawi   Approved 18-Feb-2024 Task T357866 (86 days ago)
Wikipedia Bikol   Created 24-Nov-2007
Wikipedia Bishnupriya Manipuri   Created 05-Jan-2007
Wikipedia Buginese   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Buryat   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Cantonese 2   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Cebuano   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Chavacano   Created 07-Jan-2007
Wikipedia Crimean Tatar 2   Created 12-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Dagaare   Created 06-Nov-2023
Wikipedia Dagbani   Created 30-Jun-2021
Wikipedia Dinka   Created 12-Jul-2017
Wikipedia Doteli   Created 24-Apr-2017
Wikipedia Egyptian Arabic   Created 24-Nov-2008
Wikipedia Emiliano-Romagnolo   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Erzya 3   Created 26-May-2008
Wikipedia Extremaduran   Created 26-May-2008
Wikipedia Fante   Created 20-Apr-2023
Wikipedia Fiji Hindi   Created 26-May-2008
Wikipedia Fon   Created 03-Oct-2023
Wikipedia Franco-Provençal   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Friulian   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Gagauz 2   Created 14-Nov-2010
Wikipedia Gan   Created 26-May-2008
Wikipedia Ghanaian Pidgin   Created 05-Jul-2023
Wikipedia Goan Konkani   Created 16-Jun-2015
Wikipedia Gorontalo   Created 18-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Gothic   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Guianan Creole   Created 22-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Gungbe   Created 23-Mar-2022
Wikipedia Gurenɛ   Created 27-Feb-2023
Wikipedia Hakka 2   Created 27-May-2007
Wikipedia Hill Mari   Created 17-Oct-2010
Wikipedia Igala   Approved 02-Apr-2024 Task T361644 (42 days ago)
Wikipedia Ilokano   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Inari Sami 2   Created 19-Oct-2020
Wikipedia Ingush   Created 18-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Jamaican   Created 01-May-2016
Wikipedia Kabardian   Created 12-Mar-2011
Wikipedia Kabiye   Created 23-Jun-2017
Wikipedia Kabyle   Created 06-May-2007
Wikipedia Kalmyk   Created 22-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Kapampangan   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Karachay-Balkar   Created 18-Mar-2010
Wikipedia Karakalpak 3   Created 26-May-2008
Wikipedia Kari Seediq   Created 20-Mar-2021
Wikipedia Komi-Permyak 2   Created 17-Oct-2010
Wikipedia Kotava   Created 29-Jul-2020
Wikipedia Kurdish (Sorani)   Created 13-Aug-2009
Wikipedia Kusaal   Approved 10-Mar-2024 Task T359757 (65 days ago)
Wikipedia Ladin   Created 17-Aug-2020
Wikipedia Ladino   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Lak   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Latgalian 3   Created 13-Feb-2011
Wikipedia Lezgi   Created 27-Mar-2012
Wikipedia Ligurian   Created 22-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Lingua Franca Nova 2   Created 18-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Livvi-Karelian   Created 26-Sep-2016
Wikipedia Lombard   Created 22-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Lower Sorbian 2   Created 12-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Madurese 2   Created 15-Dec-2020
Wikipedia Maithili   Created 06-Nov-2014
Wikipedia Mazandarani   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Meadow Mari   Created 09-Jul-2009
Wikipedia Meitei   Created 23-Feb-2021
Wikipedia Minangkabau   Created 06-Feb-2013
Wikipedia Mingrelian   Created 19-Jul-2011
Wikipedia Mirandese   Created 13-Aug-2009
Wikipedia Moksha   Created 26-May-2008
Wikipedia Mon   Created 04-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Moroccan   Created 10-Jul-2020
Wikipedia Moroccan Amazigh   Created 06-Nov-2023
Wikipedia Neapolitan   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Nepal Bhasa   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Nias   Created 12-Jan-2021
Wikipedia Nigerian Pidgin   Created 17-Aug-2022
Wikipedia N'Ko   Created 26-Sep-2019
Wikipedia Norfuk   Created 22-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Norman   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Northern Luri   Created 16-Jun-2015
Wikipedia North Frisian 3   Created 04-Aug-2010
Wikipedia Novial   Created 25-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Old Church Slavonic   Created 07-Jan-2007
Wikipedia Old English   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Ossetian   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Pa'O   Created 19-Jul-2022
Wikipedia Paiwan   Created 06-Nov-2021
Wikipedia Palatinate German 2   Created 14-Nov-2010
Wikipedia Pangasinan   Created 07-Jan-2007
Wikipedia Papiamentu   Created 07-Jan-2007
Wikipedia Pennsylvania German   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Picard   Created 25-Dec-2009
Wikipedia Piedmontese   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Pontic   Created 05-Mar-2009
Wikipedia Ripuarian   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Rusyn   Created 23-Jan-2011
Wikipedia Sakha   Created 26-May-2008
Wikipedia Samogitian   Created 22-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Santali   Created 06-Aug-2018
Wikipedia Saraiki   Created 15-Dec-2020
Wikipedia Saterland Frisian   Created 12-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Sakizaya   Created 21-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Scots   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Sepedi   Created 29-Oct-2011
Wikipedia Serbo-Croatian   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Shan   Created 14-Nov-2018
Wikipedia Silesian   Created 26-May-2008
Wikipedia South Azerbaijani   Created 22-Jul-2015
Wikipedia Southern Altai   Created 23-Feb-2021
Wikipedia Sranan Tongo 2   Created 26-May-2008
Wikipedia Tachelhit   Created 30-Jun-2021
Wikipedia Talysh   Created 29-Aug-2023
Wikipedia Tarantino   Created 07-Jan-2007
Wikipedia Tatar   Created 22-Jan-2011
Wikipedia Tetum   Created 22-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Toba Batak   Created 06-Nov-2023
Wikipedia Tulu   Created 04-Aug-2016
Wikipedia Tuvan   Created 11-Aug-2013
Wikipedia Tyap   Created 16-May-2022
Wikipedia Udmurt   Created 22-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Upper Sorbian   Created 25-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Venetian   Created 22-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Veps 2   Created 01-Feb-2012
Wikipedia Vlax Romany   Created 25-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Võro   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Waray-Waray   Created 21-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Wayuu   Created 27-Feb-2023
Wikipedia West Flemish   Created 22-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Western Armenian   Created 01-Apr-2019
Wikipedia Western Panjabi   Created 13-Aug-2009
Wikipedia Wu   Created 23-Dec-2006
Wikipedia Zazaki   Created 05-Jan-2007
Wikipedia Zeelandic   Created 07-Jan-2007
Wikiquote Assamese   Created 04-Jan-2023
Wikiquote Banjar   Created 06-Nov-2023
Wikiquote Bengali   Created 10-Oct-2022
Wikiquote Breton   Created 24-Nov-2007
Wikiquote Central Bikol   Created 10-Oct-2022
Wikiquote Gungbe   Created 04-Jan-2023
Wikiquote Limburgish   Created 24-Nov-2007
Wikiquote Sanskrit   Created 06-Feb-2013
Wikiquote Sakha   Created 08-Jun-2018
Wikiquote Tagalog   Created 10-Oct-2022
Wikiquote Igbo   Created 10-Oct-2022
Wikisource Armenian   Created 24-Nov-2007
Wikisource Assamese   Created 03-Jan-2013
Wikisource Balinese   Created 30-Jun-2021
Wikisource Basque   Created 19-Apr-2018
Wikisource Belarusian 2   Created 27-Mar-2012
Wikisource Bengali 2   Created 27-Sep-2007
Wikisource Breton   Created 14-Nov-2010
Wikisource Burmese   Approved 27-Mar-2024 Task T361085 (48 days ago)
Wikisource Eastern Punjabi   Created 14-Apr-2017
Wikisource Esperanto   Created 14-Nov-2010
Wikisource Georgian   Approved 22-Apr-2024 Task T363085 (22 days ago)
Wikisource Gujarati   Created 27-Mar-2012
Wikisource Hindi   Created 10-Oct-2019
Wikisource Javanese   Created 04-Aug-2021
Wikisource Ligurian   Created 10-Jul-2020
Wikisource Limburgish   Created 26-May-2008
Wikisource Malay   Approved 20-Apr-2024 Task T363039 (24 days ago)
Wikisource Marathi   Created 01-Feb-2012
Wikisource Neapolitan   Created 14-Aug-2019
Wikisource Oriya   Created 20-Oct-2014
Wikisource Piedmontese   Created 08-Jun-2018
Wikisource Sakha   Created 19-Feb-2011
Wikisource Sanskrit   Created 22-Feb-2011
Wikisource Sundanese   Created 16-Aug-2023
Wikisource Tamil   Created 18-May-2007
Wikisource Venetian   Created 13-Nov-2010
Wikisource Walloon   Created 15-Dec-2020
Wikiversity Arabic   Created 19-Jul-2011
Wikiversity Chinese   Created 06-Aug-2018
Wikiversity Czech   Created 26-May-2008
Wikiversity Finnish 2   Created 06-Apr-2009
Wikiversity Greek   Created 12-Jan-2008
Wikiversity Hindi   Created 03-Aug-2017
Wikiversity Italian 2   Created 25-May-2007
Wikiversity Japanese 2   Created 26-May-2008
Wikiversity Korean   Created 06-Feb-2013
Wikiversity Portuguese   Created 26-May-2008
Wikiversity Russian 2   Created 12-Nov-2009
Wikiversity Slovene   Created 27-Mar-2012
Wikiversity Swedish 2   Created 14-Nov-2010
Wikivoyage Bengali   Created 08-Jun-2018
Wikivoyage Chinese   Created 14-Jan-2014
Wikivoyage Esperanto   Created 15-Dec-2020
Wikivoyage Finnish   Created 01-Dec-2016
Wikivoyage Greek   Created 16-May-2013
Wikivoyage Hebrew   Created 27-Mar-2013
Wikivoyage Hindi   Created 27-Sep-2017
Wikivoyage Japanese   Created 13-Aug-2020
Wikivoyage Spanish   Created 03-Jan-2013
Wikivoyage Pashto   Created 04-Jun-2018
Wikivoyage Persian   Created 02-Oct-2014
Wikivoyage Portuguese   Created 03-Jan-2013
Wikivoyage Polish   Created 06-Feb-2013
Wikivoyage Romanian   Created 06-Feb-2013
Wikivoyage Shan   Created 23-Mar-2022
Wikivoyage Turkish   Created 19-Jan-2021
Wikivoyage Ukrainian   Created 27-Mar-2013
Wikivoyage Vietnamese   Created 11-Aug-2013
Wiktionary Bikol   Created 12-Jan-2021
Wiktionary Cantonese   Created 14-Nov-2018
Wiktionary Central Kurdish   Created 29-Mar-2023
Wiktionary Fiji Hindi   Created 06-Nov-2017
Wiktionary Gorontalo   Created 04-Jan-2023
Wiktionary Gungbe   Created 17-Aug-2022
Wiktionary Kabardian   Created 20-Apr-2023
Wiktionary Karakalpak   Approved 09-Apr-2024 Task T362135 (35 days ago)
Wiktionary Konkani   Created 06-Apr-2020
Wiktionary Lombard   Created 06-Nov-2021
Wiktionary Mandailing   Created 26-Jul-2023
Wiktionary Meitei   Created 23-Feb-2021
Wiktionary Mon   Created 18-Mar-2021
Wiktionary Minangkabau   Created 21-Nov-2019
Wiktionary Nias   Created 12-Jan-2021
Wiktionary Oriya   Reopened 29-Sep-2011
Wiktionary Pa'O   Created 16-Aug-2023
Wiktionary Saraiki   Created 15-Dec-2020
Wiktionary Shan   Created 22-Jun-2020
Wiktionary Tacawit   Created 22-Nov-2019
Wiktionary Tyap   Created 20-Apr-2023
Wiktionary Upper Sorbian   Created 27-Sep-2007
Wiktionary Venetian   Created 16-May-2013
Wiktionary Western Panjabi   Created 01-Feb-2012
Wiktionary Zazaki 2   Created 12-Jan-2021
Wiktionary Banjar   Created 17-Aug-2022
Wiktionary Igbo   Created 10-Oct-2022

Rejected

Closed requests
Project Official status Status since Official request
Old Wikipedia   Rejected 03-Mar-2012
MediaWiki Russian   Rejected 03-Jan-2009
Wikibooks Classical Chinese   Rejected 27-Feb-2010
Wikibooks Greenlandic   Rejected 21-Jul-2007
Wikibooks Laki   Rejected 18-Dec-2019
Wikibooks Lojban   Rejected 06-Jun-2019
Wikibooks Meitei   Rejected 08-Nov-2019
Wikibooks Multilingual   Rejected 03-Mar-2010
Wikibooks Multilingual 2   Rejected 12-Dec-2019
Wikibooks Rajasthani   Rejected 05-Dec-2017
Wikibooks Riograndenser Hunsrückisch   Rejected 02-May-2018
Wikibooks Simple English   Rejected 26-Sep-2018
Wikibooks Sindhi   Rejected 08-Apr-2007
Wikijunior Hungarian   Rejected 17-Feb-2011
Wikijunior Sindhi   Rejected 23-Nov-2006
Wikinews Hausa   Rejected 08-Nov-2019
Wikinews Irish   Rejected 04-Dec-2018
Wikinews Kazakh   Rejected 04-Dec-2018
Wikinews Latina   Rejected 25-Nov-2008
Wikinews Literary Chinese   Rejected 11-Oct-2019
Wikinews Meitei   Rejected 08-Nov-2019
Wikinews multilingual   Rejected 03-Mar-2010
Wikinews Old English   Rejected 11-Oct-2019
Wikinews Riograndenser Hunsrückisch   Rejected 02-May-2018
Wikinews Simple English   Rejected 18-Feb-2008
Wikinews Simple English 2   Rejected 17-Feb-2009
Wikinews Sindhi   Rejected 06-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Aeres   Rejected 08-Aug-2007
Wikipedia Ahe   Rejected 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Albanskiy   Rejected 25-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Aldorian   Rejected 26-Dec-2022
Wikipedia Algero-Moroccan Arabic   Rejected 23-Apr-2007
Wikipedia Alkaxus   Rejected 10-Aug-2012
Wikipedia American Norwegian   Rejected 11-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Ancient Greek 2   Rejected 23-Feb-2008
Wikipedia Ancient Greek 3   Rejected 03-Sep-2008
Wikipedia Ancient Hebrew   Rejected 07-Mar-2010
Wikipedia Anglish   Rejected 12-Feb-2014
Wikipedia Anglo-Norman   Rejected 23-Jan-2014
Wikipedia Antwerpish   Rejected 01-Mar-2010
Wikipedia Appalachian English   Rejected 12-Feb-2014
Wikipedia Aramaic of Jesus   Rejected 01-Mar-2010
Wikipedia Arwi   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Australian English   Rejected 02-Dec-2012
Wikipedia Avestan 2   Rejected 06-Feb-2017
Wikipedia Badini Kurdish   Rejected 06-Jun-2021
Wikipedia Bahrani Arabic   Rejected 27-Jul-2018
Wikipedia Base Ganu   Rejected 13-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Baybayin Tagalog 2   Rejected 14-Mar-2011
Wikipedia Berber   Rejected 24-Sep-2009
Wikipedia Bhili   Rejected 11-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Blacksea Turkısh   Rejected 05-Oct-2009
Wikipedia Bofonisk   Rejected 26-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Bosanski Simple   Rejected 11-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Boso Kalongan   Rejected 14-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Braille   Rejected 20-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Brazilian Portuguese 2   Rejected 04-Jan-2010
Wikipedia Brazilian Portuguese 3   Rejected 18-Mar-2010
Wikipedia Brazilian Portuguese 4   Rejected 26-Jan-2017
Wikipedia British English   Rejected 13-Sep-2008
Wikipedia Buhid   Rejected 27-Jul-2018
Wikipedia Bulu   Rejected 21-Jul-2007
Wikipedia Bungo   Rejected 23-Feb-2008
Wikipedia Chianino   Rejected 02-Jun-2021
Wikipedia Chamyuet   Rejected 06-Feb-2017
Wikipedia Chinese (Pinyin) 2   Rejected 27-Sep-2018
Wikipedia Church Slavonic   Rejected 19-Dec-2008
Wikipedia Classical Japanese 2   Rejected 20-Feb-2008
Wikipedia Classical Mongolian   Rejected 21-Jul-2022
Wikipedia Classical Tagalog   Rejected 27-Sep-2009
Wikipedia Cocopa   Rejected 13-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Colloquial Cantonese   Rejected 02-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Common Czech   Rejected 13-Sep-2008
Wikipedia Cora   Rejected 27-Jul-2018
Wikipedia Coptic 2   Rejected 13-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Creole Spanish   Rejected 26-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Cypriot Greek   Rejected 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Cyrillic Azerbaijani   Rejected 06-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Cyrillic English   Rejected 30-Aug-2013
Wikipedia Cyrillic Polish   Rejected 30-Jun-2008
Wikipedia Dalmatian   Rejected 03-Jan-2009
Wikipedia Dalmatian 2   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Dari   Rejected 05-Nov-2012
Wikipedia Daylami   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Drents   Rejected 27-May-2008
Wikipedia Early Middle English (EMe)   Rejected 13-Nov-2013
Wikipedia East Frisian Low Saxon   Rejected 21-Jun-2018
Wikipedia Egyptian   Rejected 22-Jan-2018
Wikipedia Elfdalian   Rejected 01-Oct-2007
Wikipedia Elven   Rejected 01-Oct-2007
Wikipedia Emoji   Rejected 15-May-2021
Wikipedia Empherian   Rejected 31-Dec-2017
Wikipedia Enets   Rejected 27-Jul-2018
Wikipedia English Braille   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia English-Nepali   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Etruscan   Rejected 31-Oct-2018
Wikipedia Eurofarsi   Rejected 21-May-2007
Wikipedia European Portuguese   Rejected 12-Apr-2007
Wikipedia European Portuguese 2   Rejected 19-Feb-2010
Wikipedia European Portuguese 3   Rejected 23-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Evenki   Rejected 20-Dec-2008
Wikipedia Frainc-comtou   Rejected 19-Mar-2017
Wikipedia French Simple   Rejected 18-Feb-2008
Wikipedia Ga   Rejected 04-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Galego-AGAL   Rejected 14-Apr-2008
Wikipedia Galician-Portuguese   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Gondi   Rejected 11-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Gorkha   Rejected 10-Jul-2012
Wikipedia Gronings   Rejected 21-Jun-2018
Wikipedia Hainanese   Rejected 05-Oct-2009
Wikipedia Hanja   Rejected 27-Apr-2008
Wikipedia Hanja 2   Rejected 16-Mar-2021
Wikipedia Hantec   Rejected 06-Nov-2007
Wikipedia Hawaiian Pidgin   Rejected 07-Aug-2018
Wikipedia Hazaragi   Rejected 14-Dec-2017
Wikipedia High Norwegian   Rejected 27-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Hinglish   Rejected 26-Dec-2022
Wikipedia Homshetsma   Rejected 22-Jan-2018
Wikipedia Huichol   Rejected 12-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Hunnic   Rejected 22-Apr-2016
Wikipedia Illyrian   Rejected 22-Apr-2016
Wikipedia Indonesian-Arabic Script   Rejected 23-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Insubric   Rejected 11-Jun-2007
Wikipedia Iranian Persian   Rejected 22-Oct-2010
Wikipedia Irish   Rejected 15-Nov-2012
Wikipedia Istriot   Rejected 29-Jan-2018
Wikipedia Itawis   Rejected 11-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Jamese   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Jassic   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Jawi   Rejected 07-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Jeju   Rejected 18-Feb-2008
Wikipedia Jewish Babylonian Aramaic   Rejected 20-Aug-2018
Wikipedia Kaikavian   Rejected 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Kamassian   Rejected 08-Dec-2020
Wikipedia Karakalpak 2   Rejected 09-Apr-2007
Wikipedia Khandeshi   Rejected 11-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Kumaoni   Rejected 14-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Kunwinjku   Rejected 14-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Kupang Malay   Rejected 12-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Kurmanji   Rejected 05-Mar-2010
Wikipedia Kurukh   Rejected 11-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Kwasio   Rejected 07-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Latgalian 2   Rejected 28-Oct-2007
Wikipedia Latin (non-Vatican)   Rejected 19-Mar-2018
Wikipedia latinized Belorussian   Rejected 02-Jul-2021
Wikipedia Latinized Kyrgyz   Rejected 11-Sep-2022
Wikipedia Latinized Russian   Rejected 14-Aug-2007
Wikipedia Leet(1337)   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Leonese   Rejected 13-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Libyan Arabic   Rejected 22-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Lingua Franca Nova   Rejected 25-Nov-2008
Wikipedia Lisarbin   Rejected 06-Apr-2008
Wikipedia Lishan Didan   Rejected 14-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Llanito   Rejected 19-Jul-2009
Wikipedia Lohorung   Rejected 14-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Luba-Lulua   Rejected 17-Jul-2019
Wikipedia Maasai   Rejected 23-Apr-2019
Wikipedia Magar   Rejected 12-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Mandarin   Rejected 04-Jan-2009
Wikipedia Mandarin Chinese   Rejected 19-Feb-2010
Wikipedia Mandika   Rejected 21-Jul-2007
Wikipedia Maranao   Rejected 11-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Masovian   Rejected 23-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Mesopotamian Arabic   Rejected 11-Sep-2019
Wikipedia Middle Dutch   Rejected 14-Sep-2008
Wikipedia Middle English 2   Rejected 20-Jul-2010
Wikipedia Middle English 3   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Middle English 4   Rejected 16-May-2021
Wikipedia Middle English 5   Rejected 01-Jun-2022
Wikipedia Middle Irish   Rejected 06-Jun-2018
Wikipedia Modern English   Rejected 20-Jul-2010
Wikipedia Modern Etruscan   Rejected 24-Sep-2009
Wikipedia Moldavian-Romanian   Rejected 30-May-2008
Wikipedia Moldovan Cyrillic   Rejected 02-Oct-2009
Wikipedia Montenegrin   Rejected 29-Nov-2006
Wikipedia Montenegrin 2   Rejected 06-Apr-2007
Wikipedia Montenegrin 3   Rejected 16-Dec-2010
Wikipedia Montenegrin 4   Rejected 10-May-2011
Wikipedia Morlakian   Rejected 01-Mar-2010
Wikipedia Morse Code   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Muisca   Rejected 14-Jun-2010
Wikipedia Multilingual   Rejected 19-Sep-2012
Wikipedia Mundang   Rejected 07-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Mundari   Rejected 11-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Mycenaen Greek   Rejected 01-Apr-2011
Wikipedia Namtrik   Rejected 11-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Narom   Rejected 10-Jan-2019
Wikipedia Ngomba   Rejected 14-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Nones   Rejected 07-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Norsk (bokmål)   Rejected 14-Aug-2011
Wikipedia Nord   Rejected 09-Dec-2007
Wikipedia Norn   Rejected 08-Feb-2008
Wikipedia Northern Bohemian   Rejected 12-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Northern Wuu   Rejected 13-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Northumbrian   Rejected 14-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Northwest African Arabic   Rejected 22-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Nûlaeg   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Old Devonian   Rejected 02-Sep-2009
Wikipedia Old Georgian   Rejected 07-Jan-2009
Wikipedia Old High German   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Old Norse 2   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Old Persian   Rejected 02-Sep-2009
Wikipedia Old Prussian   Rejected 22-Apr-2016
Wikipedia Old Romanian   Rejected 22-Apr-2016
Wikipedia Old Russian   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Old Saxon   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Old Tupi   Rejected 26-Dec-2022
Wikipedia Ottoman Turkish 2   Rejected 09-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Ottoman Turkish 3   Rejected 14-Jun-2010
Wikipedia Ottoman Turkish 4   Rejected 10-Oct-2018
Wikipedia Pa-prostu   Rejected 12-Apr-2008
Wikipedia Pahlavi   Rejected 25-Oct-2018
Wikipedia Pali Character Thai   Rejected 07-Mar-2010
Wikipedia Pandan Bikol   Rejected 29-Jan-2018
Wikipedia Pannonian Rusyn   Rejected 12-Nov-2008
Wikipedia Papuan Malay   Rejected 01-May-2019
Wikipedia Pax̌to   Rejected 09-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Persian (in Latinized alphabet)   Rejected 10-Jul-2020
Wikipedia Phoenician 2   Rejected 08-Apr-2007
Wikipedia Pizzonese   Rejected 04-Oct-2008
Wikipedia Polesian   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Prekmurian   Rejected 19-Jul-2017
Wikipedia Pre-reform Russian   Rejected 06-Nov-2007
Wikipedia Proto-Germanic   Rejected 22-Apr-2016
Wikipedia Proto-Indo-European 3   Rejected 22-Apr-2016
Wikipedia Prussian   Rejected 05-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Punjabi (Romanized)   Rejected 18-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Quenya   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Quiché   Rejected 18-Apr-2007
Wikipedia Radical Croatian   Rejected 14-Mar-2009
Wikipedia Resian   Rejected 14-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Romanized Khowar   Rejected 23-Jul-2018
Wikipedia Romanized Pashto   Rejected 09-Apr-2018
Wikipedia Romanized Persian   Rejected 12-Jun-2018
Wikipedia ROT13   Rejected 06-Mar-2007
Wikipedia Ruhrdeutsch   Rejected 26-Mar-2008
Wikipedia Samoic Tongan   Rejected 18-Oct-2008
Wikipedia Savoyâ   Rejected 19-Dec-2020
Wikipedia Scanian   Rejected 11-Mar-2010
Wikipedia Serbian-Macedonian   Rejected 19-Sep-2012
Wikipedia Set English   Rejected 01-Mar-2007
Wikipedia Shakhordoy   Rejected 10-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Shanghainese   Rejected 01-Mar-2023
Wikipedia Shawiya   Rejected 08-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Sherpa   Rejected 07-Aug-2018
Wikipedia Shumerian   Rejected 02-Jul-2021
Wikipedia Sichuanese Mandarin   Rejected 10-Mar-2017
Wikipedia Simple Chinese   Rejected 02-Aug-2018
Wikipedia Simple Chinese 2   Rejected 21-Oct-2018
Wikipedia Simple German 2   Rejected 02-Aug-2008
Wikipedia Simple German 3   Rejected 23-Jun-2010
Wikipedia Simple German 4   Rejected 14-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Simple Hebrew   Rejected 29-Jan-2018
Wikipedia Simple Latin   Rejected 11-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Simple Spanish 3   Rejected 11-Oct-2008
Wikipedia Simple Spanish 4   Rejected 26-Dec-2022
Wikipedia Sindarin   Rejected 15-Nov-2008
Wikipedia Sindarin 2   Rejected 18-Sep-2022
Wikipedia Sindhi (in Devanagari)   Rejected 04-Dec-2018
Wikipedia Sonsorol   Rejected 06-Jun-2019
Wikipedia South Korean   Rejected 15-Jun-2007
Wikipedia South Levantine Arabic   Rejected 07-Nov-2008
Wikipedia Southern Min written with Hanji   Rejected 30-Jan-2018
Wikipedia Southern Uzbek   Rejected 04-Nov-2019
Wikipedia Standard Zazaki   Rejected 03-Oct-2008
Wikipedia Standard Zazaki 2   Rejected 31-Mar-2013
Wikipedia Sudanese Arabic   Rejected 17-Oct-2009
Wikipedia Sunuwari   Rejected 12-Dec-2019
Wikipedia Suomen puhekieli   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Basa Surabayaan   Rejected 06-Jun-2021
Wikipedia Surzhyk 2   Rejected 04-Apr-2007
Wikipedia Swabian   Rejected 09-Jan-2018
Wikipedia Swiss German   Rejected 08-Feb-2011
Wikipedia Swiss Italian   Rejected 11-Sep-2019
Wikipedia Tabasaran   Rejected 13-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Taiwanese Hokkien   Rejected 10-Jul-2013
Wikipedia Tamazight   Rejected 24-Sep-2009
Wikipedia TanaChugah   Rejected 18-Nov-2016
Wikipedia Tày-Nùng   Rejected 11-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Tegal   Rejected 11-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Test3   Rejected 19-Sep-2012
Wikipedia Teochew   Rejected 14-Mar-2018
Wikipedia Thao   Rejected 31-Oct-2018
Wikipedia Toki Pona   Rejected 18-Mar-2017
Wikipedia Traditional Chinese   Rejected 01-Jun-2010
Wikipedia Traditional Greek   Rejected 21-Apr-2007
Wikipedia Traditional Russian   Rejected 19-Dec-2020
Wikipedia Triestino   Rejected 12-Jun-2019
Wikipedia Tsukurian   Rejected 26-Feb-2013
Wikipedia Tundra Yukaghir   Rejected 02-Jul-2021
Wikipedia Turkmen yomut   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Tuscan   Rejected 17-Feb-2008
Wikipedia Ukrainian-old   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Ukrainian Latin   Rejected 28-Mar-2008
Wikipedia Unserdeutsch 2   Rejected 29-Jan-2018
Wikipedia Usprenta   Rejected 23-Feb-2008
Wikipedia Valencià   Rejected 07-Apr-2011
Wikipedia Valenciano   Rejected 23-Jul-2018
Wikipedia Varello   Rejected 28-Feb-2013
Wikipedia Vegliot Dalmatian   Rejected 15-Jul-2009
Wikipedia Veps   Rejected 20-Dec-2008
Wikipedia Vestgjøtska   Rejected 07-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Viejšnoryjan   Rejected 11-Jun-2018
Wikipedia Vorarlbergerisch   Rejected 28-Jun-2018
Wikipedia Vulgar Latin   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikipedia Värmlandic   Rejected 15-Jun-2007
Wikipedia Värmlandic 2   Rejected 27-Jan-2008
Wikipedia Värmlandic 3   Rejected 05-Mar-2008
Wikipedia Warmian   Rejected 07-Jun-2011
Wikipedia West Frisian   Rejected 17-Oct-2007
Wikipedia West Frisian (creole)   Rejected 28-Aug-2007
Wikipedia Zaparoan   Rejected 17-Oct-2009
Wikipedia Zygiligleth   Rejected 29-Jan-2017
Wikiquote Baybayin Tagalog   Rejected 14-Mar-2011
Wikiquote Kashubian   Rejected 16-Feb-2018
Wikiquote Latvian   Rejected 10-Dec-2018
Wikiquote Lingála   Rejected 13-Jun-2019
Wikiquote Multilingual   Rejected 21-Apr-2018
Wikiquote Riograndenser Hunsrückisch   Rejected 02-May-2018
Wikiquote Simple English   Rejected 27-Apr-2018
Wikiquote Syriac   Rejected 14-May-2018
Wikisource Baybayin Tagalog 2   Rejected 14-Mar-2011
Wikisource Belorussian   Rejected 15-Jun-2007
Wikisource Bengali   Rejected 09-Apr-2007
Wikisource Classical Chinese   Rejected 03-Mar-2010
Wikisource Classical Tagalog   Rejected 27-Sep-2009
Wikisource Middle Dutch   Rejected 28-May-2008
Wikisource No linguistic content   Rejected 01-Apr-2011
Wikisource Old Norwegian   Rejected 22-Apr-2017
Wikisource Old Saxon   Rejected 04-Dec-2018
Wikisource Ottoman Turkish   Rejected 25-Jun-2011
Wikisource Wawa   Rejected 21-Feb-2018
Wikispecies Greek   Rejected 11-Sep-2016
Wikispecies Macedonian   Rejected 27-May-2008
Wikispecies Simple English   Rejected 06-Nov-2007
Wikiversity Burmese   Rejected 21-Nov-2018
Wikiversity Indonesian   Rejected 21-Nov-2018
Wikiversity Simple English   Rejected 26-Sep-2018
Wikiversity Sinhala   Rejected 14-May-2018
Wikiversity Swedish   Rejected 12-Nov-2010
Wikiversity Tajik   Rejected 14-Sep-2018
Wikiversity Tamil   Rejected 14-May-2018
Wikiversity Ukrainian-old   Rejected 31-Mar-2013
Wikivoyage Egyptian Arabic   Rejected 06-Jun-2019
Wikivoyage Gilaki   Rejected 11-Oct-2019
Wikivoyage Kazakh   Rejected 24-Dec-2018
Wikivoyage Kurdish   Rejected 11-Dec-2019
Wikivoyage Norwegian   Rejected 12-Nov-2019
Wikivoyage Simple English   Rejected 26-Sep-2018
Wikivoyage Tarifit   Rejected 14-Dec-2018
Wikivoyage Zeelandic   Rejected 11-Dec-2019
Wiktionary Andalusian   Rejected 12-Dec-2019
Wiktionary Aramaic   Rejected 07-Dec-2010
Wiktionary Aranadan   Rejected 12-Dec-2019
Wiktionary Baybayin Tagalog   Rejected 14-Mar-2011
Wiktionary Buryat   Rejected 22-May-2018
Wiktionary Chakma   Rejected 08-Jul-2019
Wiktionary Chinese Hong Kong   Rejected 08-Jan-2019
Wiktionary Classical Chinese   Rejected 03-Mar-2010
Wiktionary Etruscan   Rejected 27-Sep-2019
Wiktionary Flemish   Rejected 03-Jul-2018
Wiktionary Hindustani   Rejected 22-May-2018
Wiktionary Hong Kong Sign Language   Rejected 08-Jul-2019
Wiktionary Jassic   Rejected 12-Dec-2019
Wiktionary Khasi   Rejected 28-Sep-2018
Wiktionary Klingon   Rejected 03-Nov-2013
Wiktionary Lingwa de Planeta   Rejected 19-Mar-2017
Wiktionary Lohorung   Rejected 08-Jul-2019
Wiktionary Lugbara   Rejected 22-May-2018
Wiktionary Malvi   Rejected 22-May-2018
Wiktionary Mbya Guarani   Rejected 08-Jan-2019
Wiktionary Melanau   Rejected 23-Feb-2018
Wiktionary Muisca   Rejected 25-Nov-2008
Wiktionary multilingual   Rejected 03-Mar-2010
Wiktionary Multimedia   Rejected 23-May-2021
Wiktionary Newspeak   Rejected 11-May-2007
Wiktionary Nogai   Rejected 23-Feb-2018
Wiktionary North Levantine Arabic   Rejected 25-Jan-2019
Wiktionary Northern Luri   Rejected 25-Jan-2019
Wiktionary Pali   Rejected 14-Nov-2018
Wiktionary Pitcairnese   Rejected 06-Feb-2018
Wiktionary Polabian   Rejected 10-Jul-2018
Wiktionary Riffian   Rejected 27-Sep-2019
Wiktionary Riograndenser Hunsrückisch   Rejected 02-May-2018
Wiktionary Seychellois Creole   Rejected 14-Jun-2019
Wiktionary Slovincian   Rejected 17-Nov-2017
Wiktionary Sri Lanka Malay   Rejected 19-Mar-2018
Wiktionary Syriac   Rejected 22-May-2018
Wiktionary Värmlandic   Rejected 16-Feb-2008
Wiktionary Wixarika   Rejected 12-Dec-2019
Wiktionary Yerkish   Rejected 27-Sep-2009
Wiktionary Zazaki   Rejected 14-Jul-2007

See also

Cooperation requests for: comments (local) (global) · translation

Retrieved from "https://meta.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Requests_for_new_languages&oldid=26770810"