Wikipedia:Requests for comment/History and geography: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
Tag: Reverted |
Maintenance. |
||
| (17 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
{{rfclistintro}} |
{{rfclistintro}} |
||
</noinclude> |
</noinclude> |
||
'''[[Talk:Free Democratic Party (Germany)#rfc_940F768|Talk:Free Democratic Party (Germany)]]''' |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
Which political position should be indicated in the Free Democratic Party's infobox? |
|||
*[[Centrism|Centre]] |
|||
*[[Centre-right politics|Centre-right]] |
|||
*[[Centrism|Centre]] to [[Centre-right politics|centre-right]] |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
'''[[Talk:Arab citizens of Israel#rfc_8359DF8|Talk:Arab citizens of Israel]]''' |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
Is the current title <s>N</s>POV? (<small>Edit, change to POV from NPOV since all the answers are the other way about</small>) If not, what would be an appropriate title? [[User:Selfstudier|Selfstudier]] ([[User talk:Selfstudier|talk]]) 17:52, 20 April 2024 (UTC)}} |
|||
'''[[Talk:Sulaiman Bek#rfc_C961720|Talk:Sulaiman Bek]]''' |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
Should the alternative spelling ''Sulayman Beg'' and the mention of the presence of a Turkmen minority be included in the article?--[[User:Ermanarich|Ermanarich]] ([[User talk:Ermanarich|talk]]) 12:32, 20 April 2024 (UTC)}} |
|||
'''[[Talk:Climate change#rfc_2957C75|Talk:Climate change]]''' |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
Which of the following sections should be used in the '''Food and health''' section? |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
'''[[Talk:Governor General of Canada#rfc_363CB0C|Talk:Governor General of Canada]]''' |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
Should it be mentioned in the lead, that the governor general is described as Canada's de facto head of state? [[User:GoodDay|GoodDay]] ([[User talk:GoodDay|talk]]) 20:15, 16 April 2024 (UTC)}} |
|||
'''[[Talk:Israel–Hamas war#rfc_B7A44A1|Talk:Israel–Hamas war]]''' |
|||
{{rfcquote|text= |
|||
Western media outlets (''[[The Washington Post]]'', ''[[BBC]]'', ''[[El País]]'', ''[[The Guardian]]'', ''[[CPJ]]''), name it the "Israel–Gaza war";. |
|||
Should the article mention that in the "Media coverage" section ? |
|||
If so, could this draft work ? |
|||
{{xt|In April 2024 certain Western media outlets called the war as the Israel-Gaza war.[https://archive.ph/7niXW#selection-355.0-355.15][https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2024/04/07/israel-hamas-gaza-war-timeline-anniversary/][https://archive.ph/rTPvu#selection-431.0-431.26][https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/apr/09/us-israel-weapon][https://www.rtbf.be/article/proche-orient-des-explosions-entendues-a-damas-et-beyrouth-11358732][https://cpj.org/reports/2024/02/israel-gaza-war-brings-2023-journalist-killings-to-devastating-high/] ''The Washington Post'' published an article titled "six months of the Israel-Gaza war: a timeline of key moments".[https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2024/04/07/israel-hamas-gaza-war-timeline-anniversary/] ''BBC'' explained the history of the conflict, calling it the "Israel-Gaza war".[https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/newsbeat-44124396] ''El País'' called it the "war between Israel and Gaza".[https://elpais.com/internacional/2024-04-07/la-guerra-entre-israel-y-gaza-documentada-por-fotografos-palestinos.html] ''The Guardian'' talked about the "Israel-Gaza war" when analyzing US views.[https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/apr/09/us-israel-weapons] ''CPJ'' spoke about the "Israel-Gaza war" by writing about journalist casualties.[https://cpj.org/2024/04/journalist-casualties-in-the-israel-gaza-conflict/]}} [[User:Deblinis|Deblinis]] ([[User talk:Deblinis|talk]]) 05:16, 16 April 2024 (UTC)}} |
|||
'''[[Talk:Estonia#rfc_12382C9|Talk:Estonia]]''' |
|||
{{rfcquote|text= |
|||
An IP user added a description like 'geographiclly located in Northern Europe' in the lede. ([https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Estonia&diff=prev&oldid=1218937863 1], [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Estonia&diff=prev&oldid=1219035437 2], [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Estonia&diff=prev&oldid=1219061670 3], [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Estonia&diff=prev&oldid=1219065972 4]) I think it violates "Lithuania solution", the consensus which is made in the previous talk. ([[#RfC - The geographic locale of Estonia]]) I request other users' opinions for this issue. Do you support or oppose to add this description? [[Special:Contributions/117.53.77.84|117.53.77.84]] ([[User talk:117.53.77.84|talk]]) 15:13, 15 April 2024 (UTC)}} |
|||
'''[[Talk:Israel–Hamas war#rfc_5EF1CD4|Talk:Israel–Hamas war]]''' |
'''[[Talk:Israel–Hamas war#rfc_5EF1CD4|Talk:Israel–Hamas war]]''' |
||
{{rfcquote|text= |
{{rfcquote|text= |
||
| Line 13: | Line 46: | ||
##Operation Swords of Iron |
##Operation Swords of Iron |
||
##Operation Al-Aqsa Flood |
##Operation Al-Aqsa Flood |
||
##Battle of Al-Aqsa Flood |
|||
<small>Any additional alt names should be added to the list, with a timestamp noting when they were added</small> |
|||
07:37, 12 April 2024 (UTC)}} |
07:37, 12 April 2024 (UTC)}} |
||
'''[[Talk:Djong (ship)#rfc_06583AB|Talk:Djong (ship)]]''' |
'''[[Talk:Djong (ship)#rfc_06583AB|Talk:Djong (ship)]]''' |
||
| Line 37: | Line 69: | ||
'''The [[User:WeatherWriter|Weather Event Writer]]''' ([[User talk:WeatherWriter|Talk Page)]] 15:13, 7 April 2024 (UTC)}} |
'''The [[User:WeatherWriter|Weather Event Writer]]''' ([[User talk:WeatherWriter|Talk Page)]] 15:13, 7 April 2024 (UTC)}} |
||
'''[[Talk:2024 United States presidential election#rfc_376CBEA|Talk:2024 United States presidential election]]''' |
|||
{{rfcquote|text= |
|||
There is currently an edit dispute on whether Kennedy Jr. should appear in the infobox of states that will ''likely'' not receive polling in the 2024 presidential election ''or have not been polled yet''. |
|||
'''Option #1:''' Kennedy Jr. should appear in the infobox of ''every'' state he has ballot access in. |
|||
'''Option #2:''' If the aggregate state polling shows Kennedy Jr. under >5% or >10% (whatever is determined by the RFC): then he shouldn't be included. If no polling has been done ''or'' he is above 5-10%, then he should be included. |
|||
'''Option #3:''' Kennedy Jr. should not appear in the infobox if polling of the state has not been performed. |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
'''[[Talk:Francis Scott Key Bridge (Baltimore)#rfc_337F046|Talk:Francis Scott Key Bridge (Baltimore)]]''' |
'''[[Talk:Francis Scott Key Bridge (Baltimore)#rfc_337F046|Talk:Francis Scott Key Bridge (Baltimore)]]''' |
||
{{rfcquote|text= |
{{rfcquote|text= |
||
| Line 61: | Line 104: | ||
[[Sir Charles Trevelyan, 1st Baronet]] as shown in difference |
[[Sir Charles Trevelyan, 1st Baronet]] as shown in difference |
||
[[Special:Diff/1215143082]]. [[User:Edmund Patrick|Edmund Patrick]] –<small> [[User talk:Edmund Patrick|'''confer''']]</small> 08:33, 26 March 2024 (UTC)}} |
[[Special:Diff/1215143082]]. [[User:Edmund Patrick|Edmund Patrick]] –<small> [[User talk:Edmund Patrick|'''confer''']]</small> 08:33, 26 March 2024 (UTC)}} |
||
'''[[Talk:Sri Lanka Armed Forces#rfc_BF0AC61|Talk:Sri Lanka Armed Forces]]''' |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
Should the following sentence be included after the heading '''Deployments in Peacekeeping Missions''': |
|||
{{tqb|Sri Lankan peacekeepers have been embroiled in a child sex ring scandal in Haiti, with at least 134 soldiers being accused of sexually abusing nine children from 2004 to 2007.<ref>{{Cite web |date=2017-04-12 |title=AP Investigation: UN troops lured kids into Haiti sex ring |url=https://apnews.com/article/7ccc5fbc05124fa9b0f42ce2edb62d9d |access-date=2024-02-23 |website=AP News |language=en}}</ref>}} |
|||
? |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
'''[[Talk:1977 anti-Tamil pogrom#rfc_D09A041|Talk:1977 anti-Tamil pogrom]]''' |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
The last paragraph on the [[1977_anti-Tamil_pogrom#Presidential_Commission_of_Inquiry|Presidential Commission of Inquiry]] currently reads: |
|||
{{tqb|Following his inquiry, Justice Sansoni submitted his report, which was known as the "Sansoni Report" to President Jayewardene in July 1980.<ref name="presidential commission" /> The riots were explained in the Sansoni Report in terms of "Sinhalese reaction to Tamil separatist demands, terrorist acts committed in the name of separatism, and anti-Sinhalese statements allegedly made by Tamil politicians in the course of the 1977 general election campaign".<ref name="Kearney">{{cite journal |last1=Kearney |first1=Robert N. |date=March 1986 |title=Tension and Conflict in Sri Lanka |url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/45315688 |journal=Current History |volume=85 |issue=509 |pages=110}}</ref> The Sansoni Report has been criticized for pro-government bias,<ref>{{Cite book |last=Hoole |first=Rajan |url=https://www.uthr.org/Book/CHA02.htm#_Toc527947390 |title=Sri Lanka: The Arrogance of Power : Myths, Decadence & Murder |publisher=University Teachers for Human Rights (Jaffna) |year=2001 |chapter=Chapter 2: Antecedents of July 1983 and the Foundations of Impunity}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web |last=Sabaratnam |first=T. |date=23 November 2003 |title=Pirapaharan: Vol.1, Chap. 18 Tamils Lose Faith in Commissions |url=https://sangam.org/pirapaharan-vol-1-chap-18-tamils-lose-faith-in-commissions/ |website=Ilankai Tamil Sangam}}</ref><ref>{{Cite book |last=Sivanayagam |first=S. |title=Sri Lanka: Witness to History - A Journalist's Memoirs, 1930-2004 |date=2005 |publisher=Sivayogam |isbn=978-0-9549647-0-2 |location=London |page=283}}</ref><ref>{{Cite book |last=Manoharan |first=N. |title=Democratic Dilemma: Ethnic Violence and Human Rights in Sri Lanka |date=2008 |publisher=Samskriti |isbn=9788187374503 |location=New Delhi |page=90}}</ref> being hampered by political interference<ref>Amnesty International, June 11, 2009 Index Number: ASA 37/005/2009 |
|||
Sri Lanka: Twenty years of make-believe. Sri Lanka’s Commissions of Inquiry, p.9, https://www.amnesty.org/en/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/asa370052009eng.pdf</ref><ref>Kishali Pinto Jayawardena, Sunday Times, Feb 17th 2008, Focus on Rights, Further reflections on commission inquiries and rights violations - Part Three, https://www.sundaytimes.lk/080217/Columns/focus.html</ref><ref>Kishali Pinto Jayawardena, Sunday Times, Oct 28th 2007, Discussing mock turtles and commissions of inquiry, https://www.sundaytimes.lk/080217/Columns/focus.html</ref> and for "[[victim blaming]]" Tamils.<ref>{{Citation |last=de Silva |first=Premakumara |title=Ethnicity and Violence in Sri Lanka: An Ethnohistorical Narrative |date=2019 |work=The Palgrave Handbook of Ethnicity |page=16 |editor-last=Ratuva |editor-first=Steven |url=https://link.springer.com/referenceworkentry/10.1007/978-981-13-0242-8_47-1 |access-date=2024-03-12 |place=Singapore |publisher=Springer |language=en |last2=Haniffa |first2=Farzana |last3=Bastin |first3=Rohan}}</ref>}} |
|||
One editor wants the last paragraph to be changed to the following, as he believes both the Kearney and Manogaran sources have "accepted" the reasons attributed by Sansoni for the riots, whereas other editors believe that those sources are merely summarising Sansoni's reasons, and are not personal approvals. Do you agree with the proposed change below? |
|||
{{tqb|Following his inquiry, Justice Sansoni submitted his report, which was known as the "Sansoni Report" to President Jayewardene in July 1980.<ref name="presidential commission" /> |
|||
Over the years the Sansoni Report has been recived diffrent reviews. Robert N. Kearney found that the Sansoni Report explained the riots in terms of "Sinhalese reaction to Tamil separatist demands, terrorist acts committed in the name of separatism, and anti-Sinhalese statements allegedly made by Tamil politicians in the course of the 1977 general election campaign".<ref name="Kearney">{{cite journal |last1=Kearney |first1=Robert N. |date=March 1986 |title=Tension and Conflict in Sri Lanka |url=https://www.jstor.org/stable/45315688 |journal=Current History |volume=85 |issue=509 |pages=110}}</ref> According to Chelvadurai Manogaran, the Sansoni Report attributed many factors as the cause of the riots, including "TULFs anti-Sinhalese proganda advocating separatism, Sinhalese extremists' statements claiming that Tamils intended to wipe out the Sinhalese and acts of violence committed by the liberation Tigers". The immediate cause of the violence Manogaran finds is rumor of Sinhalese policemen been attacked in Jaffna by Tamil militants. He further states that due to the violance (in Augest 1977) and events that followed many Tamils both extreme and moderate were convinced the need to establish a separate state<ref name="Chelvadurai">{{cite book |last1=Manogaran |first1=Chelvadurai |title=Ethnic Conflict and Reconciliation in Sri Lanka |date=1987 |publisher=University of Hawaii Press |location=Honolulu |pages=63-65 |url=https://scholarspace.manoa.hawaii.edu/server/api/core/bitstreams/4f3811e7-1962-495d-bad0-12f31e6754d9/content |access-date=12 March 2024}}</ref> |
|||
The Sansoni Report has been criticized for pro-government bias by [[Rajan Hoole]] of the [[University Teachers for Human Rights]]<ref>{{Cite book |last=Hoole |first=Rajan |url=https://www.uthr.org/Book/CHA02.htm#_Toc527947390 |title=Sri Lanka: The Arrogance of Power : Myths, Decadence & Murder |publisher=University Teachers for Human Rights (Jaffna) |year=2001 |chapter=Chapter 2: Antecedents of July 1983 and the Foundations of Impunity}}</ref> and T. Sabaratnam in his biography of [[Velupillai Prabhakaran]].<ref>{{Cite web |last=Sabaratnam |first=T. |date=23 November 2003 |title=Pirapaharan: Vol.1, Chap. 18 Tamils Lose Faith in Commissions |url=https://sangam.org/pirapaharan-vol-1-chap-18-tamils-lose-faith-in-commissions/ |website=Ilankai Tamil Sangam}}</ref>}} |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
'''[[Talk:Sri Lanka Armed Forces#rfc_391BB84|Talk:Sri Lanka Armed Forces]]''' |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
The first sentence of the section on alleged war crimes in the Sri Lankan Civil War currently reads: |
|||
{{tqb|The Armed Forces along with the LTTE have been accused of committing war crimes during the war, particularly during the final stages. A panel of experts appointed by UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon to advise him on the issue of accountability with regard to any alleged violations of international human rights and humanitarian law during the final stages of the civil war found "credible allegations" which, if proven, indicated that war crimes and crimes against humanity were committed by the Sri Lankan Armed Forces and the LTTE, with most civilian casualties in the final phases of the war being blamed on Sri Lankan Army shelling, with the LTTE preventing the civilian from leaving as they used them as human shields and attempted to create an humanitarian crises.}} |
|||
Should the last phrase read: |
|||
:'''A''' {{tq|with most civilian casualties in the final phases of the war being blamed on indiscriminate Sri Lankan Army shelling and the LTTE being blamed for using civilians as a human buffer.}} |
|||
:OR |
|||
:'''B''' {{tq|with the LTTE accused of significantly adding to the death toll in the final stages of the war, by using civilians as a human buffer and shooting civilians attempting to escape the conflict zone.}} |
|||
? |
|||
[[User:Robert McClenon|Robert McClenon]] ([[User talk:Robert McClenon|talk]]) 23:06, 18 March 2024 (UTC)}} |
|||
'''[[Talk:Mohamed Hadid#rfc_5ED71D4|Talk:Mohamed Hadid]]''' |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
How should the place of birth of Mohamed Hadid be described? [[Talk:Mohamed Hadid/Archives/2018|Prior RfC]] |
|||
# Nazareth (now Israel) |
|||
# Nazareth (Israel) |
|||
# Nazareth (Palestine) |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
'''[[Talk:Russo-Ukrainian War#rfc_F3BC84D|Talk:Russo-Ukrainian War]]''' |
|||
| ⚫ | |||
Should [[Belarus]] be listed in the infobox, and accordingly described in other parts of the article concerning the [[Russian invasion of Ukraine|events since 24 January 2024]]: (a). no (as at present); (b) as ''supported by''; (c) as a co-belligerent; (d) without qualification? |
|||
[[User:Robert McClenon|Robert McClenon]] ([[User talk:Robert McClenon|talk]]) 07:27, 16 March 2024 (UTC)}} |
|||
{{RFC list footer|hist|hide_instructions={{{hide_instructions}}} }} |
{{RFC list footer|hist|hide_instructions={{{hide_instructions}}} }} |
||
Revision as of 10:01, 22 April 2024
The following discussions are requested to have community-wide attention:
Talk:Free Democratic Party (Germany)
| Which political position should be indicated in the Free Democratic Party's infobox?
Scia Della Cometa (talk) 08:37, 21 April 2024 (UTC) |
| Is the current title |
| Should the alternative spelling Sulayman Beg and the mention of the presence of a Turkmen minority be included in the article?--Ermanarich (talk) 12:32, 20 April 2024 (UTC) |
| Which of the following sections should be used in the Food and health section?
Robert McClenon (talk) 04:47, 17 April 2024 (UTC) |
Talk:Governor General of Canada
| Should it be mentioned in the lead, that the governor general is described as Canada's de facto head of state? GoodDay (talk) 20:15, 16 April 2024 (UTC) |
| Western media outlets (The Washington Post, BBC, El País, The Guardian, CPJ), name it the "Israel–Gaza war";.
Should the article mention that in the "Media coverage" section ? If so, could this draft work ? In April 2024 certain Western media outlets called the war as the Israel-Gaza war.[1][2][3][4][5][6] The Washington Post published an article titled "six months of the Israel-Gaza war: a timeline of key moments".[7] BBC explained the history of the conflict, calling it the "Israel-Gaza war".[8] El País called it the "war between Israel and Gaza".[9] The Guardian talked about the "Israel-Gaza war" when analyzing US views.[10] CPJ spoke about the "Israel-Gaza war" by writing about journalist casualties.[11] Deblinis (talk) 05:16, 16 April 2024 (UTC) |
| An IP user added a description like 'geographiclly located in Northern Europe' in the lede. (1, 2, 3, 4) I think it violates "Lithuania solution", the consensus which is made in the previous talk. (#RfC - The geographic locale of Estonia) I request other users' opinions for this issue. Do you support or oppose to add this description? 117.53.77.84 (talk) 15:13, 15 April 2024 (UTC) |
There are two primary questions.
07:37, 12 April 2024 (UTC) |
| Hi editors, this is regarding wether the article should include the quote from Zhou Qufei, Lingwai Daida or not. The history of the quote has been disputed on the talk page, since there are no consensus between Merzostin and Nitekuzee, RfC seems to be the best course of action. In light of the source and evidence, it should be determined wether to:
Option #1: Keep The Quote Option #2: Remove The Quote |
There are several editors in disagreement about how to state the result of the battle. Which option fits best? (Options picked from all previous main-space versions of the result section)
The Weather Event Writer (Talk Page) 15:13, 7 April 2024 (UTC) |
Talk:2024 United States presidential election
| There is currently an edit dispute on whether Kennedy Jr. should appear in the infobox of states that will likely not receive polling in the 2024 presidential election or have not been polled yet.
Option #1: Kennedy Jr. should appear in the infobox of every state he has ballot access in. Option #2: If the aggregate state polling shows Kennedy Jr. under >5% or >10% (whatever is determined by the RFC): then he shouldn't be included. If no polling has been done or he is above 5-10%, then he should be included. Option #3: Kennedy Jr. should not appear in the infobox if polling of the state has not been performed. |
Talk:Francis Scott Key Bridge (Baltimore)
| The lead section first sentence says "The bridge was", in past tense. Should the first sentence be in past tense (Support past tense); or in present tense (Oppose past tense)? -- GreenC 19:24, 5 April 2024 (UTC) |
| The Royal House of the Medieval Cholas has been disputed in This discussion. @Pikachu 9988 has suggested that the imperial Cholas originate from the Pottappi branch. This has been challenged by other users. This has been a subject of various edit wars on related articles. Reviving this discussion for consensus. SKAG123 (talk) 19:23, 3 April 2024 (UTC) |
As this talk page shows, there has been an intractable debate on whether the subject should be described as Greek (or Albanian etc) and what spelling his name should have and connected questions. This RfC hopes to solve this issue. The issues are as follows:
|
| With regard to WP:Verifiability, WP:NPOV, and current academic consensus, should the article present the Reconquista as a matter of historical fact at face value or as historiographical narrative?
This has been a perennial discussion (such as here), and the article would benefit from some stabilizing, somewhat binding consensus. I am hoping for robust engagement with the latest scholarship and the most reliable sources. إيان (talk) 20:11, 29 March 2024 (UTC) |
Talk:Sir Charles Trevelyan, 1st Baronet
| There is a question into the validity of a quote in the article
Sir Charles Trevelyan, 1st Baronet as shown in difference Special:Diff/1215143082. Edmund Patrick – confer 08:33, 26 March 2024 (UTC) |