User talk:Hjc2012: Difference between revisions
Content deleted Content added
Salimfadhley (talk | contribs) comments from chat |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Comments from Barry Cook conversation == |
|||
Hi Hjc2012, I've posted notes from our conversation in the hope that they will be useful when you get round to making this article: |
|||
<salimfadhley> Oh, but there's nothing on that page. It's empty apart from the text "Barry Cook" hjc2012 |
|||
<salimfadhley> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk:Articles_for_creation/Barry_Cook |
|||
<salimfadhley> There's no point in moving that -- you could recreate it yourself in sandbox in 1 minute. |
|||
<hjc2012> how |
|||
<salimfadhley> By the way, to get to your sandbox just click the link at the top of the screen that says "My Sandbox" |
|||
<hjc2012> ok |
|||
<salimfadhley> You can write what you want there. |
|||
<hjc2012> ok |
|||
<salimfadhley> With a few notable exceptions, Sandbox content is generally not checked-over unless you invite others to check it out. |
|||
<hjc2012> but notable website links are no good? you only want newspapers? |
|||
<salimfadhley> Well, I assume that there are specialist journals for martial-arts |
|||
<hjc2012> thats very limiting |
|||
<salimfadhley> Newspaper websites are better than newspapers because they are easier to verify |
|||
<salimfadhley> So we always prefer online links |
|||
<salimfadhley> In general we look for reputable publishers. |
|||
<salimfadhley> Or reputable publications. |
|||
<hjc2012> http://www.worldwidedojo.com/entertainment/cook-barry/ |
|||
<salimfadhley> So an article in the Independent would be taken more seriously than an article in the Sunday Sport |
|||
<hjc2012> http://www.fightcon.com/video/Barry-Cook-Showreel/40452867c812cf47c68879ee2aa75650 |
|||
<salimfadhley> It's hard to say whether that site counts as a reliable secondary source. |
|||
<hjc2012> http://www.cheongye.co.uk/instructor.html |
|||
<hjc2012> http://www.grapplezone.co.uk/instructor.html |
|||
<salimfadhley> The first looks like a blog, but I'm not familiar enough with the field to know for sure (worldwidedojo) |
|||
<salimfadhley> The second is just a video, and therefore unsuitable for anything. |
|||
<hjc2012> http://barryjcook.co.uk/ |
|||
<hjc2012> a video |
|||
<hjc2012> no click underneath |
|||
<salimfadhley> Chegoyne appears to be not a news-source. Seems to be a sporting association's bio so not neutral. |
|||
<hjc2012> the first is the main company all movie directors use to source martial artists for movies lol wow |
|||
<salimfadhley> Grapplezone appears to be a blog of some kind, in any case does not appear to be what we'd normally consider a reliable secondary source. |
|||
<hjc2012> never mind it seems like your fighting to not have articles |
|||
<salimfadhley> hjc2012: In that case it's definitely not a neutral source. If it's a company which sources martial artists then it's not likely to be accepted. |
|||
* hjc2012 has quit (Quit: Page closed) |
|||